South Korea · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Synthetic editorial photograph-style image of agreement papers, a payment schedule, calculator and folder on a contract review desk.
Synthetic editorial image only; it does not depict a real clinic, actual agreement, approval or legal outcome.

South Korea: surrogacy contracts, agencies and payments

The practical answer

The central risk is enforceability, not simply whether a clinic can perform assisted reproduction. On 24 April 2025, the Supreme Court of Korea held that an agreement requiring a woman to hand over a child conceived and delivered through assisted reproductive technology to another person is void under Civil Act Article 103. An agreement by the woman who gives birth to waive all rights as the child’s mother is also void. A private contract therefore cannot safely guarantee delivery of the child, transfer of parenthood, or a particular birth-registration result.

A separate rule in Article 23(3) of the Bioethics and Safety Act prohibits providing or using embryos, ova or sperm in exchange for money, a property benefit or other consideration, and also prohibits inducing or arranging that exchange. Do not treat this rule as identical to the surrogacy-contract ruling: they address different conduct and can create separate risks.

Medical treatment, agency work and surrogacy arrangements must be analysed separately. A clinic’s treatment agreement does not itself establish parentage, and registration to attract foreign patients does not legalise a surrogacy agreement. The safest course is to identify exactly what each payment buys before signing or transferring money.

What the 2025 Supreme Court decision establishes

In case 2022Meu15371, decided on 24 April 2025, the Court treated the agreement to carry and then deliver the child to intended parents as contrary to good morals and social order under Civil Act Article 103. The Court explained that the arrangement treats the woman’s body as an instrument, risks treating the child as an object of exchange and disregards the relationship formed through pregnancy and birth. It also rejected a connected promise by the birth mother to surrender all parental rights.

The Court stated that, where the woman who gave birth is genetically related to the child, she is the child’s mother even if the birth occurred under an invalid surrogacy agreement. The case was remanded because the lower court had not properly examined whether the particular parentage claim might exceptionally be an abuse of process in light of the child’s welfare. This is not a ruling that every parentage dispute has the same outcome, nor does it decide every possible donor-egg or embryo scenario. It does make one point clear: a signed agreement cannot privately rewrite legal parentage or remove the birth mother’s rights.

The decision was not framed as a simple rule that only an excessive fee makes surrogacy invalid. It gives no safe basis for assuming that an unpaid or “altruistic” agreement to deliver a child is enforceable. Nor does it set an approved compensation amount. Do not use the amount paid in the facts of the case as a market rate, lawful tariff or guarantee of recovery.

Keep three payment categories separate

1. Ova, sperm and embryos. Article 23(3) directly addresses providing or using embryos, ova or sperm for money, property benefit or other consideration, including inducing or arranging such provision or use. A payment described as “consulting”, “matching”, “donor support” or “reimbursement” still needs to be assessed by its substance and the applicable implementing rules. A label on an invoice does not decide legality.

2. Payment connected with carrying or handing over a child. The Supreme Court’s ruling makes the core promise to deliver the child, and the related waiver of the birth mother’s rights, void. Do not assume that describing the payment as compensation, expenses or an instalment makes that promise enforceable. The ruling does not, by itself, establish that every expense paid during pregnancy is a criminal offence; the legal character of a genuinely separate expense or service must be examined on its own facts.

3. Independent medical or administrative services. A genuine clinic fee for treatment, or a separately defined lawful translation or logistics service, is not automatically the same as a payment for gametes or a promise to transfer a child. It still needs a real service, a correctly identified provider, clear terms and compliance with the rules that govern that service. Do not bundle everything into one unexplained “programme fee”.

Clinics, agencies and referral rules

Clinic agreement. Ask the clinic to contract directly with the actual patient for the medical services it will provide. Obtain a written treatment plan, itemised estimate, information about foreseeable risks, consent forms, rules for storage or disposal of reproductive material, and the clinic’s cancellation and billing policy. Article 24 of the Bioethics and Safety Act addresses written consent and prior explanation for collecting ova or sperm to create embryos. Confirm which people must consent in the specific procedure. A medical consent form is not a parentage agreement.

Paid patient referrals. Article 27(3) of the Medical Service Act generally prohibits profit-motivated introduction, arrangement or inducement of patients to medical institutions or medical personnel. It contains statutory exceptions, including attracting qualifying foreign patients who are neither insured persons nor dependants under Korean National Health Insurance and who do not fall within the statutory exclusion for foreign nationals residing in Korea. Whether an intermediary’s conduct falls within the rule depends on what it actually does, who the patient is and how the payment is structured.

Foreign-patient attraction registration. Where an intermediary is carrying out “patient attraction” as defined by the Act on Supporting Overseas Expansion of Medical Services and Attraction of International Patients, registration is required. The statutory definition includes activities such as arranging appointments or treatment contracts, providing medical information and related conveniences. Registered businesses must meet the applicable conditions; a non-clinic attraction business has requirements including guarantee insurance, capital and a domestic office. Check the actual registration record, and ask the clinic directly whether it is registered where required.

These rules do not turn registration into a surrogacy licence. A business that only matches a surrogate and intended parents may raise different questions from a business that also books medical treatment or earns a referral commission. The contract label is not conclusive: review the real service, the recipient of each fee, the patient’s status and the business’s role.

A quick transaction-risk map

TransactionLegal position / riskPractical response
Agreement to carry a child and hand the child over; waiver of birth mother’s rightsVoid under the Supreme Court’s 2025 ruling and Civil Act Article 103.Do not rely on it to compel handover or determine parentage.
Payment for providing or using ova, sperm or embryos, or arranging that exchangeExpressly prohibited by Bioethics and Safety Act Article 23(3).Do not pay before Korean counsel checks the exact transaction and applicable rules.
Clinic’s treatment feeSeparate analysis; depends on the actual medical service, consent and compliance.Contract directly with the clinic and obtain itemised terms.
Agency commission for medical-patient referralsMay engage Medical Service Act and foreign-patient attraction rules.Verify patient status, statutory role and required registration.
Translation, travel or other administrative serviceNot automatically unlawful, but the real service and any bundled surrogacy purpose matter.Define deliverables and fee separately; avoid disguising a prohibited payment.
Refund or escrow clauseCannot make an invalid core surrogacy promise valid or guarantee recovery.Assess the underlying payment, recipient, service and restitution rules.

What to check in contracts for separate lawful services

For any genuinely separate service that can lawfully be supplied, the contract should identify the exact legal entity and address, the service provider, the person receiving the service, and the deliverables. State the fee, currency, taxes if applicable, payment milestones, invoice and receipt requirements, cancellation terms, refund formula, deadline for delivery, complaint channel, governing law and dispute forum. If documents are offered in two languages, say which version controls and obtain a translation before signing.

Do not rely on clauses that promise guaranteed parentage, a guaranteed birth certificate or passport, automatic transfer of parental status, or an enforceable obligation to surrender the child. Avoid clauses that require a woman to waive all rights as the birth mother or impose a penalty for exercising medical consent or seeking urgent care. The 2025 ruling directly undermines the enforceability of the core handover and rights-waiver promises; adding notarisation, a witness or a choice-of-law clause does not cure that defect.

Keep the clinic’s medical contract and consent forms separate from agency or logistics agreements. Identify who receives each payment and what work that party must actually perform. A contract that combines clinical care, gamete provision, pregnancy, handover, parentage paperwork and travel into one lump sum makes it harder to identify lawful services, allocate responsibility and assess a refund. If an agency says it has a “partner clinic”, verify the relationship directly with the clinic.

For separate services, document the independent escrow holder, release conditions, fees, evidence, disputes and insolvency terms. Ask Korean counsel to check before funding; escrow cannot validate an invalid handover promise.

Refunds: invalidity does not mean automatic repayment

Do not assume that every amount paid under an invalid surrogacy arrangement is automatically recoverable. Civil Act Article 741 contains the general rule on returning benefits obtained without legal cause. Article 746, however, generally prevents a person from demanding return of property or services transferred for an illegal cause, except where the illegal cause exists only on the recipient’s side. Which rule applies depends on the payment’s purpose and circumstances; the Supreme Court’s 2025 parentage decision did not resolve all possible refund claims arising from every surrogacy arrangement.

Separate the money into categories before making a demand: payment to a clinic for treatment actually delivered; advance payment for a service never supplied; agency fee for defined lawful work; payment linked to gametes or embryos; and payment whose purpose was the child’s delivery or a waiver of parental rights. These categories may have different legal treatment. The court may need to examine who received the money, what was actually done, each party’s role, the purpose of the relevant rules and any applicable exception. A contract’s “non-refundable” or “full refund” wording is not the final answer.

Before sending a formal demand or filing a claim, preserve the evidence and have Korean counsel analyse Articles 741 and 746 against the specific facts. Do not assume that calling a payment “illegal” automatically helps the payer: in some circumstances the illegal-cause rule can prevent recovery. Conversely, do not assume that a recipient can always keep the money; the statutory exception and the facts may matter. A written demand should identify the exact recipient, amount, date, stated purpose and service not delivered.

Before paying: a practical due-diligence checklist

Verify the parties. Obtain the full registered name, registration or business details, physical address and bank account in the same legal name. Check who is actually receiving each payment. Ask for the clinic’s direct contact details and confirm all treatment prices with it rather than relying solely on an intermediary.

Verify the regulatory role. If the intermediary arranges medical appointments or contracts for qualifying foreign patients, ask for the applicable patient-attraction registration details and check them independently. Ask the clinic for its own registration where required. A screenshot of a logo, a claimed “government partner” status or an agent’s statement is not proof of registration or approval for surrogacy.

Review every payment line. Ask for a written breakdown showing recipient, purpose, amount, currency, milestone and refund treatment. Do not transfer money to a personal or unrelated third-party account, pay in cash or cryptocurrency to avoid a record, or accept an invoice that disguises a gamete-related or handover payment as general consulting. These are risk-control recommendations; the legal result still depends on the actual facts and applicable rules.

Challenge guarantees. Stop and seek independent advice if anyone promises a “court-proof” surrogacy contract, guaranteed parentage, a guaranteed birth certificate or passport, a secret clinic arrangement, or an agreement that prevents the birth mother from changing consent or exercising medical rights. No agency registration or notarisation can override the Supreme Court’s ruling.

If you have already signed, paid or started treatment

Keep the signed versions of every agreement, amendments, advertisements, emails, messages, payment confirmations, invoices, receipts, bank statements, agency registration details, clinic treatment plans and consent forms. Record a dated chronology: who proposed the arrangement, what was promised, who received each payment, what service was delivered and what remains outstanding. Do not alter documents or delete messages.

Obtain advice from a Korean lawyer with relevant family-law, civil-contract and reproductive-medical experience. If another country is involved, get advice in that country as well: Korean parentage rules, the law governing an agency contract, and recognition of parentage abroad are separate questions. A choice-of-law clause cannot safely be assumed to displace mandatory Korean rules for conduct in Korea.

If treatment is underway, do not abruptly interrupt medically necessary care solely because a contract is disputed; obtain independent medical advice and urgent legal advice about safe next steps. Before making further discretionary payments, ask counsel to assess the recipient, legal basis and consequences. Avoid threats, pressure or public disclosure of a child’s identity or sensitive medical details.

If a child has already been born, treat parentage, registration, custody and the child’s welfare as urgent separate issues. Do not assume the surrogacy contract controls legal status, and do not make false statements or submit misleading documents to an authority. The Supreme Court’s ruling makes an individual review of the birth facts, genetic links, existing registration and the child’s circumstances essential.

Official sources

The linked primary materials are official Korean texts. Most are available in Korean; an English translation may not reflect every later amendment.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards