Global guide

Redacted draft agreements and a pen on a desk during a legal contract review

What to check in a surrogacy agreement: legal clauses, consent and risk

Start with the legal route, not the template

A surrogacy agreement should identify what each participant intends to do, but its legal effect cannot be assumed from signatures, notarisation or a governing-law clause. Review the law where treatment occurs, where the pregnancy and birth will take place, where participants live and where the intended parents need their status recognised. Check whether an arrangement is permitted, whether any particular promise is enforceable, and which separate procedure establishes legal parenthood. These are three different questions. A contract cannot itself guarantee a child, a passport, recognition abroad or the outcome of a court case. The checklist below is an analytical framework, not a universal contract or a statement that surrogacy is lawful in a particular country.

Test enforceability before negotiating details

The United Kingdom's Surrogacy Arrangements Act 1985, section 1A, makes surrogacy arrangements unenforceable by or against the parties. That does not make a signed UK agreement pointless: it may record expectations, but cannot compel transfer of a child or payment of promised sums through enforcement of the arrangement. In contrast, New York Family Court Act section 581-403 provides a statutory route to an enforceable gestational surrogacy agreement if specified eligibility, execution, representation, insurance and other requirements are met. A New York clause cannot be imported into a UK arrangement as though both systems offered the same remedy. Identify the relevant territory and verify current law before treating a model contract as binding. [S1] [S2] [S3]

Identify every party and verify the right to participate

Record the surrogate's legal name and status, every intended parent's identity, any spouse whose signature or rights may matter, the clinic, and any agency or intermediary. Distinguish a party to the agreement from a service provider and distinguish the person whose gametes are used from a legal parent. Verify capacity, age, residence, family status, any required medical assessment, independent advice and whether the arrangement is gestational or uses the surrogate's own egg. New York, for example, excludes use of the surrogate's egg for an enforceable agreement under its specified statutory route, and imposes separate eligibility requirements. Do not copy these into a global eligibility rule. Obtain documents and legal opinions confirming each specific requirement before signing. [S2] [S4]

Check signatures, timing and independence of advice

Ask who must sign, how signatures must be witnessed or notarised, in what language, and by what deadline relative to medication or embryo transfer. Verify that the surrogate can choose genuinely independent legal counsel and that fee payment does not make that lawyer act for the intended parents. New York's statutory model calls for separate independent counsel and signing before specified transfer-related medical steps; it also requires signatures to be notarised or witnessed by two non-parties. Elsewhere the form and timing can differ or the agreement may remain unenforceable despite formality. Record the final version, schedules, translations, evidence of explanation and signed copies held by each participant. Never backdate or rely on a verbal amendment for a material change. [S2] [S4]

For New York, the surrogate’s spouse ordinarily signs, subject to statutory separation exceptions; each side must have its own New York-licensed lawyer chosen from the start of contracting. New York requires the surrogate’s informed clinical consent before the agreement is signed; the agreement itself must be signed before any medication or procedures in furtherance of embryo transfer.

Protect medical consent and bodily autonomy

Separate expectations about attendance, tests and communication from the surrogate's own legally protected decisions about treatment, pregnancy and birth. A clause promising an abortion, fetal reduction, caesarean delivery or particular embryo transfer must not be presented as automatically enforceable. New York expressly preserves the surrogate's health and welfare decisions, including continuing or ending a pregnancy, choice of practitioner and decisions about the number of fetuses, and invalidates contrary contract terms. The parties can discuss preferences, medical counselling and a disagreement process, but should not confuse cooperation with control over another person's body. Have qualified local counsel and clinicians review any disputed clause before treatment. [S2] [S5]

Map embryos, genetic material and information rights

Specify, consistently with applicable consent rules, who supplies eggs, sperm or embryos; what clinic is authorised to do; the scope and duration of any storage, testing or transfer consent; and how a change or withdrawal of consent will be handled. Check separate clinical consent forms: a contract between adults may not replace permissions required by fertility law or clinic practice. State who receives medical updates, when personal information may be shared, which records remain confidential, and how data will be corrected or retained. Do not promise disclosure of the surrogate's private medical information without a lawful basis. Document translation needs, emergency contacts and who may speak to the clinic, while leaving clinical decisions with the authorised professionals and patient.

Separate compensation, reimbursements and service fees

Create a dated payment schedule that distinguishes surrogate compensation, documented expenses, insurance, clinic charges, lawyers and agency fees. Specify currencies, tax questions to investigate, payer, recipient, evidence required, deadlines and what happens to unused advances. Classification matters: Canada's Assisted Human Reproduction Act prohibits paying a surrogate for acting as a surrogate and prohibits specified paid intermediary conduct; section 12 permits only regulated expense reimbursement subject to conditions, including receipts, and special conditions govern lost work income. New York instead provides requirements for compensation escrow where compensation is agreed. Neither model defines what is permissible in another territory. Do not disguise prohibited remuneration as an expense or assume an escrow release resolves a legal disagreement. [S6] [S7] [S8] [S2]

In Canada, reimbursement of lost work income requires a qualified practitioner’s written certification that continuing work may endanger the surrogate or embryo or fetus, as well as compliance with reimbursement regulations. For a compensated New York statutory agreement, the independent escrow must be funded before medical procedures other than eligibility evaluations.

Allocate medical costs and continuing protection

Review who pays fertility care, pregnancy monitoring, delivery, unexpected hospitalisation, emergency treatment, mental-health support and postpartum care. Ask for insurance documents, not simply a line saying 'insured': inspect effective dates, exclusions, deductibles, provider networks, newborn cover, complications and how claims will be paid if coverage is refused. Identify who funds independent legal advice, counselling and medically necessary travel, subject to applicable reimbursement restrictions. In New York, the statutory agreement must disclose how the surrogate's and child's medical costs are covered and review relevant coverage exclusions; additional protections appear in the eligibility and rights provisions. Insurance is not a substitute for a back-up fund, and neither the clinic nor the surrogate should be left with an unspecified shortfall. [S2] [S4]

New York also requires qualifying comprehensive health insurance to start before transfer-related medication or procedures and continue through the expected pregnancy and twelve months after birth or pregnancy loss. Life insurance is separately prescribed. Limited payment waivers can apply when no compensation is received; the precise statutory conditions and actual policies must be checked.

Plan for changes without promising a result

Address cancelled cycles, unsuccessful transfers, miscarriage, stillbirth, multiple pregnancy, congenital conditions, complications, loss of income, extended care and a participant's death or incapacity. Distinguish events that end treatment obligations from expenses already incurred and duties that survive termination. Explain who pays for screening, storage and continuing care after a failed attempt; when a fresh written consent is needed; and who may be contacted in an emergency. Refuse clauses that penalise independent medical choices or treat a baby as a deliverable subject to quality acceptance. In a legally relevant jurisdiction, parentage and support duties may be fixed by statute or court action rather than private waiver. Record the contingency protocol as a clear schedule, not a broad promise that all problems will be solved.

In New York’s statutory model, intended parents must accept custody and support every resulting child immediately at birth regardless of number, sex, health condition or laboratory error, without overriding any superior parental claim. They must also make a will naming a guardian before embryo transfer. A termination clause cannot simply erase these obligations.

Separate birth logistics from legal parenthood

Provide a practical plan for hospital communication, delivery arrangements, immediate child care, urgent treatment and applications for birth records. Then separately identify the competent authority and documents required to establish or transfer parenthood; neither a private contract nor a foreign birth certificate automatically decides parenthood in every other country. UK official guidance says a surrogate is generally the legal parent at birth and describes a later parental-order route; the exact facts and eligibility must be checked. Cross-border arrangements also require independent advice on recognition, nationality, passports, exit and entry. The HCCH parentage project demonstrates the complexity of cross-border recognition: its working group completed a report, but this is not a universally operative surrogacy convention. [S3] [S9]

UK parental orders for couples or sole applicants generally require a genetic link with an applicant. Consent of the person who gave birth, and any other legally relevant parent, is ordinarily required; the birth parent’s consent is ineffective if given less than six weeks after birth. Statutory exceptions exist when a consenting person cannot be found or lacks capacity. A prebirth promise does not replace valid later consent. Confirm the correct procedure and other criteria for the particular family. [S10] [S11]

Define breach, termination and dispute procedures realistically

Specify which duties are administrative or financial, how notice is served, opportunities to correct a breach, record access, forum, mediation options and what happens to funds and documents after termination. A choice-of-law or arbitration clause cannot necessarily override mandatory rules on health decisions, child welfare, status or public policy. Avoid automatic penalties for miscarriage, refusal of an invasive procedure or inability to produce a child. Identify remedies separately for clinic mistakes, agency non-performance, misuse of confidential information and payment defaults; different parties and laws may govern each. Ask local counsel whether a clause is valid, void, criminally prohibited, enforceable only in part or merely an expression of intent. A dispute plan reduces confusion; it does not eliminate judicial oversight.

Use a clause-by-clause review matrix

For every proposed clause, counsel should record the legal question, the proof examined and a practical red flag. The priority checks are: parties and eligibility against ID, status and medical documents; consent and signatures against independent-advice records; clinical autonomy against law and consent forms; expenses against statutes, receipts and payment schedules; insurance against the actual policy; contingencies against care and termination provisions; parentage against the required court or civil-status route; and disputes against mandatory law and realistic remedies. Mark each line confirmed, conditional or unresolved, with a named person responsible and a deadline.

Document gap and decision gate
Unresolved evidenceSafe immediate action
No jurisdiction-specific eligibility adviceIdentify each participant’s applicable law and obtain written local advice before signing.
No executed consents or independent advicePause transfer-related steps until the required consents, counsel and execution formalities are documented.
Insurance or escrow proof missingInspect policies, exclusions, start dates and funded escrow before financial or clinical commitment.
No parentage and child-travel pathwayRequire a written authority-and-document plan; do not assume a contract or birth record will suffice.

Example: a cross-border conflict hidden by a standard form

Suppose intended parents resident in the UK engage a gestational surrogate in a place that permits a more enforceable agreement. The local contract may govern certain payments and services there. It does not follow that a UK court will compel transfer of the child or that a foreign parentage record automatically gives the intended parents UK legal status. Counsel for the birth jurisdiction and the intended parents' home jurisdiction must check their respective procedures and the practical timing of travel documents before embryo transfer. This example illustrates a legal-risk sequence, not a conclusion about any particular family's eligibility or a guarantee of a parental order. [S1] [S3]

Documents to request and the decision before signing

Request the current agreement with all exhibits and versions; participant IDs and marital-status evidence where relevant; eligibility opinions; independent-counsel letters; clinic treatment and consent forms; the agency's service agreement; detailed budgets and proof of funding; insurance policy and exclusions; an emergency plan; and a written parentage and travel roadmap prepared for the actual jurisdictions. Ask the reviewers to label each issue as required by law, required by a clinic, negotiated commercially, or still unverified. Do not sign or start transfer-related treatment while a material consent, eligibility, prohibited-payment, insurance or parentage issue remains unresolved. The useful output is a marked contract, a missing-document list and a jurisdiction-specific sequence of decisions, not a generic declaration that the program is safe.

Practical conclusion

A strong review does not simply add protective clauses. It tests whether the parties may enter the arrangement, which promises the law recognises, what medical autonomy cannot be contracted away, how money and health protection work, and which separate steps establish a child's legal status. The decisive facts are the people involved, treatment and birth locations, destination country, timing and exact documents. Commission independent local advice in each relevant jurisdiction and preserve an explicit list of unresolved questions. This page is general legal information, not an opinion on a particular agreement or permission to proceed.

Primary sources and official guidance

  1. UK Surrogacy Arrangements Act 1985, s 1A (S1)
  2. New York Family Court Act, § 581-403 (S2)
  3. UK Government, Information for foreign agencies (S3)
  4. New York Family Court Act, § 581-402 (S4)
  5. New York Family Court Act, § 581-602 (S5)
  6. Canada Assisted Human Reproduction Act, s 6 (S6)
  7. Canada Assisted Human Reproduction Act, s 12 (S7)
  8. Canada Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations (S8)
  9. HCCH, Parentage / Surrogacy Project (S9)
  10. UK Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008, s 54 (S10)
  11. UK Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Remedial) Order 2018, article 2 (S11)

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards