South Korea · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Editorial illustration of legal documents and a registration refusal on a desk

South Korea surrogacy disputes: refusals, liability and remedies

In South Korea, a surrogacy dispute cannot be resolved by treating the contract, genetic connection, birth record and legal parentage as if they were the same thing. On 24 April 2025, the Supreme Court held that a surrogacy agreement involving assisted reproduction and requiring a woman to deliver a child to another person is void. An agreement by the woman who gave birth to waive all parental rights is also void. The practical remedy depends on the immediate problem: a registry refusal, a parentage claim, a payment dispute, alleged misconduct by an intermediary, or a cross-border document issue. Start by identifying the decision or legal status that must change, rather than assuming one document settles every question.

The governing legal framework

The central rule comes from Article 103 of the Korean Civil Act: a juristic act contrary to good morals and social order is null and void. In its 2025 judgment, the Supreme Court applied that rule to a surrogacy agreement involving assisted reproduction and delivery of the child to intended parents. The Court reasoned that the arrangement objectifies the woman and the child and disregards the relationship formed through pregnancy and birth. A side agreement waiving the birth mother’s rights cannot make the invalid arrangement enforceable. The judgment is not a general substitute for checking the law that governs each separate question, including registration, damages, adoption or recognition of a foreign order.

What the Supreme Court decided in 2025

In Supreme Court Decision 2022Meu15371, decided on 24 April 2025, the woman had provided both the egg and the womb, and gave birth after an embryo created with the intended father’s sperm was transferred to her. The Court held that the agreement to hand over the child was void, as was the related waiver of parental rights. It reasoned that Korean law determines maternity through pregnancy and childbirth; where the woman who gave birth is also genetically related to the child, she is the child’s legal mother even if the birth resulted from a void agreement. The Court quashed the lower judgment and remanded the case. It should not be described as a final factual ruling on every possible family arrangement, and the remand matters when explaining what the judgment did and did not decide.

Important limits: do not overread the judgment

The 2025 decision is authoritative on the legal issues it decided, but it does not settle every consequence of every surrogacy arrangement. Its facts involved a genetic surrogate who gave birth. A case in which the gestational carrier has no genetic link, a child was born abroad, or a foreign court has already issued an order requires separate analysis. Nor does the invalidity of the agreement by itself determine custody, adoption, nationality, immigration status or recognition of a foreign parentage decision. A genetic test, an intended-parent agreement or a foreign birth certificate should not be treated as an automatic answer to all of those questions. Where the carrier is not genetically related, do not assume the judgment resolves the point without reviewing the full reasoning and later case law.

The Court also recognised a narrow exception: in special circumstances, a claim seeking confirmation of a biological parent–child relationship may be rejected as an abuse of process if recognising that status would be manifestly contrary to the child’s welfare. The court must assess the issue cautiously, taking account of how the legal status came to differ from biological reality; the duration and substance of the child’s emotional bond and lived family relationship with the existing legal parent or parents; the likely harm or disadvantage to the child and those parents if parentage is confirmed; the claimant’s reasons for bringing the claim and the harm they may suffer if it is rejected; and whether anyone else would suffer serious disadvantage. This is not a general licence to disregard biological facts. The Supreme Court did not itself decide that the exception applied; it quashed and remanded the case for the lower court to examine the issue on the facts.

Match the remedy to the dispute

  • Registration refused: request the written reason and assess the special review procedure under the Act on the Registration, etc. of Family Relationships.
  • Parentage disputed: identify the correct family-court action and the people who must be parties; preserve birth and genetic evidence.
  • Money or agency fee disputed: separate the surrogacy payment from documented medical, translation or other services; assess restitution and damages independently.
  • Threats, coercion or disclosure of the child’s identity: preserve original messages and payment records, protect the child’s privacy, and consider a police report where facts suggest a crime.

If a birth or family-registration filing is refused

Ask for the refusal and its reasons in writing. Article 43 of the Act on the Registration, etc. of Family Relationships provides for written notice of the reason when a report is not accepted. For an unlawful or improper disposition by the relevant local registration authority in a registration matter, Article 109 allows an interested person to apply to the competent Family Court for review. Under Articles 110–111, the authority may change its disposition if it accepts the application; otherwise, the court may dismiss the application or order an appropriate disposition. Article 112 limits an appeal from the Family Court’s decision to a claim that the decision violates law. Confirm that this route fits the exact decision and authority involved. Do not assume that an ordinary administrative appeal is the correct procedure, and do not invent a deadline not stated in the applicable provision. Obtain the actual written decision, filing receipt and documents submitted with the original application.

Building a parentage case

Start with the child’s actual circumstances and the legal status being challenged. Collect the birth certificate and birth report, hospital or fertility-clinic records, embryo-transfer and gamete records where lawfully available, genetic-test results, marriage and identity documents, any existing adoption or court orders, and communications showing what each participant agreed or represented. Keep originals, complete message threads, dates and proof of delivery. A parentage action must use the correct legal basis and parties; the 2025 Supreme Court decision arose from an action confirming the existence of a parent-child relationship. If a person is married, the Civil Act’s marital presumption of paternity may raise a separate issue. The Supreme Court’s 2019 ruling on donor insemination shows that lack of a genetic link does not always displace that presumption. The applicable procedural route and parties should be checked before filing. If a claim may disrupt a long-standing family relationship, also preserve lawful evidence of the child’s living arrangements, caregiving history and established emotional ties; these facts may matter to the exceptional child-welfare assessment described above.

Payments, refunds and compensation

Do not assume that declaring the surrogacy agreement void automatically produces a full refund or a damages award. Article 741 of the Civil Act governs unjust enrichment in general, but Article 746 can bar recovery of property or services provided for an illegal cause, subject to its exception where the illegal cause lies only with the recipient. How these provisions apply to a particular payment connected with a void surrogacy agreement depends on the payment’s purpose, the parties’ conduct and the legal character of the transaction; the 2025 decision did not announce an automatic refund rule. Separate payments for egg or sperm provision, embryo-related activity, medical treatment, agency services and general expenses. A tort claim under Articles 750–751 requires a legally actionable wrongful act and proof of the relevant loss and causal connection. Preserve contracts, invoices, bank transfers, receipts, messages and a dated chronology. Limitation periods and procedural deadlines can be decisive, so obtain Korean legal advice promptly.

Clinics, agencies and third-party conduct

Article 23(3) of the Bioethics and Safety Act prohibits providing or using embryos, eggs or sperm for money, property benefits or other consideration, and also prohibits inducing or arranging such provision or use. Apply that provision to the conduct and materials it actually covers; it is not a safe basis for claiming that every aspect of surrogacy is governed by one comprehensive statutory ban. A clinic, broker or agency may raise separate contractual, regulatory, civil or criminal issues depending on its role, representations, handling of reproductive material, consent records and payments. Do not allege a specific offence or licence violation merely because an intermediary participated. Identify the actor, exact conduct, date, payment and potentially applicable provision, and preserve records before making allegations.

Threats, coercion and the child’s privacy

A parentage dispute must not become a means to threaten a participant or expose a child’s identity. Keep threatening messages, call logs, recordings lawfully obtained, demands for money, account details and evidence of online publication in their original form. Do not edit screenshots in a way that removes context, publicly post the child’s personal information, or threaten disclosure in response. A threat, extortion, defamation or privacy-related offence is not established automatically by a family dispute; the facts and applicable criminal provisions must be assessed separately. If there is an immediate safety risk, contact local emergency services or police. Keep the child’s welfare and confidential information central to every legal step.

When another country is involved

If the child was born abroad, or a foreign court or authority has already named a parent, separate the questions: what the foreign document proves, whether it can be used for a Korean registration, whether the foreign judgment is recognised, who has legal parentage under the relevant law, and what nationality, passport or travel rules apply. These are not interchangeable outcomes. Obtain the complete foreign order or certificate, proof that it is final where relevant, the underlying application and evidence, and translations and authentication required by the receiving authority. Do not assume an apostille or a foreign birth certificate resolves Korean parentage. The 2025 Supreme Court judgment concerns Korean parentage doctrine; its application to a cross-border record must be reviewed against the facts and relevant foreign law.

A practical sequence for the first days

  1. Secure the refusal letter, court order, contract, birth records, clinic records, payment proof and original communications.
  2. Write a neutral timeline: treatment, embryo transfer, birth, handover, registration attempt, refusal, payments and later contact.
  3. Identify the immediate legal target: challenge a registration disposition, establish or contest parentage, recover money, claim damages, respond to a threat, or address a foreign order.
  4. Check standing, proper parties, forum and deadlines before filing; Article 109 is a specialised family-registration route, not a universal appeal mechanism.
  5. Have a Korean family-law practitioner review the Korean source text and current procedural rules, particularly where the surrogate is not genetically related, the birth occurred abroad, or a child has lived for years with intended or adoptive parents.
  6. Keep the child’s identity confidential and do not sign a new waiver or make a payment under pressure without advice.

Bottom line

The strongest first step is not to argue from the contract alone. Identify the exact legal status or official decision at issue, preserve the evidence, and choose the procedure that matches it. The Supreme Court of Korea has held that a surrogacy agreement involving assisted reproduction and requiring the child to be handed over to another person is void, as are related waivers of the birth mother’s rights. Parentage, registry correction, refunds, damages and cross-border recognition remain separate questions with their own conditions.

Primary sources and legislation

  1. Civil Act (Republic of Korea), current English statutory text
  2. Supreme Court of Korea, Decision 2022Meu15371, 24 April 2025
  3. Bioethics and Safety Act, Article 23, official Korean text
  4. Act on the Registration, etc. of Family Relationships, current official Korean text (Articles 43, 109–112)
  5. Civil Act, Article 746 (Performance for Illegal Cause), current official Korean text
  6. Supreme Court of Korea, 2016Meu2510 en banc decision, 23 October 2019, official full judgment text

Not an individual legal opinion.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards