Spain · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Two professionals review blank and redacted contract forms at a desk with a laptop and calculator.
Editorial illustration only; it is not a real clinic, contract, approval or legal record.

Spain: surrogacy clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

The short answer

As at 20 October 2026, Spanish law treats as void a contract under which a woman agrees to gestate and relinquish maternal filiation in favour of the commissioning person or another party. The rule applies whether or not a price is paid. The core provisions are Article 10 of Law 14/2006 and Article 32 of Organic Law 2/2010, as amended by Organic Law 1/2023. Spanish law also classifies advertising that promotes commercial surrogacy practices as illicit advertising.

These rules do not mean that every fertility clinic, IVF service, medical consultation, translation, or travel service is automatically unlawful or void. The decisive questions are what each contract actually promises, what an agency markets, how money is routed, whether the arrangement contemplates a transfer of the child outside ordinary legal procedures, and which acts occur in Spain or abroad. Do not treat a foreign clinic’s licence or an agency’s marketing as proof that the whole arrangement will have legal effect in Spain.

1. What Article 10 makes void

Article 10(1) of Law 14/2006 makes null and void a contract for gestation in which the woman renounces maternal filiation in favour of the contracting party or a third person, with or without payment. An “altruistic” label, reimbursement-only wording, or a different name for the agreement does not remove the rule if the substance is the same. The contract cannot itself give the intended parent an enforceable right to require the woman to relinquish legal motherhood.

The same article says that filiation for a child born through surrogacy is determined by childbirth. It preserves the possibility of a paternity claim by the biological father under ordinary legal rules. This is not an automatic recognition of both intended parents, and it does not validate the surrogacy contract. The rule on the core agreement should be kept separate from the status of each related service contract, which requires examination of its own terms and purpose.

2. Clinics, agencies and separate services

Start with the object of each agreement, not its title. A contract for an ordinary, legally permitted reproductive-health service is not automatically a surrogacy contract merely because it concerns fertility. Conversely, calling a package “coordination”, “consulting”, “matching”, “case management” or “medical support” does not make it safe if its real purpose is to arrange gestation and a promised transfer of maternal filiation.

A clinic authorisation or registration is not a licence to override Article 10, and it does not establish that an agency’s fees, the intended parentage, a foreign judgment or Spanish registration are guaranteed. Services performed abroad may also be subject to the destination country’s law; that is a separate question from Spanish public policy and Spanish rules on advertising or recognition. Have a Spanish lawyer assess the actual documents and payment flow, rather than relying on a provider’s general statement that the program is “legal”.

3. Commercial advertising by agencies

Article 3(a) of the General Advertising Law 34/1988 expressly includes advertising that promotes commercial practices for surrogacy among illicit advertising. Article 33 of Organic Law 2/2010, as amended by Organic Law 1/2023 provides that public authorities entitled to act under the advertising legislation are to bring court proceedings seeking a declaration that such advertising is unlawful and an order to stop it.

The wording is relevant to commercial websites, social-media campaigns, brochures, lead-generation pages and package promotions, depending on their actual content and context. It creates a direct legal risk for promotional activity; it should not be exaggerated into a claim that every agency-related act is automatically a crime or that the statute expressly criminalises every private conversation. The precise application to a particular advertiser, service or foreign operator requires a fact-specific analysis, including territorial links and the nature of the promotion.

4. When criminal-law risk may arise

Article 221 of the Spanish Criminal Code addresses a more specific situation: a minor is handed to another person in return for financial compensation, legal procedures for guardianship, foster care or adoption are bypassed, and the purpose is to establish a relationship analogous to parentage. The provision sets imprisonment of one to five years and special disqualification from parental authority, guardianship, curatorship or custody for four to ten years. The same penalties apply to the recipient and the intermediary, even where the handover occurs abroad.

This is not a finding that every surrogacy payment or every intermediary automatically satisfies Article 221. Its statutory elements, the acts of each participant, the intended relationship and the relevant jurisdiction must be assessed by a qualified criminal lawyer. Article 10 nullity, illicit advertising and possible criminal liability are separate legal questions; one should not be used as a shortcut to assume the others.

5. Foreign programs and promises about Spain

A contract may be permitted under the law of the country where a program operates without being enforceable or recognised in Spain. In judgment 1626/2024 of 4 December 2024, the Spanish Supreme Court refused recognition of a United States judgment validating a surrogacy contract and attributing parentage to the intended parents, treating recognition as contrary to Spanish public policy. The decision is a concrete warning, not a promise that every foreign case will have an identical procedural outcome.

The Instruction of the Directorate-General for Legal Certainty and Public Faith dated 28 April 2025, in force from 1 May 2025, states that Civil Registry and consular Civil Registry officers must not accept a foreign registry certificate, a simple declaration accompanied by a medical birth certificate, or even a final foreign court judgment as a sufficient title to register the birth and filiation of a child born through surrogacy. It points instead to ordinary Spanish routes for determining the child’s legal situation after arrival, including biological parentage where applicable, later adoption if the legal requirements are met, or family foster care where appropriate. Therefore, a promise of “guaranteed Spanish registration”, parentage, citizenship or a passport is a serious red flag. These are distinct legal outcomes and none should be guaranteed by an agency.

An important discrepancy in official information remains: a Spanish government portal page last updated on 31 March 2026 still cites the superseded 2010 and 2019 instructions and describes the earlier procedure. The BOE Instruction of 28 April 2025 expressly withdrew those instructions and states that applications to register filiation that were pending on 1 May 2025 would not be registered. Treat the portal summary as potentially outdated on this point and ask Spanish counsel or the competent Civil Registry to confirm the procedure for the specific case; do not rely only on an agency’s summary.

6. What happens to money already paid?

Nullity does not automatically produce an immediate, full refund. Article 1303 of the Civil Code states a general rule of reciprocal restitution after an obligation is declared void, but Articles 1305 and 1306 contain special rules where the cause or object is unlawful. Whether those provisions apply, and whether a claimant can recover a particular payment, depends on the legal character of the contract, the parties’ conduct and fault, what services were actually performed, and the applicable law.

Separate the sums paid to the agency, clinic, lawyer, carrier, insurer, travel provider and any escrow account. A fee for a genuinely independent service may need a different analysis from a payment conditional on performance of the void core arrangement. The governing-law and court clauses, the identity and location of the recipient, refund wording, invoices, timing and evidence of misleading promises may all matter. Do not assume either “everything is refundable” or “nothing can be recovered”. Obtain advice on the exact documents before making a demand or commencing proceedings.

7. Contract and payment clauses to examine

For due diligence, request the complete signed agreement and every annex, not only a brochure or summary. Check: (1) the full legal names of all parties and the entity receiving each payment; (2) an itemised budget separating agency fees, medical treatment, legal work, insurance, travel, contingencies and any payment to another participant; (3) payment milestones, escrow arrangements, who controls releases and what happens if a provider closes; (4) cancellation, refund and dispute clauses; and (5) governing law, forum, arbitration language and enforceability in Spain.

Also check who controls medical decisions, how informed consent and health risks are handled, whether independent advice is available to the gestational carrier, and whether the documents preserve her autonomy. These are due-diligence questions, not a claim that one standard clause makes a surrogacy agreement valid under Spanish law. Ask for a written explanation of what is and is not promised about parentage, registration, citizenship and travel. A clause cannot turn a void core surrogacy contract into an enforceable one merely by choosing foreign law.

8. Practical risk map

Promise or clauseMain legal riskSafer next step
“The contract guarantees parentage in Spain.”Article 10 nullity; foreign decisions may not be recognised.Pause and obtain an independent Spanish family-law opinion.
An agency markets a commercial surrogacy package in Spain.Potentially illicit advertising; a court action may seek cessation.Do not rely only on the provider’s own legal assurances.
Payment is tied to handing over a child.Potential criminal-law exposure if every statutory element is present; not automatic.Do not proceed without independent criminal and family-law advice.
The contract says every fee is non-refundable.Refund rights depend on the contract, applicable law and nullity rules.Preserve the payment record and obtain a case-specific assessment.
One bundled price covers medical, legal and agency services.It may obscure what was actually purchased and who is responsible.Request itemised fees, separate scopes and named providers.
“A foreign birth certificate or judgment guarantees Spanish registration.”Contradicts the 2025 Civil Registry Instruction’s stated evidentiary rule.Request advice based on the current Spanish route to determine filiation.

9. Before paying or signing

  • Obtain all contracts, annexes, terms, invoices and cancellation/refund rules before transferring money.
  • Verify each company’s legal identity, beneficial ownership, registration and the name on the receiving bank account. Check any claimed foreign clinic authorisation with the competent authority in that country.
  • Ask for a complete itemised budget and written explanation of each payment recipient, escrow protection, refund trigger and what happens if the program stops.
  • Have an independent Spanish lawyer review Article 10, advertising restrictions, any Article 221 exposure, refund rules and the effect of the 2025 Instruction. Use independent destination-country counsel for that country’s law.
  • Do not accept “guaranteed” Spanish parentage, registration, citizenship or passport as a sales promise. Ask the provider to identify the legal basis and limits in writing.

The list is a risk-control checklist, not a legal route that makes surrogacy permissible in Spain.

10. If you have already signed or paid

Preserve every version of the contract, annexes, bank statements, invoices, receipts, messages, advertisements, emails and records of what the provider promised. Keep copies of medical or travel records relevant to the services purchased. Do not edit, delete or conceal evidence, and do not make public accusations before obtaining advice.

Pause further payments if safe to do so, and ask a lawyer to send a written request for an itemised account, the contractual basis for each sum, the status of promised services, and the provider’s position on cancellation and refund. Review limitation periods, jurisdiction clauses and urgent steps to preserve a claim. A misleading-advertising complaint may be relevant if the facts fit the law; possible criminal issues should be assessed by counsel, not asserted automatically. If a pregnancy or child is already involved, prioritise medical welfare and the child’s safety and obtain specialist family-law advice immediately; do not treat the matter as only a refund dispute.

Bottom line

In Spain, a surrogacy contract requiring gestation and waiver of maternal filiation is void whether paid or unpaid; commercial promotion is expressly treated as illicit advertising; and neither a foreign contract nor a provider’s guarantee secures Spanish parentage or registration. Criminal liability and refund rights require separate, fact-specific analysis. Before signing, paying, cancelling or suing, have an independent Spanish lawyer review the actual contract, advertising, payment trail and any foreign documents.

Official legal sources

Official Spanish legal texts, government guidance and judiciary information:

From our lawyers' practice

A Spanish family was promised registration that could not be assured

An agency offered a family from Valencia a package of treatment abroad, translations and “guaranteed registration of the parents in Spain”. The prospective parents had doubts and asked whether they should reject the entire package.

Our lawyer examined the agreement item by item. Translation and medical services are lawful in themselves. But neither a clinic licence nor a reference to “legal support” substantiates a promise to establish Spanish parentage. Since May 2025, Spanish registrars, including consular registrars, have not accepted foreign documents or even a final foreign judgment as a basis for registering parents following surrogacy. The family declined the package and did not pay for the promised registration. They entered a separate agreement for the translations they needed, without promises concerning legal status.

Details have been changed to protect the client's confidentiality.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards