Switzerland: Surrogacy contracts, agencies, clinics and payments — legal limits and risks
The short answer and the scope of this page
Short answer: Swiss law prohibits all forms of surrogacy. Article 119(2)(d) of the Federal Constitution declares all forms of surrogate motherhood unlawful, and Article 4 of the Reproductive Medicine Act (RMA) expressly prohibits it. The statute defines a surrogate mother as a woman prepared to become pregnant through assisted reproduction, carry the pregnancy to term, and surrender the child permanently to third parties after delivery (RMA, Art. 2(k)). The prohibition is not limited to commercial arrangements; describing a programme as altruistic or charging only “expenses” does not create a general exception.
That does not resolve every contract or payment question. A Swiss-law contract, a foreign-law contract, a clinic invoice, an agency commission and a refund claim are different issues. The decisive facts include what each party actually does, where medical and intermediary acts occur, what each payment is for, the governing law and forum, and whether a supposedly separate service is genuinely severable from the surrogacy arrangement. This page analyses those transaction risks; it does not decide the law of a foreign destination or recognition of parentage.
What Swiss law prohibits
The constitutional rule is broad: it says “all forms” of surrogate motherhood are unlawful. RMA Article 4 implements that rule by prohibiting surrogate motherhood, while Article 2(k) supplies the statutory definition. On the face of these provisions, the distinction between a paid and unpaid arrangement does not create a Swiss-law exception. Nor does a private agreement, a consent form or a promise to reimburse expenses make the prohibited arrangement permissible.
This is not a ban on every form of fertility treatment. The legal question is whether the procedure and arrangement fall within the statutory concept of surrogacy. Ordinary reproductive treatment for a patient who will carry the pregnancy is a different factual and legal situation. A clinic should not treat a general licence to provide reproductive services as permission to carry out a procedure that the RMA specifically prohibits.
Clinics, agencies and criminal exposure
RMA Article 31 provides that a person who uses an assisted reproductive technique in a surrogate mother is liable to a custodial sentence of up to three years or a monetary penalty. The same penalty applies to a person who acts as an intermediary for surrogacy. These are express statutory offences, not merely contract risks. The text targets the use of the technique and intermediary conduct; it does not expressly create a separate offence consisting simply of making any payment or intending to become a parent.
Intermediary-risk indicators may include recruiting or matching a surrogate with intended parents, arranging introductions as part of a programme, negotiating or managing the surrogacy agreement, coordinating the reproductive procedure or handover, or receiving a commission tied to placement. These are practical warning signs, not an exhaustive statutory definition and not an automatic finding of guilt. The actual role, intent, location and evidence matter. An advertisement, translation, stand-alone legal consultation or isolated contact should not be labelled criminal without analysing what was actually done. Equally, an agency should not assume that calling its fee “consulting” removes intermediary risk.
Are surrogacy contracts enforceable?
Under Article 20 of the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO), a contract is void if its object is impossible, unlawful or immoral. If Swiss law governs the agreement, a promise whose substance is to arrange or carry out a prohibited surrogacy may therefore face a serious nullity problem. Article 18 CO also directs attention to the parties’ true common intention, rather than labels chosen to disguise the agreement. Calling a placement fee “administration”, “consulting” or “coordination” does not settle its legal character.
Nullity must still be analysed contract by contract. Article 20(2) CO allows the invalidity to affect only particular clauses where the defect is separable, unless it can be assumed the agreement would not have been concluded without those clauses. A genuinely independent, lawful service may require a different analysis from the core surrogacy promise. But separating headings or invoices on paper is not enough if the service in substance facilitates the prohibited arrangement. A foreign governing-law clause also means the applicable-law question must be resolved before applying Article 20 as a final answer.
Payments, refunds and limitation periods
There is no safe general rule that a payment connected with a surrogacy programme must be refunded or can never be recovered. CO Article 62 generally requires restitution of enrichment received without legal cause. But Article 66 excludes a right to recover something given with a view to achieving an unlawful or immoral outcome. That exclusion can be important where money was paid to bring about a prohibited arrangement. Its application depends on the purpose and facts of the particular payment; it should not be extended automatically to every separate invoice or every amount described as an expense.
Classify each transfer separately: recipient, date, amount, currency, stated purpose, actual service, milestone, and whether the payment was made to achieve the surrogacy itself or for a distinct lawful service. Article 63 may apply to a voluntary payment of a debt that did not exist: recovery requires proof that the payer mistakenly believed the debt was owed. Article 67 generally sets a three-year period from the injured party’s knowledge of the right to restitution and, in any event, ten years from when that right arose. Counsel must check the exact starting date, any interruption, transitional rules and any applicable foreign law. Do not promise a refund before analysing Articles 20, 62, 63, 66 and 67 together.
Transaction-risk matrix: what a label does not prove
The matrix is a screening tool, not a declaration that a payment is lawful. The statute focuses on the underlying act and arrangement. An escrow account, a foreign bank, an “expense-only” label or a separate invoice cannot by itself legalise prohibited surrogacy or guarantee recovery.
| Transaction or payment | Swiss-law issue | Practical response |
|---|---|---|
| Clinic performs assisted reproduction in a surrogacy arrangement | RMA Arts. 4 and 31; statutory prohibition and potential criminal exposure for the person applying the technique | Do not rely on a general fertility-treatment licence; obtain a written Swiss-law assessment before proceeding. |
| Agency matching, recruitment, arrangement or placement commission | Potential intermediary conduct under RMA Art. 31(2); the facts and actual role control | Identify every act and fee recipient; do not assume “consulting” or “coordination” wording is a safe harbour. |
| Payment or compensation to a surrogate under a Swiss-law arrangement | All forms of surrogacy are prohibited; the contract may face nullity and the payment may face CO Art. 66 | Do not assume the agreement is enforceable or that the money can be recovered. |
| Separate translation, travel, legal or other service | May need separate analysis; a genuinely severable lawful service differs from a disguised intermediary fee | Verify the real service, provider, deliverable, price and independence from the surrogacy undertaking. |
| Deposit, escrow, expense reimbursement or refund | Controls over money do not cure illegality; restitution depends on CO Arts. 62–67 and the payment’s purpose | Check the underlying transaction before funding; retain a traceable payment record and itemised terms. |
Foreign clinics and governing-law clauses
A foreign clinic may operate under a different country’s law, but that fact alone does not answer the Swiss-law question. The Swiss Private International Law Act (PILA) reserves Swiss public policy where applying foreign law would produce a result incompatible with it (Art. 17), and reserves mandatory Swiss provisions that apply regardless of the law otherwise designated (Art. 18). These rules do not mean that Swiss law automatically governs every foreign contract. They mean that a clause choosing foreign law is not a complete answer to the question of Swiss enforceability.
For a cross-border programme, identify where the intended parents, agency, clinic and surrogate are located; where recruitment, negotiation, medical procedures and payment decisions occur; which law and court or arbitral forum the contract selects; and where enforcement will be sought. Swiss-side recruitment, matching or coordination can require specific analysis under RMA Article 31. Do not assume either that every programme carried out abroad is automatically a Swiss criminal offence or that placing the clinic abroad removes every Swiss-law issue. This page does not determine parentage, birth registration, nationality or travel documents; those require separate advice.
Before signing or paying: a practical checklist
Before committing money, request and review the following information in writing. The purpose is to identify the actual transaction and the people responsible, not to create paperwork that disguises a prohibited arrangement.
- Map the parties and locations. Record each legal entity’s full name, registration, address and role. Identify where the clinic will perform each medical step, where the surrogate is located, and where the agency’s recruitment and coordination work will occur.
- Demand an itemised budget. For every fee, name the recipient, currency, amount, service, due date, milestone and supporting invoice. Separate each genuinely independent service; do not accept an unexplained lump-sum package.
- Read termination and refund terms. Check what happens if a provider withdraws, a service is not delivered, the clinic cannot proceed, or the agency becomes insolvent. A refund clause does not cure an unlawful underlying promise.
- Check law, forum and enforcement. Identify governing law, court jurisdiction or arbitration, service-of-process arrangements and where a judgment or award would need to be enforced. Do not assume a foreign-law clause overrides Swiss mandatory rules or public policy.
- Verify the provider’s authority and actual role. Ask what the clinic is authorised to do and who performs each procedure. A general licence is not an exception to the statutory surrogacy ban.
- Obtain independent advice first. Use a Swiss lawyer with relevant reproductive and criminal-law expertise and, where needed, counsel in the destination country. Do not sign or fund the core arrangement while the Swiss-law position remains unresolved.
If you have already signed or paid
Do not destroy, rewrite or backdate documents. Preserve the signed agreement and every version, annex, invoice, advertisement, message, email, payment instruction, bank confirmation, receipt, refund request and response. Keep the original files and metadata where possible. Prepare a payment schedule showing date, amount, currency, sender, recipient, stated purpose and the service said to have been delivered.
Before making further non-essential payments, seek advice promptly; do not abruptly interrupt necessary medical care or make a decision affecting a pregnancy without appropriate medical and legal support. Ask for an itemised account and identify which services were actually delivered, but have counsel assess the wording and timing of any demand. A Swiss lawyer should examine the possible application of RMA Article 31, CO Articles 18, 20 and 62–67, PILA Articles 17–18, limitation periods and any foreign law. Do not relabel a payment, make a false statement to a bank or authority, or threaten a provider with a legal conclusion that has not been assessed.
Bottom line
In Switzerland, the starting point is prohibition, not a presumption that a carefully drafted contract or transparent payment schedule makes surrogacy permissible. RMA Article 31 creates specific criminal exposure for using assisted reproductive techniques in a surrogate mother and for intermediary conduct. CO Article 20 may undermine contractual enforcement. Refund or restitution is not automatic: Articles 62 and 66 make the legal basis and purpose of each payment important, Article 63 may require proof of mistake for a voluntary payment of a debt that did not exist, and Article 67 limitation dates must be checked. Cross-border contracts require a separate choice-of-law and public-policy analysis.
The safest next step is to map the actual acts, parties, locations and payments, preserve the evidence, and obtain an individual Swiss-law review before signing, paying or pursuing a refund.
Sources and legal texts
- Swiss Federal Constitution, Art. 119(2)(d) — official Fedlex entry. The official constitutional text states that all forms of surrogate motherhood are unlawful; the relevant wording was visible in the official entry and search result.
- Reproductive Medicine Act (RMA), Arts. 2(k), 4 and 31 — accessible English text. The accessible English translation is labelled as in force on 1 August 2025. Articles 2(k), 4 and 31 define surrogacy, prohibit it and set penalties for using assisted reproduction in a surrogate mother and for acting as an intermediary. English is informational, not an official language version.
- Official Fedlex entry: Reproductive Medicine Act, version 1 August 2025. The relevant wording was checked in the accessible current English text mirror; counsel should reopen the official entry during sign-off.
- Code of Obligations (CO), Arts. 18, 20, 62, 63, 66 and 67 — current French text reproduced from official text. The current French text was accessible and identifies itself as in force on 1 October 2026, verified against Fedlex on 21 October 2026. Articles 18 and 20 address contractual intent and nullity; Articles 62 and 63 concern unjust enrichment and mistaken payment; Article 66 excludes restitution for an unlawful or immoral purpose; Article 67 sets limitation periods.
- Official Fedlex entry: Code of Obligations, current French text. The provisions were checked against the current French reproduction identified as of 21 October 2026; confirm the official wording during sign-off.
- Private International Law Act (PILA), Arts. 17–18 — English informational text. The accessible English informational text is labelled as in force on 1 January 2026. Articles 17–18 reserve Swiss public policy and certain mandatory Swiss provisions in relevant cross-border cases. English is not an official language and has no legal force.
- Official Fedlex entry: Private International Law Act, version 1 January 2026.
- Official Fedlex Italian text: Reproductive Medicine Act, version in force on 1 August 2025 (Arts. 2(k), 4 and 31). The accessible official Italian version confirms the statutory definition, prohibition and penalties as of that date. It does not establish by itself whether a later amendment took effect after 1 August 2025; confirm the latest version during sign-off.
The accessible English versions of Swiss legislation are informational translations, not authoritative law. Official Swiss texts are published in German, French and Italian. The current Code of Obligations text was checked in a French reproduction identified as of 21 October 2026; the official Fedlex page rendered a JavaScript notice.
