Global guide

Neutral desktop ledger, payment records and calculator illustrating escrow accounting

Surrogacy escrow, advance payments, refunds and payment disputes

The legal question comes before the payment mechanism

A surrogacy programme can involve payments to a clinic, an agency, an independent fund manager, lawyers, insurers and the person carrying the pregnancy. These sums do not acquire the same legal character merely because they appear in one “package price”. Before making a transfer, identify the recipient, the legal basis for the payment, who owns any unspent balance, the event that permits release and the remedy if the programme stops. An escrow account can safeguard money against unilateral use, but it cannot make a prohibited payment lawful, guarantee a refund or make an otherwise unenforceable surrogacy arrangement enforceable.

There is no single worldwide escrow or refund rule. Analyse the law of the place of treatment and surrogacy, the law governing each contract, any mandatory law affecting the surrogate or fund holder, and the courts and banking systems involved. The intended parents’ country of residence may also affect whether the overall arrangement is acceptable, but this article does not determine parentage or immigration status. Payment clauses require their own analysis even where an agency markets a programme as “legal”. Rules may differ within the same country and between payments for professional services and payments to a surrogate.

Three verified examples illustrate the differences. In New York, Family Court Act § 581-403(f) requires funds for base compensation and reasonably anticipated additional expenses to be placed with an independent escrow agent before medical procedures other than eligibility evaluations, where the surrogacy agreement provides for compensation. Separately, General Business Law § 1403(a) requires a surrogacy programme within its scope to hold client funds other than its own fees in escrow apart from operating funds. Neither rule authorises treating an agency operating account as independent escrow. These are New York rules, not rules for every US state. For agreements covered by § 581-403(f), the independent escrow agent must also consent to New York courts’ jurisdiction in proceedings to enforce the escrow agreement.

Canada takes a materially different approach. Under sections 6 and 12 of the federal Assisted Human Reproduction Act, payment for acting as a surrogate and paid arranging of surrogacy are prohibited, whereas qualifying reimbursement must comply with regulations. The reimbursement regulations prescribe eligible expenditures and documentation; receipts are generally required, with a defined exception for private-vehicle travel. Reimbursement of work-related income during pregnancy has a separate medical-certification requirement. Escrow administration does not turn a disguised fee or an unaccountable advance into permitted reimbursement. Provincial obligations and the circumstances of a particular transaction also matter. Before an eligible expense is reimbursed, the payer must obtain a dated, signed declaration itemising expenses, dates and amounts, and confirming that they were not reimbursed elsewhere; receipts are required except for the specified private-vehicle case. Lost-income reimbursement also requires evidence of the income and a qualified medical practitioner’s written certification that continuing work may risk the surrogate’s health or that of the embryo or fetus.

UK government guidance states that surrogacy arrangements cannot be enforced by UK law even if written and expenses have been paid; UK payments to the surrogate are limited to reasonable expenses. In England and Wales, official guidance recommends documenting what expenses will be paid, when payments start or stop, and how parties handle breakdowns; payments must be disclosed when seeking a parental order. This is not a promise that any particular payment or repayment will be approved by a court. The ability to recover a payment, the surrogacy arrangement’s non-enforceability and decisions about legal parenthood are distinct questions. In England and Wales, if payments exceed reasonable expenses, the court considering a parental order must decide whether to authorise the excess retrospectively, taking the child’s welfare as its paramount consideration. This possibility does not make the surrogacy agreement enforceable or approve payments in advance.

Escrow is not an advance: who owns and controls the money?

Escrow means funds are held by a designated holder and released according to a separate set of agreed instructions, subject to applicable law. An advance is money paid before services are performed; its refundability depends on applicable law and the contract, not its label. An agency retainer may be an earned fee, a deposit against future work or partly refundable; an intended parent’s bank transfer directly into an agency account is not independent escrow simply because the invoice says “secure”. Obtain the fund-management agreement, account ownership and custody information, the holder’s identity, licensing or professional status where relevant, and a bank-issued confirmation of the deposit.

The escrow instructions should identify every party and beneficiary, the currency, permitted funds, signatories, records and reporting frequency; specify what documents trigger each release; and say whether a joint instruction, independent verification or a decision from a court or arbitrator is needed for contested releases. Ask who may freeze funds, how long a dispute hold lasts, what fees the holder deducts, how insolvency and bank failure are addressed, and when any remaining balance returns. Independence, segregation and legal protections differ by jurisdiction and account type. Do not assume that a bank account styled “client” has deposit insurance, a trust status or immunity from creditors without verifying its legal structure.

The payment map to request before signing

Use a payment matrix that separates recipient, purpose, release trigger, proof and refund treatment.

Payment categoryWho receives itWhen funds can be releasedRefund treatment
Clinic feesClinic or healthcare providerSpecified treatment milestone and itemised invoiceRefund or credit for unperformed services under the clinic contract and governing law
Agency feeAgency or programme organiserDefined work actually delivered or stated fee scheduleDistinguish earned work, non-refundable term if valid, and unused advance
Permitted surrogate paymentsSurrogate or authorised expense payeeLegally permitted milestone or supported reimbursement requestApply local prohibitions, expense evidence, accrued entitlements and termination rules
Escrow balance and chargesIndependent fund holderWritten release instruction and reconciliationReturn unallocated money subject to lawful fees, existing claims and hold procedures

For each line, request the exact amount or calculation formula, payment date, account details independently confirmed, maximum exposure, currency-conversion rule and who bears transfer fees or tax treatment. Keep fund deposits apart from programme fees in the accounting, even when the commercial quote combines them. A proposed “all-inclusive” amount does not show how much is already earned, reserved for third parties or still refundable. If the parties cannot produce a transparent ledger, do not fund an unexplained shortfall merely on a verbal assurance.

Refunds, cancellation and events that change the calculation

The contract should define the advance and the refund waterfall: first identify services already performed and legally due payments; next identify third-party non-cancellable charges actually incurred; then determine any valid cancellation fee and escrow administration cost; finally return the remaining amount to the person entitled to it. This is a drafting framework, not an automatic entitlement in every jurisdiction. It must distinguish cancellation before treatment, unsuccessful transfer, miscarriage, medical complications, termination by a participant, agency default and provider insolvency. Rights and health-related costs cannot simply be erased by a blanket “no refunds” clause; equally, not every disappointment generates a refund.

A concrete statutory exception to simplistic refund assumptions appears in New York Family Court Act § 581-405. It permits specified parties to terminate by recorded notice before pregnancy through assisted reproduction, yet keeps intended parents liable for the surrogate’s reimbursable expenses incurred through termination. If they terminate after medication or treatment to further embryo transfer, additional specified medical and economic costs associated with treatment may remain payable within twelve months; unless the agreement provides otherwise, the surrogate keeps payments received and accrued entitlements. This limited New York example must not be copied as a worldwide cancellation policy.

Before funding, collect the signed surrogacy and service contracts, fund-management instructions, independently verified account details, invoices and fee schedule, refund schedule, relevant insurance terms, a separate legal-advice confirmation where required and an initial transaction ledger. After every payment retain the bank record, beneficiary details, invoice, contractual milestone and approval or reimbursement evidence. In Canada, the federal reimbursement regulations require prescribed records and six-year retention by the person making regulated reimbursements. Store sensitive medical data securely and disclose only what the lawful claim or review requires.

What to do when funds or invoices are disputed

If a dispute arises, identify whether it concerns a service fee, an unauthorised withdrawal, a delayed escrow release, a disputed expense or a refund after termination. Obtain a current statement from the custodian and reconcile deposits, accrued charges, disbursements, exchange differences and balance. Send a precise written dispute notice naming transaction IDs, amounts, dates, contested clauses and requested remedy. Where the agreement and law allow it, seek a temporary hold only on the disputed money while undisputed, legally due medical or expense payments continue. Follow contractual notice and limitation requirements; assess a bank complaint, professional-regulator complaint, mediation, arbitration or court action with counsel rather than assuming every escrow company can resolve a legal dispute. If fraud or an unauthorised transfer is suspected, promptly contact the bank and fund holder about any available recall or hold, and preserve the original payment instructions and communications. Recovery is not guaranteed.

Illustration, not a legal tariff: the intended parents transfer 50,000 units. Of that amount, the parties have already disbursed 8,000 for an earned agency fee, 12,000 against supported clinic invoices and 5,000 as a documented reimbursement permitted by applicable law. A ledger may show 25,000 unspent, but that sum is not automatically refundable: check whether further earned costs, valid commitments, transfer fees, disputed instructions or lawful holds apply. Equally, the agency cannot prove its entitlement to the entire 50,000 merely by displaying a package invoice. Every figure must be reconciled to contracts and payment evidence. No rule in this example authorises surrogate compensation where the relevant law prohibits it.

Cross-border payments add currency volatility, intermediary-bank charges, sanctions screening and anti-money-laundering checks. A bank transfer receipt shows a transfer instruction or execution, not necessarily that the correct escrow conditions exist. Confirm the bank and account holder independently using a trusted channel; verify whether the fund manager can lawfully receive and distribute money to the relevant persons, and agree who bears FX differences or rejected-transfer fees. Never respond to changed payment instructions only through an email in the existing chain; verify the change by an independently obtained contact. Escrow does not resolve the separate legal questions of eligibility, parentage, birth records or travel documents.

A safer payment decision

The safest decision sequence is: establish whether each proposed payment is lawful in its actual jurisdiction; separate earned service fees, refundable advances and restricted or permitted surrogate expenses; verify the independent holder and account; sign a release-and-refund schedule before the first deposit; record every transaction; and agree an evidence-based dispute process. If the law, the account holder or the refund trigger remains unclear, suspend the proposed transfer until locally qualified counsel and the actual bank or custodian confirm it. This article is a jurisdiction-neutral transaction checklist with specific cited examples, not an opinion that any individual programme, payment or contract is legal.

Official sources and their scope

  1. New York Family Court Act § 581-403 (surrogacy agreement requirements) (S1)
  2. New York General Business Law § 1403 (S2)
  3. New York Family Court Act § 581-405 (termination) (S3)
  4. Canada Assisted Human Reproduction Act §§ 6 and 12 (S4)
  5. Canada Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations (S5)
  6. UK Government: surrogacy legal rights overview (S6)
  7. UK Government: surrogacy pathway (England and Wales) (S7)

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards