South Africa · Legal status and models

Open legal reference book and annotated papers on a wooden desk in a quiet law library
Editorial illustration only. It does not depict a real court, facility, approval or case.

Surrogacy in South Africa: Legal Framework, Payments and Prohibitions

The short answer

South Africa does not prohibit surrogacy altogether. Chapter 19 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 recognises a surrogate motherhood agreement, but only within a tightly regulated framework. The agreement must satisfy statutory requirements and be confirmed by the High Court before the surrogate is artificially fertilised. The model is altruistic rather than commercial: a surrogate cannot be paid a fee or use surrogacy as a source of income, although the Act allows specified expenses, lost earnings and pregnancy-related insurance, as well as reasonable compensation for bona fide legal or medical services.

The sequence matters. The parties must meet the domicile, consent and genetic-origin requirements; the court must assess suitability and the future child’s interests; and fertilisation must occur only after confirmation and within the statutory 18-month period. A private contract or clinic’s willingness to proceed cannot replace the court order. If the agreement does not comply with the Act, section 297(2) says it is invalid and the child is deemed, for all purposes, to be the child of the woman who gave birth.

Which law controls, and what the courts have said

The principal legislation is the Children’s Act 38 of 2005, Chapter 19, sections 292–303. Those provisions govern the agreement, court confirmation, genetic origin, timing of fertilisation, parentage consequences, termination, payments, privacy and prohibited conduct.

Section 294 has been litigated. In AB and Another v Minister of Social Development [2016] ZACC 43, the Constitutional Court did not confirm the High Court’s order declaring it invalid. In KB and Another v Minister of Social Development [2024] ZASCA 54, the Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed a challenge concerning a genetically linked sibling. Treat section 294 as operative; neither case creates a general exception for eligibility, payment, foreign parentage or travel.

The PDF records amendments through 2022; it does not prove that no later amendment or commencement notice affects Chapter 19. South African counsel must verify the latest Gazette before signing or treatment.

Formal validity: writing, place and domicile

Under section 292, an agreement is not valid unless it is in writing and signed by all parties, and is entered into in South Africa. At least one commissioning parent must be domiciled in South Africa when the agreement is made; if there is one commissioning parent, that person must be domiciled there. The surrogate and her husband or partner, if any, must also be domiciled in South Africa at that time. The agreement must be confirmed by the High Court for the area in which the commissioning parent or parents are domiciled or habitually resident.

There is a narrow statutory qualification: on good cause shown, the court may dispense with the domicile requirement that applies to the surrogate and her husband or partner. The text does not provide an equivalent general waiver of the commissioning parent’s domicile requirement or the requirement that the agreement be entered into in South Africa. Do not treat citizenship, a temporary visa, a visit to South Africa or a clinic address as proof of domicile. Domicile is a legal question that depends on the person’s circumstances and intention, and should be assessed on evidence before the application is prepared.

Section 293 adds consent rules. If a commissioning parent is married or in a permanent relationship, that spouse or partner must give written consent and become a party to the agreement before the court can confirm it. If the surrogate is married or in a permanent relationship, her spouse or partner must likewise consent in writing and join the agreement. Where the surrogate’s spouse or partner is not the genetic parent and unreasonably withholds consent, the court may confirm the agreement. This is a limited judicial power, not a blanket exemption from the consent process.

What the High Court must assess

Section 295 restricts confirmation to cases where the commissioning parent or parents cannot give birth to a child and that condition is permanent and irreversible. The court must be satisfied that they are legally competent to enter the agreement, suitable to accept parenthood, and understand the agreement’s legal consequences and their rights and obligations.

The surrogate must also be competent and suitable, understand the legal consequences, and enter the arrangement for altruistic reasons rather than commercial purposes. The Act expressly says that she must not be using surrogacy as a source of income. She must have a documented history of at least one pregnancy and viable delivery, and must have a living child of her own. These are statutory criteria, not optional clinic preferences. The court also examines whether the agreement adequately addresses the child’s contact, care, upbringing and general welfare in a stable home environment, including what happens if one or both commissioning parents die, or if they divorce or separate before birth.

The court must consider all parties’ personal and family circumstances and, above all, the future child’s interests. Ask counsel in the relevant High Court division to confirm the required filing materials and evidence.

Genetic origin: the statutory limit

Section 294 provides that conception must use the gametes of both commissioning parents. If that is not possible for biological, medical or other valid reasons, the gamete of at least one commissioning parent must be used. Where there is a single commissioning parent, that person’s gamete must be used. The wording concerns the gametes of a commissioning parent, not merely a genetic relationship between the future child and another relative.

Donor eggs or sperm are not categorically excluded, but donor material cannot be used to avoid the requirement that at least one commissioning parent contribute a gamete. A plan relying only on donor gametes, with no gamete from a commissioning parent, does not fit the wording of section 294. A clinic’s willingness to create embryos, or the fact that an existing child would share the same donors, is not a substitute for satisfying the statutory test. If the proposed treatment plan is close to the boundary of the wording, obtain a written opinion from South African counsel before embryos are created or transferred.

Altruistic model: what may and may not be paid

Section 301 prohibits giving, promising, receiving or accepting a reward or compensation in cash or in kind in connection with a surrogate motherhood agreement, subject to the statutory exceptions. South Africa therefore does not permit a commercial fee for the surrogate’s participation. Section 295 reinforces this by requiring an altruistic arrangement and prohibiting the surrogate from using surrogacy as a source of income.

The Act recognises limited claims for compensation for expenses directly related to artificial fertilisation and pregnancy, the birth, and confirmation of the agreement; loss of earnings suffered by the surrogate because of the agreement; and insurance covering death or disability brought about by the pregnancy. A person providing a bona fide professional legal or medical service for confirmation or execution of the agreement may receive reasonable compensation. The statutory language matters: these are not permission to label any promised amount an “expense” or “allowance.” The connection to the listed purpose, the amount, supporting records and the terms of the agreement should be documented.

Agency, broker, recruitment, matching and coordination fees are not automatically lawful merely because they are called service fees. Section 301(3) expressly permits reasonable compensation for bona fide legal or medical services; section 303(2) separately restricts compensated announcements of willingness to enter a surrogacy agreement. Review the intermediary’s role and fee on the facts. A prohibited payment promise may be unenforceable, and contravening section 301 is an offence under section 305.

Timing and the legal effect of a valid agreement

Section 296 sets a strict sequence: artificial fertilisation may not take place before the court confirms the agreement, and it may not take place more than 18 months after the confirmation date. Fertilisation must also comply with the National Health Act 61 of 2003. If the 18-month window expires, the parties should not assume the old order still authorises treatment; counsel should assess the required next step before proceeding.

For a child born in accordance with a valid agreement, section 297 provides that the child is, for all purposes, the child of the commissioning parent or parents from birth. The surrogate must hand the child over as soon as reasonably possible after birth. The surrogate, her spouse or partner and relatives have no rights of parenthood or care, and no right of contact unless the agreement provides for contact. Subject to sections 292 and 293, the agreement generally cannot be terminated after artificial fertilisation has taken place.

Under section 297(2), a non-compliant agreement is invalid and the child is deemed to be the child of the woman who gave birth. An informal agreement, post-birth declaration or clinic record does not cure non-compliance. South African parentage is separate from nationality, passport eligibility, immigration status and foreign recognition.

Pregnancy termination and ending the agreement

The Act does not give commissioning parents control over a surrogate’s decision to terminate a pregnancy. Under section 300, a pregnancy termination may take place under the Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996, and the decision lies with the surrogate. She must inform the commissioning parents before the termination and consult them before it is carried out, but this consultation requirement should not be misread as a transfer of decision-making authority. Contract terms cannot safely be drafted on the assumption that a surrogate can be compelled to continue a pregnancy.

Section 298 provides a distinct right where the surrogate is also a genetic parent of the child: she may terminate the surrogate motherhood agreement by written notice to the court at any time before 60 days have elapsed after birth. The court must consider the termination after notice to the parties and a hearing, and may make another order in the child’s best interests. This provision is not a general 60-day cooling-off period for every gestational surrogate; its wording depends on the surrogate also being a genetic parent.

Section 299 spells out the consequences if a genetic surrogate terminates under section 298. If termination occurs after birth, the parental rights created under section 297 end and vest in the surrogate and her husband or partner, if any, or, if she has none, the commissioning father. If termination occurs before birth, the child is treated from birth as the child of the surrogate and her husband or partner, if any, or, if she has none, the commissioning father. Under this route, the commissioning parents have no parental rights and can obtain them only through adoption; the Act also excludes the child’s maintenance or succession claims against the commissioning parents and their relatives, subject to section 299’s terms. These are statutory consequences, not matters a contract clause can override. Obtain prompt, case-specific South African legal advice before taking or responding to any termination step.

Sections 298(3) and 300(3) address possible compensation liability for certain payments under section 301. Section 298(3) applies when a genetic surrogate terminates the agreement under section 298; section 300(3) applies when the pregnancy is terminated for a non-medical reason. Neither provision creates an automatic refund of all payments; application depends on the facts and exact statutory wording.

Cross-reference caution: section 297(1)(e) in the current text refers to sections 292 and 293, although sections 298–300 separately address agreement termination and termination of pregnancy. An indexed excerpt from the South African Law Reform Commission’s 2019 review appears to recommend changing the references to sections 298 and 300, while the 2025 draft Bill proposes sections 298 and 299. Confirm the recommendation against the full 2019 report. Neither a report recommendation nor a draft amendment is operative law by itself. Do not infer the intended effect from the cross-reference alone; South African counsel should verify the current enacted text and read sections 297–300 together before advising on termination.

Prohibited conduct, privacy and potential offences

Section 303 prohibits artificially fertilising a woman in execution of a surrogacy agreement, or assisting with that fertilisation, unless a court has authorised it under the Act. It also prohibits making known, for or with a view to compensation, that a person is or might be willing to enter a surrogacy agreement. Paid advertising, recruitment or introductions can therefore raise a separate legal issue from the surrogate’s own reimbursement. The exact facts and role of each intermediary matter; do not assume that changing the label of a payment removes the restriction.

Section 302 protects identity. The identity of parties to court proceedings about a surrogacy agreement may not be published without their written consent, and no person may publish facts revealing the identity of a child born as a result of surrogacy. This should be considered before publishing case stories, photographs, testimonials or social-media content, even if names are omitted but the child could still be identified.

Section 305 expressly treats contraventions of sections 301, 302 and 303 as offences. The Act provides for a fine or imprisonment of up to 10 years, or both, for an offence under the relevant subsection; a person convicted more than once may face imprisonment of up to 20 years, a fine or both. These are statutory maximums, not a prediction of sentence in any particular case. Liability depends on the charged provision, evidence, conviction and applicable law. Anyone considering a payment, advertisement or fertilisation step outside the clear statutory path should pause and obtain advice first.

Foreign participants and cross-border consequences

The statute’s formal requirements turn on domicile and where the agreement is entered into, not simply on the passport held by a participant. Section 292 requires at least one commissioning parent to be domiciled in South Africa and the agreement to be entered into there; it also sets a domicile requirement for the surrogate and her spouse or partner, subject to the court’s power to dispense with that latter requirement for good cause. The Act does not make citizenship and domicile interchangeable.Foreign nationality alone does not establish eligibility; the court must also apply section 295 to the facts.

For intended parents living abroad, check both jurisdictions before signing. A South African order does not guarantee foreign recognition of parentage, a passport, nationality, or permission for the child to leave or enter a country. These depend on the destination state’s law, procedure, facts and documents. Assess separately: (1) agreement validity in South Africa; (2) South African parentage; (3) nationality and travel documents; and (4) recognition or registration abroad. A positive answer to one does not resolve the others.

The 2025 draft Bill: proposed changes are not current law

On 26 September 2025, the Department of Social Development published the Children’s Amendment Bill, 2025 for public comment. The draft proposes changes to Chapter 19, including replacing domicile with ordinary residence in section 292; expressly including health and age in suitability criteria; removing the surrogate’s prior-pregnancy/viable-delivery and living-child criteria; requiring additional court material, including psychosocial and medical reports, agency/intermediary details, payment evidence and insurance estimates; changing the cross-reference in section 297(1)(e) to sections 298 and 299; and inserting a power to make surrogacy regulations in proposed section 303A. Publication in a Gazette does not itself make a proposal operative law. The latest official status located is a Parliamentary Portfolio Committee statement dated 13 May 2026: it reported that the Bill had been sent back to the Department for redrafting by the 7th Parliament in 2024, that the 2025 draft had received more than 1,800 submissions, and that the Department then expected to finalise it for submission to NEDLAC by July 2026 and to Cabinet/Parliament in March 2027. That was a timetable reported in May, not confirmation that the July milestone was met or of the Bill’s actual status on 26 October 2026. Its current enactment and commencement status therefore remains to be verified. Do not apply proposed provisions as current law.

Decision matrix: check the legal gate before acting

Use this matrix as an initial screening tool, not as a substitute for reviewing the actual agreement, evidence and current legislation. A single “no” on a mandatory statutory requirement can prevent the arrangement from proceeding as planned.

QuestionRule to screenPractical check
Is a signed agreement enough?No. Section 292 formalities and High Court confirmation are required.Confirm signature, place, domicile, consent and court jurisdiction.
Can treatment start before the order?No. Fertilisation must follow confirmation and occur within 18 months.Obtain the order first; record its date and check the treatment window.
Can the surrogate receive a fee?No commercial reward. Only statutory expense, lost-earnings, insurance and professional-service exceptions apply.Itemise and evidence each payment; review agency or broker fees separately.
Whose child is it at birth?Under a valid agreement, the commissioning parent(s); an invalid agreement triggers section 297(2).Do not assume an informal contract or clinic record cures non-compliance.
Can only donor gametes be used?Section 294 requires a gamete from both intended parents, or at least one where the statutory reason applies; a single parent must contribute their gamete.Confirm the genetic plan before embryos are created.
Does foreign citizenship decide eligibility?Not by itself. Domicile, court criteria and foreign-law issues must be assessed separately.Obtain South African and destination-country advice before signing.
Can someone advertise a willing surrogate for payment?Section 303(2) prohibits announcements for or with a view to compensation.Review any paid recruitment, matching or promotional arrangement.

Practical checklist and limits of this guide

Before any payment, embryo creation or fertilisation, collect evidence of each commissioning parent’s domicile and the surrogate’s domicile; document marital or permanent-partner status and obtain the required written consents. Ask the treating medical team to document the medical basis for the commissioning parent’s permanent and irreversible inability to give birth, and confirm the surrogate’s documented prior pregnancy and viable delivery and her living child. Check the planned gametes against section 294 before embryos are created.

Have South African counsel prepare and review the written agreement, the High Court application and supporting evidence. The agreement should deal clearly with permitted costs, loss of earnings, insurance, the child’s stable home and welfare, contact arrangements, and the consequences of death, divorce or separation before birth. Separate lawful reimbursement from any fee, reward or intermediary payment; retain invoices, records and the contractual basis for each permitted amount. Confirm the court order before any fertilisation, record the confirmation date, and ensure treatment occurs within 18 months and complies with health legislation.

Plan separately for birth registration, nationality, passports, immigration and foreign recognition of parentage. Verify these with competent authorities and destination-country counsel; South African approval and agency assurances do not guarantee foreign documents.This is not advice for a specific family or an exhaustive 2026 update.

Primary sources, judgments and draft legislation

These sources support the statutory outline and cited decisions; the legal position and later commencement notices must be checked again before reliance.

  1. Children’s Act 38 of 2005 — official Justice Department PDF
  2. AB and Another v Minister of Social Development [2016] ZACC 43 — judgment text (SAFLII)
  3. KB and Another v Minister of Social Development [2024] ZASCA 54 — Supreme Court of Appeal judgment
  4. Children’s Amendment Bill, 2025 — draft published for comment (26 September 2025)
  5. Portfolio Committee on Social Development, statement on delays in the Children’s Amendment Bill (13 May 2026)
  6. South African Law Reform Commission, Review of Legislation Administered by the Department of Social Development (2019)

Guides for South Africa

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards