South Africa · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Redacted refusal document and indexed evidence on a legal work desk

South Africa: Surrogacy refusals, disputes and legal remedies

Which refusal and which remedy?

A refusal in a South African surrogacy case is not a single type of decision. A High Court may decline to confirm a surrogate motherhood agreement; a clinic or intermediary may refuse a service; parties may disagree about performance, payments or the child; or a public office may reject a document. The available remedy depends on who acted, whether the agreement was validly confirmed, whether fertilisation or birth has occurred and whose rights are affected. Identify the disputed act and its date before choosing a court procedure.

Use three separate routes. For a High Court confirmation refusal, obtain the order and reasons, assess whether evidence can be supplemented or whether an appeal or other court procedure is available. For a private contractual or clinical dispute, review the signed agreement, statutory prohibitions, professional duties and the appropriate civil or regulatory forum. For a public official's refusal or failure to decide, assess administrative-law remedies, including written reasons and judicial review where the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act (PAJA) applies. Neither a complaint nor a demand letter automatically suspends time limits.

Court confirmation and treatment

Sections 292–295 of the Children's Act 38 of 2005 control High Court confirmation. The agreement must be written, signed and entered into in South Africa; at least one commissioning parent (or the single commissioning parent) must be domiciled there. The surrogate and any spouse or partner generally must also be domiciled there, but section 292(2) permits a court, on good cause, to dispense with that particular domicile requirement. The agreement must be confirmed by the High Court linked to the commissioning parent's domicile or habitual residence. There is no equivalent general waiver of the commissioning parent's domicile condition in section 292.

A confirmation refusal may concern the written consents required by section 293; the genetic-origin rule in section 294; or the conditions in section 295. Those conditions include the commissioning parent’s or parents’ permanent and irreversible inability to give birth, their competence, suitability and understanding of the agreement; the surrogate’s competence and suitability, understanding of the legal consequences, not using surrogacy as a source of income, an altruistic rather than commercial purpose, a documented history of at least one pregnancy and viable delivery, and a living child of her own. The agreement must make adequate provision for the child’s contact, care, upbringing and general welfare in a stable home, including the child’s position if a commissioning parent dies or the commissioning parents separate or divorce before birth. Section 293(3) permits confirmation if the surrogate’s spouse or partner, who is not the child’s genetic parent, unreasonably withholds consent. Section 294 permits use of the gametes of at least one commissioning parent where use of both is not possible for biological, medical or other valid reasons; it does not expressly provide a route with no genetic contribution from a commissioning parent. The court considers the child’s interests above all. Missing evidence may sometimes be supplied later, but a substantive statutory barrier cannot be fixed by paperwork alone.

Ask a South African litigation lawyer to classify the court's decision before acting. Check whether it was a final dismissal, postponement, request for further evidence or a defect in the proposed order. Obtain the filed papers, transcript if available, full reasons, proof of service and any deadline set by the court rules. Supplementation or a corrected application may sometimes be appropriate; appeal, rescission or variation depend on the kind of order and procedural requirements. This article does not assert a universal surrogacy appeal period or promise that a different judge will approve the same facts.

Section 296 prohibits artificial fertilisation before confirmation and after 18 months from confirmation; section 303 restricts fertilisation or assistance without judicial authorisation. If a clinic proposes proceeding while approval is pending, do not treat a contract, agency assurance or foreign authorisation as a substitute for the South African court order. Preserve treatment records and request a written explanation of any proposed change. If fertilisation happened without a valid authorisation, seek urgent specialist advice: subsequent approval cannot safely be assumed to retroactively cure the original defect.

Parentage and termination disputes

Under section 297(1), a child born in accordance with a valid agreement is, from birth, the child of the commissioning parent or parents, and the surrogate must hand the child over as soon as reasonably possible. The surrogate, her spouse or partner, and her relatives have no parental or care rights under the arrangement and no right to contact with the child unless the agreement provides for it. The child has no maintenance or succession claim against the surrogate, her spouse or partner, or any of their relatives. These consequences depend on a valid agreement; section 298 provides a narrow statutory termination route for a surrogate who is also a genetic parent, discussed below. For a handover or contact dispute, produce the confirmed agreement, court order and birth or hospital records. Seek child-focused urgent judicial relief if necessary; do not rely on force, threats, private removal or disclosure of confidential identities.

Section 297(2) creates a severe consequence where the surrogate motherhood agreement does not comply with the Act: the arrangement is invalid and a child born from action taken under it is deemed the child of the woman who gave birth. That is not the same legal position as under a valid confirmed agreement. A contract recital, DNA report or foreign document does not by itself repair non-compliance. If parentage is contested, counsel must analyse the exact statutory defect, existing orders, rights of the child and any lawful route to a fresh order; never assume automatic parental status.

A narrow statutory termination right is especially important. Under section 298, a surrogate who is also a genetic parent may file written notice with the court before 60 days have elapsed after birth. After notification to parties and a hearing, the court determines voluntariness and understanding and must terminate confirmation when the statutory conditions are met; it can also make an appropriate order in the child's best interests. This is not a general right for every gestational surrogate to cancel after fertilisation, and it is not merely a private withdrawal letter.

Termination under section 298 triggers the parentage consequences in section 299: rights may shift to the surrogate and, depending on the statutory family configuration, her husband or partner or the commissioning father; other commissioning parents may lose parental rights and may need adoption to acquire them. The timing, whether before or after birth, matters. Section 298(3) restricts the surrogate's liability for exercising that right, subject to the statutory reimbursement qualification linked to section 301. Counsel should request urgent directions where a child's care or registration is immediately in dispute, rather than treating reimbursement as a substitute for parental rights.

A decision to terminate a pregnancy belongs to the surrogate under section 300 and the applicable Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act. Section 300 requires prior information and consultation with commissioning parents; consultation is not their veto. The agreement ends if the pregnancy is terminated lawfully. The section generally excludes liability for exercising the right, with a limited statutory reimbursement rule for non-medical termination involving payments under section 301. Do not draft or threaten specific-performance orders compelling pregnancy, termination or a medical procedure. Medical urgency requires independent clinical advice.

Payments, services and public refusals

Section 301 prohibits giving, promising or receiving a reward or compensation in cash or kind in connection with surrogacy, subject to defined exceptions: expenses directly related to fertilisation, pregnancy, birth and confirmation of the agreement; the surrogate’s proven loss of earnings; insurance covering her against death or disability brought about by pregnancy; and reasonable compensation for bona fide legal or medical professional services under section 301(3). Whether an invoice qualifies depends on its true purpose, supporting proof and recipient, not its label as a ‘support fee’. Compile invoices, payment records, medical records and itemised budgets before demanding repayment. A prohibited promised fee does not become enforceable because it appears in a signed agreement; suspected criminal conduct requires separate assessment. Section 303(2) separately prohibits announcing, for or with a view to compensation, that a person is or may be willing to enter a surrogacy agreement; paid recruitment or advertising should be assessed separately.

A clinic's refusal to treat, an agency's failure to supply records or a disagreement over medical expenses is not automatically an administrative act under PAJA. Ask who owes which duty: hospital or professional, service provider, commissioning parent or surrogate. Request the precise contractual provision, clinical reason or professional standard cited, and preserve emails and consent forms. A civil claim, professional complaint or negotiated correction may be suitable, but no remedy authorises treatment without informed consent or contrary to the Children’s Act. Avoid assuming that every agency is licensed or state-regulated under one surrogacy-specific system.

For a refusal by the Department of Home Affairs or another public decision-maker, first identify the actual decision, empowering law and affected person. Constitutional section 33 protects lawful, reasonable, procedurally fair administrative action; PAJA may permit review if its definition and exclusions are satisfied. A registration or documentation problem may also require a correction under the specific registration legislation, rather than only PAJA. Ask for the written decision, reasons, official reference number and existing internal appeal route. A judge's refusal to confirm an agreement is not itself an administrative decision under PAJA.

Deadlines, evidence and next actions

Under PAJA section 5, a person materially and adversely affected who has not received reasons generally has 90 days from awareness (actual or reasonably expected) to request written reasons; the administrator generally has 90 days to provide them. PAJA section 7 ordinarily requires judicial review without unreasonable delay and within 180 days, counted by the statutory rule after internal remedies or awareness of the action and reasons. Available internal remedies ordinarily must first be exhausted, subject to a judicial exemption; extensions involve section 9 and judicial assessment. These periods are not the deadlines for appealing a High Court surrogacy order.

Where PAJA applies, potential relief under section 8 includes an order for reasons, setting aside and remitting an administrative decision, directions to decide, a declaration or interim protection. Substitution of the official's decision and compensation are exceptional remedies, not routine damages. The applicant must demonstrate the relevant legal defect, such as lack of authority, procedural unfairness, material error of law or irrationality; disagreement alone is insufficient. A court will assess standing, admissibility, urgency, interests of the child and proper respondents. Costs and case-specific procedural rules need independent advice.

Build one dated evidence file with the proposed and signed agreement, proof of every signature and consent, South African confirmation order or refusal and reasons, expert medical material, genetic information handled confidentially, fertility dates, invoices, communications, receipts, proof of domicile and hospital or birth records when relevant. Make a chronology of the exact refusal, the person who received it and all follow-up actions. Keep originals unchanged; preserve email headers and secure access. Ask counsel to separate admissible evidence from allegations and privileged material, and redact children's and parties' identifying data in working copies.

Section 302 imposes a specific confidentiality rule: the identities of parties to court proceedings concerning a surrogacy agreement may not be published without their written consent, and no person may publish facts that reveal the identity of a child born as a result of such an agreement. Share records through secure channels and redact identifying details in working copies. Do not publish case materials merely because they are accessible.

A practical first response is to stop irreversible steps, secure the decision and record its date, check for immediate child-safety or medical risks, and obtain South African counsel familiar with Chapter 19 and the relevant court rules. Send one precise written request identifying the act, the correction or reasons sought and the supporting record. Calculate all possible deadlines independently; seek urgent interim relief only where the legal grounds and facts warrant it. Track who must act next and confirm receipt. Negotiation can narrow issues, but do not miss a court deadline while waiting for a reply.

If intended parents or a child have another nationality, a South African agreement or order does not guarantee foreign parentage recognition, citizenship, a passport or permission to travel. Those questions belong to the destination state's law and the applicable document and immigration process. Keep a separate dossier of court orders, civil records, translations and legalisation requirements. Do not promise cross-border recognition as a remedy for an invalid domestic arrangement, and do not move a child while parental authority or travel permissions are disputed without specific legal advice.

The Constitutional Court’s majority in AB and Another v Minister of Social Development [2016] ZACC 43 did not confirm the High Court order declaring section 294 unconstitutional and upheld the appeal. Section 294 permits use of at least one commissioning parent’s gamete where use of both is not possible for biological, medical or other valid reasons; it does not state a route requiring no genetic contribution from a commissioning parent. Infertility or inability to provide a gamete is not, by itself, a statutory waiver. A refusal may be challengeable for a proven legal or procedural error, but payment or an intention to parent does not replace the statutory conditions. Before advising on a live case, counsel should check the full judgment and any later binding authority. Identify the decision-maker and statutory stage, protect the child and medical autonomy, preserve evidence, and choose the remedy with a lawyer before any deadline expires. The statutory consolidation is dated 28 May 2025; South African counsel must confirm whether any later amendment or commencement notice affects Chapter 19 before relying on this analysis.

Legal sources

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards