South Africa surrogacy: can foreign intended parents qualify?
The short answer
Foreign citizenship is not, by itself, an express disqualification under Chapter 19 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005. The decisive early question is whether at least one commissioning parent is domiciled in South Africa when the surrogacy agreement is entered into. The agreement must also be made in South Africa and confirmed by the appropriate High Court before artificial fertilisation.
Other statutory checks still apply: legal capacity and suitability, permanent and irreversible inability to give birth, required partner consent, the genetic-link rule, and a credible plan for the child’s care and best interests. A clinic’s willingness, a visa, South African relatives or a future move do not replace these tests.
In practice, the strongest application is consistent on paper and in real life: it explains where the applicants actually live, why South Africa is their domicile, which court has jurisdiction, who will raise the child, and what happens if plans change.
Citizenship, immigration status and domicile are different questions
Sections 292–295 do not set South African citizenship as a standalone eligibility condition for commissioning parents. They do, however, impose a domicile requirement. A foreign national may therefore be considered, but foreign nationality does not relax the statutory test and does not automatically establish domicile.
Domicile is not the same as a passport, permanent residence, a temporary visa, tax residence, a mailing address or South African property ownership. Immigration permission is separate. Because a domicile of choice requires lawful presence, counsel should check the actual immigration position and whether the proposed stay is consistent with an intention to settle indefinitely.
The requirement in section 292(1)(c) applies when the agreement is entered into. It is not safely postponed until birth or treated as a box that can be completed after a clinic has begun a cycle. If no commissioning parent can establish South African domicile at the relevant time, do not assume that the court can simply waive the problem. Section 292(2) allows the court, on good cause shown, to dispense with the domicile requirement for the surrogate mother and her spouse or partner under section 292(1)(d); it does not set out an equivalent express waiver for a commissioning parent.
How South African domicile is assessed
Under section 1 of the Domicile Act 3 of 1992, a person with the necessary legal capacity acquires a domicile of choice when lawfully present in a place and intending to settle there for an indefinite period. Both elements matter: physical presence must be real, and the intention must be more than a convenient statement made for the surrogacy application.
The court assesses the evidence as a whole. Relevant facts may include where the applicant lives day to day, employment and the likely duration of that employment, the home available to the intended family, immigration permissions, financial arrangements, close family ties, and whether the person has established a settled life elsewhere. No single item—such as owning a flat, visiting frequently or keeping citizenship—necessarily decides the question.
A domicile of origin may continue until another domicile is acquired, but applicants should not rely on that proposition without analysing their own history. A person who has lived and worked abroad for years may have acquired a domicile of choice there, depending on lawful presence and intention.
Court jurisdiction and the 2025 EW decision
There are two related but distinct checks. First, section 292(1)(c) requires at least one commissioning parent to be domiciled in South Africa. Second, section 292(1)(e) requires confirmation by a High Court within whose area the commissioning parent or parents are domiciled or habitually resident. Establishing domicile somewhere in South Africa does not automatically answer every question about the correct court division.
In Ex Parte EW and Others [2025] ZAGPPHC 109, decided on 24 January 2025, a South African citizen and his Polish husband lived and worked in Switzerland. The court expressly accepted that the two men met section 295(a)’s condition that the inability to give birth to a child be permanent and irreversible. It nevertheless dismissed the application because South African domicile and territorial jurisdiction were not established, and the evidence about the child’s future home, finances and support was inadequate. The judgment’s stated grounds for dismissal were these evidentiary and jurisdictional problems, not Polish nationality or the same-sex marriage. This is a fact-specific High Court decision, not a blanket eligibility rule.
A court may reject an application if the claimed legal connection to South Africa conflicts with the applicants’ actual arrangements or depends on conditional future plans. Support the domicile case and child-care plan with consistent documents and, where appropriate, corroborating affidavits—not declarations of intention alone.
Single applicants, marriage and permanent relationships
The Act expressly refers to a single commissioning parent in sections 292 and 294. Marriage is therefore not stated as a universal prerequisite. A single applicant must still satisfy the other requirements, including domicile, competence, suitability, the medical criterion and the genetic-link rule. The fact that single applicants are contemplated does not mean every individual case must be approved.
Section 293(1) adds an important rule: where a commissioning parent is married or involved in a permanent relationship, that person’s husband, wife or partner must give written consent and become a party to the agreement before the court may confirm it. The trigger is not limited to a formally registered marriage; a permanent relationship can matter even if the couple is unmarried.
Identify each role accurately in the draft agreement and court papers: who is a commissioning parent, and who is joining as a spouse or partner under section 293. Do not omit a current spouse or permanent partner because the relationship is strained, private or described differently in everyday life. If consent is disputed or unavailable, obtain advice before proceeding; the specific statutory exception for unreasonable withholding in section 293(3) concerns the surrogate mother’s non-genetic husband or partner, not a general waiver for an intended parent’s partner.
Medical and genetic eligibility
Section 295(a) says the court may not confirm an agreement unless the commissioning parent or parents are unable to give birth to a child and the condition is permanent and irreversible. Section 295(b) also requires legal competence, suitability to accept parenthood, and understanding of the agreement, the Act and the parties’ rights and obligations. A wish to avoid pregnancy, convenience or a clinic’s intake policy should not be assumed to meet the statutory wording.
The evidential record should explain the relevant medical circumstances clearly and consistently. Specialist medical material may be needed, alongside the other reports or affidavits the court requires on the facts. The Act does not provide a universal document checklist that guarantees confirmation; the court evaluates the application as a whole.
Section 294 also restricts the genetic arrangement. The intended child must be conceived using the gametes of both commissioning parents, unless that is not possible for biological, medical or other valid reasons, in which case the gamete of at least one commissioning parent is required. Where there is a single commissioning parent, the statute refers to that person’s gamete. If the proposed plan involves no gamete from an intended parent, or relies on a reason for using only one, obtain specialist South African advice before committing to treatment.
Best interests and a credible home plan
Section 295(d) requires the agreement to make adequate provision for the child’s contact, care, upbringing and general welfare in a stable home environment. It must address the child’s position if a commissioning parent dies or the intended parents divorce or separate before birth. Under section 295(e), the court considers the personal circumstances and family situations of everyone involved, with the future child’s best interests paramount.
For applicants living abroad or moving between countries, explain the actual post-birth plan rather than relying on a vague intention to relocate. The court may need to understand where the child will live, who will provide daily care, whether housing and income are credible, what support is available, and who could care for the child if both intended parents cannot do so. A proposed guardian who lives in another country is not automatically disqualifying, but the plan should explain why that arrangement is workable and in the child’s interests.
These points are not a separate citizenship test and do not mean the child must always be raised in South Africa. They are part of the court’s case-specific assessment. The 2025 EW decision shows how gaps in evidence about home, finances, family support and future residence can undermine an application even where the applicants say they intend to return. Separately, section 295(c) requires the surrogate mother to be legally competent and suitable, understand the agreement’s effects, act altruistically rather than for income, have a documented history of at least one pregnancy and viable delivery, and have a living child of her own.
Eligibility evidence matrix
Use this matrix as a preparation tool, not as an official closed list of documents. It separates the legal question from the evidence that may help answer it. A South African lawyer should tailor the supporting record to the facts and the court division.
| Issue to test | What the law asks | Evidence to discuss with counsel |
|---|---|---|
| Nationality and status | Citizenship is not stated as the decisive criterion; domicile is. | Passports; current immigration permissions; a clear timeline of residence and work. |
| Domicile | Lawful presence plus intention to settle indefinitely. | Home and lease/title records; employment; finances; family ties; sworn evidence consistent with actual plans. |
| Court jurisdiction | A High Court must have the statutory territorial connection. | Proposed address and actual living arrangements; counsel’s written venue analysis. |
| Family status | Single applicant is contemplated; spouse/permanent partner consent and party status may be required. | Marriage/partnership history; written consent; agreement identifying each party’s role. |
| Medical and genetics | Permanent, irreversible inability to give birth; section 294 genetic-link rule. | Relevant specialist reports and documented explanation of the proposed gamete plan. |
| Child’s future | Suitable parent(s), stable home, care and contingency arrangements. | Housing, income, support network, care plan, guardianship/contingency provisions. |
Agreement sequence and consequences
The statutory sequence matters. The surrogacy agreement must be written, signed by all parties and entered into in South Africa. It must be confirmed by the High Court before artificial fertilisation. Under section 296, fertilisation must not take place before confirmation or after 18 months have elapsed from the date of confirmation. Coordinate the legal timetable with the clinic; do not treat a court order as an indefinite authorisation.
The legal effect of a valid agreement is substantial: under section 297, the child born in accordance with it is for all purposes the child of the commissioning parent or parents from birth, and the surrogate generally has no parental rights, subject to the Act’s specific provisions. By contrast, section 297(2) states that an agreement that does not comply with the Act is invalid and the child is deemed for all purposes to be the child of the woman who gave birth. This is a major reason not to proceed informally or to leave eligibility questions until after treatment.
Separate rules on surrogate consent or termination, permitted expense reimbursement, clinic compliance, birth registration, nationality and international travel are outside this article’s scope; they may still affect the overall plan.
Practical pre-filing checklist
Before signing or starting treatment, ask South African counsel to answer these questions in writing. If a key answer is uncertain, pause and resolve it rather than assuming that later paperwork will cure the problem.
- Which commissioning parent can prove South African domicile on the date the agreement will be entered into, and what evidence supports lawful presence and an indefinite intention to settle?
- Does the chosen High Court have territorial jurisdiction, and do the affidavits accurately describe where each applicant lives and where the child will be raised?
- Have all marital and permanent-relationship facts been disclosed, and has any spouse or partner whose consent is required signed and joined the agreement?
- Do the medical materials address permanent and irreversible inability to give birth and the applicants’ suitability? Does the gamete plan comply with section 294?
- Does the agreement address stable care, contact, upbringing, death, separation or divorce, and a realistic support and contingency plan?
- Is the agreement signed and confirmed before fertilisation, and can the treatment occur within the 18-month statutory window?
- Have separate advice been obtained on immigration status, foreign parentage recognition, nationality, passport and travel requirements in every relevant country?
Scope, sources and review limits
It is not individual advice and does not decide a particular applicant’s domicile, visa status, medical eligibility, court venue or likely outcome. The links below identify the main legislation and a reported High Court decision used in the analysis.
The official Department of Justice PDF of the Children’s Act was consulted, but current amendments and commencement status must be rechecked before filing. Before relying on the case, South African counsel should compare the complete signed/revised judgment, especially the cross-references in paragraphs 55 and 57; those references remain unverified.
For an individual case, South African counsel must assess domicile and jurisdiction on the facts, then review the agreement, medical evidence, relationship disclosures and child-care plan. Recheck legislation and case law before filing.
