South Africa · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Redacted agreement papers, an itemized payment schedule and a calculator arranged for a contract-risk review.
Illustrative image only; the papers are not real contracts, invoices or court forms.

South Africa surrogacy: contracts, agencies and payments

The short answer: altruistic surrogacy, not a commercial package

South Africa’s Children’s Act 38 of 2005 regulates surrogate motherhood through Chapter 19. The central financial rule is restrictive: a surrogate may not be paid a fee for carrying a child, and a third party cannot make a prohibited payment lawful simply by calling it coordination, support, a package or an administrative charge. A promise to pay compensation connected with the arrangement is generally not enforceable unless it fits a statutory exception.

The main exceptions are expenses directly related to artificial fertilisation, pregnancy, birth and confirmation of the agreement; the surrogate’s actual loss of earnings; specified insurance against death or disability caused by pregnancy; and reasonable compensation for bona fide professional legal or medical services. Those categories are not interchangeable. A genuine clinic invoice is not the same thing as an agency’s matching or coordination fee.

Check validity before discussing the price

Payment terms cannot repair an invalid agreement. Under sections 292–295, the agreement must be written and signed by all parties, entered into in South Africa, and confirmed by the High Court with jurisdiction where the commissioning parent or parents are domiciled or habitually resident. At least one commissioning parent must be domiciled in South Africa when the agreement is made. The surrogate and her spouse or partner, if any, must also be domiciled there; the court may dispense with the latter requirement on good cause shown.

Section 293 addresses consent separately from domicile: the spouse or permanent partner of a commissioning parent and the surrogate’s spouse or permanent partner must ordinarily consent in writing and become parties to the agreement. Under section 293(3), a court may nevertheless confirm the agreement if the surrogate’s husband or partner is not the child’s genetic parent and unreasonably withholds consent. This narrow exception is not a general waiver of the commissioning parent’s partner-consent requirement.

The Act also regulates partner consent, the genetic origin of the child, and the court’s assessment of the parties. The commissioning parent or parents must meet the statutory permanent and irreversible inability-to-give-birth requirement and suitability criteria. The surrogate must be suitable, understand the consequences, have a documented history of at least one pregnancy and viable delivery and a living child of her own, and enter the arrangement for altruistic rather than income-producing reasons. The agreement must address the child’s care and welfare, including the death, separation or divorce of the commissioning parents. As a rule, both commissioning parents’ gametes must be used; if biological, medical or other valid reasons make that impossible, at least one commissioning parent’s gamete must be used. If there is a single commissioning parent, that person’s gamete must be used.

  • Artificial fertilisation must not take place before court confirmation.
  • Fertilisation must take place within 18 months after confirmation; it must also comply with the National Health Act.
  • Do not assume that a signed private agreement, a clinic’s acceptance or a payment receipt substitutes for the court order.
  • If the agreement does not comply with the Act, section 297(2) treats it as invalid and deems a child born as a result of steps taken under it to be the child of the woman who gave birth. If validity is in doubt, get South African advice before proceeding.

Which payments may be allowed?

Section 301 prohibits giving, promising, receiving or agreeing to receive a reward or compensation in cash or in kind in connection with a surrogate motherhood agreement, subject to the statutory exceptions. Under section 301(2), a compensation promise to the surrogate or another person is generally unenforceable unless the claim falls within the listed categories. The expense category is limited to costs directly related to fertilisation, pregnancy, birth and confirmation of the agreement; it is not an open-ended allowance for the surrogate’s time or inconvenience.

Loss of earnings means earnings actually lost because of the arrangement, not a bonus for agreeing to participate or for delivering a child. The insurance exception concerns cover for death or disability brought about by pregnancy. Section 301(3) separately addresses bona fide professional legal and medical services. The statute does not provide a universal price list, fixed allowance or automatic approval for every expense commonly mentioned by agencies.

  • Potentially eligible: documented, directly related pregnancy or birth expenses; actual lost earnings; qualifying insurance; reasonable bona fide legal or medical fees.
  • High risk: a fee for carrying or handing over the child, a success bonus, a disguised gift, an unexplained flat allowance, or payment for introducing or matching a surrogate.
  • Travel, childcare, clothing, supplements, household help or phone costs should not be assumed lawful merely because they appear on another person’s budget. Show the actual purpose, amount, timing and direct connection, and obtain case-specific legal advice.

Agency, coordinator and introduction fees are a separate risk

Section 301(3) does not authorise payment for every service that may be helpful. The service must genuinely be a professional legal or medical service, and the compensation must be reasonable. In Ex Parte HPP and Others; Ex Parte DME and Others (2017), the High Court considered a R5,000 fee for surrogacy coordination. The court held that the coordinator’s services did not fall within the permitted direct-expense or professional legal/medical categories and declared the facilitation agreements unlawful and unenforceable.

Section 303(2) also prohibits making known, for compensation, that a person is or may be willing to enter a surrogate motherhood agreement. In Ex Parte HPP, the court treated a paid introduction fee as unlawful and reiterated the concern about commercial facilitation. Do not assume that a matching fee becomes permissible because it is invoiced separately, described as emotional support or bundled with other services.

An agency may be involved without charging a fee, and a clinic may provide actual medical services. But the roles and money flows must be examined separately. Ask who performed each service, what qualifications they hold, what the invoice covers, who receives the money and whether any amount rewards the introduction, recruitment or coordination of the surrogacy arrangement.

What the court needs to see

In Ex parte WH (2011), the High Court directed that where an agency is involved, the application should reveal the agency’s business, whether money is paid to or by it, what it did to introduce the surrogate, how it learned that the person might be willing to act as a surrogate, and whether the surrogate received compensation from the agency or commissioning parents. The judgment called for an agency affidavit with these particulars. Ex Parte HPP reiterated the need for full and candid disclosure, including payments to a coordinator.

Ex Parte KAF (2018) illustrates a related point: the court examined the surrogate’s financial position and the proposed expense schedule. An unexplained global amount and incomplete financial information raised concerns. After further disclosure and a breakdown of proposed items, the court accepted the particular expense arrangement on those facts. That outcome does not establish universal approved rates or mean that every itemised payment is lawful.

These judgments provide court guidance, not proof of a general agency-licensing regime. A lawyer should be able to trace each payment from the agreement to an invoice, recipient and supporting record. Hiding a fee in a separate contract or omitting the agency from the papers can create a more serious problem than the wording of the invoice alone.

Build an evidence-based payment schedule

Use a schedule that identifies every payment separately. For each item, record the recipient, purpose, amount or calculation, payment date or trigger, supporting evidence and the statutory category relied on. This is a practical evidence recommendation, not an exhaustive statutory form prescribed by the Act. The court must be able to assess the substance of the transaction, not just the label given to it.

Keep the following records where relevant:

  • Expenses: quotes, itemised invoices and receipts showing what was bought, for whom and why it was directly connected to fertilisation, pregnancy, birth or confirmation.
  • Lost earnings: the actual period of absence and evidence such as payslips, employer confirmation or other reliable records showing the loss rather than a negotiated reward.
  • Insurance: the policy, insured person, covered risk, duration and proof that the cover concerns death or disability brought about by pregnancy.
  • Legal or medical fees: the provider’s identity and professional status, a description of the actual service, an itemised invoice and a basis for assessing reasonableness.
  • Agency involvement: the service agreement, all invoices, bank transfers, messages about introductions and any payments to or from the surrogate or another intermediary.

Clauses to review before signing

The surrogacy agreement, legal-service engagement, medical-service engagement and expense schedule should not blur together. Separate documents may be practical, but they must describe the real arrangement honestly.

Ask South African counsel to review whether the documents:

  • list each allowed expense and explain how it will be evidenced, paid and reconciled, without a disguised fee for the surrogate’s participation;
  • separate genuine legal and medical work from coordination, matching, recruitment, emotional support or project management;
  • identify every agency and disclose the full payment flow, including amounts paid by third parties;
  • address confidentiality and publicity by clinics or intermediaries: section 302(1) restricts publication of the identity of parties to surrogacy court proceedings without the written consent of those concerned, while section 302(2) prohibits publishing facts that identify a child born under a surrogacy agreement;
  • avoid a success fee, a payment for handing over the child, or a penalty that purports to override statutory rights; and
  • address changes, cancellation, pregnancy termination, insurance and disputes consistently with the Act. Section 300 gives the decision to terminate the pregnancy to the surrogate, but she must inform the commissioning parents before termination and consult them beforehand; do not assume a private clause can override that statutory process.

Payment-risk matrix: use it as a screening tool, not a guarantee

The table below is a first-pass screen. The legal result depends on the real service, purpose, evidence, timing and facts. “Lower risk” does not mean pre-approved by a court.

Payment or arrangementInitial legal assessmentPrudent next step
Direct pregnancy, birth or confirmation expensePotentially within section 301(2)(a) if genuinely direct and supported.Itemise the cost, keep invoices and explain the connection.
Surrogate’s lost earningsPotentially within section 301(2)(b) if earnings were actually lost.Document the period and evidence the loss; do not add a reward.
Pregnancy-related death/disability insurancePotentially within section 301(2)(c).Keep the policy and confirm the covered risk.
Bona fide legal or medical serviceReasonable compensation may be allowed by section 301(3).Verify the provider, actual work and itemised fee.
Agency, coordinator, matching or introduction feeHigh risk; HPP treated the facilitation fee as unlawful and unenforceable.Do not pay or sign without independent South African legal advice; disclose the agency.
Unexplained lump sum or disguised benefitHigh scrutiny; the label does not prove that the payment is allowed.Request a breakdown, evidence and a written legal assessment.
Fertilisation before court confirmationNot permitted under section 296.Pause the procedure until a valid court order is in place.

A practical checklist for intended parents and the surrogate

Before committing money, ask the attorney handling the High Court application to confirm the current statutory requirements and the proposed payment structure in writing. The following checklist helps identify missing information; it does not replace the court’s assessment.

  • Confirm that the agreement, signatures, domicile facts, partner consents, genetic-origin requirements and section 295 criteria have been addressed.
  • Confirm that court approval will be obtained before any artificial fertilisation and that the 18-month window will be observed.
  • List every recipient and every payment, including payments to clinics, lawyers, agencies, coordinators and the surrogate.
  • Classify each item under the correct statutory category; remove or redesign any fee that appears to reward participation, recruitment or introduction.
  • Collect itemised invoices, proof of lost earnings, insurance documents and a clear explanation of expenses.
  • Obtain the agency’s written description of its role and all relevant payment information; ask counsel whether an agency affidavit is required.
  • Ensure that all payments and side agreements are disclosed candidly in the court papers.

If a fee has already been paid or a dispute has started

Preserve the signed agreements, amendments, invoices, receipts, bank statements, messages, agency advertisements and medical or legal engagement letters. Do not alter records, create a backdated explanation or ask another party to conceal a payment. Pause any further questionable payment and do not begin fertilisation unless the required court confirmation is in place.

In HPP, the facilitation agreements were declared unlawful and unenforceable, but the court still confirmed the underlying surrogacy agreements on the particular facts. The judgment expressly treated that as a discretionary, case-specific decision and warned that a later court may take a different view. Do not treat the case as permission to use paid coordinators. A separate question—whether money already paid can be recovered—depends on the transaction and applicable contract law; the Act and the cases do not support promising an automatic refund.

Contravention of sections 301 and 303 is an offence under section 305. HPP described the statutory penalties it considered as up to 10 years’ imprisonment for a first conviction and up to 20 years for a repeat conviction, or a fine or both. The penalty text and its present application must be checked against the current consolidated Act before reliance. If the payment may be unlawful, obtain independent South African legal advice promptly and make complete disclosure to the lawyer handling the court application.

Scope and source limitations

This article addresses South African contracts, intermediary services and payments. It does not determine citizenship, immigration, travel documents, recognition of parentage abroad, clinic licensing, tax treatment or the law of another country. Those questions require separate analysis and may change the practical result.

No post-2025 change to Chapter 19 was confirmed, but that is not proof that none exists.

Sources and legal materials

  1. Children’s Act 38 of 2005 — official enacted text (not a consolidated 2026 edition)
  2. Children’s Act — consolidated text dated 28 May 2025
  3. Ex parte WH and Others [2011] ZAGPPHC 185 — reproduced judgment text
  4. Ex Parte HPP and Others; Ex Parte DME and Others [2017] ZAGPPHC 70 — reproduced judgment text
  5. Ex Parte KAF and Others [2018] ZAGPJHC 529 — reproduced judgment text
  6. Department of Justice and Constitutional Development — Children’s Act page
  7. Proclamation 263 of 2025 — commencement of specified sections of the Children’s Amendment Act, 2022

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards