Spain · Legal status and models

Open legal reference books and carefully arranged case papers on a desk in a quiet research room.

Spain Surrogacy Law: Contract Nullity, Advertising and Parentage

Quick answer and scope

Spain’s surrogacy framework is restrictive on two separate levels: the agreement itself is void, and a foreign document naming intended parents does not automatically establish parentage in Spain. Article 10 of Law 14/2006 applies whether the arrangement is paid or unpaid. Maternity is determined by the fact of birth, while the law preserves the possibility of a biological father claiming paternity under ordinary rules. For children born abroad, the Civil Registry approach changed on 1 May 2025: none of the following is an acceptable title for registering birth and parentage through the surrogacy route: a foreign civil-registry certificate, a simple declaration accompanied by a medical certificate of birth, or a final foreign judgment.

This page answers a narrow question: what Spanish law says about the validity of a surrogacy arrangement, whether paying compensation changes the result, and what Spanish registration authorities can accept when a child is born abroad. It is a country-framework overview, not an individual eligibility assessment or a guarantee about a particular case. Nationality, habitual residence, genetic links, the place and date of birth, the exact foreign proceedings, and the child’s current living arrangements may affect the available route. They do not turn a void Spanish surrogacy contract into an enforceable agreement. The country where treatment takes place may regulate clinics, consent and contract formation differently, while Spanish law governs how Spanish authorities assess parentage and civil registration. These are separate legal questions: permission in one jurisdiction is not a promise of recognition in another. This article does not compare every destination country or determine nationality, passport eligibility or immigration status; each requires separate advice under the relevant rules.

The governing statutory rules

The controlling statutory rule is Article 10(1) of Law 14/2006 on Assisted Human Reproduction Techniques. It declares null and void a contract under which a woman agrees to gestate and relinquish maternal parentage in favour of the contracting party or a third person, whether the arrangement is made “with or without a price.” Article 32 of Organic Law 1/2023 repeats this rule and calls for institutional information about its illegality. The result is not merely that a contract must be carefully drafted: the contract cannot be relied on as a valid legal instrument to transfer maternity to the intended parent.

There is no altruistic-contract exception in Article 10. If no payment is promised, the agreement is still null because the statute expressly covers arrangements with or without a price. Calling a payment “expenses,” using an agency fee, or splitting the arrangement into several documents does not by itself change the legal test. The exact treatment of any separate reimbursement or service agreement would require a fact-specific analysis; do not assume that relabelling compensation makes the surrogacy arrangement valid. Equally, this article does not conclude that every related payment or private act is automatically a criminal offence.

Article 10(2) states that the parentage of a child born through surrogacy is determined by the birth. This rule matters even where the gestational woman did not provide the egg: under the Spanish approach described by the Supreme Court, the fact of giving birth is central to maternal filiation. Article 10(3) preserves a possible action to claim paternity in relation to the biological father under the ordinary rules. That is a separate legal route, not enforcement of the surrogacy contract. It depends on the facts and applicable procedure; a genetic link or foreign document should not be treated as a promise that the claim will succeed.

Do not confuse the surrogacy prohibition with a blanket ban on every assisted-reproduction treatment in Spain. Law 14/2006 regulates several assisted-reproduction techniques, but Article 10 specifically nullifies an agreement under which a woman carries a pregnancy and relinquishes maternal parentage. A person’s eligibility for a different fertility treatment, access to a clinic, or a clinic’s authorisation is a separate question governed by the relevant rules and facts. This article does not assess those eligibility requirements, medical indications, donor conditions, or clinic licensing; those topics need their own current review.

Legal position at a glance

SituationLegal positionPractical effect
Paid or commercial arrangementThe contract is void, regardless of compensation.No enforceable contractual transfer of maternity.
Unpaid or “altruistic” arrangementThe same nullity rule applies.There is no statutory safe harbour merely because the surrogate receives no fee.
Commercial promotion and advertisingOrganic Law 1/2023 treats advertising promoting commercial surrogacy practices as unlawful.Authorities with statutory standing may seek a court declaration of illegality and cessation; do not assume every related act is a separate criminal offence.
Foreign civil-registry certificate, simple declaration plus medical birth certificate, or final foreign judgmentThe instruction published on 1 May 2025 says none of these is an acceptable title for registering birth and parentage through the surrogacy route.The earlier 2010 and 2019 instructions were expressly withdrawn; obtain current case-specific advice before filing.

Foreign judgments and civil registration

The Supreme Court’s plenary Civil Chamber judgment 1626/2024, dated 4 December 2024, is an important interpretive development. The Court refused to recognise a United States judgment that validated a surrogacy contract and attributed parentage to the intended parents, treating that recognition as contrary to Spanish public policy. The 2025 BOE instruction’s account of the ruling emphasizes the dignity and integrity of the woman who gave birth and the child’s interests, including the child’s relationship with the birth mother and knowledge of biological origins. The ruling is case-specific, but it rejects the idea that a foreign court order automatically overrides Spanish fundamental principles.

The administrative instruction of 28 April 2025, published in the Official State Gazette (BOE) on 1 May 2025, expressly withdrew the earlier instructions of 5 October 2010 and 18 February 2019. It says Civil Registry officials, including consular registries, must not accept as a suitable title for registering the birth and parentage of a child born through surrogacy: (1) a foreign civil-register certificate; (2) a simple declaration accompanied by a medical certificate of birth; or (3) a final judgment of the foreign country’s courts. Pending applications for registration of parentage that existed when the instruction was published are not to be completed under that former route.

The 2025 instruction points to ordinary Spanish-law routes once the child is in Spain: biological parentage may be established where legally available, and adoption may be considered later if a sufficiently safeguarded family unit is demonstrated. It also mentions foster care as a possible child-protection measure in an appropriate case; foster care is not the same as legal parentage. None of these routes is automatic. Their availability depends on the child’s circumstances, applicable statutory conditions, evidence and the competent authority’s assessment of the child’s best interests.

Practical steps before and after birth

Before signing or paying, obtain independent written advice from a Spanish family-law lawyer who is not selected or paid by the agency arranging the program. Ask the lawyer to address the nullity of the agreement, any proposed reimbursement or intermediary contract, the intended parents’ actual legal position, and the consequences if the child is born abroad. Ask the foreign-country lawyer separately about local law and enforceability there. A clinic’s or agency’s statement that a program is “legal abroad” answers only one question; it does not establish that the agreement is valid in Spain or that Spanish authorities will recognise parentage.

If a child has already been born abroad, do not assume that the foreign birth certificate or court order will be transcribed into the Spanish Civil Registry. First confirm the child’s lawful status and travel documents under the law of the birth country; the 2025 instruction says applicants may seek a passport and permissions from local authorities where available, but it does not guarantee a Spanish passport or nationality. Obtain advice on the correct Spanish route before travelling or filing. If the child is already in Spain, ask counsel to assess biological parentage, possible adoption, and any immediate protective or family-court steps.

For a case-specific review, preserve the complete file rather than only the document that names the intended parents. Depending on the facts, counsel may need the original foreign birth record, any court decisions and proof of finality, the surrogacy agreement, records of the birth and consent, identity documents, evidence relevant to biological parentage, translations, legalisations or apostilles, and current residence and travel papers. This is a preparation list, not a statement that every item is legally required in every case. Do not alter, backdate, conceal or create documents to fit the registry route; ask counsel how to obtain lawful copies and translations.

If a Civil Registry or consulate refuses a requested entry, obtain the written decision and the exact legal reason rather than relying on an oral explanation. Ask a Spanish lawyer to identify the competent authority, the available review or court route, the deadline and whether any protective step is needed for the child while the matter is pending. Deadlines and remedies depend on the type of decision and procedural posture; this guide does not state a universal appeal period. Do not file a new application based on the withdrawn 2010 or 2019 instructions without checking the current legal position.

Questions that must remain separate

Keep four legal questions separate. First, whether a surrogacy contract is valid in Spain: Article 10 says it is void. Second, who is legally recorded as a parent: the Spanish rule centres on birth, with a separate possible biological-paternity claim. Third, whether a foreign document can be used in the Spanish Civil Registry: the 2025 instruction changes that administrative route. Fourth, whether the child can travel, obtain nationality or receive a passport: those questions require separate examination of the relevant nationality, immigration and consular rules. A foreign clinic’s approval, a local birth certificate, or the intended parents’ citizenship does not by itself answer all four.

The legal effect should not be overstated in either direction. Nullity means the parties cannot rely on the surrogacy contract as a valid source of the intended parent’s maternity. It does not, without further analysis, decide every possible dispute about a separate service contract, a refund, damages, agency conduct, medical care or the legal consequences of conduct abroad. Likewise, the prohibition on commercial advertising is a specific legal rule with its own enforcement mechanism; it should not be rewritten as a claim that every discussion of surrogacy, every payment or every intermediary act automatically carries criminal liability. Those questions require the exact facts, relevant statutes and advice on the jurisdictions involved.

A conflict in official online guidance

There is a material inconsistency in official online information. The Spanish Government’s public guidance page, marked as updated on 31 March 2026 when, still describes the 2010 instruction and a route based on a foreign judicial decision, exequatur or incidental recognition. The later BOE instruction of 28 April 2025 expressly withdrew the 2010 and 2019 instructions and states that a final foreign judgment is not an acceptable title for this registration route. The public page therefore appears outdated on this point. Do not rely on its older procedural description without written confirmation from the relevant Civil Registry or Spanish counsel.

The 2025 instruction’s BOE record shows publication on 1 May 2025 and no subsequent modification in the record consulted. This is not a guarantee that no later court order, unpublished administrative action or individual fact changes the analysis.

Practical conclusion

Practical bottom line: do not treat surrogacy in Spain as a choice between a lawful commercial model and a lawful altruistic model. The statutory contract is void either way. Do not assume a foreign judgment or birth certificate will establish Spanish parentage; the 2025 instruction says they are not acceptable titles for that registration route. Before making payments, obtain independent Spanish family-law advice and written confirmation of the proposed procedure. If a child has already been born, prioritise the child’s legal status, safe travel and a case-specific parentage plan.

Official sources

Source conflict note: the Government guidance page below still describes the withdrawn 2010/2019 procedure; the later 2025 BOE instruction is the current published instruction identified. Verify the administrative position before relying on this guide.

  1. [S1] Ley 14/2006, de 26 de mayo, sobre técnicas de reproducción humana asistida (Article 10) — Law 14/2006, Article 10: nullity, maternity by birth and biological-father paternity claim.
  2. [S2] Ley Orgánica 1/2023, de 28 de febrero (Articles 32-33) — Organic Law 1/2023, Articles 32–33: nullity rule and commercial advertising.
  3. [S3] Instrucción de 28 de abril de 2025, BOE-A-2025-8647 — Administrative instruction that changed the registration route in 2025.
  4. [S4] Supreme Court official press release, 9 December 2024, on judgment 1626/2024 — Official court communication about a specific Supreme Court judgment.
  5. [S5] Ley 1/2000, de Enjuiciamiento Civil (Articles 764 et seq.) — Civil proceedings for parentage and paternity.
  6. [S6] Ley 20/2011, de 21 de julio, del Registro Civil — Civil Registry framework.
  7. [S7] Spanish Government public guidance: Gestación por sustitución (page marked updated 31 March 2026) — Official public guidance page retained here to disclose its conflict with the later instruction.

Guides for Spain

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards