Thailand Surrogacy Disputes: Refusals, Liability and Remedies
Start with the legal issue, not the contract
This guide addresses a practical question: what can a person do when a Thai surrogacy plan is refused, a clinic or committee will not proceed, the parties disagree during pregnancy, someone seeks to end the arrangement, intended parents refuse a child, or birth registration and parentage are contested? The remedy depends on the stage of the case and whether the arrangement complied with Thailand’s assisted-reproduction law.
A refusal is not automatically unlawful, and a private agreement cannot cure statutory ineligibility or make a prohibited arrangement lawful. Conversely, where a surrogacy is carried out under the 2015 Act, the intended parents cannot simply reject the child. Keep separate the questions of eligibility, committee permission, medical consent, payment, parentage, birth registration, professional conduct and cross-border recognition.
The governing law and the current reform position
The main statute is the Protection of Children Born Through Assisted Reproductive Technologies Act B.E. 2558 (2015), especially sections 21–28 (surrogacy conditions and restrictions), 29–34 (parentage and child protection), 44–49 (professional and criminal consequences), and 56 (certain pre-Act births). The Thai-language text is reproduced in a legal database that identifies the Office of the Council of State as its source, but it warns that later amendments may not yet appear. The formally published Thai text in the Royal Gazette controls.
Thailand’s marriage-equality amendment took effect on 23 January 2025. That change did not, by itself, establish that every married couple is eligible for surrogacy under the separate 2015 Act, whose wording still uses “lawful husband and wife”. The Department of Health Service Support announced a consultation on a revised bill for 2–31 July 2026. The official notice confirms a consultation, not enactment.
The official notice says the draft would replace “husband and wife” with “spouses” and adjust the rules for couples with a foreign spouse. Until an enacted text and commencement date are verified, these remain proposals, not current eligibility rules.
Eligibility, approval and the written agreement
Section 21 sets cumulative eligibility conditions. The intended parents must be a lawfully married couple where the wife cannot become pregnant herself. The text ties eligibility to Thai nationality and requires the marriage to have been registered for at least three years if either spouse is not Thai; it is generally read as requiring both spouses to be Thai, or one Thai spouse plus a marriage registered for at least three years. Do not assume a couple with no Thai spouse qualifies. The surrogate must not be an ascendant or descendant of either intended parent and ordinarily must be a blood relative; another woman may be considered only if no such blood relative is available and the applicable Ministry of Public Health rules allow it.
Section 22 prohibits using the surrogate’s own egg. It permits an embryo made from the intended husband’s sperm and intended wife’s egg, or from one intended spouse’s gamete together with a donor’s gamete. Under section 23, the medical service provider must obtain the Committee’s permission for the specific couple before proceeding. Eligibility on paper, a clinic advertisement or an agent’s assurance is not the same as permission.
Published Department of Health Service Support guidance and the 2015 Committee notice add screening and filing criteria. They require a medical indication that the wife cannot become pregnant herself and physical, psychological and environmental assessments. The listed surrogate criteria include a nationality matching that of one intended spouse, age 20–40, and prior deliveries within the stated limits (no more than three natural deliveries or one caesarean delivery), and written consent from the surrogate’s lawful husband or male cohabiting partner where required. The 2015 notice lists prescribed forms คทพ. 1–4 among the application documents. Before filing or challenging a refusal, ask the competent authority to identify the exact current rule, form and missing or disputed evidence.
Commercial payments, intermediaries and advertising
Sections 24, 27 and 28 impose distinct restrictions: surrogacy for commercial benefit is prohibited; a person may not act as a paid intermediary or broker for arranging or referring surrogacy; and advertising or publicising that a surrogate is available, or that intended parents seek a surrogate, is prohibited whether or not the advertising is commercial. Section 48 provides a maximum of ten years’ imprisonment and a fine up to THB 200,000 for commercial surrogacy. Section 49 provides up to five years’ imprisonment, a fine up to THB 100,000, or both for violations including the intermediary and advertising bans.
The Act also contemplates prescribed health-related expenses: section 25 calls for rules on the agreement and expenses for the surrogate’s care during pregnancy, termination of pregnancy, delivery and after birth, plus the child’s health care for at least 30 days after birth. This is not a blanket permission for any payment, nor does it mean every reimbursement is automatically unlawful. The exact current ministerial rules and the purpose, recipient and documentation of each payment must be checked. Do not make or promise a payment on an assumption that a private contract overrides the statute.
If a clinic or committee refuses to proceed
First classify the refusal. It may concern statutory eligibility, missing documents, lack of committee permission, a clinical-safety decision, or a clinic’s own policy. Ask for a written decision or explanation, the legal or regulatory provision relied on, the date of service, the status of the application and a copy of the file. Preserve the original message, envelope, portal notice and attachments. If the issue is a correctable document defect, ask whether a fresh or supplemented application is permitted; do not assume that resubmission must be accepted.
The official Thai government service portal describes a case-specific approval process: the Committee is to decide within 60 working days after receiving a complete application, with extensions of up to 30 working days each, no more than twice. If the application is incomplete, officials should record the defects, list the additional documents required and set a deadline; failure to meet it may mean the application is treated as abandoned. The portal also says that changing the provider, intended couple, surrogate, sperm or egg requires a new application. These details come from the published service procedure, not an independently verified consolidated notice; obtain the current written requirements before relying on them.
The Administrative Procedure Act B.E. 2539 (1996) contains general review rules. Section 44 describes a 15-day written appeal for certain administrative orders where no specific route applies; section 48 addresses challenges to administrative orders of committees, generally within 90 days, subject to exceptions. It has not been verified that either route applies to a particular surrogacy-committee refusal, or which forum and deadline would govern it. Treat every deadline as urgent: obtain Thai administrative-law advice immediately, identify the date notice was received, and ask whether interim suspension is available. Filing an appeal does not automatically suspend an order.
Disputes during pregnancy and pregnancy termination
Section 26 concerns termination of a pregnancy in a surrogacy arrangement, not merely cancellation of the contract. The available English translation renders the Thai phrase as “an abortion of the surrogacy”. The procedure must be performed by a medical practitioner and requires written consent from the intended lawful husband and wife and the surrogate, subject to Medical Council rules approved by the Committee. If the surrogate does not consent, the section 25 surrogacy agreement is deemed terminated and she is not required to reimburse expenses under it. This provision does not authorize a pregnancy termination against the surrogate’s will; confirm the current medical rules with Thai counsel before acting.
Separate a medical decision from a money or contract dispute. Preserve the written agreement, consent forms, medical records, expense records and communications showing who proposed what and when. If the dispute involves pressure, threats, restraint, violence or withholding necessary care, prioritise immediate safety and seek local legal and appropriate emergency or protection assistance. Do not attempt self-help, interfere with treatment, or assume that a contract determines every medical decision. The current clinical rules and the facts of the pregnancy matter.
After birth: parentage and refusal to accept the child
Section 29 provides that a child born through assisted reproductive technology under the Act is the legal child of the intended lawful couple, including where donor sperm, eggs or an embryo were used; the donor and child do not acquire family-law or succession rights and duties between them under the Thai Civil and Commercial Code. Separately, section 33 prohibits the intended lawful couple from refusing to accept a child born through surrogacy, and section 49 makes a breach punishable by up to five years’ imprisonment, a fine up to THB 100,000, or both.
The parentage rule in section 29 should not be assumed to resolve every case involving an unapproved, non-compliant or cross-border arrangement; the applicable statutory framework and evidence of compliance matter. Section 33 contains no express health or disability exception to the prohibition on refusing the child. If acceptance, care or parentage is disputed, secure the child’s immediate safety, preserve birth and treatment records, and obtain urgent Thai family-law advice. Do not move the child across a border or rely on an informal handover as a substitute for lawful registration, guardianship and travel arrangements.
Birth registration, guardianship and older cases
Under section 31, the surrogacy agreement prescribed under section 25 is to be shown to the antenatal or delivery provider as evidence for the birth certificate and birth notification process. Section 32 places the birth-notification duty on the intended couple. If they have died before birth, are outside Thailand, or do not appear after delivery, the surrogate must notify the birth, subject to the applicable civil-registration rules.
If both intended parents die before the child is born, section 30 makes the surrogate the child’s guardian until a new guardian is appointed. The surrogate, a competent child-protection official, an interested person or a public prosecutor may ask the court to appoint a guardian; the child’s welfare is central. Section 4 assigns parentage cases under the Act to the competent Juvenile and Family Court. Separately, section 56 allows intended spouses or a public prosecutor to petition for a court order establishing parentage for a child born through surrogacy before the Act came into force on 30 July 2015, even without a written agreement, subject to protection for bona fide third-party rights. Birth registration, parentage, guardianship, nationality and permission to travel are different questions. This route is available regardless of whether the intended couple was lawfully married.
Liability, evidence and practical next steps
The Act’s criminal penalties are maximum statutory sanctions, not automatic outcomes in every dispute. Section 47 provides up to six months’ imprisonment, a fine up to THB 10,000, or both for a medical practitioner who breaches section 23’s permission requirement. Sections 44–45 treat certain failures to follow statutory ART standards as professional-ethics violations. A professional complaint, criminal report, administrative challenge and civil claim are separate tracks. The provisions reviewed do not establish one automatic refund or damages formula for every disagreement. Any civil claim needs separate analysis of the agreement, legality, negligence, causation, actual loss, standing, limitation periods and enforcement. Do not assume that an unlawful agreement is enforceable or that a payment will necessarily be recovered.
Build a dated evidence file. Keep passports and nationality records; marriage certificate and registration date; medical evidence that the wife cannot become pregnant herself; proof of the surrogate’s prior birth and blood relationship; any required partner consent; committee approval; clinic and practitioner details; the signed pre-pregnancy agreement and applicable expense rules; gamete/embryo records; invoices and payment trails; advertisements or broker messages; the written refusal and proof of when it was received; consent forms; medical and birth records; and registration, passport or consular correspondence. Preserve originals and backups, translate documents accurately, protect the child’s and surrogate’s privacy, and do not alter messages or records.
| Issue | First practical step | Evidence to preserve |
|---|---|---|
| Refusal before treatment | Get written reasons; verify eligibility and the correct review route promptly. | Application, refusal, date received, eligibility documents. |
| Payment or broker dispute | Pause disputed transfers; assess the statutory restrictions before demanding payment. | Agreement, invoices, bank records, messages and adverts. |
| Pregnancy-termination or consent dispute | Prioritise medical safety; check written consent and current rules under section 26. | Consent forms, medical records, dated communications. |
| Child rejected or registration blocked | Protect the child; obtain urgent family-law advice on parentage and registration. | Birth/medical records, agreement, registry responses. |
| Clinic or practitioner conduct | Separate a professional complaint from damages or criminal action. | Provider details, records, consent, chronology and losses. |
For a foreign or mixed-nationality family, Thai parentage does not itself establish citizenship, a passport, immigration status or recognition abroad. Check the child’s nationality rules, consular documentation, foreign parentage recognition and travel permissions separately before starting the process. Marriage equality and a draft bill do not replace the eligibility, approval and evidence checks under the law currently in force.
A safe sequence is: protect health and the child; classify the dispute; preserve evidence; obtain the written decision and service date; consult Thai counsel promptly on the competent body and deadline; and plan parentage, birth registration, guardianship and cross-border documents separately. Verify the current Royal Gazette text and implementing rules before acting. No outcome can be promised from the existence of a contract or a clinic’s marketing.
Sources and legal materials
- Official Office of the Council of State law index: Thai ART Act
- Official health-service notice: July 2026 draft-bill consultation
- Thai Government PRD: marriage-equality commencement
- Official government page listing the Administrative Procedure Act
- Administrative Procedure Act, section 44 (Thai text reproduction)
- Administrative Procedure Act, sections 44–48 (Thai text reproduction)
- Detailed Thai text reproduction of the ART Act (not a certified English translation)
- Original Thai ART Act as published in the Royal Gazette (government-hosted PDF; 2015 text, not consolidated)
- Department of Health Service Support guidance on surrogacy eligibility and approval (Thai; check current rules)
- 2015 Committee notice on surrogacy approval (Thai text reproduction; later amendments may be missing)
- Unofficial English translation of the ART Act (educational only; Thai original controls)
- Official Ministry PDF: 2019 amendment to the Committee surrogacy-approval notice
- Official Thai Government Services Portal: surrogacy approval procedure (confirm current rules)
