Malaysia · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Editorial illustration of a desk with documents, calculator and laptop for reviewing contract and payment risks.
A contract-and-payment review workspace; editorial illustration, not a real clinic or case.

Malaysia: surrogacy contracts, agencies and payments

The short answer

In Malaysia, do not treat a signed surrogacy agreement as a legally secure way to arrange a pregnancy, transfer a child, guarantee intended-parent status or recover money. The Ministry of Health’s National Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Policy expressly says surrogacy is prohibited and that surrogacy agreements are not enforceable by law, even when the intended parents and surrogate have signed a contract. The Malaysian Medical Council (MMC) repeats that surrogacy is prohibited by the National ART Policy in its 2025 guidance for medical practitioners. The practical starting point is therefore not to negotiate a better surrogacy contract, but to pause the arrangement and obtain independent Malaysian legal advice before signing, paying, or asking a clinic or intermediary to proceed.

What kind of rule is this?

The distinction between legislation and professional or administrative policy matters. The National ART Policy is a Ministry of Health policy document, not a surrogacy statute enacted by Parliament. The MMC’s Guideline on Medically Assisted Reproduction, version 2/2025, was adopted on 19 August 2025 and is professional guidance directed at registered medical practitioners; it says that its recommendations complement the professional-conduct framework and related guidance. Both sources nevertheless state the relevant operational position clearly: surrogacy is prohibited in the Malaysian ART framework, and the National ART Policy expressly rejects enforceability of surrogacy agreements. This is stronger than a mere absence of regulation, but it should not be misdescribed as a specific criminal offence created by a standalone surrogacy Act.

How Malaysian contract law affects the agreement

The Contracts Act 1950 provides the general framework. Section 10 treats an agreement as a contract only where the parties have capacity and free consent, the consideration and object are lawful, and the agreement is not otherwise declared void. Section 24 says consideration or an object is unlawful if it is forbidden by law, would defeat a law, is fraudulent, involves or implies injury to another person or property, or is regarded by a court as immoral or contrary to public policy. An agreement with an unlawful object or consideration is void. Read together with the National ART Policy’s express statement on enforceability, these rules create a serious obstacle to enforcing promises whose purpose is to arrange surrogacy. A signature, notarisation, detailed payment schedule, penalty clause or choice-of-law clause does not itself cure that problem.

What the case law does—and does not—show

In Yogananthy A/S Thambaiya v Harta Pusaka Idris Osman, the Federal Court considered section 24(e) in a commercial dispute involving an agreement found to be a sham and contrary to public policy because of the facts, including a conflict of interest. The court explained that an agreement may be void on public-policy grounds even without a separate statutory provision expressly prohibiting the transaction. This was not a surrogacy case and does not decide every question about surrogacy contracts. It is relevant only as a general illustration of why a court may refuse enforcement where public policy is engaged. The direct surrogacy-specific statement remains the National ART Policy, not this unrelated judgment.

Clinics and medical professionals

The MMC guideline says medically assisted reproduction should be offered only to legally married couples. It also states that gamete and embryo donation for fertilisation is not permissible under the National ART Policy and prohibits commercial trading in gametes and embryos. Section 9 says surrogacy is prohibited by that policy. The guideline applies to registered medical practitioners and is intended to be read with the professional-conduct rules and other relevant guidance. A clinic’s willingness to discuss or advertise a service is not proof that the service is permitted, that the clinic can lawfully provide it, or that the proposed contract will be enforceable. Professional consequences for a doctor may be possible if applicable duties are breached, but the precise process and sanction must be checked against the facts and the rules in force; do not assume that every participant automatically commits a criminal offence.

Agency and intermediary agreements

An agency agreement must be assessed by what the intermediary is actually promising to do. If the core service is to recruit a surrogate, arrange the prohibited pregnancy, procure an unenforceable surrogacy agreement or guarantee transfer of a child, the customer should assume a high enforceability risk. Calling the payment a “coordination fee”, “consulting package”, “programme administration” or “success fee” does not change the substance of the service. The sources do not establish a separate criminal offence consisting solely of acting as a surrogacy broker; that is not the same as saying every intermediary activity is lawful. Fraudulent representations, coercion, exploitation, unlicensed healthcare or child-placement conduct may raise separate legal issues and require separate statutory analysis. A genuinely independent contract for ordinary lawful services, such as translation or legal advice, needs its own assessment.

Payments, deposits and expenses

Do not assume that a promised surrogate fee, agency commission, “success” payment, cancellation charge or refund is recoverable simply because it is written into a contract. The National ART Policy says the surrogacy agreement itself is unenforceable. Section 7.1.1 does not distinguish commercial from altruistic surrogacy or provide an express exception for expense reimbursement. Do not assume that an unpaid arrangement, or a payment labelled as expense reimbursement, falls outside the policy if the arrangement is in substance surrogacy. At the same time, this does not mean that every payment to a clinic or professional for a separate, lawful service is automatically void. Identify the actual recipient, the service purchased, the invoice description, the payment trigger and whether the service can be separated from the surrogacy arrangement. Avoid cash or opaque transfers, and do not pay more while the legal basis and refund position remain unclear.

Practical risk matrix

The matrix below is a screening tool, not a declaration that every transaction in a row is criminal or automatically void. The result depends on the actual service, the wording and structure of the agreement, the parties’ conduct and any other applicable law.

Arrangement or payment Main risk Practical response
Surrogacy agreement with the surrogateThe National ART Policy says the agreement is not enforceable, even if signed.Do not rely on it to compel pregnancy, transfer, parentage or payment.
Clinic treatment agreementA genuine, separate treatment contract is not identical to a surrogacy agreement; the proposed surrogacy service remains prohibited by policy.Verify the actual procedure, provider and applicable MMC/MOH requirements before paying.
Agency or programme packageA fee described as administration or coordination may still be consideration for arranging surrogacy.Review the full service description and contract; do not assume a label makes it lawful or enforceable.
Surrogate fee, commission or depositA contractual payment promise may be difficult to enforce; refund is not automatic.Identify recipient and trigger, preserve proof, and obtain advice before further transfers.
Separate lawful professional serviceA genuinely independent service may be assessed separately, but a mixed agreement may be affected by section 25.Use a clear scope, separate pricing and invoice only after independent legal review.

Clauses that cannot safely be relied on

Do not rely on a private agreement to compel a woman to continue a pregnancy, undergo a particular medical procedure, waive medical consent, hand over a child, accept a predetermined parentage outcome or pay a contractual penalty for changing her decision. The ART Policy says the surrogacy agreement is unenforceable; the contract therefore cannot safely be treated as a substitute for legal rules on consent, parentage, birth registration, custody or the child’s welfare. A clause stating that the intended parents will automatically be the legal parents does not itself establish parentage. Nor does the agreement guarantee a birth certificate, nationality, passport, exit permission or recognition in another country. Those are separate legal questions requiring advice in the relevant jurisdictions.

Can the whole contract or a payment term be separated?

Sometimes an intermediary describes one part of the package as a lawful service and another as a surrogacy fee. Section 25 of the Contracts Act is important: where an unlawful part forms part of a single consideration or object, the provision says the agreement is void. Whether a particular contract contains genuinely independent obligations, and whether any lawful part can survive, is a matter of construction and applicable law—not something the provider can settle by placing separate headings on an invoice. Ask an independent Malaysian lawyer to review the full agreement, all schedules, marketing materials, side letters and payment instructions together. Do not assume that a “severability” clause will preserve the rest of the package.

Before signing or paying

If no agreement has been signed and no money has been sent, pause before taking either step. Obtain advice from a Malaysian lawyer who is independent of the clinic, agency and any person receiving a commission. Give the lawyer the full proposed contract and every related document, not just a brochure or summary. Ask for written answers to these specific questions: which service is actually being purchased; whether it involves arranging surrogacy; which obligations are likely to be unenforceable; who holds each payment; what happens if the programme is stopped; and whether any genuinely separate lawful services are priced and contracted independently. Request the clinic’s legal name and relevant facility details, an itemised quote and a clear invoice. Marketing assurances are not legal opinions.

If you have already signed or paid

Do not sign a replacement agreement, backdated document, false invoice or side letter designed to disguise the arrangement. Preserve the existing paperwork and obtain independent advice before sending a termination notice, accepting a proposed refund or making further payments. Ask counsel to identify which amounts went to the surrogate, the agency, the clinic and other providers; which services were actually delivered; and whether any separate lawful service or restitution claim may be available. Section 66 of the Contracts Act provides for restoration of an advantage received under an agreement found to be void, or a contract that becomes void. It does not guarantee repayment in every case. Its application to a surrogacy-related payment, particularly where public policy is involved, requires case-specific analysis. Do not promise yourself a refund until that analysis is complete.

Documents and evidence to preserve

Keep a complete, unedited record: every version of the contract and its annexes; the agency’s terms and advertising; emails, messages and call notes; invoices, receipts, bank-transfer confirmations and beneficiary details; the clinic’s name and service description; consent forms; and any refund, cancellation or termination correspondence. Preserve original electronic files and metadata where possible, and export conversations without deleting context. Make a dated timeline of what was promised, who said it, what was paid, to whom, and what service was delivered. Do not publish the surrogate’s identity or medical information. Share sensitive records only with advisers who need them and use a secure channel.

Disputes, complaints and possible remedies

The right next step depends on the dispute. A demand for performance of the surrogacy agreement faces the policy’s express unenforceability statement. A claim about a separately contracted lawful service, a misleading representation, a payment made by mistake or coercion, or professional conduct may raise different issues. Section 66 may be relevant to restoration, but it is not a guaranteed refund mechanism. A lawyer should distinguish a contract claim from a possible restitution, misrepresentation, consumer, regulatory or professional complaint and identify the proper defendant, forum, limitation period and evidence. Where a doctor’s conduct is at issue, ask counsel whether the facts justify a complaint to the relevant professional or health authority. Avoid threats or public accusations before the evidence and legal route have been assessed.

Foreign parties and cross-border arrangements

A foreign intended parent, a foreign agency, a contract signed abroad or payment made to an overseas account does not by itself remove the Malaysian issues. The location of the clinic, the place where the surrogate lives and gives birth, the parties’ residence and nationality, the contract’s governing-law clause and the intended destination of the child may all matter. A foreign court order or foreign-law contract should not be assumed to bind Malaysian authorities or settle parentage, registration, nationality or travel. Before starting or continuing a cross-border programme, obtain coordinated advice on the Malaysian side and in every country whose law will determine parentage, immigration or recognition. This article does not resolve those separate questions.

Practical decision rule and points to confirm

The safest working rule is simple: do not sign, pay or proceed on the promise that a Malaysian surrogacy contract will be enforceable. The strongest direct source is the Ministry of Health’s National ART Policy; the MMC’s 2025 guideline confirms the clinical-professional position, and the Contracts Act supplies the general rules on lawful objects, public policy and void agreements.

Primary and supporting sources

The official policy PDF is linked from the Ministry of Health publication page.

  1. Ministry of Health Malaysia, National Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Policy (2021) (MOH_ART_2021)
  2. Malaysian Medical Council, Guideline on Medically Assisted Reproduction, V2/2025 (adopted 19 August 2025) (MMC_MAR_2025)
  3. Laws of Malaysia, Contracts Act 1950 (Act 136), official reprint (CONTRACTS_ACT_136)
  4. Yogananthy A/S Thambaiya v Harta Pusaka Idris Osman, Federal Court, [2020] 3 MLRA 393 (case summary) (FC_YOGANANTHY)

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards