New Zealand surrogacy: what clinics, intermediaries and agreements may lawfully do
Start with the distinction that controls the deal
Before paying an agency or clinic, separate the surrogacy arrangement from legitimate professional services. New Zealand permits an altruistic surrogacy arrangement in principle but does not make the arrangement enforceable. A signed promise about pregnancy, payment, handover or intended parenthood is not a court order. As at 25 October 2026, analyse the transaction under the Human Assisted Reproductive Technology Act 2004 (HART Act), especially section 14, rather than assuming an attractive agency brochure describes the law.
Section 14(1) says a surrogacy arrangement is not itself illegal, yet cannot be enforced by or against any person. Neither notarisation, an overseas governing-law clause nor an elaborate penalty clause should be relied on to compel someone to become pregnant, continue treatment, surrender the child or perform the arrangement. Section 14(2) expressly preserves the operation of Part 2 of the Status of Children Act 1969. This is a limit on the surrogacy bargain, not a statement that every separate contract for lawful services is automatically void.
Payments: where the criminal-law boundary lies
Section 14(3) criminalises giving, receiving or agreeing to give or receive valuable consideration for one's own participation, another person's participation, or arranging another person's participation in surrogacy. The statutory definition of valuable consideration includes an inducement, a discount or priority in receiving a service. Under section 14(5), conviction may result in up to one year of imprisonment, a fine up to NZ$100,000, or both. No payment needs to have changed hands before an agreement to pay potentially engages the prohibition.
Section 14(4)(a) expressly excludes payments to the provider concerned for reasonable and necessary expenses of collecting, storing, transporting or using embryos or gametes; counselling parties concerning the surrogacy agreement; insemination or IVF; and ovulation or pregnancy tests. The identity of the payee, actual service and necessity matter. A clinic invoice is not a blanket exemption for a recruitment commission, disguised participant bonus or unrelated package. Obtain an itemised estimate matching each service to this statutory category before agreeing to payment.
Section 14(4)(b) separately excludes payment to a legal adviser for independent legal advice to the woman who is or might become pregnant under the arrangement. The statute does not say that all lawyer fees, every intended-parent fee or agency legal bundles fall within that exception. Arrange genuinely independent advice for the surrogate; have each other party's legal costs classified separately. A contract must not turn payment for advice into a reward for consent, pregnancy or relinquishment of the child.
Expenses paid directly to the surrogate demand particular care. In its 2022 Review of Surrogacy, the New Zealand Law Commission explained that HART section 14 does not expressly authorise payments to the surrogate for other reasonable costs and that the boundary of valuable consideration is uncertain. Official adoption guidance speaks broadly of reasonable expenses, but guidance does not expand the statutory exception. Do not treat travel, accommodation, maternity items, lost earnings or insurance as automatically exempt; seek current individual New Zealand advice before promising or reimbursing them.
The safer distinction is purpose, recipient and evidence, not whether a transfer is called a reimbursement. A flat pregnancy fee, success bonus, allowance without receipts or payment conditional on a child being handed over can function as prohibited consideration. Conversely, an itemised third-party IVF invoice may fit section 14(4) if reasonable, necessary and paid to the provider. A receipt alone does not legalise a charge; a genuine expense outside the express categories may still require a reasoned legal assessment.
Clinics, agencies and written agreements
An intermediary's role is especially sensitive: section 14(3) expressly includes payment for arranging someone else's participation. Therefore no one should assume that a success-based matching fee, recruitment commission, introduction fee or premium placement is lawful merely because an agency also does administration. A service agreement should identify each deliverable, supplier and price and separate ordinary administrative work from recruitment. The legality and enforceability of a particular independent service fee are fact-specific; obtain written advice before paying, especially where the service originates overseas.
Advertising is a different exposure. HART section 15 restricts publishing or arranging publication of material inviting public participation or enquiries about conduct prohibited by sections 8, 13 or 14, subject to the provision's scope and definitions. A surrogacy-related advertisement is not necessarily prohibited merely because it exists, but advertising paid participation or forbidden recruitment may fall within the restriction. Review the exact wording, placement, audience and payer before launching online campaigns, referral programmes or public calls for compensated surrogates. Section 15(1) also requires an intention to obtain responses from members of the public; section 15(2) expressly includes Internet dissemination in the definition of publication. Under section 15(3), an offence is punishable by up to three months' imprisonment, a fine of up to NZ$2,500, or both.
For clinic-assisted IVF surrogacy, do not substitute a private contract for ethical approval. Official New Zealand guidance says that IVF surrogacy requires approval from the Ethics Committee on Assisted Reproductive Technology (ECART). HART sections 16 and 17 regulate relevant assisted reproductive procedures, prior written approval and observance of conditions. Traditional arrangements completed privately without a clinic may follow a different ethical-review path; that does not remove section 14 or later parentage questions. Ask the treating clinic to confirm the specific procedure and approval pathway in writing. The duty to obtain ethics approval is determined by the HART Act's defined category of assisted reproductive procedures and applicable guidelines; this is not a claim that every ordinary IVF service separately requires ECART approval.
A clinic's treatment agreement should specify the licensed or responsible provider, proposed procedures, counselling and consent stages, ECART dependencies, clinical cancellation rules, fees, storage charges, medical-record access and what happens if approval is delayed or refused. Do not label every commercial term as an ECART requirement unless the clinic can document that requirement. Request copies of the proposed approval submissions, information sheets and fee schedule; identify which activities are prohibited until prior consent or approval is obtained.
The surrogacy memorandum may usefully record intentions, expectations, contact, confidentiality, counselling, expense review and a dispute discussion process. It should clearly state that the arrangement itself is not enforceable and cannot guarantee the child's transfer. Avoid clauses compelling medical treatment, controlling a surrogate's bodily decisions, imposing punitive withdrawal charges or promising automatic legal parenthood. Genuine informed consent, access to independent advice and independent medical judgment must not be displaced by financial pressure.
Do not overstate the effect of unenforceability. A separately identifiable, otherwise lawful agreement with a clinic or adviser may be governed by ordinary contractual principles, but HART section 14 does not itself decide the validity, severability or refund rights under every third-party service contract. Conversely, a service-provider signature cannot rescue a fee that is consideration for arranging participation. Have New Zealand counsel review each payment clause and the actual economic substance rather than relying on labels, choice-of-law clauses or a generic global surrogacy template.
For refunds, insist on a stage-by-stage schedule separating money earned for lawful services already supplied from deposits for work not yet performed. Identify who holds funds, when a clinic may invoice, what happens after an ECART refusal, an unsuccessful treatment cycle, withdrawal or a provider default, and which documented costs remain payable. Do not promise that a non-enforceable surrogacy arrangement creates a damages claim for a lost pregnancy or a right to a child; any genuine service-contract remedy needs separate legal review.
A transaction-level risk matrix
| Proposed transaction | Working legal assessment | Safe response |
|---|---|---|
| Surrogate fee or success bonus | High risk: valuable consideration for participation is prohibited by section 14(3), including an agreement to pay. | Do not promise or transfer it; remove the provision and obtain legal advice. |
| Itemised IVF, testing and counselling provider invoice | Potentially within section 14(4)(a) if the statutory purpose, payee, necessity and reasonableness are established. | Verify provider identity, written estimate, procedure and receipts. |
| Surrogate's travel costs, missed wages or monthly allowance | Not an express section 14(4) exemption for direct payment to the surrogate; scope remains legally sensitive. | Do not assume approval from general guidance; request transaction-specific advice. |
| Agency matching or referral commission | High risk if paid for arranging another person's participation; unrelated lawful administration must be independently assessed. | Split deliverables, identify payee and avoid success-linked recruitment charges. |
Documents, payment controls and disputes
Before engagement, obtain the complete contracts and annexes, names and registration details of providers, agency business model, proof of who actually supplies clinical care, itemised budget, advertising scripts, referral agreements, invoices and any proposed fund-holding or escrow instructions. Record which party gives consent, which party pays, the currency, timing, cancellation rules and cross-border transfers. Ask separately for the ECART pathway, independent legal advice and a written explanation of each proposed exception to section 14.
Use payments that are traceable to an identified lawful service, with invoices, bank records, dates and a clear recipient. Avoid cash, personal-wallet transfers, side letters, split invoices or opaque foreign affiliates designed to hide recruitment fees. Escrow is a custody mechanism, not an exemption from HART. Before remitting funds, require a lawyer to approve the actual payment flow, including refund triggers and any extra intermediary commission; pause a payment if its substance cannot be explained.
If trouble arises, preserve contracts, communications, advertisements, payment instructions, medical records and receipts. Ask the provider for an itemised account and written grounds for retaining funds. A dispute about an independently lawful clinical service may raise ordinary consumer or contract questions; a demand to enforce the surrogate's participation or child handover is fundamentally different. Where criminal exposure or misleading advertising is suspected, seek New Zealand legal advice before threatening litigation, negotiating a settlement or making another transfer.
Parentage, overseas parties and changing law
Payment compliance does not establish legal parentage. Official Oranga Tamariki guidance describes adoption through the New Zealand Family Court as the current route for intending parents to obtain legal parent status after surrogacy, with consent and assessment requirements. A clinic's success letter or notarised agreement cannot substitute for the applicable legal process. Birth registration, nationality and departure documents require separate analysis, especially where a party or birth is outside New Zealand; those procedures are not determined by the agency-fee contract.
Overseas participants should check both New Zealand law and each other relevant country's rules before entering a transaction. Overseas agency incorporation or a foreign law clause does not automatically remove New Zealand exposure when recruitment, participants, treatment or payments connect with New Zealand. Equally, New Zealand's permission for altruistic arrangements does not establish a foreign parent's eligibility, an overseas payment's legality or recognition of parentage abroad. Identify each cross-border act and obtain jurisdiction-specific advice rather than extrapolating from one country's website.
Reform is not yet a safe contractual assumption. On 25 October 2026, the official parliamentary tracker shows the Improving Arrangements for Surrogacy Bill at the second-reading stage, without royal assent. The proposals concerning payments, approvals and parentage are not operative merely because they appear in a committee report or bill. Before signature and again before each significant payment, recheck the current HART Act text and parliamentary progress; any later amendment may change the analysis prospectively or under transitional rules.
Practical decision before signing
Example: intended parents are quoted a clinic invoice for IVF and counselling, plus a separate agency success fee for finding a surrogate and a fixed monthly payment to her. These three transfers cannot be assessed as a single 'programme cost'. The clinic items might satisfy section 14(4)(a) with evidence; the recruitment success fee engages section 14(3); and the monthly transfer requires particular analysis and is not expressly exempt. Renaming all amounts 'expenses' changes none of these tests.
Decision: do not sign or pay against a global package price. First identify the person being paid and for what act; classify each amount against section 14(3) and the narrow section 14(4) exceptions; verify the clinic's ECART position; separate a non-enforceable surrogacy memorandum from lawful supplier contracts; negotiate documented refund terms; and obtain independent, current New Zealand advice on unsettled expense or agency-fee issues. This is a decision framework, not a transaction-specific legal clearance or an assurance that a child will be transferred.
Sources / Official materials
- S_HART14 — HART Act 2004, s 14, current 10 July 2026 version
- S_HARTFULL — HART Act 2004, ss 5, 15–17
- S_LAWCOM — NZ Law Commission, Review of Surrogacy, 2022, chapter 8
- S_ORANGA — Oranga Tamariki, Surrogacy and adoption
- S_ECART — ACART, advice and guidelines on donation and surrogacy
- S_PARL — NZ Parliament, Improving Arrangements for Surrogacy Bill status
