Malaysia · Legal status and models

Open legal reference book and working papers on a desk in a quiet law library; illustrative image, not evidence of a legal ruling.
Editorial illustration only. The image is not a legal source or depiction of a specific clinic.

Surrogacy in Malaysia: Legal Status, Policy and Contract Risks

The current position: a practical answer

As of 24 October 2026, the safest evidence-based answer is that surrogacy is prohibited under Malaysia’s National Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Policy, and the Malaysian Medical Council’s 2025 guideline expressly repeats that position. The Ministry of Health policy also states that surrogacy agreements are not enforceable even when signed. These are important official policy and professional-guidance statements, but they should not be misdescribed as a standalone Act of Parliament or, without separate authority, as proof that every surrogacy-related act is a criminal offence.

The position is not a simple “commercial surrogacy is banned but altruistic surrogacy is allowed” model. The official definition is broad: a woman carries a baby on behalf of another couple. The sources do not establish an exception for a relative, a friend, an arrangement without a fee, or reimbursement-only payments. A person should therefore not treat the absence of a profit motive as permission to proceed.

A second distinction is equally important. The policy status of the medical procedure, the enforceability of a private agreement, legal parentage, birth registration, custody, nationality and permission to travel are separate questions. Approval or treatment by a clinic cannot by itself settle the legal status of the child or bind a civil-registration, immigration or consular authority.

What the sources establish—and what they do not

The central official sources are the National ART Policy published by Malaysia’s Ministry of Health in 2021 and the Malaysian Medical Council’s Guideline of Medically Assisted Reproduction, version 2/2025. The Ministry still lists the 2021 policy in its clinical-publication catalogue; the catalogue page itself shows a last-updated date of 18 August 2026. This confirms that the policy remains officially listed, but the page-level date does not by itself establish its legal force or every aspect of its current administrative application. The 2025 medical guideline identifies that policy as the basis for the surrogacy prohibition.

The sources did not identify a dedicated Malaysian statute comprehensively regulating surrogacy. Academic legal writing has also described this gap, but an older article cannot prove that no later enactment, subsidiary instrument or relevant state measure exists. This does not mean that no Malaysian law can affect any part of a surrogacy arrangement. A final legal opinion would require an up-to-date check of federal legislation, relevant state enactments and gazettes, and reported judgments.

The distinction matters because a policy, a professional guideline, a statute, a court judgment and a state fatwa do not have identical legal status or reach. A policy can guide or govern healthcare administration; professional guidance sets expectations for doctors; legislation creates legal rules; a court interprets applicable law in a case; and the effect of a religious ruling depends on the relevant constitutional and state-law framework. One source should not be used as a substitute for another.

The national medical-policy position

Section 7 of the 2021 National ART Policy addresses surrogacy. Section 7.1.1 states that surrogacy is prohibited because of the legal implications and the welfare and rights of the child. It also states that surrogacy agreements are not enforceable by law, even where the commissioning parents and surrogate have signed a legal contract. This is the Ministry’s stated policy position and should be quoted as such.

Section 9 of the Malaysian Medical Council’s Medically Assisted Reproduction Guideline V2/2025 defines surrogacy as a woman offering to carry a baby through pregnancy on behalf of another couple and says that the practice is prohibited by the National ART Policy. The guideline also states that medically assisted reproduction should be offered only to legally married couples. That marriage requirement is relevant to access to medical treatment, but it does not itself resolve every question about parentage or the civil consequences of a child’s birth.

The guideline is professional guidance, not a newly enacted surrogacy statute. Its clear wording nevertheless means that a patient should not assume a Malaysian doctor or ART facility may provide or arrange surrogacy merely because the intended parents consent, all parties are adults, or the arrangement is described as private. A clinic’s willingness to discuss a case is not evidence that the proposed procedure complies with the national policy.

Commercial and altruistic arrangements

Commercial surrogacy usually involves payment beyond expenses; altruistic surrogacy is commonly described as an arrangement in which the surrogate receives no fee or only expense reimbursement. These labels are useful descriptions, but they do not create a legal exception by themselves. The official Malaysian ART wording prohibits surrogacy in general and does not set out a separate permission for unpaid arrangements, family members, friends, or reimbursement-only models.

Accordingly, the defensible conclusion is narrow: the sources do not support presenting altruistic surrogacy as a lawful alternative in Malaysia. This does not mean that every payment connected with pregnancy is independently a criminal offence; the material does not establish such a general criminal rule. It means that removing the fee does not remove the stated policy prohibition on the underlying surrogacy arrangement.

Commercial arrangements can raise additional questions about payment, public policy, agency conduct, medical fees, expense reimbursement and the purpose of each transfer. But those questions should be analysed separately from the initial prohibition. Neither a label such as “expenses only” nor a contract clause calling payment a reimbursement guarantees enforceability. Do not structure payments to disguise their real purpose or rely on a clinic or intermediary’s informal assurance. The ART Policy separately prohibits commercial trading in gametes and embryos; that distinct rule should not be treated as proof that every payment to a surrogate is separately criminalized.

Contracts, public policy and enforcement risk

The Ministry’s 2021 policy expressly says that a surrogacy agreement is not enforceable even if the parties have signed it. A signature, notarisation, witness, payment schedule or clause requiring the surrogate to surrender the child therefore cannot safely be treated as a guarantee that a Malaysian court will compel performance. The policy statement is a serious warning against relying on contract language to secure a particular birth, handover or parental outcome.

At the same time, Malaysian law gives no complete, case-tested account of every civil consequence of an agreement: for example, whether a particular payment could be recovered, how expenses would be treated, what remedies might be available after a breach, or how a court would characterise a specific contract under general contract and public-policy principles. Those issues require analysis of the actual agreement, facts, applicable law and any later authority. Do not convert the policy statement into an unsupported claim that every related payment is automatically forfeited or every participant is criminally liable.

The practical risk is asymmetric. Intended parents may pay substantial sums without a reliable contractual route to compel transfer of the child; a surrogate may face pressure or uncertainty about expenses and responsibilities; and the child’s legal status is not decided by the adults’ agreement. Before any payment or treatment, obtain written Malaysian legal advice on the agreement and the separate parentage, registration and child-welfare questions.

Muslim parties and state-level religious rulings

For Muslim parties, the analysis must also account for the state-based Islamic-law framework. The official Selangor Mufti Department publishes a gazetted fatwa on surrogate motherhood under sections 47 and 48(6) of the Administration of the Islamic Religion (State of Selangor) Enactment 2003. The published ruling prohibits using a surrogate mother to obtain a child. Negeri Sembilan’s official Mufti Department separately records a 2019 Fatwa Committee decision stating that surrogacy is forbidden in Islam even when the sperm and ovum come from a legally married couple; it also addresses a polygamous-family example.

These sources establish important state-level religious positions, but they should not be presented as if one webpage alone proves the exact legal effect of every fatwa in all Malaysian states. The relevant state, whether the ruling was gazetted there, the wording of the applicable enactment, the parties’ religious status and the conduct in question all matter. The nationwide ART policy and MMC guidance are separate sources and do not depend on a person being Muslim.

If any intended parent, surrogate or other participant is Muslim, obtain advice for the particular state before any clinical or contractual step. Do not assume that a family relationship, a second wife carrying an embryo created with another wife’s egg, or use of only the spouses’ own gametes creates an exception. Do not assume that a fatwa or committee decision recorded in one state has identical legal effect in every other state; check the relevant enactment and gazette.

Non-Muslim parties and the unresolved civil-law position

For non-Muslim parties, the absence of a clearly identified dedicated surrogacy statute does not amount to permission. The national ART policy and the Malaysian Medical Council’s professional guideline still state that the practice is prohibited in the medical setting. No separate civil-law safe harbour allows non-Muslims to use a commercial or altruistic arrangement in Malaysia.

General civil law may become relevant to contracts, public policy, birth registration, legitimacy, parentage, custody, maintenance and inheritance. However, the sources did not locate a Malaysian reported judgment that definitively resolves all of these issues for modern gestational surrogacy. That is a limitation of the present search, not proof that no relevant case exists. A final opinion should verify current law reports and the facts of any analogous cases before stating a categorical rule.

The correct advice is therefore not that all non-Muslim arrangements are automatically criminal or that all are legally valid. Rather, the clinical policy position is prohibitory, contractual enforcement is expressly questioned by the Ministry’s policy, and the full civil-law consequences for a particular child and family may remain uncertain. Those are distinct conclusions and must remain distinct in any client advice.

Legal status at a glance

The table summarises what a reader can safely take from Malaysian law and policy. “Established” means the source states the proposition; it does not mean that every downstream legal consequence has been tested in court.

QuestionWhat the law establishesPractical meaning and limit
Is surrogacy permitted as a medical practice?The 2021 National ART Policy prohibits it; the 2025 MMC guideline repeats that position.Do not plan a Malaysian clinical arrangement on the assumption that consent or private status makes it acceptable.
Does no payment make it acceptable?No separate altruistic exception appears in the reviewed policy wording.Do not treat a relative, friend or expense-only arrangement as a safe harbour.
Is a signed agreement enforceable?The Ministry policy says surrogacy agreements are not enforceable, even if signed.Do not rely on a contract to compel handover or parentage; other civil consequences need case-specific advice.
Are Muslim parties treated identically in every state?Official state fatwa material prohibits surrogacy in the reviewed examples.Check the relevant state enactment, gazettal, personal status and exact scope; do not extrapolate automatically nationwide.
Does genetics decide legal parentage?Malaysian law does not provide that a genetic link or agreement automatically determines legal parentage.Parentage, registration, custody and nationality need separate analysis.
Does a foreign birth settle the Malaysian position?No automatic recognition guarantee exists.Plan recognition, documents, immigration and travel separately in every relevant jurisdiction.

Parentage, birth registration and the child’s position

Surrogacy creates a distinction between genetic connection, the woman who gives birth, the person recorded on the birth record and the person recognised as a legal parent for a particular purpose. Those concepts may overlap, but they are not interchangeable. The adults’ contract does not by itself establish that intended parents will be recorded as parents, obtain custody, or acquire authority to make every decision for the child.

The child’s interests require separate attention to birth registration, legal parentage, custody and care, maintenance, inheritance, identity documents and nationality. Nationality is not automatically determined by the place of birth, the genetic link, a clinic letter or a surrogacy agreement; it depends on the applicable citizenship rules and the facts. A birth certificate issued by one authority also does not guarantee that another authority will recognise the same parentage or issue a passport.

Before treatment or birth, counsel should map the intended legal route for each issue and identify the competent authority. Relevant facts may include the marital status of the surrogate, the intended parents’ marital and citizenship status, genetic relationships, where treatment occurs, where the child is born, and which documents can lawfully be obtained. Because the law does not settle every scenario, avoid promising a particular parentage or citizenship outcome.

Arrangements involving another country

A foreign clinic or birth does not automatically remove Malaysian legal and practical risks. The country where treatment occurs may regulate the clinic and agreement, while Malaysian law and administration may become relevant when an intended parent, surrogate or child is in Malaysia, or when Malaysian registration, recognition, immigration or family-law relief is sought. A foreign order or birth certificate should not be assumed to have automatic effect in Malaysia without checking the applicable recognition rules and procedure.

Cross-border planning must therefore be jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction. Before entering an arrangement, obtain advice in Malaysia, in the treatment and birth country, and in each intended parent’s country of nationality where relevant. Confirm in writing who will issue the birth record, which parent or parents will be named, whether a court or administrative order is required, what evidence is needed, and how a passport, entry permission and exit permission will be obtained. A clinic’s experience with other clients is not a guarantee for this family.

Do not assume that a foreign arrangement becomes lawful in Malaysia merely because it complied with the law where it took place. Equally, do not assume that the child will be left without any remedy; available routes depend on the facts and law. The safe approach is to identify possible refusal points before treatment and prepare lawful alternatives rather than trying to solve parentage or travel problems after birth.

A practical pre-action checklist

Before signing an agreement, transferring money, starting treatment or transferring an embryo, assemble the facts that change the legal analysis: the state in Malaysia; the religion and marital status of each participant; whether the surrogate is related to either intended parent; whose gametes and embryo will be used; where each clinical step and the birth will occur; and whether money is a fee, expense reimbursement or another payment.

Ask the clinic and any intermediary to identify in writing the legal and professional basis on which the proposed procedure would be provided despite the National ART Policy and the MMC guideline. Ask for the current policy, the facility’s applicable standard operating rules and a written explanation of what the clinic will not do. A verbal assurance that “others have done it” is not legal authority. If a provider cannot explain the conflict, pause rather than treat the uncertainty as approval.

Instruct Malaysian counsel to address, separately: the current statutory and policy position; the agreement and payment risks; any applicable state fatwa; legal parentage and birth registration; custody, care and maintenance; inheritance and identity records; nationality, passport and travel; and available remedies if the surrogate, intended parents, clinic or authority changes position. Seek advice in the foreign jurisdiction too if any part of the arrangement occurs abroad.

Keep complete, truthful records of advice, consent, medical treatment, payments and communications. Do not make a false declaration about parentage, marital status or the circumstances of birth. If a pregnancy or foreign arrangement is already underway, seek urgent case-specific advice from a lawyer experienced in Malaysian family and cross-border law; do not rely on this general article to make irreversible decisions.

Conclusion and review limits

For planning purposes, Malaysia should not be treated as a jurisdiction where either commercial or altruistic surrogacy is clearly authorised. The 2021 National ART Policy prohibits surrogacy and says agreements are unenforceable; the 2025 Malaysian Medical Council guideline repeats the prohibition. Malaysian law provides no altruistic exception, no reliable contractual route to compel handover, and no automatic route to intended parentage or citizenship.

The conclusions above are deliberately limited. This guide draws on current official medical guidance, the Ministry’s policy publication, official state religious material and academic legal commentary. Other federal or state gazette materials, state fatwas, facility practices or reported judgments may be relevant. Confirm the applicable requirements against the full Ministry text and obtain local legal advice.

Sources and verification limits

The guide reflects official and secondary sources as of 24 October 2026. Confirm relevant case law and the current Ministry texts with Malaysian counsel; primary sources take precedence.

Guides for Malaysia

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards