Italy · Legal status and models

An open legal volume on a desk in a quiet legal research chamber.
Editorial illustration; it is not a court seal or official document.

Surrogacy in Italy: Prohibition and Legal Consequences

Legal position as of 20 October 2026

As of 20 October 2026, Italy’s legal position is restrictive: surrogacy is prohibited and criminally punishable under Article 12(6) of Law No. 40/2004. Since 3 December 2024, Law No. 169/2024 has added an express rule allowing Italian law to punish an Italian citizen for the specified surrogacy conduct committed abroad. A programme being lawful where it takes place, or being described as altruistic rather than commercial, does not by itself remove the Italian-law risk. Three questions must nevertheless be kept separate: whether conduct is criminal, whether a foreign birth record or judgment will be recognised in Italy, and how a child’s relationship with an intended parent can receive legal protection. The first question is governed principally by the criminal statute; the second and third by private international law, civil-status rules and case law. This article maps the framework, not the outcome of an individual case. [1], [2]

What the Italian ban covers

Article 12(6) of Law No. 40/2004 provides criminal sanctions for anyone who, in any form, carries out, organises or advertises the commercialisation of gametes or embryos, or surrogacy. The wording treats surrogacy as a prohibited category in its own right; it does not make payment the element that turns an otherwise lawful arrangement into an offence. The Constitutional Court has repeatedly treated the ban as a deliberate legislative choice connected to the dignity of the gestational woman and the protection of human relationships. In judgment No. 272/2017, the Court did not invalidate the prohibition. In judgment No. 33/2021, it again distinguished the prohibition itself from the separate question of how to protect a child already born through the practice. The prohibition therefore cannot safely be read as limited to a particular family type, a particular genetic arrangement or a particular destination country. [1], [3]

Offence and statutory sanctions

The penalty stated in Article 12(6) is imprisonment for three months to two years and a fine from €600,000 to €1 million. The provision names three forms of conduct: carrying out, organising and advertising. Its wording is broad, but criminal responsibility is personal; the facts, role, intent, territorial connection and applicable version of the law must be assessed for each person. A prospective parent should not assume that liability is limited to an agency or clinic, because the 2024 amendment was expressly directed at surrogacy conduct by Italian citizens abroad, and the Supreme Court’s 2026 interlocutory order describes the amendment as extending responsibility to adults who resort to surrogacy abroad. Conversely, one should not declare every donor, relative, interpreter or support person criminally liable merely because they are connected with a family. The statute does not provide a role-by-role safe-harbour list. Obtain Italian criminal-law advice before making assumptions about an individual’s exposure. [1]

Commercial and altruistic models

The practical distinction is between commercial surrogacy, in which the gestational carrier receives compensation beyond permitted expense reimbursement, and altruistic surrogacy, in which payment is absent or limited to expenses. Those labels matter in jurisdictions that regulate the two models differently. Article 12(6), however, prohibits surrogacy without setting out an express exception for an unpaid, family-based, friendship-based or expense-only arrangement. On the text of the Italian provision, an altruistic label is therefore not a reliable route around the ban. Nor should a person assume that describing a payment as “expenses”, “support”, a gift or reimbursement settles the legal classification. The real arrangements and the governing law must be examined. The separate reference in the same paragraph to commercialisation of gametes or embryos should not be confused with the surrogacy limb: the statute names both categories, and the surrogacy limb is not written as though only a sale of gametes or embryos is prohibited. [1]

Who may face criminal exposure

The statutory verbs—“realizes, organizes or advertises”—make each person’s actual conduct central. The facts may differ for a clinic, intermediary, agency or promoter, an intended parent who commissions the process, and the person who carries the pregnancy. The 2024 amendment expressly addresses specified surrogacy conduct abroad by an Italian citizen. Order No. 5656/2026 discusses that amendment’s deterrent purpose in a civil parentage case; it does not decide the elements of the criminal offence or establish that every intended parent is liable. An Italian citizen should therefore treat resorting to surrogacy abroad as a serious criminal-law risk, not as automatically outside Italian jurisdiction. Criminal liability still depends on the statutory wording, the individual’s conduct and proof in criminal proceedings. Because the statute does not assign liability through a role-by-role chart, advice should be based on citizenship, acts, dates, contracts, payments and the actual division of tasks—not clinic marketing or forum posts. [1], [2], [6]

The cross-border extension from 3 December 2024

Law No. 169 of 4 November 2024 amended Article 12(6) by adding: where the preceding facts, insofar as they concern surrogacy, are committed abroad, the Italian citizen is punished under Italian law. The Act was published in the Official Gazette on 18 November 2024 and entered into force on 3 December 2024. The new clause is nationality-based: it expressly refers to an Italian citizen, not simply to a person who resides in Italy. Residence, dual nationality, the nationality of each intended parent and the location of each relevant act can still matter to the full analysis, but should not be treated as interchangeable. The clause means that foreign authorisation is not a complete answer to the Italian criminal-law question for an Italian citizen. It does not, by itself, mean that every foreign participant is automatically subject to Italian law; other jurisdictional rules and the person’s own conduct need separate analysis. [2], [6]

Effective date and non-retroactivity

The date of the conduct matters. Article 25(2) of the Italian Constitution states that no one may be punished except under a law that entered into force before the act was committed. The extraterritorial sentence added by Law No. 169/2024 entered into force on 3 December 2024. A case involving conduct abroad before that date therefore requires a careful criminal-law analysis of the offence, the earlier version of Article 12(6), the reach of Italian criminal jurisdiction at the relevant time and the constitutional rule against retroactive punishment. Do not infer either that the 2024 amendment automatically applies retroactively or that older conduct is necessarily free of all legal risk. The timing of each act, not merely the child’s birth date or the date on which a contract was signed, may be relevant. Preserve dated records and ask an Italian criminal lawyer to assess the precise chronology. [2], [8]

This is not a general ban on every fertility treatment

The surrogacy prohibition should not be expanded into the inaccurate claim that every form of assisted reproduction is criminal in Italy. Law No. 40/2004 regulates medically assisted procreation more broadly and contains separate eligibility, consent, facility and technique rules. Those rules have themselves been affected by constitutional judgments, including decisions concerning heterologous assisted reproduction and parental status. Whether a particular IVF or donor-conception arrangement is permitted is a different question from whether it involves gestation by a surrogate. A programme that avoids surrogacy may still need a separate assessment under the rules governing access to assisted reproduction, the couple’s status, the technique used and the relevant clinic. Conversely, the fact that a fertility technique is lawful does not make a surrogacy arrangement lawful. Do not rely on a clinic’s general statement that it offers “legal IVF” as an answer to the distinct Italian surrogacy prohibition. [1], [9]

Foreign legality does not settle the Italian question

A foreign country may permit compensated or altruistic surrogacy and may issue a valid birth certificate or court order under its own law. That can establish important facts about the procedure and the child’s status under the law of birth. It does not displace Article 12(6) for conduct covered by Italian law, including the express extraterritorial rule for Italian citizens. Criminal law and recognition of civil status are different legal tracks: a document may be formally valid abroad yet face a separate recognition assessment in Italy. Equally, the existence of a criminal prohibition does not mean the child loses all rights or that every relationship with an intended parent is legally irrelevant. The legal system can discourage the adult conduct while still needing to protect the child. A sound analysis must therefore identify the relevant actors and dates, the foreign law and documents, and the Italian criminal and civil consequences separately. [1], [2], [3]

Parentage and criminal legality are separate questions

A foreign birth certificate does not automatically guarantee that every intended parent named in it will be entered as a parent in Italy. The Civil Joint Sections of the Court of Cassation, in judgment No. 38162/2022, reaffirmed that a foreign judgment recognising a non-biological intended parent following surrogacy is not automatically recognised in Italy, even where the arrangement complied with the law of the country of birth. The Court relied on the Italian public-policy status of the surrogacy prohibition. The treatment of a biological parent and that of a non-biological intended parent may differ; one must not promise that a certificate listing two intended parents will simply be transcribed as written. The result depends on the facts, the form of the foreign act or judgment, the person’s biological link, the applicable recognition route and current case law. This civil-status analysis does not itself decide whether a participant has committed a criminal offence. [5]

The constitutional and Supreme Court case-law line

In judgment No. 272/2017, the Constitutional Court maintained the prohibition and stressed that the child’s concrete interests still matter when a court considers whether to remove or preserve an existing parent-child status. In judgment No. 33/2021, the Court did not authorise surrogacy or require automatic transcription of a foreign order. Instead, it warned that the legal system must provide effective protection for a child born through surrogacy and invited the legislature to address gaps in the law. In judgment No. 38162/2022, the Supreme Court’s Joint Sections rejected automatic recognition of a foreign order naming a non-biological intended parent, while identifying adoption in special cases under Article 44(1)(d) of Law No. 184/1983 as a possible legal route for protecting the child’s relationship. That route is a judicial procedure, not an automatic consequence of the foreign birth certificate. Its availability and suitability depend on the facts and applicable requirements; it should never be represented as guaranteed. [3], [4], [5]

The important 2026 development: Order No. 5656/2026

The status of this question should be described cautiously. Interlocutory Order No. 5656, published on 12 March 2026, sent the case to the First President for possible assignment to the Joint Sections. It asks whether the legal model for recognizing children born to parents who are related by blood—where status may be established after a judicial assessment of the child’s interests—could be extended by interpretation to children born abroad through surrogacy. The order notes that adoption in special cases may be inadequate where the child cannot initiate proceedings or the intended parent is unwilling or unable to proceed. This remains a referral, not a final ruling extending the model; it does not legalize surrogacy, remove the criminal prohibition or create automatic recognition. In the official Court of Cassation case-law index, we have not found a later published Joint Sections ruling on this question. The index does not establish whether the case has been assigned or whether an unpublished procedural step exists. Before relying on any new parentage route, verify the current case status and obtain case-specific advice. [6], [10]

A 2026 decision and the 2025 assisted-reproduction ruling must be read narrowly

The Court of Cassation’s judgment No. 7919/2026, published on 31 March 2026, continued to refuse transcription in a fact-specific case involving an intended parent who died before the surrogacy process was completed. The Court focused on the absence of a sufficiently concrete, completed shared parental project and a lived relationship with the child; it did not create a general rule that every foreign surrogacy birth must be treated identically. Separately, Constitutional Court judgment No. 68/2025 concerned a child born in Italy after assisted reproduction lawfully carried out abroad by a female couple. The Court required recognition of the consenting intended mother in that assisted-reproduction context. It expressly distinguished surrogacy, which remains criminally prohibited and raises different public-policy concerns. It would therefore be incorrect to cite the 2025 decision as having abolished the surrogacy ban or automatically settled parentage after surrogacy. [7], [9]

Practical steps before any programme or payment

Before signing an agreement, transferring money, advertising, arranging a clinic or travelling, obtain advice from an Italian criminal lawyer if any participant is an Italian citizen or any relevant act may occur in Italy. Give counsel the citizenship and residence of every intended parent, the surrogate’s role and location, the clinic and agency identities, the proposed compensation and expense structure, the planned dates and locations, and all draft contracts and messages. Ask for written answers to four distinct questions: which acts may fall within Article 12(6); whether the 2024 extraterritorial sentence applies to the relevant person and dates; what other country’s criminal, medical and family law applies; and what legal-parentage and nationality documents can realistically be obtained. Do not treat an agency’s assurances, a foreign lawyer’s opinion limited to local law, or a clinic’s licence as a full Italian-law opinion. If the proposed arrangement is surrogacy, the safest course is not to proceed on the assumption that an altruistic label or foreign legality removes the Italian risk. [1], [2], [6], [8]

If the child has already been born abroad

Prioritise the child’s practical needs while obtaining coordinated Italian advice on both civil status and possible criminal exposure. Preserve the original birth record, any court order, the surrogate’s consent and contractual records, medical records, proof of genetic relationships where relevant, translations, apostilles or legalisations, travel documents and correspondence with authorities. Do not alter a certificate, conceal the circumstances of birth or make an inaccurate declaration to a registrar or consulate. Ask the competent Italian consulate and municipality, through qualified counsel where appropriate, what documents can be received, what information must be reported and what procedure is available for recognition or adoption. A refusal to transcribe a foreign record is not the same as a final decision that the child has no legal protection. Consider separately the biological parent’s status, the intended parent’s possible route under adoption or any later judicial development, the child’s nationality and travel arrangements. No single certificate or court order should be assumed to settle every issue across Italy and the country of birth. [5], [6], [7]

Decision matrix

Situation Legal starting point What to check
Surrogacy carried out in Italy Prohibited; criminal penalties apply. Actual acts and each participant’s role.
Foreign programme involving an Italian citizen after 3 December 2024 Italian criminal law may apply. Citizenship, dates, acts and jurisdiction.
Free or expense-only arrangement No express exception for altruistic surrogacy. Actual substance of payments and agreements.
Foreign record naming a non-biological intended parent Automatic recognition is not guaranteed. Document type, biological link, judicial route and current case law.
Child already born; parentage dispute The child’s interests must be protected; no automatic outcome is guaranteed. Adoption route and current status of the question in Order No. 5656/2026.
Assisted reproduction without surrogacy Separate rules under Law No. 40/2004 apply. Access, technique, consent and clinic.

Conclusion and limits

The current starting point is clear: Italy prohibits surrogacy, prescribes criminal penalties, and since 3 December 2024 expressly extends Italian criminal law to specified surrogacy conduct abroad by Italian citizens. An unpaid arrangement is not an express exception. What remains fact-sensitive includes each person’s criminal liability, the temporal reach of the amendment in an older case, and the legal route for a child’s relationship with a non-biological intended parent. The 2026 referral in order No. 5656/2026 signals possible change in the parentage-remedy debate, but it is not itself a final change in the law. A qualified Italian lawyer should verify the latest criminal-law and family-law developments against the exact facts before anyone acts. [1], [2], [6]

Primary legal sources and decisions

  1. Law No. 40/2004, Article 12 (current text)
  2. Law No. 169 of 4 November 2024
  3. Constitutional Court, Judgment No. 272/2017
  4. Constitutional Court, Judgment No. 33/2021
  5. Court of Cassation, Joint Civil Sections, Judgment No. 38162/2022 (official monthly review)
  6. Court of Cassation, Interlocutory Order No. 5656/2026, 12 March 2026
  7. Court of Cassation, Judgment No. 7919/2026, 31 March 2026
  8. Constitution of the Italian Republic, Article 25
  9. Constitutional Court, Judgment No. 68/2025
  10. Court of Cassation, current civil case-law index

Guides for Italy

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards