Italy · Eligibility of intended parents

An anonymised legal case file and a branching eligibility worksheet on a dark desk

Who can be an intended parent for surrogacy in Italy?

The short answer

No category of intended parent has a lawful surrogacy eligibility route in Italy. The controlling rule is a prohibition, not an eligibility test: Italian law does not offer a route for a single person, a married or unmarried couple, a same-sex couple, a foreign national, or an Italian resident to qualify for surrogacy in Italy. Citizenship, residence, infertility, a genetic connection to the child, or an altruistic rather than paid arrangement does not create a stated exception to Article 12(6) of Law No. 40/2004. The important distinction is between a surrogacy arrangement carried out in Italy and one carried out abroad. Since 3 December 2024, Italian law also addresses specified surrogacy conduct abroad by Italian citizens. The foreign country’s law, Italian nationality, each participant’s acts and any parentage or registration issue must be analysed separately.

The domestic prohibition and its penalty

Article 12(6) of Law No. 40/2004 says anyone who, in any form, carries out, organises or advertises the commercialisation of gametes or embryos or surrogacy is punishable by imprisonment for 3 months to 2 years and a fine of €600,000 to €1 million. The statutory language is broad and the provision does not create an exception for altruistic surrogacy. An Italian Ministry of Justice legal explainer states that the sanction also applies to intended parents; this is institutional legal commentary, not a finding that every act by a particular person satisfies the offence elements. This article reports the enacted wording; it does not conclude that every prospective parent automatically commits an offence merely by thinking about parenthood or seeking preliminary legal advice. Criminal liability turns on the person’s actual conduct and the applicable interpretation of the provision. Intended parents should not assume that only clinics or agencies are at risk, or that calling a payment a reimbursement makes the arrangement lawful.

A first-pass decision matrix

SituationLegal effect
Any intended parents arranging or carrying out surrogacy in Italythere is no lawful surrogacy route; assess the prohibition before taking any step.
Foreign visitors or residentsa residence permit, visa or non-Italian passport does not create an exception for conduct in Italy.
Married opposite-sex couples, unmarried cohabiting couples, same-sex couples and single peoplenone has a separate surrogacy eligibility route.
Italian citizens considering a programme abroadLaw No. 169/2024 creates an additional and material Italian-law risk, explained below.
Non-Italian citizens considering a programme abroad while living in Italydo not assume that residence alone makes the specific extraterritorial extension applicable to them; equally, do not assume immunity for acts undertaken in Italy. Location, conduct, role and nationality all matter.

Italian citizens considering surrogacy abroad

Law No. 169 of 4 November 2024 amended Article 12(6), effective 3 December 2024. Its added sentence says that if the surrogacy-related acts described in the preceding sentence are committed abroad, an Italian citizen is punishable under Italian law. Official Italian consular guidance states that the foreign country’s permission does not prevent prosecution under Italian law. The key connecting factor in this added sentence is Italian citizenship, not residence in Italy alone. An Italian citizen should obtain independent Italian criminal-law advice before signing a contract, instructing an agency, arranging medical steps, transferring funds or travelling for a surrogacy programme abroad. The precise liability of a particular participant still depends on the conduct, timing, evidence and legal interpretation; the statute should not be reduced to a prediction of conviction in every case.

Foreign nationals and residence: what changes?

The amendment expressly names an Italian citizen. It does not say that every foreign national living in Italy is, solely because of that residence, subject to the same extraterritorial rule for conduct entirely abroad. That narrow reading must not be converted into a promise of safety: the domestic prohibition uses the word “anyone”, and acts performed in Italy, participation in a scheme or other jurisdictional connections may change the analysis. Dual nationality, citizenship status at the relevant time, where decisions and payments were made, and the roles of each intended parent and intermediary should be reviewed individually. No general conclusion about a foreign resident’s criminal exposure abroad can responsibly be made from residence alone. A destination-country opinion also cannot answer the separate question of Italian jurisdiction.

Do not confuse surrogacy with ordinary PMA

Article 5 of Law No. 40/2004 governs access to medically assisted reproduction (PMA), not surrogacy. It describes eligible applicants as adult couples of different sexes, married or cohabiting, of potentially fertile age, and both living. Other provisions and constitutional rulings have affected the broader PMA framework, so a clinic must apply current rules to the specific treatment. But even where a couple satisfies Article 5 for a lawful PMA technique, that does not authorise a surrogate to carry a pregnancy for them in Italy. Article 5 is not a surrogacy licence, and an eligibility test for IVF or another PMA technique must not be reused as an eligibility test for surrogacy. A single person or same-sex couple should not be told that a PMA case has created a route to surrogacy.

What the 2025 Constitutional Court decisions do—and do not—say

Two 2025 Constitutional Court decisions illustrate the distinction. Judgment No. 68/2025 addressed a child born in Italy after a female couple had used medically assisted reproduction abroad in compliance with the law there; it held that the consenting intended mother who had assumed parental responsibility must also be recognised as a parent. Judgment No. 69/2025 rejected a constitutional challenge to the exclusion of single women from access to PMA under Article 5. Neither judgment legalises surrogacy or creates a surrogacy eligibility category. Their subject is PMA and, in Judgment No. 68/2025, the status of a child following that distinct treatment. Applying either decision to surrogacy without examining the different facts and legal rule would be a category error. They are relevant context, not an exception to the surrogacy ban.

Three separate cross-border questions

Surrogacy being lawful or available in a destination country is not the same as it being lawful under Italian law for an Italian citizen, and neither point resolves who will be recognised as a legal parent in Italy. Keep at least three questions separate: (1) whether the arrangement and each participant’s acts are lawful where they occur; (2) whether Italian criminal law may apply to a participant, particularly an Italian citizen acting abroad; and (3) how Italian authorities will treat the child’s foreign birth record or a foreign parentage order. A genetic link, contract, clinic certificate or foreign birth certificate should not be treated as a guarantee of recognition, citizenship, passport issuance or permission to travel. Those consequences depend on separate legal rules and facts and are outside this article’s eligibility conclusion.

Two important cautions about liability and consular records

First, Article 12(8) expressly excludes punishment of the man or woman on whom certain PMA techniques are applied for offences listed in paragraphs 1, 2, 4 and 5; it does not list the surrogacy offence in paragraph 6. Do not assume that this text immunises intended parents in a surrogacy case. The precise application of criminal liability to a particular person must be assessed by an Italian criminal lawyer. Second, official Italian consular guidance says that where a consulate receives a child’s birth record that is, or may be presumed to be, based on surrogacy, it must inform the competent Italian judicial authority when forwarding the record to the relevant municipality. That is a reporting step, not proof that a particular person has committed an offence and not a decision on parentage.

What to prepare before making a commitment

Prepare a factual file and obtain advice on Italian law and destination-country law separately. Gather every intended parent’s passport and citizenship history; residence and immigration documents; evidence of marriage or cohabitation; a dated timeline of proposed or completed steps; the destination, clinic, agency and intermediaries; draft contracts, invoices, payment instructions and communications; any intended genetic connection; and the documents expected after birth. Ask Italian counsel to analyse the exact conduct under Article 12(6), Law No. 169/2024, relevant dates, citizenship (including dual nationality), territorial connections and potential criminal exposure. Ask destination-country counsel separately about local legality, contract validity, parentage, registration, citizenship and travel. Obtain written advice before signing, paying, advertising, instructing an intermediary or travelling. A clinic’s assurance or a local lawyer’s answer alone does not settle the Italian-law issue.

If steps have already been taken or a child has been born

If a contract has been signed, money transferred, treatment started or a child born, do not assume either that prosecution is inevitable or that there is no risk. Preserve authentic records and communications; do not backdate, alter, destroy or make false statements in documents. Seek prompt confidential advice from an Italian criminal-law specialist and a separate family/private-international-law specialist where parentage or registration is involved. If a child has already been born, advice should address the child’s immediate care, documents, nationality and travel needs without treating those issues as a defence to, or proof of, an offence. The practical answer to “Am I eligible?” is: no person has a lawful surrogacy eligibility route in Italy; an Italian citizen considering surrogacy abroad faces an express extraterritorial provision effective from 3 December 2024; other cases require a fact-specific assessment, not a conclusion based on marital status or residence.

Timing and the 2024 amendment

Law No. 169/2024’s new extraterritorial sentence entered into force on 3 December 2024. Article 25(2) of the Italian Constitution bars punishment unless a law was in force before the act. The new sentence cannot by itself be applied retroactively to create criminal liability for completed conduct that it did not cover when done. This is not blanket immunity for events before 3 December 2024: surrogacy carried out in Italy was already criminalised, and the legal treatment of earlier, continuing or multi-step conduct may depend on the rules in force at the time and the facts. Anyone whose timeline crosses that date should give Italian criminal-law counsel a complete, dated account rather than assume that the birth, contract or payment date alone decides the issue.

Official legal sources and guidance checked

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards