Costa Rica: surrogacy disputes, refusals, liability and remedies
Remedies for Costa Rican surrogacy disputes: refusals, registration, evidence and liability.
What this guide covers
This guide addresses disputes among intended parents, a gestational carrier, a clinic, an agency or a Costa Rican public authority about a surrogacy arrangement. A “refusal” may mean a delayed public response, a birth-registration denial, a clinic’s refusal of service, or a private dispute over payment or performance.
Separate four questions: what was decided or done; the child’s current legal status; which remedy can review the decision or conduct; and what evidence proves the facts. Success on delay or missing information does not itself authorize surrogacy or establish the intended parents’ legal parentage.
The legal position in brief
As of 22 October 2026, the primary materials do not establish a comprehensive Costa Rican statute specifically regulating gestational surrogacy. In judgment No. 2026-013258 of 21 April 2026, the public hospital—not the Court as a general holding—said that specific national rules for surrogacy and using or transferring cryopreserved embryos for that purpose were absent. The Court ordered information to be provided and the pending request decided; it did not authorize the procedure.
Do not read that conclusion as saying there are no relevant instruments. Executive Decree No. 39210-MP-S (2015) is an IVF authorization decree, not a dedicated surrogacy statute. The Constitutional Chamber annulled it in resolution No. 2016-001692 of 3 February 2016 for violating the principle of statutory reservation; however, the official SINALEVI record notes that the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, by resolution of 26 February 2016, directed that the decree remain in force. Costa Rican counsel must reconcile these materials and confirm the decree’s operative status and its interaction with later technical rules; it is not a blanket surrogacy authorization. Separately, the official Gazette text published on 30 September 2015 as legislative Bill file No. 18.824 proposed banning surrogacy and a prison penalty of three to six years. It appeared under “Legislative Projects” and is a proposal, not itself an enacted statute. Do not cite its proposed penalty as current criminal law without confirming the bill’s final status and later legislation.
This does not mean that every statute, decree, Gazette publication or bill has been exhaustively checked. The First Chamber’s 2022 decision rejected a claimed general right to surrogacy based on Artavia Murillo; the 2025 and 2026 Constitutional Chamber rulings address specific embryo-transfer or response issues, not general authorization. IVF, embryo-handling and clinic-licensing rules do not automatically create a surrogacy pathway.
Do not infer either extreme from a regulatory gap. The absence of a dedicated statute alone does not prove that every surrogacy-related act is criminal; nor does it establish that a contract is enforceable, a clinic may provide the service, or intended parents will be legally registered as parents. Each issue depends on the applicable rules and facts.
Parentage and civil registration
Costa Rica’s Family Code is a key starting point, but it does not provide a dedicated statutory scheme for surrogacy. Article 78 states that filiation itself cannot be settled by transaction or arbitration, although monetary rights arising from legally established filiation may be settled. Article 92 says parenthood may be established through notorious possession of status or other evidence. These provisions do not resolve a surrogacy arrangement by themselves; they show why a private contract cannot safely be treated as conclusive proof of legal parentage.
Registration rules add a practical evidentiary point. Article 13 of the Civil Registry Regulation requires registration documents to comply with the law and accurately reflect the legal facts established by them; article 20 says that, for hospital births, the birth declaration is checked against the mother’s medical record. Birth and hospital records are therefore important evidence, but a dispute may still turn on supporting documents, the correct procedure for establishing filiation, or the legal effect claimed for the agreement. Identify exactly what the written decision addresses.
What recent courts actually decided
In judgment No. 2026-013258 of 21 April 2026, the Constitutional Chamber partially upheld an amparo against the CCSS. It found violations because requested technical information about a cryopreserved embryo was incomplete and a request for a decision on its use or transfer for a surrogacy process was delayed. The Court ordered the hospital to provide the missing information within 10 days and decide that request within one month after notification. It did not authorize surrogacy, and rejected a separate demand to respect a claimed right to use the embryo because it was framed as an exhortation, not a request requiring a substantive response. Costs, damages and losses linked to the successful parts were left for quantification in contentious-administrative enforcement proceedings.
Judgment No. 2025-015172 of 20 May 2025 concerned transfer of cryopreserved embryos in an IVF treatment setting. It ordered the CCSS to define and approve technical guidelines for safe transfer within 15 business days. This case-specific deadline does not prove that the guidelines were later adopted or remain current; verify the current Ministry of Health/CCSS rules before arranging a transfer. The ruling is relevant to embryo-transfer disputes, but it is not a blanket authorization of surrogacy, a ruling on every surrogacy agreement, or an automatic parentage order. The 2026 Court expressly referred the authorities to the earlier judgment.
The First Chamber’s judgment No. 000943-F-S1-2022 of 5 May 2022 rejected the argument that the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ 2012 Artavia Murillo IVF judgment recognized a human right to surrogacy. It distinguished IVF from gestational surrogacy and denied damages based on that asserted extension. The lower-court reasoning reproduced in the judgment treated the specific agreement as not legitimate; the First Chamber’s own ruling did not establish a comprehensive statutory ban or decide every possible arrangement or private-law claim. Artavia Murillo is not an automatic guarantee of surrogacy.
Match the remedy to the problem
Use the following as a triage guide, not as a substitute for reviewing the actual decision and current procedural rules.
| Issue | First step | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Public authority: silence or missing records | First move: request the specific records and a reasoned decision in writing; keep proof of delivery. Consider constitutional amparo if a public body’s action or omission affects a protected fundamental right. | Limit: the likely remedy may be disclosure or a timely answer, not approval of surrogacy. |
| Civil Registry: registration refused | First move: obtain the written refusal and the date it was notified. The Civil Registry Regulation provides for an appeal to the Supreme Electoral Tribunal (TSE) against covered refusals. | Limit: the stated appeal period is generally three days after notification. Confirm the applicable route and deadline immediately. |
| Parentage or adoption disagreement | First move: get Costa Rican family-law advice on the proper family-court or registration process. | Limit: a contract or DNA evidence does not automatically replace the existing civil status. Adoption, where legally available, has its own statutory conditions and is not an automatic workaround. |
| Clinic, agency, payment or medical dispute | First move: separate the service or payment complaint from the child’s legal status. Review possible contractual, civil-liability, health-regulatory or professional-disciplinary routes. | Limit: prove the legal basis, breach, causation and loss. Do not assume a court can compel a gestational carrier to surrender a child or enforce every contract term. |
If a public body is silent or refuses records
Address a written request to the authority competent for the specific issue. Separate requests for existing records—such as medical reports, embryo laboratory data, consent forms, file references or correspondence—from the request for substantive authorization. Identify the requested decision, relevant dates, urgency, contact details and attached evidence; ask for a receipt, the responsible office and a reasoned written answer.
Under Law No. 9097, a qualifying petition generally requires a response within 10 working days unless a special rule applies. Article 32 of the Law on Constitutional Jurisdiction separately addresses when amparo may be brought for failure to answer a petition if no specific response period is set. A complex request for substantive authorization is different: the applicable procedure and reasonable time must be assessed on their own terms. Silence should not be treated as automatic approval of surrogacy or embryo transfer.
Article 29 of the Law on Constitutional Jurisdiction allows amparo against public action or omission that violates or threatens a fundamental right. The 2026 case shows that it may secure missing information and a timely decision. It does not mean that every refusal is unconstitutional or that the Court must grant the substantive request. For ordinary administrative legality, complex procedural disputes or damages, contentious-administrative proceedings may be the appropriate route. The right forum depends on the actual claim; do not assume that an internal appeal is always required or that it is never relevant.
If the Civil Registry refuses registration
Ask for the complete written resolution, its legal and factual reasons, the documents considered and the appeal instructions. Record the date and method of notification. Article 50 of the Civil Registry Regulation provides that covered decisions denying civil-registration procedures are reviewed by the TSE on appeal; article 51 states a three-day period after notification, except where a special period applies. Treat this as an urgent deadline and verify the current rule and the instruction on your particular resolution with Costa Rican counsel.
Submit the appeal through the proper channel with a concise chronology, the specific error alleged, supporting documents and a clear request for relief. Request access to the file if needed, but do not let an informal request for clarification cause a short appeal period to expire. If the real dispute is legal parentage rather than a correctable document defect, counsel should assess whether a family-court process or another judicial route is needed. Amparo is not a general substitute for an ordinary appeal on disputed facts.
Clinic, agency, contract and damages
Collect the signed agreement and amendments, identify every contracting party, and review governing-law, forum, dispute-resolution, payment, refund, cancellation, confidentiality and representation clauses. Preserve the exact wording of promises about parentage, registration, clinic approval, travel documents or guaranteed outcomes. Obtain independent Costa Rican family- and health-law advice before asserting a contract claim.
A separate claim may be worth assessing if there is evidence of negligent medical care, unauthorized handling or loss of reproductive material, misleading representations, privacy breaches, unpaid refunds or another actionable breach. Depending on the facts, routes may include a civil claim, a complaint to the competent health regulator, or a professional-disciplinary complaint. The proper defendant, forum, limitation period and available remedy require individual review. A complaint or damages claim against a provider does not itself establish legal parentage.
Damages are fact-specific. The 2026 award concerned the proven information and delay violations, not denial of a general right to surrogacy. Another claimant must independently prove a legal basis, causation and recoverable loss.
Evidence to secure now
Preserve the original files and metadata; keep an indexed, dated copy set. Depending on the dispute, collect:
- Written refusal or decision, the full envelope or email headers, and proof of the date it was served.
- Every application, appeal, follow-up, receipt, file number, deadline notice and authority response.
- Signed contracts, amendments, invoices, receipts, bank transfers, refund terms and the clinic’s or agency’s exact advertising or written assurances.
- Consent forms, medical records, laboratory and embryology reports, cryostorage or transfer records, chain-of-custody information and names of responsible providers.
- Messages, emails, call notes, witness details and a chronological log of who said or did what, when and through which channel.
- Birth and hospital records, current civil-register extracts, existing parentage or adoption orders, identity documents, and foreign judgments with any required certified translation or authentication.
- Do not edit, backdate, recreate or conceal documents. Keep the child’s and gestational carrier’s sensitive medical and identity information secure, and share it only with people who need it for the proceeding.
Cross-border consequences are separate
A Costa Rican administrative or court remedy does not automatically settle nationality, passport issuance, exit permission, entry into another country or recognition of parentage abroad. Check the law and practice of every relevant country separately, including the child’s likely country of nationality and the intended parents’ country of residence. Consular authorities may require documents beyond a Costa Rican birth certificate or private agreement.
Do not assume that birth in Costa Rica, a genetic link, a pending court case or a contract guarantees nationality or permission to travel. Plan the registration, parentage and travel questions in parallel, but do not treat them as interchangeable.
A practical sequence
- Classify the dispute: records, delay, registry refusal, parentage, medical conduct, contract or money.
- Identify every deadline today. For a Civil Registry refusal, check the short TSE appeal period immediately; do not wait for a separate opinion before preserving it.
- Send the precise request or appeal through the official channel and retain proof of filing and delivery.
- Build an indexed evidence file and write a neutral chronology. Separate facts you can prove from statements that remain disputed.
- Ask Costa Rican counsel to choose the forum and remedy: administrative appeal, constitutional amparo, contentious-administrative claim, family proceeding, civil claim or regulatory complaint.
- Protect the child’s safety, identity and best interests. Do not misstate who gave birth, submit inaccurate registry information or rely on informal arrangements to bypass official procedures.
- If any participant or intended parent is abroad, check foreign recognition, nationality and travel-document requirements at the same time.
Limits and publication review
The proper route may depend on where the embryo was created, pregnancy and birth occurred; genetic links; the gestational carrier’s informed consent; payments; public or private provider status; the wording and date of refusal; the child’s current status; and existing domestic or foreign orders. Verify these facts before choosing a remedy.
Before use, verify current law and deadlines, review the full file, and obtain Costa Rican counsel’s assessment.
Primary sources
- Código de Familia, Ley n.º 5476 (arts. 78 y 92)
- Sala Constitucional, resolución n.º 2026-013258 (21 de abril de 2026)
- Sala Constitucional, resolución n.º 15172-2025 (20 de mayo de 2025)
- Sala Primera, resolución n.º 000943-F-S1-2022 (5 de mayo de 2022)
- Reglamento del Registro del Estado Civil, Decreto TSE n.º 6-2011 y sus reformas (arts. 13, 20, 50–51)
- Ley de la Jurisdicción Constitucional, Ley n.º 7135 (arts. 29 y 32)
- Ley de Regulación del Derecho de Petición, Ley n.º 9097
- Código Procesal Contencioso-Administrativo, Ley n.º 8508
- Decreto Ejecutivo n.º 39210-MP-S, autorización de FIV y transferencia embrionaria (2015; ficha SINALEVI con nota sobre resolución de la Corte IDH de 26 de febrero de 2016)
- Sala Constitucional, resolución n.º 2016-001692 (3 de febrero de 2016)
- La Gaceta n.º 190, 30 de septiembre de 2015, proyecto de ley, expediente 18.824 (texto propuesto)
