Costa Rica · Legal status and models

Open legal reference book with research notes on a desk in a quiet law library

Surrogacy in Costa Rica: what the law establishes—and what remains unresolved

Short answer: no clear surrogacy safe harbour

As of 26 October 2026, the official primary materials do not establish a comprehensive Costa Rican statute specifically authorising and regulating gestational or traditional surrogacy, or a complete legal route for intended parents, the person carrying the pregnancy, clinics and intermediaries. In the 21 April 2026 case, the public hospital stated in its response, reproduced in the judgment, that no specific national legislation or regulation governed surrogacy. The Constitutional Chamber did not itself decide that surrogacy is generally lawful or unlawful; it found procedural violations in handling that individual request and ordered complete information and a decision within specified deadlines, not approval of the procedure.

The safest description is therefore a regulatory gap with important consequences, not a categorical claim that every surrogacy arrangement is prohibited and not a promise that an arrangement is permitted. The absence of a specific statute does not automatically settle criminal exposure, contract enforceability, legal parentage, birth registration or recognition abroad. Each question can be governed by different rules and authorities. Altruistic intent does not itself remove those uncertainties, and payment does not automatically prove a particular offence. A proposed programme should not be marketed or entered into as “legal in Costa Rica” without a current, fact-specific opinion from Costa Rican counsel and confirmation from the relevant medical and civil-registration authorities.

Which rules actually apply?

Costa Rica does have a regulatory framework for in vitro fertilisation and embryo transfer (FIV/IVF), including Executive Decrees No. 39210-MP-S, No. 39616-S and No. 39646-S. These instruments address IVF authorisation, technical and operational standards, and the habilitation of health establishments. The Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ Artavia Murillo judgment concerned Costa Rica’s former general prohibition of IVF and the reproductive, family-life and equality rights affected by that prohibition. In its compliance process, the Inter-American Court addressed the measures required to restore access to IVF.

Those sources matter, but their scope must not be overstated. IVF is a medical technique; surrogacy adds a separate arrangement in which one person carries a pregnancy for intended parent(s). Rules governing embryo creation, storage, transfer, clinic standards or professional qualifications do not by themselves establish who is the legal parent at birth, whether a surrogacy agreement is enforceable, what payments may be made, or how a child’s documents will be issued. A clinic’s ability to perform IVF is not proof that it is authorised to provide a surrogacy programme. Nor does a general human-rights ruling on access to IVF automatically decide the legality of gestational-carrier arrangements.

The legal timeline—and a point that can mislead readers

In 2016, Costa Rica’s Constitutional Chamber annulled Executive Decree No. 39210-MP-S on the ground that the subject required formal legislation under the principle of legal reservation. In its 26 February 2016 supervision resolution in Artavia Murillo, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights directed that the decree remain in force, without prejudice to later legislation consistent with the Court’s judgment. Costa Rica then developed additional technical regulations for IVF establishments and their operation. The official materials, including later Costa Rican judicial decisions and the Procuraduría General’s 2025 opinion, continue to describe the IVF framework through these decrees.

This history should be described accurately rather than compressed into “the decree was annulled, so IVF is illegal” or “the decree exists, so surrogacy is legal.” The later international compliance order and the subsequent regulatory practice are essential to understanding the current IVF position. They do not, however, supply a surrogacy statute. A legal memorandum should identify the exact instrument, its current text, the effect of the relevant court orders and the particular procedure under consideration.

What the courts have—and have not—decided

The Supreme Court’s First Chamber, in resolution No. 000943-F-S1-2022 of 5 May 2022, considered a claim connected with surrogacy and explained that the Inter-American Court’s 2012 Artavia Murillo judgment dealt with IVF, not access to a surrogate uterus. The ruling therefore did not recognise a human right to surrogacy that could support the particular damages claim before it. This is a meaningful limit on arguments that the IVF judgment itself guarantees access to surrogacy. It is not, by itself, a comprehensive statutory prohibition of every possible surrogacy arrangement.

A separate Constitutional Chamber decision, No. 2025-015172 of 20 May 2025, concerned a couple seeking to move their own cryopreserved embryos from a public hospital to an authorised private clinic to continue homologous IVF. The Court ordered the Costa Rican Social Security Fund (CCSS) to define and approve technical guidelines within 15 working days from notification of the judgment, and to complete the inter-clinic transfer within 15 working days after approval of the guidelines, subject to the conditions and prohibitions in Decrees No. 39210-MP-S and No. 39616-S. That individual order concerned the couple’s own IVF treatment, not use of an embryo in surrogacy; it should not be treated as a general surrogacy authorization. The materials reviewed here do not establish whether the guidelines were subsequently implemented, so their current status must be checked.

A different issue arose in Constitutional Chamber resolution No. 2026-013258 of 21 April 2026. The applicant sought information about a cryopreserved embryo and a decision on its use or transfer in a proposed altruistic surrogacy process. The Chamber partially upheld the amparo concerning the failure to provide complete information and the delay in deciding the specific request. It ordered the hospital to provide the complete information within 10 days from notification of the judgment and to decide the request within one month from that same notification. The Court did not order that the request be granted, establish a general entitlement to surrogacy, or resolve all questions about surrogacy agreements and parentage. The legal significance is procedural: an authority must answer a concrete request within the terms of the judgment, not that the requested treatment has been universally approved.

Commercial and altruistic surrogacy: neither label settles legality

Altruistic surrogacy generally means that the gestational carrier is not paid a profit or fee for carrying the pregnancy, although reimbursement of documented expenses may be contemplated. Commercial surrogacy generally involves compensation beyond expense reimbursement. These labels are useful descriptions, but they are not a substitute for a Costa Rican rule specifying which payments are allowed, which services may be provided, how consent must be documented, and what legal effects an agreement will have. The primary sources do not establish a complete Costa Rican statutory scheme that expressly permits one model and prohibits the other.

Do not infer that an altruistic arrangement is authorised simply because no profit is intended. A proposed payment can still raise questions about its purpose, recipient, documentation and relationship to medical services or placement of a child. Conversely, do not label every payment or expense reimbursement criminal without identifying an applicable offence and its elements. Agency fees, matching fees, medical bills, insurance, lost earnings, travel, accommodation and post-birth support should be itemised separately and reviewed under the actual law. Any claim that a commercial model is lawful, prohibited or routinely accepted by authorities needs specific, current evidence. Until that evidence is obtained, the responsible conclusion is that the distinction is legally important but does not resolve the regulatory gap.

Contracts, consent and legal parentage are separate questions

A written agreement can record intentions and allocate practical responsibilities, but it cannot create legal effects that mandatory law does not recognise. Before signing, counsel should analyse at least four separate issues: whether the proposed medical procedure may be performed; whether the agreement or any payment terms are enforceable; how parentage will be determined after birth; and whether the birth record, nationality documents and travel permissions can actually be obtained. A positive answer on one issue does not answer the others.

The agreement should not promise that the gestational carrier can irrevocably waive every right, that intended parent(s) will automatically be entered on the birth certificate, or that a foreign court or consulate will accept the arrangement. These outcomes cannot be assumed from the fact that an embryo is genetically related to an intended parent, from the parties’ nationality, or from the use of a private clinic. The precise rules for parentage, consent, registration and recognition require current Costa Rican family-law advice, together with advice in every country whose nationality, residence or travel rules will apply. If the proposed programme involves donor gametes, a single intended parent, same-sex intended parents or foreign nationals, those facts should be identified for separate analysis rather than treated as incidental details.

Legal status matrix

The following matrix is a decision aid, not a declaration that an arrangement is approved. It separates settled points of law from matters that remain open and identifies the next check required before a family commits money or starts treatment.

IssueWhat the sources showPractical next step
Comprehensive surrogacy lawThe 2026 judgment reproduces the hospital’s statement that no specific national surrogacy rules existed; the Court’s holding was procedural.Do not treat silence as automatic permission or a universal ban; obtain current case-specific advice.
IVF and embryo handlingSeparate executive rules govern IVF technique and health-establishment standards.Confirm the exact procedure and current clinic habilitation; IVF authorisation is not surrogacy authorisation.
Inter-clinic embryo transport for own IVFIn one case, the 2025 ruling ordered the Costa Rican Social Security Fund (CCSS) to approve technical guidelines within 15 working days of notification and transfer the couple’s own embryos for homologous IVF within 15 working days after guideline approval.Check implementation and current guidelines; do not extend the ruling to surrogacy.
Altruistic modelNo general statutory safe harbour identified.Document all reimbursements and obtain a case-specific opinion before conception.
Commercial modelNo verified comprehensive rule classifying every payment or intermediary service.Itemise fees and have counsel assess each payment and activity; avoid categorical marketing claims.
Parentage and birth recordNo surrogacy-specific parentage route established by the sources.Obtain a written parentage and registration plan before starting.
Public-hospital requestThe 2026 judgment required complete information within 10 days from notification and a decision on the specific request within one month from the same notification; it did not approve surrogacy generally.Separate the request for information from the request for authorisation; keep proof of filing.
Prenatal fosteringLaw No. 10506 regulates a distinct process and intermediation in that process.Do not use it as a substitute for surrogacy advice; assess the actual facts with counsel.

Prenatal fostering is not a surrogacy statute

Costa Rica’s Law No. 10506, the Ley de Acogimiento Prenatal, establishes a process for prenatal fostering where a pregnant woman does not intend to assume care of the child after birth. It assigns a role to the National Child Welfare Agency (Patronato Nacional de la Infancia, PANI) and includes a prohibition on intermediation in requests for that specific prenatal-fostering process. It is a distinct legal mechanism; its existence does not amount to a statutory surrogacy framework or a shortcut for validating a pre-arranged surrogacy placement.

The difference matters because a surrogacy programme is usually planned before conception and includes a reproductive arrangement, while prenatal fostering concerns the route described in the statute for a pregnant woman who does not intend to care for the child after birth. The two should not be merged by labels alone. If facts include an agreement to place a child with a particular person or couple, agency involvement, money, or a pre-conception plan, Costa Rican counsel should assess whether Law No. 10506, its intermediation rule, the amended Penal Code and child-protection law are relevant. This is a reason to obtain advice, not a basis for asserting that every surrogacy arrangement falls within the offence or procedure.

Public medical institutions and the 2026 decision

The 2026 judgment illustrates the difference between a procedural duty and substantive authorization. A court may require an authority to provide records and decide a request on time without deciding that the proposed procedure is lawful or requiring approval.

A person facing a similar situation should keep the initial application, proof of delivery, follow-up letters, medical records, consent forms and every written response. The application should state precisely what is requested: information, embryo transfer, use in a proposed procedure, or a reasoned administrative decision. Those are not identical requests. If an institution refuses or delays, the available remedy depends on the actual act or omission, the authority responsible and the relief sought. A court order requiring a response should not be described as a court order authorising surrogacy itself.

Before committing to a programme: practical checks

Do not pay a non-refundable agency deposit, begin medication, create or transfer embryos, or sign a final agreement on the assumption that surrogacy is lawful. First obtain a written opinion from an independent Costa Rican lawyer who works with family law, assisted reproduction and administrative regulation. Ask the lawyer to identify the exact current legal provisions and court decisions, distinguish binding law from a clinic’s internal policy, and address the commercial or altruistic structure proposed. Request written confirmation from the relevant health authority and the actual clinic about its licence or habilitation, the procedures it is authorised to perform, and whether it will undertake the specific gestational-carrier arrangement—not just IVF.

Next, map parentage and documentation before conception. Identify the intended legal parent(s), the gestational carrier’s legal status, any donor, the expected birth-registration process, and the authorities that will issue identity, nationality and travel documents. Obtain separate advice for the destination or home country: a Costa Rican document may not automatically determine parentage or nationality abroad. Review every payment and reimbursement, insurance and medical-cost allocation, consent process, contingency for miscarriage or medical complications, and dispute-resolution clause. Require written answers, not sales statements. If any key issue remains unanswered, treat that as a stop condition rather than assuming the parties can solve it after birth.

If a programme is already underway

If a person has already signed an agreement, stored embryos, paid an intermediary, become pregnant or had a child, the next step is not to rely on a generic statement that the arrangement is “valid” or “invalid.” Preserve all agreements, payment records, clinic correspondence, consent forms, medical records and registration documents. Ask counsel to assess the exact stage reached, any immediate medical deadlines, the available administrative decisions and the possible parentage and travel routes. Avoid moving embryos, changing records or making representations to an authority without checking the legal and medical consequences first.

Where an authority has received a formal request, make sure the requested relief is clearly stated and keep proof of the date of filing. The 2026 judgment shows that a failure to provide information or decide a specific request may be challengeable; it does not guarantee a favourable substantive decision. If a child has already been born, the priority is lawful care, accurate civil-status registration and a realistic plan for identity and travel documents, not a retrospective assumption that the original contract controls. The relevant foreign law must be checked before travel or a request for recognition is made.

Conclusion: what can safely be said

The evidence supports a narrow but useful conclusion. Costa Rica has rules for IVF and health establishments, but the sources do not show a comprehensive statute that resolves the legality and effects of surrogacy as a distinct arrangement. The 2022 Supreme Court ruling prevents treating Artavia Murillo as a guarantee of surrogacy access. The 2026 Constitutional Chamber ruling protects procedural rights in a particular request; it does not establish a general permission. Law No. 10506 addresses prenatal fostering, not a surrogacy programme. The 2025 ruling on transfer of a couple’s own embryos for homologous IVF is limited to that individual case and does not resolve surrogacy.

Accordingly, neither “commercial surrogacy is permitted” nor “all altruistic surrogacy is prohibited” is a conclusion this evidence can support. The decisive next step is a current written analysis of the exact arrangement, including payments, medical procedure, parentage, registration and cross-border consequences, supported by confirmation from competent Costa Rican authorities.

Official primary sources (links open the source language)

  1. Sala Constitucional, resolución n.º 2026-013258 (21 April 2026) — Specific request involving altruistic surrogacy; no general authorization.
  2. Sala Primera, resolución n.º 000943-F-S1-2022 (5 May 2022) — IVF judgment distinguished from surrogacy; not a comprehensive statutory ban.
  3. Sala Constitucional, resolución n.º 2025-015172 (20 May 2025) — IVF embryo-transfer dispute; not a surrogacy authorization.
  4. Ley n.º 10506, Ley de Acogimiento Prenatal (published 12 September 2024) — Prenatal-fostering statute and related intermediation rules.
  5. Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos, caso Artavia Murillo y otros vs. Costa Rica, supervisión de cumplimiento (26 de febrero de 2016) — Official order maintaining Decree 39210-MP-S in force for IVF, subject to later legislation; not a surrogacy ruling.
  6. Procuraduría General de la República, dictamen PGR-C-237-2025 (8 December 2025) — Official opinion on the technical IVF framework, not surrogacy.

Guides for Costa Rica

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards