Costa Rica surrogacy: intended-parent eligibility
Short answer: no confirmed surrogacy-specific eligibility scheme
As of 26 October 2026, the reviewed official sources do not establish a complete Costa Rican statutory scheme determining which intended parents may use gestational surrogacy. The text of Article 2 of Decree No. 39210-MP-S lists general categories of IVF recipients, but the sources do not settle whether those categories apply to the intended parents, the gestational carrier or both. Nor did I verify a separate surrogacy-specific rule based on foreign nationality or Costa Rican residence. This does not prove that every category is permitted or that any category is automatically excluded. Before payment, embryo creation or transfer, or treatment, obtain a written opinion on the exact arrangement under current Costa Rican law and the law of every country relevant to parentage and travel.
What “eligibility” means here
Eligibility is only one part of the legal decision. It must be separated from whether a clinic may lawfully perform the medical procedure, whether a contract is enforceable, who will be treated as a legal parent at birth, how the birth is registered, and whether the child can obtain nationality and travel documents. A favourable answer to one question does not answer the others. This article concerns the initial intended-parent screening question: whether foreign status, residence and family status determine access to a surrogacy arrangement in Costa Rica. The relevant evidence is the official legislation and decisions identified below; this is not an exhaustive audit of every administrative file, court record or unpublished practice.
Regulatory baseline: IVF is not a surrogacy code
Decree No. 39210-MP-S is the framework for in-vitro fertilisation and embryo transfer. Its defined procedure concerns fertilising an egg outside the body and transferring the embryo to a woman’s uterus. It provides a framework for IVF; it does not, on its face, set out a separate gestational-carrier programme with intended-parent eligibility categories, rules for foreign applicants, a residency threshold, or a marital-status test. A rule allowing or regulating IVF should therefore not be cited as if it expressly authorises every form of gestational surrogacy. The distinction matters most where an embryo is to be transferred to a person who is not intended to raise the child.
The decree’s legal history is unusual. Costa Rica’s Constitutional Chamber declared Decree No. 39210-MP-S unconstitutional on formal grounds in Resolution No. 2016-001692 (3 February 2016). On 26 February 2016, however, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ordered, in its supervision of compliance with Artavia Murillo, that the decree remain in force pending later legislation; the preamble to Decree No. 39616-S records that order, and later Costa Rican judicial materials continue to refer to Decree 39210-MP-S as the IVF framework. Because this history involves a domestic constitutional ruling and an international compliance order, counsel should confirm the decree’s current legal effect and consolidated text before relying on it. Decree No. 39616-S sets technical standards for IVF establishments, while Decree No. 39646-S sets their health-facility habilitation requirements. Neither creates a separate eligibility programme for intended parents using a gestational carrier.
The 2022 judicial decision distinguishes IVF from surrogacy
In Resolution No. 00943-2022 of 5 May 2022, the First Chamber of the Supreme Court discussed IVF and defined partial and complete surrogacy in the course of its analysis. The official case summary states that the Inter-American Court’s 2012 Artavia Murillo judgment concerned access to IVF, not a right to access a surrogate uterus; the First Chamber did not treat that judgment as establishing a human right to surrogacy. This decision is important because a general right to reproductive treatment cannot safely be converted into a conclusion that every surrogacy model is legally available. It does not, however, create a detailed statutory eligibility test for foreign, resident, married or single intended parents.
The 2025 embryo-transfer ruling has a narrower scope
Constitutional Chamber Resolution No. 15172-2025, dated 20 May 2025, concerned people undergoing IVF in a public hospital who sought to move their cryopreserved embryos to a private centre to continue treatment. The Chamber ordered the Costa Rican Social Security Fund to define technical guidelines for safe embryo transfer, subject to the applicable IVF rules. That ruling addresses transfer of embryos in an IVF pathway. It should not be represented as a general authorisation for gestational surrogacy, approval of a surrogacy contract, or a ruling that foreign intended parents satisfy eligibility requirements.
The 2026 decision requires a response, not approval
In Resolution No. 13258-2026 of 21 April 2026, the Constitutional Chamber partially upheld an amparo concerning access to information about a cryopreserved embryo and delay in deciding a request to use or transfer it for altruistic gestational surrogacy. The Court ordered the hospital to provide the requested information within 10 days and to resolve the request within one month. The judgment did not itself authorise the surrogacy procedure or decide a general eligibility category. It records the hospital’s position that Costa Rica lacked specific legislation or national rules for surrogacy, but the operative relief was about information and timely administrative decision-making. The practical lesson is that a request should be answered on time; it is not that the request must be approved.
Foreign nationality and Costa Rican residence
No published rule says that foreign nationals are eligible, ineligible, or eligible only after a specified period of residence. Nor did I verify a surrogacy-specific visa, residence permit or minimum-stay pathway. Immigration permission to enter or remain in Costa Rica is a separate question from whether a clinic can perform the proposed treatment and whether the intended parents can establish parentage. A tourist entry, temporary residence card or permanent residence status should not be treated as a surrogacy approval. If a provider says that foreigners are accepted, ask for the legal basis and whether that statement concerns medical intake only or the complete arrangement and its legal consequences.
Marriage, single applicants and relationship type
No verified surrogacy-specific rule in the sources sets a positive or negative eligibility test based on being married, unmarried, single, in a different-sex couple or in a same-sex couple. It would be unsafe to promise that all of these categories qualify; it would be equally unsafe to assert a blanket prohibition without a current legal source. Ask the Costa Rican adviser to analyse the intended parents’ exact civil status and the proposed route to parentage, including any foreign marriage or partnership document. A clinic’s internal policy may be narrower than the law, may change, and is not itself proof of a statutory eligibility rule.
The text of Article 2 of Decree No. 39210-MP-S lists two general categories of IVF recipients: (1) a couple of two adults where at least one has infertility and neither has been judicially declared incapable; and (2) an adult woman without a partner who has infertility and has not been judicially declared incapable. These are general IVF categories, not a clear surrogacy-specific eligibility rule. Costa Rican law does not settle whether the intended parents, the gestational carrier, or both must meet these criteria when an embryo is transferred to a gestational carrier. Do not assume that single men, unmarried or same-sex couples, or foreign applicants are automatically included or excluded; obtain a current written interpretation for the exact arrangement.
Decision matrix: what can and cannot be concluded
Use this matrix as a screening tool, not as a substitute for a legal opinion. It distinguishes a verified rule from a question that remains unresolved in the sources.
| Factor | What the law establishes | What to do next |
|---|---|---|
| Nationality | No verified nationality-based eligibility rule was found. | Do not assume foreign applicants are automatically accepted or barred. |
| Residence | No verified surrogacy-specific residence period or immigration route was found. | Check immigration status separately from treatment eligibility. |
| Family status | No verified test based on marriage, single status or couple type was found. | Obtain a case-specific opinion; distinguish clinic policy from law. |
| Embryo and procedure | IVF and embryo-transfer rules do not themselves establish a surrogacy pathway. | Identify the exact procedure, embryo source and storage/transfer route. |
Interpretation note: “no verified surrogacy-specific test” does not mean the general IVF recipient categories are irrelevant. The written opinion should state whether Article 2 applies to the intended parents, the gestational carrier, both, or neither in the proposed arrangement.
Facts that can change the assessment
The answer may depend on the actual procedure and records, not only on the applicants’ passports. Important facts include whether the arrangement is gestational or traditional surrogacy; whose egg and sperm created the embryo; whether donor gametes are involved; where fertilisation and embryo storage occurred; whether embryos are held by a public or private facility; whether a transfer between facilities is requested; whether the gestational carrier has independent advice and gives informed consent; and where the intended parents expect parentage to be recognised. These facts do not automatically make the arrangement lawful. They identify the questions counsel must answer before the parties commit to treatment.
Documents to assemble for a preliminary legal review
Prepare a factual file, while making clear that this is a practical pre-review list rather than an official statutory checklist. Include identity and passport documents for each intended parent; proof of current immigration status if relevant; marriage, divorce or partnership documents; a short medical summary explaining why surrogacy is proposed; records identifying the genetic contributors and the source, status and storage location of any embryo; existing consent forms for gametes, embryos and treatment; and the draft agreement or written proposal from the clinic or agency. Ask the provider for its current Costa Rican authorisation and the exact legal basis on which it proposes to carry out the specific procedure. Do not assume that a document list supplied by a clinic is a government eligibility list.
Safe sequence before signing or paying
First, describe the proposed pathway in writing: the intended parents, gestational carrier, genetic material, embryo location, clinic, payment structure and intended place of birth. Second, obtain a written opinion from Costa Rican counsel that addresses the exact facts, cites current primary law and explains what remains uncertain. Third, have separate advice on parentage and immigration/nationality in the intended parents’ home state. Fourth, ask the clinic to confirm in writing whether it accepts the case medically and what legal authority supports each step. Fifth, agree on contingency plans for refusal, delay, pregnancy complications, disagreement, withdrawal of consent and a child’s documentation. Avoid non-refundable deposits or embryo transfer until these points have been reviewed.
Public and private providers are not interchangeable
The 2026 Constitutional Chamber case arose from a request involving a public hospital and an embryo stored in the public system. Its ruling about timely responses does not decide every question facing a private clinic. Public bodies are constrained by the principle of legality and may need a clear legal basis before acting; a private provider’s willingness to proceed does not, by itself, establish that the procedure is authorised, that the contract is enforceable or that the intended parents will be recognised. Verify the provider’s actual licence or health authorisation for the relevant assisted-reproduction services, but do not confuse an IVF facility authorisation with express approval of gestational surrogacy.
Parentage, birth registration and travel are separate decisions
Even if a clinic agrees to treatment, that does not settle who the law treats as a parent at birth. Nor does it guarantee that the birth record will name the intended parents, that a foreign civil registry will recognise the record, that the child will acquire a particular nationality, or that a passport and exit permission will be issued promptly. These questions may involve Costa Rican family and civil-registration law, the law of the parents’ country, and conflict-of-laws rules. Obtain a separate written plan for parentage, birth registration, recognition abroad, nationality and travel documents before treatment begins. Do not rely on a promise that the child’s citizenship or departure is “automatic.”
If an authority or provider delays or refuses
Keep the complete application, proof of delivery, medical records, all written replies and a dated chronology. Ask the decision-maker to identify the legal basis for any refusal, the competent authority, missing documents and available review route. Where a public body has not answered, a focused request for information and a reasoned decision may be appropriate; Resolution No. 13258-2026 shows that unreasonable delay and failure to provide records can raise separate constitutional issues. But that remedy concerned the handling of a particular request. It does not guarantee a favourable decision on surrogacy eligibility, and the correct procedure and deadline must be checked for the individual case.
Practical conclusion and limits of this guide
The reliable conclusion is limited but useful: the official sources do not establish a clear statutory eligibility checklist for intended parents in Costa Rican gestational surrogacy, and they do not verify that nationality, residence or marital status alone decides access. The case law distinguishes surrogacy from IVF and does not convert the right to IVF into a general right to surrogacy. The 2026 ruling required information and a timely decision, not approval. Before proceeding, obtain current Costa Rican advice on the exact procedure and separate advice on parentage and cross-border consequences.
The text of the general IVF framework lists recipient categories, but does not settle how they apply when a gestational carrier carries the embryo. That issue, the current legal effect of Decree No.
Official sources
- Decreto Ejecutivo No. 39210-MP-S — Autorización para la realización de la técnica de reproducción asistida de Fecundación In Vitro y transferencia embrionaria
- Sala Primera, Resolución No. 00943-2022, 5 May 2022
- Sala Constitucional, Resolución No. 15172-2025, 20 May 2025
- Sala Constitucional, Resolución No. 13258-2026, 21 April 2026
- Sala Constitucional, Resolución No. 2016-001692, 3 February 2016
- Decreto Ejecutivo No. 39616-S — Norma para Establecimientos de Salud que realizan la Técnica de Reproducción Asistida de Fecundación In Vitro y Transferencia Embrionaria (FIV)
- Decreto Ejecutivo No. 39646-S — Norma para la habilitación de establecimientos de salud que realizan la técnica de reproducción asistida de Fecundación In Vitro y Transferencia Embrionaria (FIV-TE)
- Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos, Resolución de supervisión de cumplimiento de sentencia, 26 de febrero de 2016, Caso Artavia Murillo y otros (“Fecundación in vitro”) vs. Costa Rica
