Croatia · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Editorial illustration of a legal case file, a redacted document and an evidence timeline on a desk.
Editorial illustration only; not evidence of any real authority, clinic, legal approval or person.

Croatia: Surrogacy Disputes, Refusals, Liability and Remedies

The first question is not simply who broke a promise. Croatian law expressly prohibits surrogacy arrangements, so the legal route depends on whether the dispute concerns an invalid agreement, separate misconduct, a healthcare service, an official decision, or a child’s legal status.

The legal starting point: a prohibited arrangement is not an enforceable promise

Article 31 of Croatia’s Act on Medically Assisted Reproduction prohibits seeking or offering a service to bear a child for another person. It also prohibits arranging or carrying out assisted reproduction to have a child for others and hand the child over. Agreements and other legal transactions for that purpose are null and void, whether paid or unpaid.

A claimant should not assume a court will compel pregnancy, continuation of pregnancy, delivery of a child or another promise forming part of the prohibited arrangement. An agency likewise cannot assume a fee is recoverable merely because it is called a “success fee”. The statutory prohibition and nullity must be addressed first.

The rule does not automatically resolve separate questions about money already paid, misleading statements, independent lawful services, medical injury or an authority’s decision. Each requires its own legal basis and evidence. This guide does not conclude that every participant committed a crime or that a refund or damages award is automatic.

Identify the actual dispute before choosing a remedy

Classify the problem before choosing a procedure. Repayment of an agency fee is usually a private-law money dispute. Alleged deliberate false statements about Croatian legality, licensing, success rates or parentage may raise separate misrepresentation or tort issues. A healthcare complaint is different from a claim to enforce the surrogacy arrangement. A registrar’s refusal may be reviewable administratively, while parentage or recognition of a foreign judgment requires separate family-law and cross-border analysis.

State the exact correction and lawful result sought: repayment of a defined sum, medical-record access, a reasoned official decision, regulatory investigation or review of a decision. Do not frame the remedy as completing the programme or forcing a child’s handover where that would enforce the prohibited arrangement.

Identify the clinic, agency, professional, payment recipient, registry and foreign authority separately; their duties and defences may differ.

If an authority refuses an application, obtain the formal decision

If a Croatian registrar, ministry or other public body refuses an application or does not act, establish whether you received a formal administrative decision, an informal email, a request for missing documents or a statement that the request cannot be processed. Ask for a written, reasoned decision stating the legal basis, material facts, available remedy and deadline. Keep the envelope, delivery receipt or electronic service record because service may start the clock.

Where permitted, request the file and copies of the evidence relied on. Compare the decision with the application and applicable law. Grounds may include a wrong legal test, omission of a relevant submission, a material factual error, inadequate reasons or procedural unfairness. Identify the error and supporting document.

The appeal should not merely repeat personal hardship. A child’s welfare and family life may be legally relevant, but do not automatically override the surrogacy prohibition or establish a right to the requested entry. The route depends on the actual decision and governing rules.

Administrative appeal and judicial review: deadlines matter

Under Croatia’s General Administrative Procedure Act, an appeal against a first-instance decision is generally due within 15 days of service unless a longer period applies. It is normally lodged through the first-instance body for the competent second-instance body. Check the decision’s remedy instruction and any special law; not every refusal has an ordinary appeal.

The 2024 Administrative Disputes Act generally allows 30 days from service of the challenged individual decision or the decision on an objection to challenged conduct. It also covers failure to decide or act on time. For failure to issue an individual decision or act within a prescribed period, Article 40(2) allows an action no earlier than eight days after that period expires. Other legally prescribed remedies generally must be exhausted first. The route and calculation depend on the decision and special rules. For proceedings begun before 1 July 2024, check the transitional rules separately: in April 2026 the Constitutional Court set aside Article 169(2), which had created an exception for certain pending cases. Do not assume the former Act applies without case-specific advice.

An administrative action does not automatically suspend the decision. Interim protection requires statutory conditions. A court may review legality, annul a decision or, where permitted, require a decision or action; related restitution or damages may sometimes be considered. It cannot grant a result contrary to the governing law.

If a deadline may have expired, seek Croatian procedural advice immediately. Informal correspondence, an inspection complaint, negotiations or a file request should not be assumed to stop a formal deadline.

Money paid under a null surrogacy arrangement

Article 323 of the Croatian Civil Obligations Act provides that each party must return what it received under a null contract. If return is impossible or unsuitable because of the nature of the performance, an appropriate monetary equivalent may be due, subject to law. A party culpable for entering the null contract may also owe damages caused by nullity if the other party did not know and was not required to know the reason for nullity.

This is not a refund guarantee. Identify every recipient and payment, the stated purpose, the parts tied to the prohibited arrangement, what was actually supplied and the legal basis for repayment. Non-returnable services, payments to different entities, separate lawful services, the claimant’s knowledge and conduct, and contract wording can affect the result. Do not assume that separate services are legally severable.

Preserve contracts, invoices, transfers, receipts, cancellation terms and refund messages. Send a written demand specifying amount, recipient, dates, legal basis and response date. Do not demand performance of the surrogacy promise. Before signing a settlement, release or new agreement, assess its effect on claims and evidence.

Fraud, misrepresentation, negligence and damages require separate proof

Nullity does not make every related act lawful, but it does not automatically prove fraud or a right to compensation. A separate claim may be possible if evidence supports an independent wrong, such as knowingly false statements about legality, a fabricated licence, diversion of funds, breach of an independent professional duty or negligent medical care. Identify the cause of action, defendant, jurisdiction and remedy before filing.

For civil damages, prove the statement or duty, who made or breached it, the falsity or breach, reasonable reliance, actual loss and causation. Advertising may show what was promised but does not alone prove falsity, reliance, causation or quantum. Criminal reports, regulatory complaints, civil claims and refund demands serve different purposes; one does not establish the others.

Article 230 of the Civil Obligations Act generally gives a non-contractual damages claim three years from knowledge of the damage and responsible person, with a five-year outer period from the damage. Contractual damages follow the limitation period for the relevant obligation. Check the claim’s legal character, special periods, suspension or interruption and current consolidated text.

Healthcare complaints and regulatory oversight

If the issue concerns healthcare quality, content, consent, safety or records, separate it from any request to enforce the prohibited arrangement. Preserve the clinical file, consent forms, treatment plan, prescriptions, test results, invoices and correspondence. State the specific act or omission and the result sought.

Croatia’s Ministry of Health publishes guidance describing a direct or written complaint to the head of a healthcare institution and an eight-day written response expectation. The page cites an older amendment list for the Health Protection Act. Verify the current statutory basis, deadline and applicability to the particular public or private provider before relying on eight days. The guidance also identifies the competent minister, professional chamber and court as possible further channels where appropriate.

Article 55 of the Assisted Reproduction Act assigns ministry inspection responsibility for supervision of the Act and professional work at covered authorised institutions. A report may prompt regulatory assessment, but inspection is not a private refund or damages award. Do not assert a specific fine or offence without checking current provisions and the responsible party.

Parentage and a child’s status must be analysed separately

Article 58.a of Croatia’s Family Act, inserted by the 2023 amendments that took effect on 31 December 2023, states that the child’s mother is the woman who gave birth. For a child born before that date, or a proceeding already pending then, Croatian counsel should assess the provision’s temporal application and any relevant transitional rules; do not assume retrospective effect. Together with Article 31 of the Assisted Reproduction Act, this means a private agreement, genetic link, payment record or agency promise does not by itself establish legal parentage in Croatia.

The Family Act also prioritises protection of a child’s rights and welfare in relevant decisions. That principle matters but does not guarantee that a foreign birth certificate, judgment or intended-parent arrangement will be registered or recognised in a particular way. Recognition of foreign decisions, correction of civil-status records, paternity, nationality and travel documents may involve different legal tests and authorities.

If a child has been born, avoid steps that risk safe care or inconsistent registrations. Obtain the birth record, hospital documents, foreign decisions and proof of service/finality, relevant genetic evidence, and nationality or residence records. Ask counsel to analyse care, parentage, registration, nationality, passport and cross-border movement separately. The void agreement does not resolve these questions.

Evidence to preserve before sending complaints or claims

Create a dated chronology from first contact to refusal, cancellation or discovery of alleged wrongdoing. Preserve original emails with headers, complete chat exports, advertisements, screenshots with URLs and capture dates, all contract versions, invoices, transfers, receipts and written promises about legality, licensing, success, refunds, parentage or handover. Keep originals unchanged and work from copies; retain an unredacted original securely if personal data must be hidden in a working copy.

For an administrative dispute, keep the filed application, attachments, submission proof, requests for more documents, decision, service record and remedy instruction. For healthcare issues, request relevant records and preserve consent and treatment documents. For alleged misrepresentation, identify the exact statement, author, date, payment made in response and proof of loss. Damages also require evidence of amount and causation.

Inventory each original by source, receipt date, filename and storage location. If records may be deleted, promptly request lawful preservation. Do not publish personal medical or child information online; share sensitive material only when needed for advice or formal proceedings.

Choose the route that matches the problem

Use this matrix for initial triage, not as a prediction of success. Each remedy requires its own legal basis, correct recipient or authority, and supporting evidence.

Dispute typePotential routeKey evidence / caution
Payment under a surrogacy agreementAssess restitution after nullity under Civil Obligations Act Article 323; identify each recipient and the exact basis for repayment.Contract, payment trail, service breakdown; refund is not automatic.
Alleged false representation or diversion of fundsAssess a separate civil claim and, where facts support it, a regulatory or criminal report.Exact statement, author, date, reliance, payment and loss; a complaint is not proof.
Healthcare quality, consent or recordsUse the applicable provider complaint route and consider the competent chamber, Ministry or court.Medical records, consent, chronology; verify the current deadline and procedure.
Formal administrative refusalUse the remedy stated in the decision; assess administrative court review after required remedies.Full decision, proof of service, application file; usually short statutory deadlines.
Child’s parentage or foreign documentSeek a separate family-law and cross-border assessment focused on the child’s status and welfare.Birth and hospital records, foreign decisions, finality/service evidence; no automatic recognition.

A practical sequence for the next steps

  1. Protect immediate welfare and medical needs. If a child or patient faces immediate danger, contact emergency or safeguarding services.
  2. State one target: refund, records, review of an official refusal, healthcare investigation or damages for an independent wrong. Do not seek specific performance of the prohibited arrangement.
  3. Preserve evidence and calculate the earliest plausible deadline. Record service dates and when each loss became known. Do not assume negotiation or a complaint pauses time.
  4. Send the right request to the right recipient: refund demand to the payment recipient, formal appeal under the decision’s instructions, healthcare complaint through the applicable provider process, or regulatory report identifying the suspected breach.
  5. Consult Croatian counsel before filing, especially where foreign parties or documents, child status, medical confidentiality or limitation periods are involved. Confirm current law, forum, standing, evidence, costs and interim relief.
  6. Coordinate but do not merge routes. A regulator may investigate without ordering repayment; a civil court may decide a money claim without deciding parentage; an administrative court may review a refusal without validating a surrogacy agreement. Record each case number and response deadline.

Limits of this guide and the final decision

Official statutory publications were accessed; full consolidated amendment history remains unverified. The Ministry complaint page cites an older amendment list, so the eight-day statement needs confirmation.

Relevant facts include where the agreement and treatment occurred, who received payment, the parties’ residence and nationality, whether a formal decision exists, whether a child has been born, and whether a foreign judgment is final and recognisable. They can affect jurisdiction, applicable law, standing, interim relief and deadlines. The surrogacy prohibition is not a conclusion about every separate service contract, every participant’s liability or a child’s status.

Primary sources and source-status notes

The links below lead to the official Croatian publication or Ministry guidance. Check amendments and applicability before relying on a deadline or making a filing.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards