Costa Rica surrogacy contracts, agencies and payments: legal limits and risks
This is a transaction-risk review, not a statement that a surrogacy programme is authorized. The key current source is Constitutional Chamber Resolution No. 13258-2026 (21 April 2026), concerning a request to use or transfer a cryopreserved embryo for surrogacy. The Court partially granted the application because information was incomplete and the response delayed; it ordered the hospital to provide the requested information and decide the request within specified periods.
The ruling did not approve the procedure, create a general right to surrogacy, or decide private-contract enforceability. The official record includes the hospital’s position that Costa Rica has no specific national surrogacy legislation or regulation. As at 22 October 2026, the prudent conclusion is material uncertainty: neither every private agreement is necessarily void or criminal, nor are clinics, agencies or payments thereby authorized.
1. What the latest court decision does—and does not—say
The 2026 case matters because it is recent and concerns surrogacy directly, but its holding is procedural. The majority found a failure to provide complete information and an unjustified delay in resolving the request about embryo use or transfer. It ordered the hospital to provide the information and decide the request; it did not decide the ultimate authorization question in favour of the applicant.
The hospital’s statement about no specific national framework is its position in that case, not a general statutory ban imposed by the Court. The judgment does not establish that every private arrangement is lawful. Later legislation, a competent-authority decision or the facts of a programme may change the analysis.
2. A signed contract is not the same as an enforceable surrogacy arrangement
Costa Rican private law recognises contractual freedom, but it is not unlimited. The Procuraduría General de la República’s 2025 opinion, discussing general principles rather than surrogacy, summarises limits such as public order, morality, third-party rights, good faith and reasonable balance between the parties. A contract label cannot cure an unlawful purpose or create powers that the law has not granted.
Costa Rica has no specific statutory regime, so a private agreement must not be marketed as guaranteed enforceable. A court may distinguish payment for lawful services from clauses that compel medical treatment, predetermine parentage, force post-birth handover, or purport to bind a civil registry or public hospital.
3. Clinics: a general health permit is not surrogacy approval
Costa Rican health rules require applicable permits or habilitation for health facilities and services. Verify the clinic’s current permit, covered services, responsible clinicians and technical requirements. Obtain the official document and confirm it with the issuing authority; a website badge or agency statement is insufficient.
Do not treat an ordinary permit or IVF experience as surrogacy approval. Costa Rica separately regulates in-vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (FIV-TE) through Decrees 39210-MP-S (2015), 39616-S (2016) and 39646-S (2016, amended in 2025). These address FIV access, technical operation and clinic habilitation; the texts do not expressly establish a comprehensive surrogacy regime or confirm that transfer to a gestational carrier is covered. Resolution 15172-2025 concerned embryo transfer from a public hospital to a private clinic in the particular applicants’ case under technical safeguards; it is not general authorization for a surrogacy program. Resolution 13258-2026 required a response to a specific request, not general approval. Public bodies remain subject to legality and private providers must comply with applicable health rules and other law. Obtain current written advice on the exact procedure.
4. Agencies and intermediaries: verify what they actually do
The sources did not establish a specific Costa Rican licence category for surrogacy agencies. This remains a verification question, not proof that no licence exists or that every agency is illegal or authorized. Ask for the legal entity, registration number, tax details, address, directors, subcontractors and legal basis for each activity.
Separate coordination and translation from medical treatment, legal representation, escrow or custody of funds. The contract should say who provides each service, who is responsible if a subcontractor fails, what fees are earned, and who holds the money. Treat promises that the agency can “guarantee” a birth certificate, parentage, nationality, passport or exit clearance as a warning sign: those outcomes are decided under applicable public law, not by the agency’s marketing language.
5. Payments, compensation and refunds
Costa Rican law does not support a categorical statement that all surrogacy-related payments are permitted or all compensation is prohibited. Without a specific framework, the payment’s legal character, purpose, recipient, documentation and link to medical care matter. Do not rely on an agency’s assurance without written advice for the proposed transaction.
Require a written, itemised budget separating clinic fees, laboratory work, professional services, agency coordination, insurance, travel, documented pregnancy-related expenses and any proposed compensation. Each amount should identify the payee, currency, due date, evidence required and refund rule. Avoid cash, unexplained third-party accounts, vague “success fees”, or payment descriptions that disguise the true recipient or purpose.
Use independent escrow or a client-money account only after local counsel checks the provider, account ownership, release conditions, insolvency risk and dispute process. Tie instalments to verifiable services, not to child delivery or guaranteed public recognition of intended parents. Define outcomes if authorization is refused, the clinic declines, consent is withdrawn, or the programme stops for medical reasons.
6. Clauses to settle before signing or transferring funds
A contract review should address, at minimum:
- Parties and scope: the full legal names of all parties; the exact services; each party’s responsibilities; and the identity of every clinic, doctor, agency, laboratory and payment holder.
- Conditions before performance: written advice from independent Costa Rican counsel and counsel in the intended parents’ country of residence; confirmation of the clinic’s current permissions; and a clear process if an authority refuses or does not answer.
- Consent and medical decisions: independent advice for the gestational carrier, understandable informed-consent documents, privacy safeguards and respect for the carrier’s own medical decisions. Do not use penalties to coerce treatment, pregnancy decisions or consent.
- Money: itemised fees, milestones, receipts, escrow control, permitted expense categories, cancellation dates, refund calculations, responsibility for extra medical costs and a process for disputed invoices.
- Failure and termination: separate rules for failed embryo transfer, miscarriage, medical contraindication, withdrawal of consent, clinic closure, regulatory refusal, non-performance and force majeure. Do not assume one clause can resolve every event or guarantee a particular legal outcome.
- Records and disputes: access to records, confidentiality and data handling, language versions, governing-law and forum clauses, notice addresses, mediation or litigation steps, and an express statement that no party can contractually bind a registry, court, immigration authority or public hospital.
7. Practical matrix: what each document proves
Treat each document as evidence of only what it actually covers. None of the following, on its own, establishes that a surrogacy programme is legally authorized or that intended parents will be recognised as legal parents.
| Item shown | What it may establish | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Clinic health permit | Permission for the listed establishment or service to operate within the permit’s scope. | Specific authorization for gestational surrogacy or every proposed procedure. |
| Agency registration or company extract | Existence or registration details of the entity identified in the record. | A surrogacy-specific licence, competence, solvency or lawful performance of every promised service. |
| Signed programme contract | The written terms and evidence of what the parties agreed to. | That every clause is enforceable, or that parentage and birth registration are predetermined. |
| Escrow statement or payment receipt | Where money was deposited or transferred and the amount recorded. | Legality of the underlying purpose, refund entitlement in every scenario, or a guaranteed outcome. |
| Embryo-transfer or medical record | A medical event or service recorded by the provider. | Legal parentage, birth-certificate content, nationality, passport or permission to leave Costa Rica. |
| Agency promise or draft birth plan | What the intermediary says it expects or intends to arrange. | A binding decision by a court, registry, health authority or immigration authority. |
8. Documents to verify before paying
Obtain and independently check the clinic’s current health permit or habilitation certificate, the service scope, professional registration details for the responsible clinicians, the draft medical-service contract, and any official written response on the specific proposed procedure. If the programme relies on a public hospital or a transfer of cryopreserved material, request the institution’s written decision and the applicable technical protocol.
For the agency, obtain current company-registry details, the person authorised to sign, a complete fee schedule, subcontractor list, refund policy, escrow agreement, sample receipts and a written description of exactly what is and is not included. Ask for documentary support for every claim of government approval, clinic partnership, licence, insurance cover or guaranteed result. Verify each claim with the named institution rather than through the intermediary alone.
Keep the proposed agreements in editable form and obtain independent advice before signing or paying. Ask counsel to mark each clause as supported, uncertain or unacceptable; identify the source for any claimed permission; and state what remains unresolved. A verbal assurance, notarisation, apostille or translation can authenticate or evidence a document but does not make an otherwise unlawful transaction valid.
9. If the programme stops, is delayed or a party defaults
Preserve every version of the contracts, messages, invoices, bank records, receipts, medical records, consent documents, permit copies and refund calculations. Send a written notice identifying the breached promise, the amount claimed, the contractual clause relied on, the requested remedy and a reasonable response date. Do not alter records or rely on verbal summaries alone.
A Costa Rican lawyer should assess whether the claim supports damages, refund, termination, restitution or another remedy. Results may differ for clinic services, agency fees, expense reimbursement and disputed compensation. If fraud, coercion, threats or falsified records are suspected, seek separate advice on reporting. Do not use a refund dispute to pressure anyone about medical treatment or consent.
10. Civil registration and child-protection red lines
Do not agree to false statements about who gave birth, genetic relationships, consent, identity or other facts in a civil-status record. Costa Rica’s Penal Code, Article 182, criminalizes specified conduct including causing false facts to be entered in a birth record where they alter civil data or parentage; Article 183 bis addresses specified violations of adoption procedures. These provisions are not a special surrogacy code and their application depends on the facts and legal elements, but they make any proposal to falsify registration or bypass child-protection procedures a serious warning sign.
A contract cannot guarantee a parentage entry accepted by the Civil Registry, compel anyone to hand over a child, or replace a required legal procedure. Separate four questions: (1) may the medical service be provided; (2) is the payment obligation valid; (3) who is legally recognized as a parent; and (4) can the child obtain travel documents and leave the country? Resolving one does not resolve the others.
11. Cross-border enforcement is a separate risk
The law governing payment or agency obligations may not control parentage, birth registration, nationality, immigration or recognition abroad. A choice-of-law or court clause in a private contract does not automatically bind a foreign court or public authority, and a judgment or document may require a separate recognition process.
Before committing funds, identify the proper defendant, where its assets are located, the competent court or forum, proceeding language, service requirements and whether a judgment can be enforced where the money or assets are held. Separately confirm how destination-country law assesses the child’s status and travel; do not infer this from Costa Rican clinic paperwork.
12. A safer sequence for a real transaction
Before any non-refundable payment, follow this order:
- First, obtain an independent written opinion from Costa Rican counsel on the proposed medical steps, contracts, payment model and the current official record. Ask counsel to distinguish confirmed rules from gaps and unresolved interpretations.
- Second, obtain a separate written opinion in the intended parents’ country of residence on parentage, registration, nationality, entry/exit documents and recognition of any Costa Rican records.
- Third, verify the clinic’s current permits and the exact scope of each service directly with the issuing authority; separately verify the agency’s legal identity, signatory and subcontractors.
- Fourth, negotiate the contracts, consent process, payment schedule, escrow controls, cancellation rules and refunds only after the legal conditions are identified. Do not let the agency’s standard form substitute for independent advice.
- Fifth, make each payment traceable and conditional on a defined lawful service. Stop before the next stage if the provider cannot supply the promised document, an authority has not answered a necessary question, or a party asks for false records or pressured consent.
Conclusion
For Costa Rica, the responsible answer is caution, not a categorical yes or no. Decrees 39210-MP-S, 39616-S and 39646-S regulate FIV-TE, but the reviewed texts do not establish a comprehensive surrogacy regime or confirm that transfer to a gestational carrier is authorized. Neither Resolution 13258-2026 nor the case-specific order in Resolution 15172-2025 grants general approval. Obtain independent written advice in Costa Rica and the intended parents’ destination country before signing or paying.
Official sources
- SRC-01 — Constitutional Chamber, Resolution No. 13258-2026 (21 April 2026) — procedural holding on information and a pending surrogacy-related request; not general authorization.
- SRC-02 — Procuraduría General de la República, PGR-OJ-084-2025 (27 May 2025) — general contractual-freedom principles; non-binding and not surrogacy-specific.
- SRC-03 — Executive Decree No. 43432-S (2022) — general health operating and service-habilitation permits.
- SRC-04 — Penal Code, Articles 182 and 183 bis — specified false civil-registration and adoption-procedure offences.
- SRC-05 — Procuraduría General de la República, PGR-C-186-2023 (6 October 2023) — general principle of legality for public administration.
- SRC-06 — Executive Decree No. 39210-MP-S (2015) — FIV and embryo-transfer rules; not a surrogacy-specific authorization.
- SRC-07 — Executive Decree No. 39616-S (2016) — published standard for FIV establishments; current amendments should be confirmed in the legal database.
- SRC-08 — Executive Decree No. 39646-S (2016), current consolidated text amended in 2025 — technical habilitation requirements for FIV-TE facilities.
- SRC-09 — Procuraduría General de la República, PGR-C-237-2025 (8 December 2025) — official opinion on FIV-TE regulatory requirements, not surrogacy-specific.
- SRC-10 — Constitutional Chamber, Resolution No. 15172-2025 (20 May 2025) — case-specific embryo transfer between a public hospital and a private clinic; not general surrogacy approval.
