Brazil surrogacy: contracts, agencies and payments
In Brazil, a surrogacy arrangement should not be treated as an ordinary paid service contract. The central medical-ethics rule is that temporary transfer of the uterus must not have a lucrative or commercial character. At the same time, clinics, lawyers and other professionals may charge for genuine services; the difficult question is what a particular payment is actually buying and whether the structure disguises commercial surrogacy. Brazilian law does not provide a single comprehensive statutory code resolving every contract, intermediary fee or reimbursement question. The article therefore separates established professional rules from general contract law and from points that need an individual Brazilian legal opinion.
The short answer: separate the arrangement from the services
The safer starting point is to separate four relationships in writing: (1) intended parents and carrier; (2) patients and fertility clinic; (3) each party and its own lawyer or independent adviser; and (4) any agency or coordinator and the party paying it. Do not accept one bundled “surrogacy package” price without a breakdown. A contract can record consent, responsibilities and genuine service fees, but cannot by itself legalise a commercial gestational arrangement, guarantee every clause will be enforced, or determine the child’s legal parentage, nationality or travel documents.
Before paying, identify what each payment buys, which professional rule applies, what evidence supports the amount, what happens if treatment fails or a dispute arises, and which issues need prior confirmation from the Regional Council of Medicine (CRM), civil registry or court.
Which rules govern the arrangement?
CFM Resolution 2,320/2022 sets professional ethical standards for doctors using assisted-reproduction techniques. On 26 March 2025, the CFM said Brazil still lacked a specific statute comprehensively regulating assisted reproduction and identified Resolution 2,320/2022 as the applicable ethical framework.
The resolution is not a complete civil statute for every agency, payment or private agreement. It directly concerns medical professionals and clinic practice. General contract questions remain governed by the Civil Code, including good faith and limits on contractual freedom. Depending on the relationship, consumer protection, sanitary rules, data protection and civil-registration rules may also apply. A clinic’s ethical duty, sanitary licence, contractual remedy and legal parentage are distinct questions.
Clinical eligibility and the required record
Under the CFM framework, temporary uterus transfer is contemplated where a medical condition prevents or contraindicates pregnancy for the intended genetic parent. The carrier is ordinarily required to be a blood relative, up to the fourth degree, of one intended parent. If that relationship is unavailable, an exception may be requested from the competent Regional Council of Medicine; do not assume the clinic can waive the requirement on its own. The CFM rules also state that the carrier should have at least one living child and should not be the egg or embryo donor.
The clinical file should document informed consent by the people involved, medical assessment of physical and emotional suitability, a commitment between the intended parents and carrier addressing filiation, the intended parents’ commitment to provide medical and multidisciplinary care for the carrier through the puerperium, their commitment to register the child, and written approval from the carrier’s spouse or partner where she is married or in a stable union. The precise current text and any amendments must be checked against the official resolution.
A TRF1 notice published on 16 July 2026 reports that its Fifth Panel upheld an authorization in case no. 1033483-38.2025.4.01.3500, despite the carrier not having a living child. The underlying decision is dated 17 May 2026. The public notice concerns that specific case and does not create a nationwide automatic exemption. Obtain the full judgment and advice on its status and applicability before relying on it.
Payment to the carrier: compensation versus expenses
The CFM rule is that temporary uterus transfer must not have a lucrative or commercial character. A fixed fee for carrying a pregnancy, “salary,” inconvenience payment, success bonus, or sum payable on birth or handover creates serious risk. Calling it a gift, allowance, reimbursement or administrative expense does not decide its legal character; the substance, calculation, timing, recipient and connection to pregnancy matter.
Brazilian rules provide no comprehensive official list of reimbursable expenses, universal cap or blanket safe harbour. Do not promise legality just because receipts will be kept. Before transfer, ask Brazilian counsel to assess the exact items and payment route; obtain written CRM guidance where appropriate. If reimbursement is considered defensible, use actual, necessary, proportionate pregnancy-related costs, approved in advance in writing and supported by itemised receipts or direct vendor invoices. Avoid fixed monthly stipends, unexplained cash, payments to relatives, success-linked instalments and undocumented “miscellaneous” sums.
The intended parents’ commitment to medical care through the puerperium is a separate requirement, not permission to pay compensation for gestation.
Clinic fees, agency fees and other intermediaries
Fees for real medical services, laboratory work, consultations, legal advice, translation or independent psychological assessment are not automatically the same as carrier remuneration. They should identify the actual service, provider, scope, price, timing and invoice. An unallocated package fee, commission for finding a carrier, payment conditional on pregnancy or live birth, or intermediary that hides the recipient deserves heightened scrutiny.
The CFM framework restricts commercial surrogacy and does not allow the fertility clinic to intermediate the carrier’s selection. This does not establish that every independent agency fee is unlawful or every coordination service is permitted. Published Brazilian rules do not resolve every agency model. Require a written task list, identities of subcontractors and beneficiaries, disclosure of commissions and conflicts, and details of any recruitment, matching, negotiation or payment to the carrier. Have Brazilian counsel classify the proposed fee in writing; do not pay a success fee or apparent commercial procurement fee without that review.
What a contract can do—and what it cannot guarantee
The Civil Code recognises contractual freedom within the social function of contracts and requires good faith in negotiation and performance (arts. 421–422); it also permits atypical contracts subject to general rules (art. 425). A transaction may be invalid if its object is unlawful or it seeks to evade a mandatory rule (art. 166). These provisions neither automatically validate a surrogacy agreement nor establish that every non-commercial agreement is void. Enforceability must be assessed clause by clause against the facts, professional rules and participants’ rights.
Keep medical decisions separate from financial duties. A contract should not force a procedure, waive emergency care, predetermine a medical decision, guarantee a child or transfer parentage by signature alone. Specify informed-consent decision-making, access to independent advice, privacy and what happens if consent is withdrawn, treatment fails, complications arise, or intended parents separate or die. Counsel should review termination, refunds, dispute forum, language, records and liability clauses. A contract cannot displace mandatory law or the child’s independent interests.
Due diligence on the clinic and the agency
Verify the fertility centre’s exact legal entity and address, responsible technical professional, current sanitary licence and status with local health surveillance. ANVISA publishes inspection materials for assisted human reproduction centres under RDC 771/2022; because public lists change, confirm current regularisation with the local authority. Marketing, a polished website or an agency referral is not proof of a valid licence.
ANVISA publishes inspection materials for assisted human reproduction centres under RDC 771/2022; the relevant inspection route became effective on 20 September 2024. Because public lists change, confirm current regularisation with the local authority.
For every intermediary, verify company registration, actual contracting party, address, invoice, bank-account ownership, relevant professional credentials and complaint process. Do not route funds through an unrelated personal account or accept hidden commissions or sub-agents.
Documents, parentage and sensitive information
Before treatment, retain identity and relationship documents; the clinic agreement and itemised price list; informed-consent forms; medical and psychosocial reports; the carrier commitment term addressing filiation; written CRM authorisation if an exception is used; spouse/partner approval where required; the care plan through the puerperium; all agency and professional-service contracts; invoices, receipts and transfer proofs; and required approvals for biological-material transport. Keep signed versions and amendments, not just screenshots.
The CNJ’s consolidated notarial rules (Provimento 149/2023, as amended) are the relevant identified source for birth registration after assisted reproduction and appear to require documentation for gestational surrogacy, including a commitment term from the temporary uterus donor clarifying filiation. Confirm the operative wording and registry requirements with the competent registry before birth. A private contract alone does not guarantee a birth certificate, foreign parentage recognition, nationality or travel documents.
Medical, genetic and sexual-life information is sensitive personal data under Brazil’s LGPD. Limit collection to a defined purpose, restrict access, identify recipients, set retention/deletion periods, secure electronic transfers and assess international transfers before sending records. Blanket consent to share “everything” is not a substitute for a lawful basis and safeguards.
Payment risk matrix
| Payment or arrangement | Initial risk position | Practical check before paying |
|---|---|---|
| Itemised clinic, laboratory or consultation fee | Potentially distinct from carrier remuneration; still subject to professional and sanitary rules. | Verify provider, licence, exact service, written price, invoice, cancellation and refund terms. |
| Independent legal, translation or psychological service | Potentially legitimate where real and independent work is performed. | Require a defined scope, fee, credentials, invoice and conflict disclosure. |
| Carrier “compensation,” wage, inconvenience payment or success bonus | High risk under the non-commercial CFM rule; enforceability is not established. | Do not transfer without case-specific written advice and any necessary CRM guidance. |
| Travel, medicine, lodging or other expense reimbursement | Fact-sensitive; no comprehensive safe-harbour list or cap has been published. | Obtain advance written legal review; use actual, necessary, itemised costs and transparent proof. |
| Agency matching, recruitment or success fee | No blanket answer for every model; high risk if linked to commercial procurement or a paid carrier. | Demand a task-by-task fee schedule and written Brazilian legal analysis before signing. |
| Deposit, escrow or “non-refundable package” | Risk depends on the contract, consumer-law applicability and the underlying services. | Identify who holds funds, release triggers, accounting, cancellation rights and refund calculation. |
This matrix is a screening tool, not a legal approval. The classification can change with the recipient, the real service, the amount, timing, documentation and contractual purpose.
A safer sequence before signing or transferring money
- Ask the clinic for its current CFM checklist and all documents required in the clinical file.
- Before embryo transfer, confirm the medical indication, carrier relationship or CRM exception route, assessments, informed consent and required written approvals.
- Separate the carrier commitment, clinic treatment agreement, legal-services engagement and agency agreement; classify every payment before signing.
- For each charge, obtain the recipient, service, amount, currency, invoice, due date, conditions, refund method and any third-party share.
- Obtain written Brazilian legal advice on any carrier-related payment or agency commission. If called reimbursement, ask which expense categories, evidence and payment method support that classification.
- Verify the clinic’s current sanitary status and any transporter; confirm birth-registration documents directly with the registry.
- Pay traceably to the named contracting party after the agreed milestone and against an invoice. Keep the contract version, transfer proof, receipts, messages and approvals together.
Pause if the provider hides beneficiaries, asks for a false invoice, suggests splitting payments to conceal their purpose, guarantees parentage or citizenship, or demands a large non-refundable amount before licences, documents and refund terms are verified.
If a payment or contract dispute arises
Preserve the full signed agreement and all versions, advertisements, messages, invoices, receipts, bank records, clinic-file requests, consents and proof of services delivered. Create a dated timeline and separate medical care, fee accounting/refund, intermediary conduct, data misuse, registration and parentage. Do not rely on an oral promise that contradicts the signed terms.
Brazilian counsel can send a formal notice identifying the clause, amount, evidence and requested remedy. Depending on the facts, options may include a consumer complaint if the Consumer Code applies, a professional-conduct complaint to the CRM, a sanitary report to the local authority or ANVISA, or a civil claim or urgent court application. The Consumer Code requires clear information and contains rules on defective services and contract terms, but its application and any refund or damages depend on the relationship and facts.
Agency payment, a carrier agreement or clinic approval does not automatically settle parentage. The TRF1 decision mentioned above is a case-specific qualification to one eligibility condition, not a general ruling on compensation, agency fees or contract enforceability.
Bottom line: treat the non-commercial rule as the central payment constraint; distinguish real professional services from compensation for gestation; document every obligation and transfer; independently verify the clinic and intermediaries; and obtain written Brazilian legal advice before committing funds.
Sources
The official materials on this point include the CFM page dated 26 March 2025 and the TRF1 case notice. Confirm CFM Resolution 2,320/2022 and the current consolidated CNJ act against their full official texts. The CFM statement that Brazil lacked specific legislation on assisted reproduction is dated 26 March 2025 and does not establish the legal position after that date. Verify later legislative developments and the current CNJ text before relying on this guide.
- CFM Resolution No. 2,320/2022 (official PDF)
- CFM: assisted reproduction framework, 26 March 2025
- CFM: physical and mental assessment, 20 September 2022
- Brazilian Civil Code, Law No. 10,406/2002
- CNJ Provimento No. 149/2023, consolidated notarial rules
- ANVISA: inspection of assisted human reproduction centres
- ANVISA: alert on irregular transport of gametes and embryos, 13 June 2025
- Brazilian Consumer Protection Code, Law No. 8,078/1990
- Brazilian General Personal Data Protection Law, Law No. 13,709/2018
- TRF1: case-specific decision on the living-child condition, 16 July 2026
