Bulgaria: Surrogacy clinics, agencies, contracts and payments — legal risks
The legal answer before any payment
A Bulgarian clinic, agency or consultant may offer genuine medical or administrative services, but paying one does not make a surrogacy arrangement lawful or enforceable. The question is not whether an invoice or notarised contract exists; it is precisely what each party undertakes to do, where the procedure would take place, whether the medical provider is authorised for that activity and who would be recognised as the child's legal parents. This guide concerns transaction design, intermediary conduct, documents and payment risks in Bulgaria, not eligibility or a complete account of foreign parentage law.
The operative medical starting point is Ordinance No H-2 of 12 July 2023, published in the Bulgarian State Gazette. Article 1 makes its assisted-reproduction medical standard applicable to providers carrying out those activities. Within the standard's rules on donor gametes, Annex 1, section IV, point 5.7.9 lists achieving surrogate pregnancies among activities not permitted. That is a concrete restriction on clinical practice; a private agreement or an agent's promise cannot exempt a clinic. Have Bulgarian counsel check the consolidated text and any subsequent amendment immediately before action, particularly if a proposal re-labels the procedure as ordinary embryo transfer. Scope matters: item 5.7 appears under the heading 'When donor gametes are used'. Counsel must determine whether that wording reaches the precise proposed technique, including any partner-provided gametes, and whether other provisions apply. This item alone cannot prove the legal status of every conceivable surrogacy method; equally, a method outside its wording is not thereby authorised.
Another provision of the same standard, section IV, point 5.7.4, prohibits commercialising donation of sperm, eggs and embryos; it permits only reimbursement of reasonable expenses connected with donation under the stated rules. This narrowly defined reimbursement is not permission to compensate a gestational carrier or sell a future parental status. Conversely, an ordinary fee for an independently lawful consultation is not automatically a surrogacy payment. Identify the actual recipient, purpose and legal basis of every transfer rather than treating every fertility-related charge as either lawful or unlawful as a group.
Parentage creates a separate and potentially decisive barrier. Bulgarian Family Code Article 60(1)–(2) states that maternal origin follows birth: the mother is the woman who gives birth, including after assisted reproduction. Article 60(5) limits challenges based on assisted reproduction; Article 61 addresses the presumption concerning the mother's husband. An intended mother's genetics, an agency declaration or a clause requiring a birth-certificate change does not itself displace those provisions. The status of any intended father, adoption, foreign judgments and recognition abroad requires distinct, fact-specific analysis; none is guaranteed by the service contract.
Clinics and intermediaries: verify the actual service
Before treating a clinic as a lawful operator, obtain its exact Bulgarian legal name, registration number, address and the particular assisted-reproduction activities it is authorised to perform. The Executive Agency Medical Supervision publishes a facilities list identifying activities and permits or certificates; check the specific facility and current scope, rather than relying on a marketing name or an intermediary's badge. Registration for IVF, storage or handling gametes is not permission to organise surrogate pregnancies. A listed institution may perform authorised treatment while a different advertised package falls outside that authorisation.
For a legitimate fertility service, request the clinic's own written service description, medical indication, proposed treatment site, information on informed consent, patient identity, storage arrangements and an itemised cost estimate. Ordinance H-2 regulates assisted reproduction and, in Article 75, requires written agreements between medical establishments collaborating or transferring reproductive cells or zygotes. Those inter-facility agreements are not a contract transferring a child to intended parents. Ask which licensed provider will actually perform each clinical step and who controls or stores reproductive material if a provider ceases operating.
An agency may introduce parties, translate, arrange appointments or provide non-medical administration, subject to the rules governing each particular service. That does not itself confer the authority to perform medical interventions, approve a surrogate pregnancy, register legal parentage or promise a passport. Ask for the agency's company details, actual contracting entity, beneficial payee, separate service scope, liability arrangements and evidence supporting every advertised authorisation. Do not infer that every intermediary act is specifically criminal: a precise analysis of the acts, applicable law and evidence is required; the immediate danger is purchasing a prohibited outcome disguised as coordination.
Warning signs include a 'Bulgarian surrogacy licence' without verifiable issuing authority, anonymous carriers, pressure to send a non-refundable reservation fee, claims that genetics overrides the birth mother, or an assurance that a foreign court order will automatically fix Bulgarian records. A scheme involving a clinic in one state, agency in another and intended parents resident in a third may trigger several legal systems. An agent's choice-of-law clause cannot by itself remove mandatory Bulgarian medical rules governing a procedure carried out in Bulgaria. Save each advertisement and proposal before asking for corrections.
Contracts: what can and cannot be promised
Under Bulgaria's Obligations and Contracts Act, Article 26, contracts contrary to law, designed to circumvent it or offensive to good morals may be void. Whether a particular promise, agency package or clause is void depends on its wording, purpose and applicable law; do not assume the whole document has already been judicially invalidated. A purported promise that a carrier must surrender a child or that a clinic must carry out prohibited treatment is especially hazardous. Signing before a notary, selecting another governing law or splitting the transaction among several entities does not automatically cure the core problem.
Separate any genuinely lawful medical or administrative service from promises of conception, gestation, handover, parentage, documents or citizenship. Article 26(4) recognises possible severability of invalid clauses only under its conditions; do not assume an otherwise impermissible programme becomes safe because invoices are separated. For each proposed obligation ask: is the act independently lawful; who has legal authority to do it; what measurable deliverable is due; what if consent is withdrawn; and can an ordinary court enforce that particular promise? Where the answer relies on changing a person's legal status by private agreement, stop and obtain a written local legal opinion.
Treat medical fees, coordination fees, donor-related expense reimbursement and sums linked to a carrier as different categories. Ordinary clinic costs can concern authorised healthcare; agency fees need an identifiable legitimate service. Section IV, point 5.7.4 of the medical standard is specifically about donor-gamete commercialisation, not a general safe harbour for surrogacy reimbursements. Bulgarian law sets no standard 'surrogate compensation rate', permissible deposit or refundable amount. Do not quote marketing price lists as law, and do not wire sums merely because a contract calls them 'expenses'.
A useful payment schedule names the legal payee, currency, invoice issuer, exact service, objective completion event, tax treatment where applicable, cancellation mechanism and refund method. Avoid cash routed through private individuals, unrelated foreign accounts, crypto-wallets or payment instructions that change after signing without credible explanation. Keep receipts, bank transfer confirmations, versions of the agreement and contemporaneous written instructions. Payment documentation can establish what was sent, but cannot validate an otherwise unlawful bargain. Seek independent advice before accepting escrow language: an escrow label alone says nothing about licensing, control or recovery.
Payments and documentary controls
Insist on distinct written answers concerning treatment cancellation, medical contraindications, donor or embryo storage, change of clinic, data confidentiality, translation discrepancies, consent withdrawal, service delays and insolvency. Define which legitimate work is chargeable if the arrangement ends before treatment and how unused sums are returned. Do not make refund rights depend on a carrier surrendering parental rights or a registry producing a particular parental entry. Fees tied to birth, handover or promised nationality should be escalated for review, not silently treated as routine milestones. Ensure all contract language versions identify the same parties and sums.
Where clinics exchange reproductive material or work jointly, Article 75 of Ordinance H-2 requires specific written provider-to-provider arrangements and recording/reporting obligations. The provision is a traceability and quality safeguard for authorised medical activity, not authority for an agent to trade embryos or contract for a surrogate birth. Request records identifying the lawful custodian, cross-provider movement and responsibility for storage; do not expect access to protected patient or donor information beyond applicable consent and privacy rules. If an intermediary cannot identify the medical provider or claims to own embryos personally, halt payment pending documentary clarification.
The financial dispute forum, the place of medical treatment, the governing contract law and the place where a child would be born may all differ. A judgment on an invoice does not resolve who is legally a parent. For a foreign-intended-parent plan, obtain separate written advice on Bulgarian medical restrictions and parentage plus the law of the country of residence, nationality and any proposed birth state. This article does not assert that a foreign arrangement will be recognised, that a child will obtain a particular citizenship, or that a birth certificate can be rewritten by an agency; those are different proceedings.
Cross-border risks and a practical example
Consider a proposal labelled 'IVF and international coordination': the clinic is listed for assisted reproduction, the agent invoices for translation, and a separate schedule promises that another woman will carry the embryo and transfer the baby to clients. The clinic's registration and the genuine translation work do not legalise the carrier and handover promises. Under the medical standard and Family Code, the surrogacy and intended-parentage elements create different legal problems. The practical response is to suspend the package, identify each actor and intended procedure, and have independent Bulgarian counsel analyse individual clauses before any transfer of funds.
Before paying, request one complete document set: proposed clinic and agency agreements with all annexes; itemised invoices and payee account details; legal identity and authorisation evidence for each medical operator; the procedure description and location; proposed consent and storage forms; termination/refund terms; and the agency's written legal basis for any carrier or parentage promise. Preserve the full advertising trail. Give the same documents to a Bulgarian healthcare/family-law lawyer independent of the seller, and where relevant to counsel in the intended parents' home country. Ask for a clause-by-clause opinion, not a verbal statement that 'the clinic has done it before'.
Decision checklist and remedies
If money was already paid, do not assume an automatic refund or that no remedy exists. Preserve contracts, messages, invoices, receipts and bank records; identify each payee and jurisdiction; promptly ask the bank about a transfer recall where feasible; and request a written account of services actually provided. Article 34 of the Obligations and Contracts Act provides for restitution when a contract is found void or avoided, but the claim, defendants, practical recovery and any other causes of action depend on facts and legal assessment. Do not threaten false criminal allegations or sign a broad release before independent advice. Article 34 addresses reciprocal return of benefits, not a guaranteed repayment of every invoice regardless of work performed; any valuation, set-off or alternative claim needs case-specific advice.
The defensible decision is to distinguish independently authorised fertility services from surrogacy promises whose clinical legality and contractual enforceability have not been established. Check the exact licence, transaction purpose, contract enforceability, recipient of each payment and the non-contractual rules of parentage independently. If the proposal depends on a Bulgarian surrogate pregnancy, guaranteed surrender of a child or automatic recognition of the intended parents, do not proceed on an agency assurance. Obtain a dated, document-specific Bulgarian legal opinion and separate cross-border advice when required.
Primary sources
- S1: Bulgarian Ministry of Justice — Family Code, Arts 60–61
- S2: State Gazette — Ordinance No H-2 of 12 July 2023 (Assisted Reproduction), Annex 1, IV 5.7.4 and 5.7.9; Arts 1 and 75
- S3: Ministry of Justice — Obligations and Contracts Act, Arts 26 and 34
- S4: Executive Agency Medical Supervision — facilities with assisted-reproduction authorisations
