Canada surrogacy contracts, agencies and payments: legal limits and risks
The practical answer
In Canada, surrogacy is not a free-form commercial service. Federal law draws a line between prohibited consideration for carrying a child or arranging a surrogate’s services and reimbursement of specified out-of-pocket expenses. A written agreement is still important, but it cannot legalize a payment prohibited by federal law and does not, by itself, settle legal parentage. The governing questions are: what is each payment actually for; who receives it; which documents support it; and what provincial parentage law applies where the child will be born. The federal rules apply across Canada, while family-law consequences and contract remedies can differ by province or territory. This is a transaction-risk guide, not a conclusion that any particular agency, clinic, fee schedule or proposed agreement is lawful.
The federal boundary: compensation and arranging services
Section 6 of the federal Assisted Human Reproduction Act prohibits paying, offering to pay or advertising consideration to a woman to act as a surrogate. It separately prohibits accepting consideration for arranging a surrogate’s services, offering to arrange them for consideration, and paying or offering to pay another person to arrange those services. The risk therefore concerns both the proposed payment to the surrogate and the role and remuneration of an intermediary; the payer cannot assume that only the surrogate is exposed. The Act also prohibits counselling or inducing a woman to become a surrogate, or performing a medical procedure to assist her to become one, when the person knows or has reason to believe she is under 21. The statutory wording is broad. Do not assume that calling an amount a “gift”, “bonus”, “allowance”, “coordination fee” or “administrative fee” determines its legal character. A contract or invoice cannot override the federal prohibition. Borderline arrangements require advice based on the actual services, payment flow and facts.
Agency and clinic fees: analyse the service, not the label
An agency invoice deserves particular scrutiny if the agency finds, matches, recruits or arranges the services of a surrogate. Section 6(2) addresses consideration accepted for arranging those services, and section 6(3) addresses payment to another person for that arrangement. The legislation does not create a safe harbour simply because a fee is described as “management”, “consulting” or “programme administration”. At the same time, do not jump to the opposite conclusion that every charge by every clinic, lawyer or professional is automatically prohibited: a genuine medical, legal or other distinct service may raise a different question from paid surrogate-matching. The legal issue is what the recipient is being paid to do and how the service relates to arranging the surrogate’s services. Before paying, obtain an itemised written scope of work, identify the recipient of each amount, separate service contracts and invoices, and ask Canadian counsel to assess any fee connected with matching or coordination. A commercial website or agency’s own assurance is not legal clearance.
What may be reimbursed: categories and limits
The federal regulations permit reimbursement only for specified expenses incurred in relation to the surrogacy. These are reimbursements, not a price for carrying the pregnancy. The category must fit the regulations, the expense must genuinely have been incurred, and the required evidence must be collected. The examples below summarise the main categories; they are not permission to reimburse every cost that can be associated with a programme.
| Expense category | Examples and practical limit |
|---|---|
| Travel | Transport, parking, meals and accommodation connected with the surrogacy. Personal-car travel follows a special declaration and distance method. |
| Care and support | Care of dependants or pets, counselling services, and legal services or disbursements. |
| Health-related items | Drugs and medical devices; products or services provided or recommended in writing by a person authorised under provincial law to assess, monitor and provide health care to a woman during pregnancy, delivery or the postpartum period; and the written recommendation itself where applicable. |
| Pregnancy and birth | Midwife or doula services, prenatal exercise classes, and expenses related to delivery. |
| Everyday pregnancy costs | Groceries, excluding non-food items; maternity clothes; and telecommunications. Keep evidence linking the expense to the surrogacy. |
| Insurance and records | Health, disability, travel or life insurance coverage, and obtaining or confirming medical or other records. |
Lost work-related income is a separate, narrow route
Income replacement is not a general monthly stipend. Under section 12(3) of the Act, a surrogate’s loss of work-related income during pregnancy may be reimbursed only if a qualified medical practitioner certifies in writing that continuing to work may pose a risk to the surrogate’s health or to the embryo or foetus, and the reimbursement complies with the regulations. The regulations require a signed declaration stating the relevant dates and amount, evidence of the income that would otherwise have been earned, and the medical certification. The declaration must also state that no other source has compensated the same loss, in whole or in part. The statutory condition and documentary requirements matter: an agreement cannot replace the medical certificate or convert ordinary lost wages into an unrestricted fee. If the facts do not meet these conditions, do not promise reimbursement as though it were automatically permitted.
Source conflict to flag: Health Canada’s public guidance page also lists pre-pregnancy and post-partum periods among examples in its income-loss section. That wording appears broader than section 12(3) of the Act and section 8 of the Regulations, which expressly frame the qualifying loss and non-work period as during pregnancy. Do not assume the webpage expands statutory eligibility. Obtain written clarification from Health Canada and Canadian counsel before relying on any pre-pregnancy or post-partum income-loss reimbursement.
The reimbursement file: what must be collected and retained
For each eligible expense, the person making the reimbursement must obtain a dated and signed declaration identifying the requester and address, each expense, its amount and date, the amount requested if lower than the expense, the connection to the surrogacy, and confirmation that the same expense has not been paid by another source. Applicable written medical or pregnancy-care recommendations must also be collected, as must a receipt for each expense unless a regulatory exception applies. For a personal-automobile trip, the declaration records the departure and destination addresses and the kilometres driven; follow the regulation’s method rather than inventing a flat mileage amount. For qualifying income-loss reimbursement, collect the separate declaration, expected-income evidence and written medical certification. Keep the full reimbursement file, including declarations, receipts and supporting documents, for six years after each reimbursement. Health Canada may require the records. A spreadsheet is useful for reconciliation, but it does not replace source documents.
What a careful written agreement should cover
Use the agreement to document intentions and organise lawful performance, not to promise that every clause will be enforceable. Before signing, have the parties obtain independent Canadian legal advice appropriate to the province or territory. At a minimum, the agreement and linked schedules should identify the parties and their roles; state that no prohibited compensation is payable; define eligible expense categories and the evidence required; set a reimbursement submission and review process; prevent duplicate reimbursement; explain how disputed or rejected expenses are handled; allocate responsibility for legal advice, insurance, medical and clinic charges; identify separately contracted professional services; address confidentiality and handling of records; set out cancellation and failed-cycle cost allocation without disguising a payment for arranging surrogate services; and state that parentage will be determined under applicable law and any required post-birth steps. Avoid clauses that assume the surrogate can be compelled to make a medical decision or that intended parents automatically become legal parents solely because the agreement was signed. Counsel should review the exact wording and the province-specific procedure.
- Identify all parties and each separate service provider.
- Attach a reimbursement schedule based on statutory categories, not a promised surrogate fee.
- Specify declarations, receipts, written recommendations and the six-year retention duty.
- Separate agency, legal, clinic and other professional scopes and invoices; obtain advice on any matching or coordination fee.
- Set clear timelines for expense submission, review, corrections and genuine disputes.
- Address cancellation, insurance, confidentiality, records and service-provider failure without overriding mandatory law.
- Describe the applicable parentage process as a separate legal step, not a guaranteed contractual outcome.
Contract validity and parentage depend on provincial law
Section 6(5) of the federal Act expressly says that the federal prohibition does not affect the validity under provincial law of an agreement to act as a surrogate. That is not a declaration that all such agreements are enforceable. Provincial legislation can distinguish the agreement’s evidentiary role from the legal effect of parentage provisions, require pre-conception steps or independent legal advice, and require the surrogate’s written consent after birth. Ontario illustrates the distinction: section 10 of its Children’s Law Reform Act sets conditions for parentage following surrogacy, including independent legal advice before signing and written consent after the child is born; the consent cannot be given before the child is seven days old. The section 10 route also requires the agreement to be made before conception, limits the number of intended parents to four, and requires conception through assisted reproduction. Section 10(9) states that a surrogacy agreement is unenforceable in law, although it may be evidence of the parties’ intentions. Do not generalise Ontario’s rule to another province or territory.
Québec: a separate contract and reimbursement regime
Québec needs a separate check. Where the intended parent(s) and surrogate are domiciled in Québec, the Civil Code requires a surrogacy agreement before pregnancy and separate pre-pregnancy information meetings for the surrogate and intended parent(s). The agreement must be executed by notarial act en minute and drawn up in French; the parties may be bound by a non-French version only if they expressly choose it after examining the French version. It must specify the expenses payable or reimbursable and any compensation for work-income loss, and provide for a deposit in the executing notary’s trust account. The surrogate must be at least 21, and this regime requires the parties to have been domiciled in Québec for at least one year before signing. Québec government guidance also states that only the surrogate may decide to terminate the agreement; intended parents cannot withdraw from the project after entering it and cannot claim reimbursement of amounts already paid to the surrogate under the regulation. Review the cancellation and payment consequences with Québec counsel before signing. Québec’s own Regulation (CCQ, r. 4.2) distinguishes expenses that must be paid from those that may be reimbursed by agreement and sets documentation and six-year record-retention rules; the federal expense table is not a complete Québec analysis. For the standard legal-establishment route, consent to establish filiation may be given only between the eighth and 30th day after birth. The federal prohibition on paying a surrogate or paying for arranging surrogate services still applies. Cross-border or different-domicile cases follow separate rules; confirm the route and current regulation with Québec counsel before signing or paying.
Payment and contract red flags
Pause and obtain legal advice before signing or transferring money if a proposal includes any of the following patterns.
| Pattern | Why it needs review |
|---|---|
| Fixed “surrogate fee”, bonus or reward | May be consideration for carrying the pregnancy rather than reimbursement of an incurred eligible expense. |
| Agency fee tied to matching or arranging | May engage the federal prohibition on consideration for arranging surrogate services; the label alone does not resolve it. |
| Round monthly allowance without reconciliation | May not show that each payment equals an eligible, actually incurred expense supported by required records. |
| Missing receipts or duplicate claims | Creates a direct compliance problem; reimbursement declarations must address the expense and whether another source paid it. |
| Promise that the contract guarantees parentage or irrevocable consent | Confuses contractual intent with provincial parentage law and any required post-birth consent or court process. |
A safer sequence before the first payment
Use this sequence before any funds move: (1) identify the province or territory where the birth and parentage steps are expected to occur; (2) obtain advice from a lawyer familiar with both federal assisted-reproduction rules and that province’s family law; (3) review the proposed agency’s actual tasks and all recipients of payment; (4) classify each proposed amount as a separate professional-service charge, an eligible expense reimbursement, or a legally uncertain payment; (5) remove or resolve any amount that may be prohibited rather than renaming it; (6) sign the required agreement before conception where the provincial process requires that timing; (7) use a reimbursement form, receipt workflow and record-retention owner from the beginning; and (8) confirm clinic terms, insurance, cancellation provisions and parentage steps independently. If the agency will not disclose the fee recipient, refuses itemised invoices, or tells you that a contract makes all payments legal, treat that as a serious due-diligence warning.
If money has already been paid or a dispute has started
Do not backdate a declaration, invent a receipt, relabel a payment after the event, or delete messages and invoices. Preserve the signed agreement, advertisements, bank records, invoices, messages, receipts and a factual timeline. Pause further ambiguous transfers while a Canadian lawyer assesses the purpose of each payment, the people involved and any potential reporting or remediation duties. A payment that may be problematic should not be “fixed” by changing its description without a genuine factual basis. Health Canada describes compliance measures that can include compliance letters, inspections, seizure of materials, recommending prosecution or referral to law enforcement; the measure in any case depends on the facts and applicable law. If a provider refuses to account for money or stops performing, review the contract’s dispute and refund provisions with counsel, but do not assume that a disputed or unenforceable clause will produce a particular remedy.
Two practical questions
Can reimbursements be paid weekly or monthly? For the federal reimbursement framework, Health Canada guidance leaves timing to the parties and says weekly or monthly may be practical for a surrogate. This concerns timing only: each payment must match eligible expenses and the required records; a fixed fee or unaccountable allowance is not made lawful by calling it a reimbursement. Reconcile each expense and prevent duplicate payment. Is reimbursement compulsory? Health Canada says there is no general obligation under the federal framework to reimburse. That does not let a party ignore a promise in a signed agreement or a provincial rule: Québec, for example, distinguishes expenses that must be paid from those that may be reimbursed by agreement. Do not assume reimbursement is optional without checking the contract and applicable provincial law. Whenever a reimbursement is made, the relevant statutory and regulatory conditions still apply. Before approving a budget, have Canadian counsel classify each payment and confirm the province-specific agreement and parentage steps.
Primary legislation and official guidance
- S1 — Assisted Human Reproduction Act, section 6 — federal prohibition and intermediary rule
- S2 — Assisted Human Reproduction Act, section 12 — reimbursement and income-loss conditions
- S3 — Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations, section 4 — eligible surrogacy expenses
- S4 — Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations, section 6 — declaration and receipt requirements
- S5 — Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations, section 8 — work-related income-loss documents
- S6 — Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations, section 11 — six-year record retention
- S7 — Health Canada — reimbursement guidance and compliance overview
- S8 — Ontario Children’s Law Reform Act, section 10 — partial source access; verify current text
- S9 — Government of Québec — Rules for surrogacy where all parties live in Québec
- S10 — Civil Code of Québec, arts. 541.1–541.25 — official consolidated text
- S11 — Regulation respecting parental projects involving surrogacy in which the parties to the agreement are domiciled in Québec (CCQ, r. 4.2)
- S12 — Health Canada — Compliance approach for the Reimbursement Related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations
- S13 — Health Canada — Guidance document: Reimbursement related to Assisted Human Reproduction Regulations
The Act page stated current to 30 September 2026; individual regulation pages displayed different consolidation dates, including 21 September and 21 July 2026. Health Canada guidance is administrative guidance, not legislation; the Act and regulations prevail. The official Québec Civil Code PDF was updated to 12 August 2026. The official result for CCQ, r. Confirm the current consolidated regulation and its application before relying on individual Québec expense categories.
