Surrogacy in Belgium: clinic contracts, agencies and payments—what is enforceable?
The central answer
Belgium has no comprehensive statute specifically establishing a surrogacy scheme, and surrogacy is not expressly prohibited as such. This is not the same as permission to sell a programme, enforce a promise to deliver a child, or acquire parenthood through a private contract. The Belgian Institute for the Equality of Women and Men described the regulatory gap again in 2026. The safe question is not simply whether surrogacy takes place, but which separate activity, provider, payment and legal consequence is actually supported by law.
The Constitutional Court made the decisive distinction in judgment 56/2023 of 30 March 2023, paragraph B.4: surrogacy occurs in practice, but an agreement intended to bind the people in the surrogacy arrangement—for example to hand over the child at birth—is unlawful, has no legal effect and cannot be forcibly performed. This judicial explanation is a warning against presenting a surrogacy agreement as an ordinary enforceable service-purchase contract. It does not erase separate statutory contracts with a fertility centre. The Court expressly limited the question it decided to the constitutionality of former Civil Code article 318(4), concerning a challenge to the gestational woman's husband's presumed paternity. Its discussion of surrogacy contracts in B.4 must not be mistaken for a judgment validating or invalidating every independent clinical or intermediary clause.
Three different arrangements
First identify the actual counterparties. A licensed fertility centre may provide medically assisted reproduction and sign the agreement required for its clinical services. Intended parents and the pregnant woman may exchange written understandings about practical arrangements, but the child-transfer promise cannot be enforced. An agency or facilitator may advertise matching, coordination or translation; its fee is not automatically a lawful or recoverable medical charge. Put each function, entity, bank account and applicable law on a separate line before anyone pays.
The fertility centre: services and limits
Under article 3 of the Belgian Act of 6 July 2007 on medically assisted reproduction, IVF and preservation of embryos or gametes are activities for recognised fertility centres. Article 5 permits centres to refuse requests on medical grounds or by invoking a conscience clause. Therefore a website, intermediary introduction or initial consultation does not establish that a particular centre accepts surrogacy or a particular set of participants. Ask the centre, directly and in writing, which treatment it actually proposes and who its contracting patient or intended-parent parties will be.
When a centre accepts an assisted-reproduction request, article 6 of the 6 July 2007 Act requires information and psychological support before and during treatment. Article 7 requires a written agreement before any medical procedure between the centre and the person or persons who are the 'authors of the parental project' for that treatment; it records their identity, age and address and the centre's details. Where those authors are a couple, both sign; there are two copies. Article 8 governs signed written changes to their instructions. In a surrogacy proposal, do not assume that the intended parents, the woman receiving treatment and the statutory signatories are necessarily the same people: have the centre identify each person's role and required consent in writing. This statutory treatment agreement does not transfer parentage or compel delivery of a child.
A refusal by a fertility centre is not necessarily a finding that surrogacy is criminal or that the applicants are categorically ineligible. Article 5 requires written notice of the refusal within one month following the physician’s decision, stating medical grounds or the conscience clause and, if requested, details of another centre. Ask for that written decision rather than treating a broker’s description of “approval” or “rejection” as the centre’s formal position. Whether the centre offers any surrogacy-specific process remains a matter for individual confirmation.
Agencies and intermediaries
Belgium’s lack of a dedicated surrogacy framework means that one cannot infer an official surrogacy-agency licensing system or a generally authorised paid matching market. Nor does absence of a surrogacy-specific prohibition prove that any recruitment commission is lawful. A broker should be asked for its legal identity, registration, physical address, authorised activities, actual named medical partner, conflict-of-interest policy and full price schedule. Verify these assertions independently, including with the centre; no “guaranteed Belgian package” should be accepted on advertising alone.
Surrogate arrangements cannot guarantee parenthood
A signed memorandum may record expectations about appointments, communication, accommodation or expense documentation. It cannot override medical consent, impose an enforceable obligation to transfer the baby, or decide legal parentage. Avoid clauses purporting to impose penalties for refusal to relinquish the child, irrevocable medical decisions, or automatic transfer of parental status. Court judgment 56/2023 is specific about the absence of binding effect for a child-handover agreement; enforceability of other independent clauses requires clause-by-clause legal analysis rather than a blanket “all contracts valid” or “all contracts void” label.
Separate the woman’s ongoing informed medical choices from the intended parents’ planning. A contract must not be treated as a substitute for consent to an examination, treatment or obstetric decision. If a party changes their mind or pregnancy care changes, the immediate response should be appropriate clinical advice, documentation and independent legal advice, not threats of forced performance. Confidentiality provisions should protect health information without preventing access to doctors, an independent lawyer or competent authorities. These are safeguards and drafting recommendations, not a claim that every suggested clause has a dedicated Belgian surrogacy statute.
Parentage is not sold in the contract
Without a surrogacy-specific parentage route, ordinary Belgian rules apply. The Constitutional Court records that the woman who gives birth is the legal mother and, if she is married, her husband may benefit from the legal presumption of paternity. In judgment 56/2023 the Court addressed a narrowly framed ability to challenge that presumption where the gestational woman and her husband had no parental project; the family court must assess the facts. That judgment does not confer automatic parentage on any intended parent, even a genetic parent. Obtain tailored advice before treatment on the birth registration and possible judicial steps.
Payments: classify before transferring money
Do not group all transfers under “surrogacy fee”. Distinguish (1) invoices for actual clinical treatment by the identified centre, (2) documented travel, accommodation, medication or other genuine outlays, (3) a facilitator’s coordination charge, and (4) money contingent on pregnancy, delivery or surrender of the child. Each has a different legal basis and risk profile. An expense reimbursement is not automatically approved merely because the contract calls it “compensation”; a commercial reward is not automatically a recognised medical expense. Belgian law sets no nationwide surrogacy tariff or safe statutory cap.
Insist on a written itemised budget before any deposit: who receives each amount, for what deliverable, at what stage, against what receipt, with which VAT or tax treatment if applicable, and under what cancellation or refund conditions. Prefer traceable bank transfers to the named contracted entity over cash or payments to an unrelated personal account. Keep invoices and proof of actual expenses. These are transaction-control recommendations; they do not, by themselves, legalise a prohibited underlying obligation or guarantee a refund through a court.
The 2007 Act also specifically restricts commerce in human embryos and regulates donation of gametes and embryos. For example, articles 19 and 22 prohibit commercialisation of surplus embryos or human embryos in the relevant contexts, and the statutory regime addresses donation separately from surrogacy. Do not confuse the ban on trading embryos with a clearly established universal criminal ban on every surrogacy-related payment; equally, do not use a “donation” label to disguise what is effectively a purchase. Have the planned money flow reviewed against the actual activity and the current consolidated law.
Contract and money risk matrix
The matrix below is a practical screening device, not a statutory list of licensed products or a declaration that any payment is automatically legal. “Review” means obtain the medical centre’s confirmation and Belgian legal advice on the specific documents before committing funds.
| Transaction | What should be documented | Legal and practical screening |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical treatment invoice | Named centre; actual service and written terms | Check provider, consent, price and cancellation; not parentage. |
| Gestational woman’s documented costs | Receipts and purpose of each reimbursement | Review necessity, recipient and legality; label alone is insufficient. |
| Broker or matching commission | Identity, scope and specific billable performance | No inferred official surrogacy-agency licence or guaranteed recoverability. |
| Child-handover or “success” fee | Payment linked to surrender or parentage promise | High risk: private handover commitment is unenforceable. |
| Promise of birth record or passport | A private seller says authorities are bound | Not binding on registry, court, consulate or foreign state. |
Warning signs before a deposit
Pause if an intermediary promises an enforceable handover, an immediate intended-parent birth certificate, a passport as part of a private package, or a no-questions refund without identifying the debtor. Other warning signs are a fictitious clinic authorisation, a demand to pay an individual unrelated to the agreement, substantial unreceipted “compensation”, secrecy from the gestational woman’s independent adviser, and pressure to sign translated papers without understanding their controlling language. Any one of these calls for verification, not automatic assumptions of fraud or illegality.
Documents worth requesting
Request the centre’s written eligibility and treatment position, its legal name and recognition details, the complete ART consent and service agreement, any intermediary service contract, the draft practical understanding with the gestational woman, an itemised payment schedule, invoice samples, cancellation/refund terms, insurance coverage and responsibility for complications. Also collect identification and civil-status records that a Belgian family-law specialist needs to assess parentage. Check governing-law and dispute clauses, translations, privacy and record access. A checklist is not proof that all these documents exist or that every clause is enforceable.
A sequence that preserves options
Before signing: identify every participant and ask the centre whether it will independently accept the proposal. Before paying: commission separate reviews of the clinic contract, any broker contract and any surrogacy understanding; obtain an itemised estimate and check who holds deposits. Before treatment: ensure the centre’s statutory consent process and medical safeguards are completed. During treatment: keep receipts, written changes and independent advice available. Before birth: plan civil registration and the likely court process without assuming a private contract settles parentage. These stages are procedural recommendations, not a government-authorised programme.
Two examples of the difference
Example A: intended parents pay a fertility centre against an invoice for a consultation and laboratory service, with written cancellation conditions. There is an identifiable medical-service contract, but its enforceability and refund scope depend on the actual agreement and applicable law; it does not transfer the child’s legal parentage. Example B: a broker demands a large success fee and claims a signed handover paper guarantees the child and an immediate passport. The Court’s rule on child-transfer commitments directly contradicts that claimed guarantee; payment recovery and the broker’s other duties still require individual legal assessment.
If a clinic refuses or a transaction breaks down
For a clinical refusal, obtain the written reasons under article 5 and ask for another centre’s details if desired. For contested invoices, stop nonessential future transfers, preserve the signed version and messages, ask the counterparty in writing for its legal basis and an itemised reconciliation, and get local advice on any civil claim, consumer issue or potential report to authorities. Never assume that lack of enforceability of a child-handover promise automatically settles the refund of a separate medical or agency fee. If pregnancy or a child is involved, prioritise immediate welfare and family-law advice over payment pressure.
International cases require separate planning
A foreign agency, overseas clinic or intended parents living abroad can introduce additional contract, health, nationality and recognition laws. Belgian consular guidance warns that a foreign surrogacy birth record or judgment does not automatically create recognised Belgian parentage and may require court intervention. This article does not decide the rules of the other country, passport entitlement or the result of a particular petition. Before paying any cross-border package, obtain written advice both in Belgium and in the other relevant jurisdiction, including on legal parentage, travel and return. The cited notice is published on Belgium's embassy website for South Africa and states a restrictive administrative position about documents and travel. Do not generalise its wording into a binding outcome for every nationality, destination or case; seek a case-specific answer from the competent Belgian consular or registry authority and legal advice about possible court relief before planning a child's journey.
Practical bottom line
Belgian law supports a defined regulated medical-treatment relationship, but does not convert a surrogate handover undertaking into an enforceable purchase of a child or a shortcut to parentage. Agency activities and expense or reward arrangements need transaction-specific analysis; a website and a signed private paper cannot supply missing law. The defensible next decision is to verify the centre, separate all agreements, demand an auditable payment schedule, and take independent Belgian clinical-contract and family-law advice before making an irreversible commitment.
Sources and verification limits
- S1: Institut pour l’égalité des femmes et des hommes — La gestation pour autrui (2026)
- S2: Loi du 6 juillet 2007 relative à la procréation médicalement assistée (texte consolidé)
- S3: Cour constitutionnelle, arrêt n° 56/2023 du 30 mars 2023, B.4
- S4: FPS Foreign Affairs, Surrogacy, consular guidance (updated 30 September 2026)
