United States · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Minimal professional desk with blank contract papers, clipboard, pen and calculator

US Surrogacy: Clinics, Agencies, Contracts and Payments — Legal Risks

The short answer: state law controls

This article focuses on gestational surrogacy, where the carrier does not provide the egg, and the contracts connecting intended parents, the carrier, an agency or facilitator, the person holding funds, the clinic and each party’s lawyer. There is no single nationwide checklist that makes every arrangement enforceable. The state statutes below impose different requirements for contract formation, compensation, escrow and intermediaries.

Do not assume that a contract valid where signed will necessarily be enforceable where the carrier lives, treatment occurs, the agency operates or the child is expected to be born. Use this only for pre-payment triage, not as a 50-state survey, parentage or citizenship opinion, or licence confirmation.

This comparison is limited to gestational arrangements; traditional/genetic surrogacy can be treated differently and needs separate state-specific review.

Identify every state with a meaningful connection

Before selecting governing law, map the intended parents’ residence; the carrier’s residence when the agreement is signed and during pregnancy; where the agency does business; where the contract is signed; where screening, IVF and embryo transfer occur; the expected birth state; and where the escrow account is maintained. These facts can affect applicable law, court jurisdiction and regulatory duties.

For example, New York’s surrogacy-program statute applies where a program does business in New York or the carrier resides there when the agreement is executed. Michigan’s 2024 Act 24 requires a Michigan connection such as a party’s residence, an expected Michigan birth or assisted-reproduction procedures in the state. These are examples, not a complete conflicts-of-law test. A choice-of-law clause does not automatically displace mandatory law in another connected state.

New York’s eligibility rules are more specific. At least one intended parent must be a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident. The statute has reciprocal six-month residence conditions: if neither intended parent has lived in New York for at least six months, the carrier must have; if the carrier has not lived there for at least six months, at least one intended parent must have. Intended parents must also fit § 581-402’s adult/family-status categories: an unmarried adult acting alone, spouses together, or adult intimate partners together; a married person may proceed without their spouse only under the statute’s separation conditions. Check eligibility before paying a matching or agency fee.

The carrier must also satisfy § 581-402: be at least 21, a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident, not provide the egg, complete the required medical evaluation and informed-consent process, and meet independent-counsel and insurance requirements. The statute allows an uncompensated carrier to waive certain obligations for intended-parent payment of counsel, insurance and medical costs; the exact waiver scope should be checked before contracting.

Michigan Act 24 also sets threshold eligibility conditions: the surrogate must be at least 21, have previously given birth, and complete a medical evaluation and mental-health consultation; each intended parent must be at least 21 and complete a mental-health consultation. The surrogate and each intended parent must have independent counsel licensed in Michigan throughout negotiations, execution and the agreement’s duration. Intended parents must pay for the surrogate’s independent counsel. Verify current statutory text and each party’s compliance before signing.

Sign the agreement before treatment begins

Do not begin injectable medication or embryo transfer on the strength of an agency intake form, email exchange or unsigned draft. The final agreement should be reviewed by separate, independent lawyers for the carrier and intended parent(s), with each lawyer representing only their own client.

New York Family Court Act § 581-403 requires a written agreement; signatures notarized or witnessed by two persons who are not parties; signatures from each intended parent, the carrier and, where applicable, the carrier’s spouse; and execution before the carrier takes medication or begins medical procedures in furtherance of embryo transfer. Before execution, the carrier must give informed consent to the relevant procedures and agree to undergo embryo transfer and attempt to carry and give birth. If the carrier’s spouse is required to sign, the spouse must agree to surrender custody of all resulting children to the intended parents immediately upon birth. The agreement must include an acknowledgment that the carrier and any signing spouse received the Surrogate’s Bill of Rights from their legal counsel. A spouse’s signature may be omitted only under the statute’s separation exceptions: a separation decree or judgment, a qualifying written separation agreement, or living separate and apart for at least three years before execution. The agreement must provide that intended parents accept custody of every resulting child immediately upon birth and assume support regardless of number, sex or physical or mental condition, including a child conceived because of laboratory error, without diminishing any superior parental-interest claim; their rights and obligations under the agreement are not assignable. The agreement must record its execution date, city and state; names and contact details for the intended parents and carrier; known gamete sources; any licensed and registered program; and each party’s attorney. It must provide counseling on request, including after delivery, at the intended parents’ expense, and warn that compensation may affect public-benefit eligibility or benefit amounts for the carrier or spouse. Separate, independent New York-licensed counsel is required for each party from the start of the contractual process throughout the agreement. Before embryo transfer, each intended parent must execute a will naming a guardian for every resulting child and authorizing the executor to perform the agreement’s obligations, including seeking a parentage judgment, if no intended parent is living.

The prior pass recorded the official California legislative text for Family Code § 7962 as amended in 2019. The recorded text requires separate independent licensed attorneys chosen by the parties before execution, notarized signatures or equivalent attestation, full execution before embryo transfer or injectable medication, and disclosures about medical expenses and insurance.

Michigan Act 24, effective April 2, 2025, requires each intended parent, the carrier and the carrier’s spouse, if applicable, to be parties to the agreement and sign it before relevant medical procedures; each signature must be attested by a notarial officer. The carrier and each intended parent must have independent Michigan-licensed counsel throughout negotiations, execution and the agreement’s duration. Intended parents must pay for the carrier’s independent counsel. The agreement must also include the Act’s required terms on the spouse’s acknowledgment, intended-parent parentage and support, agreed expenses and medical costs, the carrier’s authority over health decisions, and statutory termination rights. Local counsel should confirm the current text and each required party’s status.

A compact comparison of three state regimes

This comparison is illustrative, not exhaustive.

StateContract and payment controlsPractical check
New YorkFormal execution and separate counsel; base compensation and reasonably anticipated additional expenses must be placed with an independent escrow agent before medical procedures other than eligibility evaluations. Compensation must be reasonable and negotiated in good faith.Check statutory eligibility, the escrow agreement, program licensing requirements and prohibited referral or ownership relationships.
CaliforniaSeparate independent licensed lawyers, notarization or equivalent attestation, and a completed gestational-carrier agreement before transfer or injectable medication. A non-attorney facilitator must direct client funds to a qualifying independent bonded escrow arrangement or an attorney trust account.Verify the fund-management agreement, who controls disbursements and whether the facilitator has a prohibited financial interest in the escrow company.
MichiganWhere Act 24 applies, the agreement must be signed and notarized before relevant procedures, with independent counsel throughout. It may provide for compensation, support and reasonable expenses.Review the statutory termination rules and the limits on remedies that would compel reproductive or medical acts.

Write a precise payment schedule

Separate the carrier’s base compensation from reimbursement of documented expenses, lost wages, childcare, travel, medical co-payments and deductibles, bed rest or complications, insurance premiums, life or disability cover, agency fees, escrow administration, clinic and laboratory charges, and legal fees. For each category, state the amount or calculation method, trigger, payee, supporting documents, due date, cap (if any), and process for challenging a payment.

New York Family Court Act § 581-502 permits reasonable compensation negotiated in good faith. It bars payment to purchase gametes or embryos or to secure release of a parental interest. Base compensation may cover the pregnancy and the eight-week recovery period after birth. Supplemental compensation for medically confirmed pregnancy or delivery complications and related lost wages may—but need not—continue up to twelve months after birth or the specified pregnancy end. Compensation must not depend on the purported genetic quality of gametes or embryos or the actual genetic or physical traits of a donor or child.

Michigan Act 24 expressly allows an agreement to provide compensation, support and reasonable expenses. These examples do not create a nationwide rate, cap or universal payment formula. Do not rely on a bundled agency estimate without a written itemisation.

Keep client funds separate and traceable

Before paying, check the escrow or trust agreement for the account holder, permitted uses, authorised approvers, required evidence, reconciliation, refund instructions and closure procedure. Avoid undocumented cash or personal-account transfers.

In New York, the carrier’s base compensation and reasonably anticipated additional expenses must be in escrow with an independent escrow agent before covered medical procedures begin, except medical evaluations used to determine eligibility. The separate program rules also require intended-parent funds other than the program’s own fees to be held in an escrow account separate from operating funds.

Under California Family Code § 7961, a non-attorney facilitator must direct client funds to an independent, bonded escrow depository maintained by a licensed, independent, bonded escrow company or to an attorney’s trust account. The facilitator may not have a financial interest in the escrow company or act as its agent. Disbursements must follow the assisted-reproduction agreement and the fund-management agreement. These are state-specific examples, not a universal U.S. escrow rule.

California § 7961(d) has a narrow exception: the escrow-direction rule does not cover funds that are both outside the fund-management agreement and paid directly to a medical doctor for medical services or a psychologist for psychological services. Do not extend this exception to other vendors.

Audit agency, clinic contracts and conflicts

Identify the legal entity receiving each fee and separate the agency service contract from the carrier agreement and escrow agreement. Define services and exclusions, when fees are earned, refunds for failed matching/transfer, replacement matching, reimbursable expenses and record transfer if the agency closes.

New York General Business Law § 1403 states that a covered surrogacy program must be licensed under the state’s regulatory framework; it also restricts ownership or management by a party’s attorney or treating health-care provider and prohibits referral-related payments to or from those professionals. The program must give prospective parties written notice of the surrogate’s bill of rights. The New York State Department of Health publishes a list of licensed gestational-surrogacy organizations, marked revised October 2026; confirm the exact legal entity and its current license/renewal status directly with the Department. A website or registration number alone does not prove compliance.

California defines a surrogacy or donor facilitator broadly to include a person or organisation that advertises to solicit parties, acts as an intermediary or charges for agreement-related services. A business calling itself a “consultant” is not thereby exempt from applicable rules. The three state examples here do not establish a nationwide agency licence or approve any particular business.

Treat the clinic and embryology laboratory as separate counterparties. Review consent and service forms, cancellation and failed-cycle terms, embryo storage and records access, itemised clinical/laboratory/medication fees, and refunds of unused amounts. Verify the clinic’s and laboratory’s authorisation or accreditation under the relevant state and professional rules; this guide does not certify any provider or catalogue every licensing rule. Keep clinical fees separate from agency commission and carrier compensation.

Resolve insurance and medical-cost exposure in writing

Obtain the full policy, endorsements and written insurer confirmation. Check surrogacy exclusions, start date, maternity and delivery, deductibles and out-of-pocket limits, benefit coordination, subrogation, notice deadlines, provider networks, complications and newborn/neonatal-intensive-care costs. Allocate premiums, uncovered costs, travel, lost wages, childcare, bed rest and postnatal expenses. “Insurance is covered” is not enough without the actual terms.

New York requires comprehensive health coverage throughout the expected pregnancy and for twelve months after birth, stillbirth, miscarriage or pregnancy termination, plus payment or reimbursement of specified out-of-pocket medical costs through that period. The agreement must disclose how intended parents will cover the carrier’s and child’s medical expenses and, if comprehensive health coverage is used, summarize pregnancy-related coverage and exclusions. Intended parents must also procure and pay for a life-insurance policy for the carrier with a minimum benefit of $750,000, or the maximum available if lower. The policy must remain in force throughout the expected pregnancy and for twelve months after birth, stillbirth, a miscarriage resulting in termination, or termination of pregnancy; the carrier chooses the beneficiary. The carrier may also designate the beneficiary of the disability policy. Disability coverage must also be procured and paid for at the carrier’s request under § 581-403. Statutory waiver rules can apply to an uncompensated carrier, so do not assume the same package applies to every arrangement.

California’s agreement must disclose how the carrier’s and newborn’s medical expenses will be covered, relevant policy terms, potential liability, third-party liens and notice requirements. Uncertain coverage may be stated as uncertain; this does not compel insurer coverage.

Protect medical autonomy; do not promise control

The contract should allocate costs and explain communication, consent and reimbursement procedures; it should not be treated as a transfer of bodily autonomy. Michigan Act 24 requires the agreement to preserve the carrier’s health and welfare decisions about herself and the pregnancy, including whether to continue or terminate the pregnancy, reduce or retain the number of fetuses or embryos, consent to a caesarean section or multiple-embryo transfer; the agreement must also permit her to use a health-care practitioner of her choosing. Contrary terms are void and unenforceable. The Act also bars specific performance to force a surrogate to become pregnant, terminate a pregnancy or submit to medical procedures.

New York Family Court Act § 581-403 likewise requires the agreement to preserve the carrier’s health and welfare decisions and the right to continue or terminate the pregnancy or reduce or retain the number of fetuses or embryos; contrary terms are void and unenforceable.

Have independent counsel review any clause about embryo-transfer attempts, the number of embryos, prenatal testing, selective reduction, abortion, medical treatment, confidentiality, contact during pregnancy or birth planning. Do not rely on a penalty, forfeiture or payment condition as a way to compel a medical decision. The enforceability of other clauses depends on the applicable state law and facts; a contract cannot safely be drafted from a generic template alone.

Plan termination, refunds and breach remedies

Regulate separately: no match, agency withdrawal, failed transfer, no pregnancy, pregnancy loss, pre-transfer termination, material breach, fraud and insolvency. Specify payable incurred costs, unearned agency fees, refund formula and deadline, escrow release, record custody and dispute forum. An agency refund clause does not end separate carrier-agreement duties.

Under Michigan Act 24, a party may terminate before gamete or embryo transfer and, after a transfer that does not result in pregnancy, before another transfer. Unless the agreement provides otherwise, termination releases the parties from the agreement except that intended parents remain responsible for reimbursable expenses incurred by the carrier through the termination date. Unless fraud is involved, a party is not liable for a penalty or liquidated damages for termination under this provision. A surrogacy agreement that substantially complies with §§ 302–303 is enforceable. If a child was conceived under an agreement that does not substantially meet the material requirements of Part 3, a court must determine parentage consistent with the parties’ intent, taking the child’s best interests into account.

Statutory remedies may differ from private contract wording. Michigan excludes specific performance to compel pregnancy, termination or medical procedures. Obtain state-specific advice before relying on arbitration, liquidated damages or a “no-refund” term.

Before relying on a refund or release, counsel should compare the signed termination clause with § 722.1905.

Pre-payment checklist

  • A short written state-law analysis identifying all connected states and the rules applicable to the exact arrangement.
  • A final signed carrier agreement, separate engagement letters for each party’s independent lawyer, and evidence of any required notarisation or witnesses. In New York, each intended parent must also execute a will before embryo transfer, naming a guardian for every resulting child and authorising the executor to perform the agreement’s obligations, including seeking a parentage judgment, if no intended parent is living.
  • A separate agency services agreement with itemised fees, earned-fee milestones, cancellation terms, refund triggers, exclusions and affiliate disclosures.
  • A signed escrow or attorney-trust agreement, account details, permitted disbursements, supporting-document rules and a written refund process.
  • Written insurance confirmation and the full policy language, including exclusions, deductibles, subrogation and newborn coverage.
  • Evidence of the agency’s licence or regulatory status where required, plus disclosure of ownership and referral relationships.
  • A payment ledger, invoices and receipts; written treatment of failed transfers, pregnancy loss, complications and postnatal costs; and tax advice on how payments must be reported.

Do not release funds or authorise treatment while a material clause, eligibility question, insurance exclusion or escrow control remains unresolved. Have counsel confirm that the actual signed documents—not only a summary or agency brochure—match the applicable law.

Limits of this guide and next step

This guide covers gestational-surrogacy contracts, compensation, intermediaries and client funds. It does not decide parentage, birth registration, nationality, immigration, foreign recognition, tax, clinic licensing or every state’s law; those require separate advice.

As of 23 October 2026. The New York pages reviewed display revision dates of 7 March 2025 for Family Court Act §§ 581-402 and 581-403, and 27 December 2024 for Family Court Act § 581-502 and General Business Law §§ 1401 and 1403. Before signing, counsel should verify later amendments and current regulations, confirm the official §§ 7960–7962 text, and apply the law to the actual parties and procedures.

Primary legal sources and source limitations

Sections 7960 and 7961 link to FindLaw reproductions marked current as of 1 January 2026. Verify all three California sections against the official text before reliance.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards