United States · Legal status and models

Open legal reference book and research notes on a desk in a quiet legal research room; editorial illustration, not an official document.
Editorial illustration only; not evidence of verified facilities, laws or approvals.

Surrogacy in the United States: legality, restrictions and compensation models

The short answer

There is no single nationwide “yes” or “no” to surrogacy in the United States. No overarching federal statute governs gestational-carrier arrangements. State statutes, court decisions and regulatory rules determine whether a particular arrangement may be made, whether its agreement is enforceable, what compensation is permitted and how legal parentage is established. A program that is workable in one state may be restricted or legally uncertain in another.

The practical question is whether this model, with these participants, payments and reproductive method, is permitted and enforceable under the law of every relevant state. These examples are illustrative, not a fifty-state survey or a guarantee of availability.

Who makes the rules?

State law is the starting point. ASRM describes the landscape as a mix of state statutes, court opinions and regulatory policies: some states expressly regulate gestational-carrier agreements, some lack a clear specific statute, and some void or restrict certain contracts. Because the law changes, an old state chart or agency advertisement cannot establish the current rule.

Distinguish statutes, court decisions, administrative rules and professional guidance. Statutes may set effective dates and conditions; court decisions interpret law within a jurisdiction; administrative rules cover delegated matters such as licensing. Clinic protocols and professional guidance may inform treatment and safety, but do not by themselves make an agreement enforceable or determine parentage. Federal law can affect related issues but does not replace state-law review.

Gestational and traditional surrogacy are not interchangeable

In gestational surrogacy, an embryo created through in-vitro fertilization is transferred to a carrier who has not contributed the egg. The embryo may use gametes from one or both intended parents, donors, or a combination allowed by the applicable law. In traditional (genetic) surrogacy, the carrier contributes her own egg and is genetically related to the child. This difference can change the parentage analysis and the legal route available after birth.

Many statutes cover only gestational-carrier agreements, not traditional surrogacy. A state may regulate one model, restrict another or leave questions to general parentage or adoption law. Check the statute’s definitions and scope before applying it; conception method, genetic links and the agreement itself matter.

A practical sample of state rules

The following examples show why a national label is misleading. Each row describes a specific statutory feature, not a comprehensive opinion on every fact pattern. Before relying on an example, check the current text, amendments, court interpretations and any separate eligibility or parentage provisions.

Example jurisdiction Current rule illustrated Practical consequence
California Family Code § 7962 sets formal requirements for a written gestational-carrier agreement, including parties, gamete-source information and medical-expense arrangements. Read the full statutory framework; do not infer every eligibility, compensation or parentage rule from one section.
New York The Child-Parent Security Act, effective 15 February 2021, permits regulated gestational surrogacy, protects carrier rights and permits compensation under safeguards. Check the carrier’s residence or delivery location, intended-parent residency conditions, separate counsel and licensed matching-program rules.
Texas Family Code chapter 160, subchapter I requires judicial validation of a gestational agreement; an unvalidated agreement is unenforceable. Court timing, residence, medical evidence, screening and post-birth steps matter.
Louisiana A narrow statutory route requires a married couple using their own gametes and advance court approval; compensated contracts are null and unenforceable in Louisiana. Do not assume another state’s contract or payment model will be accepted.
Florida Section 742.15 imposes marriage, age and medical conditions, limits payment to specified reasonable expenses, requires a parentage clause if neither intended parent is genetic parent, and contains a 2026 foreign-country-of-concern restriction. Verify every party’s status and the current definition in Florida law before proceeding.
Nebraska Section 25-21,200 makes a defined category of compensated surrogate-parenthood contracts void and unenforceable. Read the statutory definition carefully; do not assume it resolves every uncompensated or gestational arrangement.

How to read a state’s legal status

For practical screening, states can be grouped into broad patterns: an express statutory route with safeguards; a framework built partly from case law or other parentage rules; an area where the statute is silent or the result is uncertain; or a rule that voids or restricts a type of contract or payment. These are working categories, not official nationwide classifications. A state can allow gestational surrogacy but impose narrow eligibility conditions, or recognize parentage while restricting compensation.

“Not expressly prohibited” does not mean approved, and a clinic’s offer does not prove enforceability. Likewise, a limit on compensated contracts does not answer every question about an uncompensated arrangement. Check the statutory definition, parties’ facts and controlling cases before concluding.

Commercial, compensated and altruistic arrangements

The words “commercial” and “altruistic” are not used identically in every statute. For this article, a compensated arrangement means that the carrier receives value beyond reimbursement of permitted actual expenses; an altruistic arrangement generally excludes that additional compensation but may still involve medical bills, insurance, travel, lost wages or legal costs where the law allows them. A state may classify a payment differently from another state, and some statutes distinguish compensation from reasonable expenses expressly.

There is no nationwide rule that all paid surrogacy is permitted or that all payments are prohibited. New York expressly protects a gestational surrogate’s right to compensation under its statutory framework, with the compensation held in escrow by an independent agent. By contrast, Louisiana declares a compensated gestational-carrier contract null and unenforceable in Louisiana, and Florida limits the contract to specified reasonable expenses. Nebraska’s statute declares a defined category of compensated surrogate-parenthood contracts void and unenforceable. The exact payment wording therefore matters: do not relabel compensation as “expenses” without a factual and legal basis.

Agency and clinic fees are distinct from carrier compensation; their licensing, tax treatment and disclosure rules must be checked separately.

California and New York: statutory routes with safeguards

California Family Code section 7962 sets requirements for a written assisted-reproduction agreement for a gestational carrier, including information about the agreement date, the intended parent or parents, the source of gametes and how medical expenses will be covered. The surrounding statutory provisions must be read as a whole. This section is a useful example of a formal statutory framework, but a reader should not treat a short excerpt as a complete opinion on eligibility, payment, parentage or the correct court procedure.

New York’s Child-Parent Security Act took effect on 15 February 2021 and permits gestational surrogacy subject to statutory conditions. It protects carriers, requires independent legal counsel for the parties, allows compensation under statutory safeguards, and requires gestational-surrogacy organizations (matching programs) to be licensed. The New York Department of Health says these protections apply when the carrier resides in New York and/or gives birth there. Family Court Act § 581-402 separately requires the carrier to be a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident and at least one intended parent to have one of those statuses. The six-month New York-residency condition is conditional: the carrier must have lived in New York for six months if neither intended parent has been a New York resident for that period; if the carrier has not, at least one intended parent must have. “Lawful permanent resident” is a U.S. immigration status, not a status conferred by New York State. Check all statutory eligibility requirements against the parties’ facts.

Louisiana, Florida and Nebraska: important restrictions

Louisiana uses a narrow statutory route. The statute defines intended parents as a married couple who each exclusively contribute their own gametes; the written agreement must meet statutory requirements and receive court approval before embryo transfer. Louisiana law says a compensated gestational-carrier contract, or a contract that fails the statutory requirements, is null and unenforceable in Louisiana, even if executed in another state. The statute also makes certain provisions requiring termination of a pregnancy or reduction of multiple fetuses null and unenforceable. Do not assume that a program designed for another state will satisfy Louisiana law.

Florida Statutes § 742.15 requires a written, binding gestational-surrogacy contract. The carrier must be at least 18; the commissioning couple must be legally married and both at least 18; and a physician must identify a qualifying medical reason, such as inability to carry a pregnancy to term or a specified health risk. Under the contract, only reasonable living, legal, medical, psychological and psychiatric expenses directly related to the prenatal, intrapartal and postpartal periods may be paid. The contract must address parentage if neither member of the commissioning couple is the child’s genetic parent; in that event, the statute requires the carrier to assume parental rights and responsibilities. Under the 2026 amendment, a contract may not be entered into in Florida if any party is a citizen or resident of a “foreign country of concern”; a contract made in violation is void and unenforceable. Florida Statutes § 286.101(1)(b), in the text, names the People’s Republic of China, Russian Federation, Islamic Republic of Iran, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, Republic of Cuba, the Venezuelan regime of Nicolás Maduro, and the Syrian Arab Republic, including agencies or entities under significant control of a listed country or regime. Check the current definition and its application to each party before proceeding.

Nebraska Revised Statute section 25-21,200 states that a “surrogate parenthood contract” is void and unenforceable and defines that term by reference to compensation for bearing a child of a man who is not the carrier’s husband. The wording is specific, so it should not be stretched into a complete answer about every uncompensated or gestational arrangement. A Nebraska analysis requires the statute’s definition and any other applicable law to be examined together.

Texas: court validation matters

Texas Family Code chapter 160, subchapter I, provides a statutory process for gestational agreements. The agreement must be validated by a court under the statutory procedure; an agreement that is not validated is unenforceable, and parentage is then determined under the otherwise applicable law. The validation criteria include jurisdictional and residence requirements, medical evidence that the intended mother cannot carry a pregnancy to term or would face an unreasonable risk, voluntary understanding by the parties, a previous pregnancy and delivery by the prospective carrier, and a plan for pregnancy-related health-care expenses. Unless waived by the court, the statute also calls for a home study of the intended parents. The court retains statutory discretion.

This is not a formality that can safely be postponed until after embryo transfer or birth. Texas illustrates a general point: a signed document alone may not deliver the legal result that the parties expect. The timing of the petition, court order, transfer, and post-birth notice or order must be checked under the current statute and local procedure.

What a prohibition or invalid contract can mean

A statute that makes a contract void or unenforceable can affect the parties’ ability to enforce payment promises, rely on a parentage clause, or use the intended administrative route. The consequences are not identical in every state. The court may have to determine parentage under other law; adoption or additional court proceedings may be necessary; or a payment term may fail even if other parts of the arrangement are treated separately. Do not promise a particular consequence without checking the actual statutory remedy and controlling case law.

“Prohibited” does not automatically mean every participant committed a crime. Check the conduct covered, persons regulated, territorial reach and stated remedy; if the rule is unclear, explain the uncertainty and obtain a state-specific opinion rather than asserting a categorical ban.

Which state law applies?

The relevant state may depend on more than the address where the agreement was signed. Facts to test include the carrier’s residence, the intended parents’ residence, where the clinic and embryo transfer are located, where the child is expected to be born, which court has jurisdiction, the agreement’s choice-of-law clause and any state public-policy rule. A choice-of-law clause is not a guarantee that another state will accept the agreement or the resulting parentage order.

The examples above show why a “surrogacy-friendly state” label is not enough. Louisiana expressly addresses certain contracts executed elsewhere; New York ties its statutory protections to the carrier’s residence and/or delivery in the state; Florida has a specific 2026 restriction involving a defined foreign-country status. These are different kinds of territorial and participant rules. A cross-border or multi-state plan needs an analysis of each relevant connection, not just a search for the most permissive statute.

Permission to use surrogacy is not the same as parentage

At least four questions must be kept separate: may the parties enter this arrangement; is the agreement enforceable; who is the legal parent under state law; and what documents or orders will be accepted by the vital-records authority and any other relevant jurisdiction? A state may authorize an arrangement but require a court order, a post-birth filing, an adoption or additional evidence before parentage is recognized. The birth certificate is evidence of a recorded status; it is not a substitute for analyzing the legal route that supports that status.

Texas, for example, connects the statutory parentage route to a validated gestational agreement and court procedure. New York provides statutory parentage pathways under the Child-Parent Security Act, but only if the applicable requirements are met. Neither example supports a general promise that intended parents will automatically be listed on a birth certificate wherever the child is born. Nationality, immigration, passport and recognition abroad are separate questions and are outside the scope of this state-framework overview.

The carrier’s consent and medical autonomy

A surrogacy agreement should not be treated as a purchase of control over another person’s body. State statutes and professional guidance may protect the carrier’s informed consent and medical decision-making. Florida requires the contract to recognize the carrier as the sole source of consent for clinical intervention and pregnancy management; Texas law says a gestational agreement may not limit the carrier’s right to make decisions to safeguard her health or the health of an embryo. New York’s statutory Bill of Rights protects the carrier’s ability to make decisions about her health and pregnancy. Louisiana makes certain clauses requiring termination or fetal reduction null and unenforceable.

These provisions are not interchangeable and should be read in their own statutory setting. The contract must not promise a particular pregnancy outcome or assume that intended parents, an agency or a clinic can override the carrier’s lawful medical decisions. Counsel should check how the applicable law treats consent, confidentiality, pregnancy loss, termination, reduction, disability-related disputes and responsibility for expenses if the arrangement ends.

Before treatment: agreement and safeguards

Before embryo transfer, confirm the statutory route and sequence. Depending on the state, requirements may include a written pre-treatment agreement; separate independent counsel for the carrier and intended parents; medical and psychosocial screening; informed consent; insurance and pregnancy-cost planning; escrow for permitted compensation; required spousal participation; and court approval before transfer. These are issues to verify, not universal requirements.

The agreement should allocate medical costs, insurance exclusions, permitted lost income and travel, escrow and legal fees, confidentiality, and the steps for establishing parentage. It should address failed treatment, no pregnancy, pregnancy loss, death or separation, unexpected genetic results and disputes. Every clause must comply with mandatory law and respect the carrier’s protected medical autonomy.

Agencies and clinics do not replace legal analysis

Licensing and oversight of matching programs, medical providers, escrow agents and other intermediaries vary by state. New York, for example, requires gestational-surrogacy organizations to be licensed by its Department of Health. That requirement should not be generalized to every state, and an agency’s claim that it is “licensed” should be checked with the regulator that actually has authority. Ask which legal entity is licensed, for which activity, in which state and for what period.

A clinic may meet medical standards but cannot guarantee that a contract is enforceable or a parentage order recognized. Verify the parties, funds, refund terms and responsibility for legal filings; clinic protocols and agency screening do not replace state-specific legal advice.

Checklist before choosing a state or signing

Before committing funds or starting treatment, ask a lawyer admitted in the relevant state to confirm each of the following in writing:

  1. The model: gestational or traditional; whose gametes will be used; and whether the state statute covers that method.
  2. The people: the carrier’s and intended parents’ ages, marital status, residence, genetic relationship, and any citizenship or residency facts that trigger a special restriction.
  3. The money: which amounts are compensation, which are actual expenses, what is prohibited, and whether escrow, insurance or disclosure rules apply.
  4. The timing: whether the agreement must be signed before medical treatment and whether a court must approve or validate it before embryo transfer.
  5. The parentage route: what petition, judgment, acknowledgment or adoption is required, when it must be filed, and which authority issues the birth record.
  6. The protections: independent counsel, screening, informed consent, medical autonomy, confidentiality and the handling of pregnancy-related decisions.
  7. The contingencies: termination before pregnancy, pregnancy loss, medical complications, disagreement, separation, death, an unexpected genetic result or a child needing additional care.
  8. The geography: whether the law of another state or country may later be relevant to recognition, citizenship, immigration or travel.

Request the actual statutory provisions, the date they were checked, any effective-date or transitional rule, and the procedural authority’s current instructions. Ask the lawyer to distinguish what the statute says from a court’s interpretation, agency practice, clinic policy and professional recommendation. If a key issue cannot be verified, pause the transfer or payment until the uncertainty is resolved.

Safe next steps

The safest next step is to identify the state or states with a real connection to the arrangement and obtain a current, state-specific review before signing or transferring an embryo. Do not choose a state solely because an online list calls it “surrogacy-friendly”, and do not assume that a contract drafted for one state will work in another. Ask counsel to analyze the exact payment model, participant eligibility, required court process, parentage pathway and any special nationality or residency restriction.

If the program has begun, preserve the signed agreement, payment records, clinic and screening documents, and court filings. Ask counsel which deadlines and corrective steps remain; do not assume a defect can be cured retroactively. Cross-border families may need separate advice on parentage recognition, nationality, immigration and travel.

Scope and review date

It gives selected state examples, not an exhaustive fifty-state survey, legal clearance for a specific program or individual legal advice. Laws and local practice can change; counsel admitted in each relevant state must verify current law and facts before reliance.

Primary and professional sources

Professional guidance is not binding law; statutory text and current amendments control where applicable.

  1. S01 — ASRM — Gestational Carrier Policy in the United States (professional overview)
  2. S02 — California Family Code § 7962 (official state code)
  3. S03 — New York State Department of Health — The Child-Parent Security Act: Gestational Surrogacy
  4. S04 — Texas Family Code, Chapter 160 (official state code PDF)
  5. S05 — Louisiana Revised Statutes § 9:2720 (official state statute)
  6. S06 — Louisiana Revised Statutes § 9:2718.1 (official definitions)
  7. S07 — Louisiana Revised Statutes § 9:2720.5 (official state statute)
  8. S08 — Florida Statutes § 742.15, 2026 (official state statute)
  9. S09 — Nebraska Revised Statute § 25-21,200 (official state statute)
  10. S10 — New York Family Court Act § 581-402 (official state legislation)
  11. S11 — Florida Statutes § 286.101(1)(b), definition of “foreign country of concern” (official state statute)

Guides for United States

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards