India surrogacy contracts, agencies and payments: lawful boundaries and risks
In India, the safest way to assess a surrogacy agreement is to follow the real purpose of each service and payment—not the label printed on a contract or invoice. The distinction between permitted expenses and prohibited commercial surrogacy is central.
The legal starting point
India’s Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 has been in force since 25 January 2022. It permits surrogacy only on an altruistic, non-commercial basis and only where statutory eligibility, certification, clinical and procedural conditions are met. For a contract, the decisive issue is not whether an amount sounds modest, is called a “gift”, or is routed through an agency. The Act defines altruistic surrogacy as excluding charges, fees, remuneration and monetary incentives to the surrogate mother, her dependants or representative, apart from medical expenses and other prescribed expenses incurred on her and insurance cover. A private agreement cannot create an exception to the Act. This article addresses contracts, clinic and agency roles, expenses and enforcement risks; it does not decide any reader’s eligibility, legal parentage, citizenship or permission to take a child abroad. Those require separate checks.
Expenses that may be covered
Expenses are not the same as a fee for carrying a child. The statutory exception is limited to medical expenses, expenses prescribed under the rules and insurance coverage for the surrogate mother. The 2022 Rules require the intending couple or woman to purchase general health insurance in the surrogate’s favour for 36 months from the date of embryo transfer, covering pregnancy complications and postpartum delivery complications, through an insurer or agent recognised by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI). The amount must be sufficient to cover all expenses for those complications. Insurance is a real policy obligation, not a cash substitute or optional “package”. The sources do not establish a universal lawful price, standard compensation amount or blanket entitlement to reimburse every item an agency calls an expense. Before paying for travel, lodging, meals, lost income, household support or a flat “care allowance”, obtain written confirmation from Indian counsel and the appropriate authority that the specific category and method are permitted under the current rules. Keep invoices, receipts, treatment dates, payer and beneficiary details.
Clinics, agencies and intermediaries
Section 3 prohibits an unregistered surrogacy clinic from conducting, associating with or helping in surrogacy activities and prohibits advertising to undertake commercial surrogacy. Section 3 also prohibits clinics, specified health professionals and any other person from conducting, offering, promoting, associating with or availing of commercial surrogacy. Its advertising restrictions are broader than commercial-surrogacy advertising: they also cover material intended to induce or solicit a woman to act as a surrogate, or to suggest that a woman is willing to do so. Section 38 prohibits commercial surrogacy and related component services, organised selection or empanelment of surrogate mothers, and the use of brokers or intermediaries to arrange surrogate mothers and procedures. It also prohibits relevant commercial-surrogacy advertising, exploitation, trading in embryos or gametes, import for surrogacy and sex selection. These provisions create serious risk for an agency paid to find, recruit, match or supply a surrogate, or to arrange the surrogacy procedure. Do not overread the statute as proving that every administrative or professional service fee is automatically unlawful: the actual service, recipient, fee calculation and connection to prohibited activity matter. A genuine clinical charge is not the same as a payment to the surrogate. Ask for a line-by-line scope of work and fee schedule. Verify the clinic’s current registration independently with the appropriate authority; a polished website, broker promise or copied certificate is not verification.
What the written agreement should do
Form 2 attached to the 2022 Rules is titled “Consent of the Surrogate Mother and Agreement for Surrogacy”. Its text records that the parties have worked out medical and other expenses and the conditions of surrogacy in writing, and that an appropriately authenticated copy is filed with the clinic, which must keep it confidential. This supports careful documentation of permitted expenses and conditions; it does not authorise compensation prohibited by the Act. Before signing, identify each party and role; distinguish clinic treatment fees from expenses incurred on the surrogate; list each permitted category, proof and payment date; attach the insurance policy; set a process for checking invoices and correcting errors; and state who handles emergencies, communications, document retention and confidentiality. Ask counsel to verify the current prescribed form and state or territory instructions. The written agreement does not replace statutory certificates, clinic registration, court requirements or informed consent.
Consent and medical autonomy
Consent and medical autonomy cannot be bought. Section 10 prohibits forcing her to undergo an abortion except under prescribed conditions. Separately, section 3(vi) requires her written consent and authorisation by the appropriate authority for an abortion during surrogacy, subject to the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971. Do not include clauses forcing abortion or continuation of a pregnancy, dictating treatment against medical advice, requiring sex selection, or imposing a financial penalty for exercising a statutory right. Section 38 prohibits exploitation of the surrogate mother and child, sex selection, and abandonment or disowning of a child born through surrogacy. Form 2 records medical expectations and handover arrangements, but no form or signature can waive mandatory protections. A signature is not a substitute for voluntary, informed consent free from threats, dependence or pressure.
Documents to verify before paying
Before transferring money or beginning procedures, ask to see and independently verify: (1) the clinic’s current registration under the Surrogacy Act and, where applicable, ART registration; (2) the responsible clinicians’ qualifications; (3) the required certificate of essentiality and eligibility certificates under section 4, including the surrogate mother’s eligibility; (4) the court order concerning parentage and custody required by section 4; (5) the prescribed consent and agreement form, correctly completed and explained; and (6) the 36-month insurance policy, including exclusions, limits and beneficiary. Eligibility conditions are detailed and may depend on the intended parents’ status, medical indication and other statutory requirements. An agent is not the authority that decides eligibility. Obtain a written estimate naming the actual recipient of every payment and separating clinical services, insurance premiums and surrogate-related expenses. Use traceable payments and genuine invoices. Do not accept false labels, blank receipts, unexplained transfers to personal accounts, or pressure to pay before documents are complete.
Payment screening matrix
Use the matrix below as a screening tool, not a legal safe harbour. The result turns on the actual service and payment, current rules and supporting documents—not the label in a contract. If a line item cannot be tied to an allowed expense or a genuine authorised service, pause and obtain written Indian legal advice before payment.
| Payment or service | Initial risk assessment |
|---|---|
| Actual medical bill for the surrogate | Potentially permitted if genuine, necessary, documented and within the rules. |
| 36-month health insurance | Required coverage; verify the policy and recognised insurer or agent. |
| Fixed fee, bonus or gift to the surrogate or her dependants | Prohibited/high risk; cash or kind, timing and label do not cure it. |
| Agency fee for matching, recruiting or arranging the surrogate or procedure | High risk; section 38 targets commercial arrangements and brokers/intermediaries. |
| Itemised fee for authorised clinical care | May be payable for lawful care; verify registration, scope and invoice. |
| Lump-sum “support”, “care” or “coordination” package | Unclear; separate components, recipients and legal basis before payment. |
Contract enforceability and refunds
The Indian Contract Act, 1872, section 23, makes an agreement void where its consideration or object is unlawful, including where it is forbidden by law or would defeat another law. Section 24 may invalidate an agreement where part of a single consideration or object is unlawful. A side letter, private escrow, cash payment, bonus after birth or “agency coordination” invoice therefore does not automatically make a prohibited arrangement enforceable. Nor does the label alone prove that every separate clinic-services contract or every expense reimbursement is void. A lawyer must examine all agreements, who promised what, the true purpose of each payment, whether lawful and unlawful parts are severable, and the evidence. Do not assume a court will order a refund, enforce a penalty, compel performance or protect a payment merely because it is written. Civil consequences and criminal liability are separate questions. Obtain advice before signing; do not disguise or retrospectively relabel payments.
Penalties and dispute response
Section 38 makes conduct prohibited by its clauses (a)–(g) punishable by imprisonment for up to 10 years and a fine of up to ₹10 lakh. Section 40 separately provides, for failing to follow altruistic surrogacy or conducting it for commercial purposes, up to 5 years’ imprisonment and a fine up to ₹5 lakh for a first offence, and up to 10 years and ₹10 lakh for a subsequent offence. Section 39 applies to specified medical practitioners and people who own or work at a surrogacy clinic, centre or laboratory and provide professional or technical services there; it covers contraventions of the Act and Rules other than conduct covered by section 38. It allows up to five years’ imprisonment and a fine up to ₹10 lakh. For a subsequent or continuing offence under section 39(1), the appropriate authority must report the registered medical practitioner’s name to the relevant State Medical Council for action, which may include suspension of registration for five years. These are statutory maximums, not a prediction that every disputed invoice triggers prosecution. The actor, legal elements and evidence matter. Section 36 empowers the appropriate authority to investigate complaints and take legal action. If a dispute arises, preserve agreements, forms, messages, advertisements, bank records, invoices, insurance and clinical records; seek local counsel promptly. Do not threaten anyone, destroy evidence or continue a prohibited payment to “fix” the arrangement.
A safer order of work
A safer sequence is: first confirm that the intended parents and medical circumstances qualify under current Indian law; then verify clinic and authority records. List every service, payee and payment. Remove any surrogate compensation, recruitment commission or concealed benefit. Ask Indian counsel to confirm each proposed expense category against the current Rules. Put permitted medical expenses, proof requirements, payment dates and insurance in a written agreement consistent with Form 2. Confirm the policy and complete the required certificates and court-related steps before procedures begin. Arrange independent advice and an explanation in the surrogate’s language, with no conflict of interest. Keep payment records and avoid cash-only or misdescribed transfers. If an agent refuses to disclose the payee or says a fee is lawful because it is called “logistics”, stop and request written advice. Do not withhold medically necessary care or required insurance while a commercial dispute is assessed.
Cross-border limits and current-law check
The Act has been in force since 25 January 2022. Eligibility, clinic registration, parentage and custody, birth registration, nationality and permission to leave India are separate legal questions; a foreign passport or contract does not answer them. This article does not determine whether a foreign intended parent is eligible or whether another country will recognise parentage. The official Surrogacy (Regulation) Amendment Rules, 2026 (G.S.R. 492(E), notification dated 17 June 2026) insert rule 10A on the deposit and use of clinic registration fees and rule 11A on renewal. In general, a renewal application in Form 3 must be submitted through the National Registry portal at least 60 days before expiry. The renewal fee is ₹1 lakh. If the application is received less than 60 days before expiry, the fee is ₹2 lakh; establishments in government-run institutes are exempt from renewal fees. A renewed certificate is valid for a further three years. These are regulatory fees paid by the clinic to the appropriate authority, not patient fees for treatment or remuneration to the surrogate. The amendment does not create an exception to the Act’s prohibition on commercial surrogacy or surrogate remuneration.
Sources and limits
The source list links the official Surrogacy Act and Contract Act texts, a checked transcription of the 2022 Rules and section-level statutory text.
- S1 — The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 — India Code official PDF
- S2 — Section 38 — current statutory transcription
- S3 — Surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022 — checked transcription
- S4 — Indian Contract Act, 1872 — government judiciary PDF
- S5 — Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 — India Code PDF
- S6 — Section 6 — written informed consent
- S7 — Section 40 — penalty for not following altruistic surrogacy
- S8 — Official Gazette PDF hosted by National ART & Surrogacy Portal — 2026 amendment
- S9 — Secondary transcription of 2026 amendment (not a substitute for Gazette)
- S10 — Ministry official PDF — Surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022
