India · Disputes, refusals and remedies

A redacted case file and indexed documents prepared for legal review in India.

India: Surrogacy Refusals, Disputes and Remedies

What this guide covers and how to triage the dispute

As at 23 October 2026, a dispute about an Indian surrogacy certificate, a clinic’s registration, coercion or unlawful conduct may require different remedies. Identify who made the decision, what act or document is challenged, when the notice was received and the concrete result needed. This guide addresses administrative and legal remedies under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 (the Act), its rules and the Constitution. It does not decide individual eligibility, parentage, citizenship, birth registration, passports, exit from India or recognition abroad. A challenge does not authorise a prohibited procedure or guarantee a certificate.

Use the table as an initial routing aid, then verify the actual order, current rules and competent authority. Central law must be read with current notifications and instructions of the relevant State or Union territory. The 2026 Rules amendment is especially relevant to clinic-registration renewals.

ProblemLikely routeFirst action
Certificate refusedSection 14 appeal, normally within 30 days of receiptKeep the application, refusal and proof of receipt date.
No decisionWritten status request; section 36(h) gives 90 days for specified applications; consider a High Court writ for unjustified delayProve receipt of the complete application. Silence is not approval.
Clinic registration/renewal refused, suspended or cancelledCheck section 14, sections 12–13 and 2026 Rule 11AKeep notices, hearing record, reasons and registration documents; verify appeal route.
Possible exploitation or illegal commercial surrogacyComplaint to appropriate authority under sections 36–37; sections 38–44 may applyPreserve lawful evidence and prioritise immediate safety.
Consent, abortion, birth record or cross-border issueSections 6–8 and 10 may matter; separate family, civil-registration, passport or nationality procedures may also applyObtain independent advice; section 14 does not resolve every issue.

Statutory appeal and the 2026 clinic-renewal rule

Section 14 provides an appeal within 30 days from receipt of the communication for the listed decisions. An order by a State appropriate authority is appealed to the State Government; an order by a Union territory authority is appealed to the Central Government. The provision covers rejection of certificates under section 4 and specified clinic-registration decisions, including suspension or cancellation. Confirm the current form, recipient and filing method with the authority and retain proof of filing. Do not assume that filing automatically authorises a surrogacy procedure; request interim protection expressly if needed.

Section 14 expressly names the surrogacy clinic, intending couple or intending woman as potential appellants. It does not expressly name the surrogate mother. If the affected person is the surrogate mother, do not assume section 14 gives her an appeal; counsel should assess standing and any alternative remedy.

There is a drafting point to check in clinic cases: section 12 addresses registration and renewal, section 13 suspension or cancellation, while section 14 links registration decisions to section 13. Rule 11A was introduced by the Surrogacy (Regulation) Amendment Rules, 2026, notified on 17 June 2026; those Rules state that they take effect on publication in the Official Gazette. Confirm the exact publication date if it affects a deadline. Rule 11A governs clinic renewals but does not remove the need to confirm the appeal route for a renewal refusal.

Under Rule 11A, a clinic must apply in Form 3 through the National Registry portal at least 60 days before expiry. The non-refundable renewal fee is ₹1 lakh. If the application is not received at least 60 days before expiry, the ₹2 lakh fee applicable to initial registration applies; government-run establishments pay no renewal fee. The signed PDF application and prescribed fee must both reach the appropriate authority before the application is treated as received. Within 60 days, the authority must renew after inspection and compliance review or reject with recorded reasons; it cannot reject without giving the applicant an opportunity to be heard. Renewal lasts three years from expiry of the prior certificate. Rule 11A also waives a new fee for resubmission by the same compliant clinic.

Evidence and administrative delay

Create a dated chronology and preserve a complete, unaltered file: application and attachments; the full refusal, suspension or cancellation order; envelope, email or portal record showing receipt; acknowledgement and tracking; the rule, notification or written instruction relied on; relevant medical and eligibility records; and correspondence showing what was requested, supplied or left unanswered. For clinic disputes, keep registration/renewal records, notices, hearing submissions, invoices, permitted-expense and insurance records, consent forms, treatment records and clinic messages. Preserve original electronic files and metadata where possible. Protect personal identifiers and disclose sensitive medical information only through an appropriate confidential process.

Section 36(h) requires the appropriate authority to consider and grant or reject applications under clause (vi) of section 3 and sub-clauses (a) to (c) of clause (iii) of section 4 within 90 days. Check that the application falls within those categories and prove when the complete application was received. Ask in writing for status, identify any missing documents and request a reasoned decision. The Act does not say that silence for 90 days automatically grants a certificate. If unjustified delay continues, counsel can assess a request for a decision or a mandamus writ.

When judicial review may be appropriate

Article 226 of the Constitution empowers High Courts to issue directions, orders and writs to public authorities to enforce fundamental rights and for other purposes. Depending on the facts, grounds may include lack of jurisdiction, applying an inapplicable rule, imposing an unlawful extra condition, ignoring material evidence, failing to provide a required hearing, inadequate reasons where reasons are required, or unjustified failure to decide. A court may set aside a decision, order lawful reconsideration or require performance of a public duty; interim relief is discretionary.

A writ is not a guaranteed second appeal on the merits. If a statutory appeal is available, the High Court may ask why it was not used first; exceptions depend on the circumstances, including jurisdictional error and procedural unfairness. Choose the court with territorial jurisdiction and assess standing, limitation and interim relief with counsel. Article 32 proceedings in the Supreme Court concern enforcement of fundamental rights and are not a general substitute for every administrative appeal. Do not assume a court will waive substantive statutory requirements.

Complaints, offences and criminal liability

The appropriate authority’s functions under sections 36–37 include investigating complaints, taking legal action and using specified powers to summon people, require documents and search places where a breach is suspected. Identify the current State/Union territory authority through the official National ART & Surrogacy Portal. A complaint should state the person or clinic, dates, conduct, potentially applicable provisions, available evidence and action requested. Ask for acknowledgement and a reference number; distinguish personal knowledge from suspicion. A complaint does not prove guilt, guarantee an investigation outcome or replace an appeal against a certificate refusal.

Sections 38–41 create offences for defined conduct, including commercial surrogacy, exploitation of a surrogate mother or child, prohibited advertising or trading in embryos/gametes and specified professional or participant contraventions. Maximum penalties include up to 10 years’ imprisonment and ₹10 lakh under section 38; up to 5 years and ₹10 lakh for specified professional/clinic contraventions under section 39; under section 40, up to 5 years and ₹5 lakh for a first offence concerning commercial or non-altruistic surrogacy, and up to 10 years and ₹10 lakh for a subsequent offence. Section 41 provides, where no specific penalty applies, up to 3 years and ₹5 lakh plus up to ₹10,000 per day for continuing contravention after conviction. These are maxima, not automatic consequences of every disagreement.

Sections 43–44 classify offences as cognizable, non-bailable and non-compoundable and limit when a court may take cognizance. Under section 44, a written complaint may be made by the appropriate authority or an authorised official/agency; a person, including a social organisation, may also complain after giving at least 15 days’ notice to the authority of the alleged offence and intention to complain to court. That notice concerns this particular private complaint route and must not delay urgent police, medical or safety assistance.

Consent, safety and the child’s interests

Section 6 requires explanation of known side effects and written informed consent from the surrogate mother in a language she understands. It expressly permits withdrawal before embryo implantation. Do not assume this resolves every dispute after implantation; medical facts, other applicable law and urgent safety needs require individual advice. Section 10 prohibits forcing a surrogate mother to abort except under conditions prescribed by law. Document threats, coercion, unsafe treatment or pressure safely and seek appropriate independent medical, legal or protective assistance.

Sections 7–8 matter after birth. The intending couple or intending woman must not abandon a child born through surrogacy because of a birth defect, medical condition, sex or multiple birth. Section 8 treats the child as the biological child of the intending couple or intending woman for rights under applicable law. Birth registration, custody, passport, nationality or recognition abroad may require separate procedures; a surrogacy-law appeal does not automatically resolve them.

Supreme Court example: a narrow age-limit ruling

In Vijaya Kumari S & Another v Union of India and connected matters (2025 INSC 1209, 9 October 2025), the Supreme Court held that the upper-age limit in section 4(iii)(c)(I) does not apply retrospectively to intending couples who (1) began the surrogacy procedure before the Act commenced on 25 January 2022, (2) had reached the stage of creating and freezing embryos after gamete extraction (Stage A), and (3) were at the threshold of transferring embryos to the surrogate mother (Stage B). The competent authority must be satisfied that these conditions and the requirements of Rule 14 are met.

This is a narrow, fact-dependent holding, not a general age exemption. Preserve dated IVF records, evidence of embryo creation and freezing, medical advice and correspondence showing when each step occurred. The official Supreme Court judgment was accessed and checked; counsel should compare the complete case facts and confirm Rule 14 compliance before relying on it. The judgment indicates that other similarly placed applicants may approach the jurisdictional High Court.

Madras High Court example: not every refusal is unlawful

In Subbulakshmi v Union of India, W.A. No. 3767 of 2024, decided on 25 April 2025, an intending couple challenged Tamil Nadu instructions requiring a surrogate mother’s eligibility certificate from the district where she lived or came from. The Madras High Court dismissed the appeal. It noted that draft Forms 17 and 17B referred to in the instructions had not been notified, but accepted implementation guidance that did not contradict the Act or statutory rules, and directed the authority to issue fresh proper instructions.

This is a fact-specific Madras High Court ruling, not a universal rule for every State or certificate. It shows that a challenge should identify the precise legal conflict or procedural defect, not merely an unfavourable result. Verify whether the instruction, form and judgment apply to the relevant authority and current rules.

Compensation, contracts and other legal routes

The Act does not create one automatic compensation award for every certificate refusal, failed treatment cycle, delay or disagreement. Section 49 says the Act operates in addition to other laws. Depending on the facts, separate claims involving medical negligence, fraud, threats, confidentiality, consumer rights or recoverable loss may need assessment under other legislation and before the correct forum. Limitation, proof of loss, causation, standing and available remedies differ.

Do not assume a private surrogacy agreement is enforceable simply because it was signed. Terms requiring prohibited commercial surrogacy or unlawful payments should not be treated as ordinary enforceable promises. Counsel should separate lawful medical expenses and insurance obligations from prohibited remuneration and examine the documents, conduct and governing law. Preserve invoices, bank records, insurance documents, consent records and independent medical evidence.

Practical next steps and limits of this guide

1. Obtain the full written decision or prove the date the application was received. 2. Identify the exact certificate, clinic-registration action, suspected offence or separate civil issue. 3. Check the Act, current rules, Gazette amendments and local instructions. 4. Calendar the possible 30-day section 14 period and Rule 11A dates for clinic renewal. 5. Prepare a dated chronology and indexed evidence bundle, protecting sensitive information. 6. State the remedy sought precisely: reconsideration, a reasoned decision, removal of an unlawful condition, investigation, interim protection or a separate civil remedy. 7. Keep proof of each filing and request written acknowledgement. If a deadline may have passed, obtain urgent advice; do not assume an extension or that a complaint pauses the appeal clock.

The Act and the 2026 amendment were checked; India-qualified counsel must confirm the application of section 14 to clinic-renewal refusals, the current State/Union territory appeal process and any later local notification.

Sources and legal materials

Official statutory texts, notices and case materials are linked below. The official Supreme Court judgment was accessed and checked. Verify later notices before use.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards