France · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Contract pages and a payment schedule on a desk during a legal risk review
Editorial illustration only. It does not depict an actual clinic, contract, authority or case.

France surrogacy: clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

The short answer: separate the agreement, service and payment risks

French law does not provide a contract-based route to make a surrogacy arrangement valid in France. In the surrogacy context, Civil Code article 16-7 declares void any agreement concerning procreation or gestation for another person; article 16-9 makes the relevant chapter a matter of public policy. Separately, Penal Code article 227-12 criminalizes intermediation between a person or couple seeking to welcome a child and a woman agreeing to carry the child for them. These rules address different risks: civil nullity is not the same as criminal liability, and neither automatically answers questions of parentage or nationality.

Do not treat an agency package, a clinic’s participation, a foreign-law clause, an escrow account or the label “expenses” as proof that the arrangement is lawful or enforceable. Equally, do not assume that every medical appointment, translation, legal consultation, travel booking or foreign act is automatically criminal. The actual service, its purpose, the people involved, where conduct occurs and how money moves all matter. This article focuses on French-law contract, payment and intermediary risk. It does not decide intended-parent eligibility, the law of a destination country, parentage recognition, citizenship or travel documents; those require separate analysis.

The civil-law starting point: the surrogacy agreement is void

Civil Code article 16-7 states that any agreement relating to procreation or gestation for another is null. Article 16-9 provides that the provisions in this chapter are of public policy. In practical terms, the parties cannot make a surrogacy agreement enforceable in France simply by calling it altruistic, choosing a foreign governing law, signing before a notary, adding detailed consent clauses or describing the payment as reimbursement. The statutory rule is not limited to a commercial model.

This conclusion concerns the agreement whose object is the arrangement of conception or gestation for another. It does not, without further analysis, determine the validity of every separate contract connected with a person’s wider plans. A translation engagement, independent legal retainer, ordinary travel booking or genuinely separate medical service must be assessed by its own scope and purpose. But separating documents on paper does not settle the issue if the real purpose of a service is to arrange the prohibited transaction. French Civil Code article 1162 also says that a contract may not derogate from public policy either through its terms or its purpose, whether or not that purpose was known to every party.

Intermediaries: the specific criminal-law exposure

Penal Code article 227-12 targets the act of intermediation between a person or couple wishing to welcome a child and a woman agreeing to carry that child with a view to handing the child to them. The basic penalty for the conduct described in that paragraph is the penalty set by the preceding paragraph: up to one year of imprisonment and a €15,000 fine. If the intermediation is carried out habitually or for profit, the penalties are doubled: up to two years’ imprisonment and a €30,000 fine. Attempt is punishable by the same penalties.

The offence turns on actual intermediary conduct, not a provider’s label, overseas address or “concierge” branding. Conversely, a person is not automatically criminally liable merely because they are an intended parent, carrier, clinic employee or professional connected to a programme. Liability depends on the statutory elements and evidence; an advertisement alone is not a criminal finding.

Separate the agency role from the clinic’s medical role

An agency may do more than advertise. Ask whether it finds or screens a carrier, makes introductions, negotiates obligations, coordinates consent or transfer arrangements, arranges handover, collects money for others, or takes a fee tied to the match or pregnancy. Those activities can be relevant to the statutory concept of intermediation, but no single task should be labelled criminal without analysing the full facts and current case law. Record what the provider actually does, not only the service names used in its brochure.

A clinic’s medical work must be analysed separately. Public Health Code article L. 2141-2 describes access to medically assisted procreation for specified applicants and requires prior consent to insemination or embryo transfer; it does not create an authorisation to contract for gestation for another person and does not displace Civil Code article 16-7. Nor does the surrogacy ban alone prove that every medical service a clinic offers is a criminal offence under article 227-12. Identify the exact treatment, where it is performed, who directs it, whether the clinic also matches or coordinates participants, and which public-health rules apply. A clinic licence or ordinary invoice is not a legal opinion on the whole arrangement.

Which contract terms can—and cannot—protect the parties?

A clause cannot cure the core problem if the agreement itself concerns gestation for another. Governing-law and forum clauses, arbitration, confidentiality, milestones, “force majeure”, a promise to deliver a birth record, penalties for withdrawal, indemnities and a refund guarantee do not turn a void agreement into an enforceable one. Article 1162 also makes the contract’s purpose relevant to public policy; changing the title from “surrogacy agreement” to “coordination services” does not control the legal analysis.

A genuinely independent service contract may need a different result if it covers lawful work that is separable from arranging surrogacy. That is a question of substance: the scope of work, the provider’s real conduct, the relationship between the fee and the arrangement, and whether the contract’s object or purpose conflicts with public policy. It is unsafe to assume either that every linked contract is automatically void or that a separately signed document will survive. Before signing, have French counsel review the complete package—including annexes, side letters, payment instructions and the real-world workflow—not just the first page or the chosen governing-law clause.

Payments: distinguish the recipient, purpose and actual service

A payment cannot validate a surrogacy agreement that French law treats as void. A promised fee to a carrier for carrying and handing over a child should not be treated as an enforceable contractual entitlement under French law. Paying an intermediary for arranging the match may also expose the intermediary to the aggravated penalties in article 227-12 where the statutory conditions are met, because a profit-making purpose doubles the stated penalties. The criminal question is the actual intermediary conduct and its purpose, not merely the fact that money changed hands.

Expense reimbursement is not a universal safe harbour. Keep itemised receipts, identify the person who incurred each expense, state the actual purpose, and avoid mixing carrier-related sums, agency fees and unrelated services into one unexplained package. Those records may help establish what a payment was for, but they do not make the underlying surrogacy agreement valid. Payments for genuinely separate legal advice, translation, travel or medical services may be assessed on their own facts if the service is lawful and genuinely distinct. An escrow account, staged payment, personal-account transfer or “administration fee” label does not cleanse an unlawful purpose. Other tax, banking, consumer or foreign-law issues may also need separate review.

Refunds, cancellation and losses: do not rely on a blanket promise

Civil Code article 1178 provides that a contract that fails the validity requirements is null; unless the parties acknowledge the nullity by agreement, it must be pronounced by a judge. Once annulled, the contract is deemed never to have existed, and performance already exchanged is subject to the restitution rules in articles 1352 to 1352-9. Those rules address the form and valuation of restitution, including money and services. Article 1352-8, for example, says restitution of a service takes place in value, assessed at the date the service was provided. Article 1178 also preserves the possibility of seeking compensation for harm under ordinary non-contractual liability rules.

This does not mean that every payment is automatically refundable in full, or that every recipient can simply keep money because the contract is void. The result depends on what was paid, to whom, for which service, what was actually performed, whether services can be separated, the evidence and the legal basis of the claim. A “100% refundable” clause is not a substitute for a legally sound arrangement, and a “non-refundable” label is not conclusive either. Before demanding, withholding or returning money, preserve the contract, amendments, invoices, bank records, messages and proof of services. Obtain case-specific advice before signing a settlement, waiver or repayment acknowledgement.

Cross-border programmes: do not assume either immunity or automatic liability

A programme advertised abroad raises more than one legal question. If a constituent element of the alleged offence occurs in France, Penal Code article 113-2 may make French criminal law applicable. For the misdemeanour addressed here, if committed wholly abroad, article 113-6 may apply to a French national only if the conduct is also punishable under the law of the place where it occurred. For misdemeanours covered by those provisions, article 113-8 adds procedural conditions: prosecution must be brought by the public prosecutor and preceded by a complaint from the victim or their successors, or an official denunciation by the authorities of the place where the act occurred. These are distinct jurisdictional bases; neither makes every foreign surrogacy programme automatically criminal in France. The exact acts and their locations, nationality, the alleged offence and the destination country’s law must be assessed.

A foreign governing-law clause or a foreign provider’s assurance does not make a surrogacy agreement enforceable in France. This article does not decide whether a foreign arrangement is valid under the destination country’s law, or how parentage, civil registration, nationality or travel documents will be treated. Those issues are legally distinct from contract enforceability and require advice in the relevant jurisdictions. If a participant is a French national or an act that may form part of the alleged offence may have occurred in France, obtain French advice before committing funds; do not assume that the foreign location alone removes the risk.

Decision matrix: a practical first-pass risk screen

Use this matrix to identify the issue that needs review; it is not a substitute for applying the statutes to the actual facts. “Potentially separate” means only that the service may have an independent legal basis if it is genuinely distinct and lawful. It is not a safe-harbour label.

Activity or payment French-law starting point Practical response
Agreement to carry a child for intended parents Void under Civil Code art. 16-7; public-policy rule applies. Do not assume performance, penalties or parentage promises can be enforced.
Agency matching, introduction or coordination Potential Penal Code art. 227-12 intermediation; facts and purpose matter. Map each task, person, fee and location; obtain French criminal-law review.
Clinic treatment or laboratory work Public-health rules apply separately; no blanket surrogacy authorisation follows from ART access rules. Identify the exact procedure and whether the clinic also intermediates.
Carrier payment or “expense” reimbursement No label removes civil nullity; profit-making intermediation may aggravate penalties. Itemise the purpose and evidence; do not treat reimbursement as automatic permission.
Independent translation, legal advice or travel service May be assessed separately if genuinely lawful and separable. Use a precise scope, named provider, invoice and proof of actual work.
Deposit, escrow or refund clause Does not validate the underlying agreement; restitution is fact-dependent. Review the underlying purpose and refund mechanics before transfer.

Before signing or paying: documents and actions to request

Ask for the full legal name, registration details, address and contracting entity of every agency, clinic, coordinator and subcontractor. Request an itemised description of each service and fee, the identity of the actual service provider, where the work will occur, who receives each payment, and whether any fee depends on a match, pregnancy, birth or handover. Ask who identifies and contacts the carrier, negotiates terms, coordinates medical procedures, collects consent, handles funds and manages post-birth steps. These facts matter more than marketing labels.

Obtain the complete draft agreement, all annexes, side letters, cancellation rules, refund terms, governing-law and dispute clauses, privacy provisions and payment instructions before making a commitment. Verify that invoice descriptions match the real work, that the bank-account holder is identified, and that separate services are genuinely separated rather than bundled to disguise the arrangement. Keep copies of invoices, receipts, transfer confirmations and messages. Do not pay cash or to an unexplained third-party account simply because a provider says this is standard.

Have an independent French lawyer review the whole arrangement before signing or transferring an irreversible amount. If the programme is abroad, obtain advice on the destination country’s current law as well; one country’s legal analysis cannot substitute for the other’s. Ask for written advice on the exact actors, activities, money flows, applicable statutes and unresolved facts—not a generic statement that the programme is “legal”.

Red flags and examples: what should make you pause?

Example 1: an agency calls itself a “concierge” and says it only coordinates logistics, but it identifies a carrier, introduces the parties and negotiates the arrangement. The label does not decide the issue; those actual activities need review under article 227-12. Example 2: a clinic issues a separate invoice for a medical procedure. That may be a distinct service, but the invoice alone does not establish that the treatment or its connection to the wider programme is lawful. Example 3: a provider holds money in escrow and promises a full refund if no child is born. Escrow may organise custody of funds, but it does not cure the underlying agreement’s nullity or guarantee the outcome of a restitution claim.

Pause if the provider promises guaranteed parentage, a passport or a birth certificate; claims that a foreign-law clause removes every French risk; offers a “100% safe” or “100% refundable” package; refuses to disclose the contracting entity; gives vague invoices; asks for unexplained cash or payments to a personal account; charges a match-linked fee without explaining the service; or insists that you sign quickly or keep the arrangement secret. None of these facts alone proves a crime or fraud. They are reasons to stop, preserve the records and obtain independent advice before paying more.

Bottom line and review limits

The safest legal starting point is to assume that a surrogacy agreement itself cannot be enforced in France, and that agency intermediation may create separate criminal exposure. Do not try to solve that problem with a different contract title, payment label, escrow account or foreign-law clause. At the same time, analyse genuinely separate medical and professional services on their real facts rather than declaring every connected act automatically unlawful.

The guide reflects the official legislative texts listed below as of 21–22 October 2026. Before acting, French counsel should verify the current statutory text and relevant case law, apply the legal elements to the exact conduct and payment flows, and address any foreign-law, parentage, immigration, tax or consumer issues separately.

Official primary legal sources (French texts)

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards