Germany · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

Germany: surrogacy clinics, agencies, contracts and payments — what is permitted and what is risky

Germany: surrogacy clinics, agencies, contracts and payments — what is permitted and what is risky

Why the description of a service matters

The central question is not whether an invoice says “consulting”, “coordination” or “reimbursement”. It is what the provider actually undertakes, where the activity occurs and whose law applies. German law prohibits defined surrogacy medical acts and surrogacy placement, while independent services do not become illegal solely because intended parents are considering a lawful programme abroad. The reverse is equally important: a foreign address, non-commercial label or separate invoice cannot itself make prohibited German conduct lawful. This is a decision guide for contracts and money flows connected with Germany, not an opinion that a particular clinic, agency or foreign programme is authorised.

Section 1(1) no. 7 of the Embryo Protection Act (ESchG) penalises undertaking artificial insemination or embryo transfer on a woman prepared to give the child permanently to others after birth. Under the statutory definition, undertaking an act includes both an attempt and its completion (Criminal Code, StGB § 11(1) no. 6). Section 1(1) provides imprisonment up to three years or a fine for the offences it lists. Under section 1(3) no. 2, the surrogate and the person intending permanent care are not punished for the specific offence in section 1(1) no. 7. This does not extend automatic immunity to doctors, organisers or unrelated offences. Ordinary medical consultations and tests should be assessed by their actual purpose and activities; do not treat routine care as authorisation to perform the prohibited intervention in Germany.

Clinics and intermediary activity under German law

The Adoption Placement Act (AdVermiG) defines a surrogate by the prior arrangement to undergo artificial or natural insemination or receive or otherwise carry an embryo not originating from her and then leave the child for adoption or permanent care (§ 13a). Under § 13b, surrogacy placement covers bringing intended parents together with a willing woman and even providing evidence of an opportunity to conclude such an arrangement. Section 13c prohibits that placement. Consequently, an agency does not escape this prohibition simply by calling itself a “directory”, “introduction desk” or “non-profit coordination service”. Whether purely informational, administrative or legal work crosses the statutory line requires a review of the precise deliverables, communications and people introduced.

Public declarations seeking or offering surrogates or commissioning parents are prohibited by AdVermiG § 13d; the fine provision in § 14(1), (3) sets a maximum of €5,000 for that category of administrative offence. Placement contrary to § 13c is a criminal offence under § 14b(1), carrying up to one year of imprisonment or a fine. Under § 14b(2), accepting or being promised a financial benefit for placement can mean up to two years or a fine; commercial or businesslike conduct raises the statutory maximum to three years or a fine. These are legal maximums, not automatic penalties. Assess an online post or referral campaign by its actual audience and function rather than assuming all advertising is permitted or every neutral discussion is forbidden.

Advertising, penalties and the position of participants

AdVermiG § 14b(3) expressly does not punish the surrogate or commissioning parents under its placement offences; ESchG § 1(3) no. 2 similarly excludes those identified participants from the particular medical offence. Those limited protections do not validate a prohibited contract, guarantee a refund or immunise every possible act. A physician performing an intervention, a matching agency, a person collecting a placement fee and an intended parent do not occupy interchangeable legal positions. Write the actor and conduct next to every risk in the transaction map. Consent, transparency and a wish to help do not by themselves displace a statutory prohibition.

A signature does not make a prohibited bargain enforceable. Civil Code (BGB) § 134 generally makes a transaction contrary to a statutory prohibition void unless the statute indicates otherwise; § 138 separately concerns transactions contrary to public morals, including specified exploitation. Whether a particular clause or an entire package is invalid depends on the prohibition’s purpose, the actual services and applicable law. Do not automatically declare every stand-alone translation, medical examination or independent legal-advice contract void. Conversely, severing an unlawful matching promise into an annex does not prove the remainder enforceable. Obtain a clause-by-clause opinion before paying an advance.

Under BGB § 139, invalidity of one part may invalidate the entire legal transaction unless it can be assumed that the parties would have concluded it without that part. A severability clause or separate invoice does not automatically settle this question. Before paying, identify precisely which genuine independent services and repayment duties could survive the removal of an unlawful matching promise.

Contracts, parentage and enforceability

No service contract, escrow receipt or “guaranteed parenthood” clause can itself determine German legal parentage. Under BGB § 1591, the mother for the German rule is the woman who gave birth. Foreign court decisions and recognition may raise distinct conflict-of-laws and procedural questions; their possible recognition does not retroactively authorise prohibited matching or treatment in Germany. The intended parents should require a separate legal assessment of any foreign birth and parentage pathway, without making payment contingent on a provider’s unsupported promise that German authorities will issue documents. That wider parentage procedure is outside this contract-and-payment review.

Money must be mapped to a real service, recipient and legal basis. German law does not contain a simple rule that every payment associated with a foreign surrogacy journey is automatically prohibited. But AdVermiG § 14b(2) specifically targets a financial benefit received or promised for surrogacy placement, and calling it “expenses”, a “success fee” or a “donation” does not resolve the issue. Separate properly documented charges for genuine independent advice, certified translations or other lawful work may be defensible on their own facts. They must not disguise an introduction, a clinical intervention prohibited where performed, or payment to secure the surrender of a child.

Payments: classify the service before transferring funds

Use this transaction classification before signing: prohibited acts are not cured by better paperwork, and potentially independent services need proof of their actual scope.

Action / serviceGerman-law risk and decision
Embryo transfer or insemination of a surrogate in Germanystatutory medical prohibition; do not commission it
Agency matching or identifying an available surrogate in Germanyplacement prohibition; do not purchase referrals
Public offers or searches for surrogatesadvertising restriction; stop publication and seek advice
Payment or promised benefit for matchingspecial criminal exposure for the intermediary; do not disguise fees
Independent legal analysis, translation or non-placement logisticspotentially distinct work, not blanket approved; verify provider, contract and locality
Foreign clinic or agency packageGerman and foreign-law questions remain; inspect location of conduct, applicable law and enforceability before paying

A reviewable agreement identifies the actual legal entity, registered address, governing law, forum, each deliverable, the person performing it and whether a clinic is a separate counterparty. A payment schedule should distinguish earned service fees from funds held for third parties, identify currency, bank beneficiary, milestones, documentary evidence, tax treatment where applicable and what happens on cancellation. Demand receipts and a detailed ledger; avoid cash, unexplained personal accounts and irrevocable large advances. Escrow should state who holds money, under which rules it may be released and how disputes are resolved. None of these safeguards can legalise an otherwise prohibited transaction.

Cross-border transactions, disputes and a safe sequence

Cross-border arrangements require at least two distinct checks: conduct connected to Germany and the rules of the foreign place where medical care or matching is actually organised. A foreign law or choice-of-law clause is not a universal safe harbour against German mandatory rules; equally, German criminal jurisdiction cannot be asserted automatically over every act abroad without analysing the facts and applicable territorial rules. Ask where recruitment, introductions, negotiations, advertising, money collection and treatment occurred and who carried each out. Verify directly with the named foreign clinic that it exists and will provide the quoted service. Do not infer legal permission from promotional websites or a mediator’s certificate.

The territorial starting point is StGB § 3 (German criminal law applies to acts committed in Germany). StGB § 9 also addresses where an offence occurs, including acts and statutory results, and contains a specific rule for participation from Germany in an act abroad. Thus where online ads are posted or targeted, and where the intermediary acts, negotiations occur and introductions are made, can matter; neither an offshore invoice nor German residence alone resolves jurisdiction.

If money was already paid, preserve the signed contract, annexes, ads, messages, invoice trail, bank confirmations and a dated chronology. Check first what was promised, which part was actually supplied and whether the legal basis for retention exists. BGB § 812 provides for restitution of benefits received without legal basis in relevant circumstances, but a refund is not automatic; § 817 can restrict recovery where the payer is also responsible for a prohibited purpose, subject to its wording and the facts. Conflict-of-laws issues may change the analysis. Before sending threats or making further instalments, request an itemised accounting and obtain advice on preservation of claims, competent forum and deadlines.

For a refund decision, separate three cases: an independent lawful service actually delivered (a fee may have been earned); a promised service not delivered (contractual remedies may exist); and payment for prohibited placement (invalidity and the § 817 restitution exclusion may both matter). A “non-refundable” label is not conclusive, but neither is illegality a refund guarantee. Record the amount, payee, service, evidence of performance and applicable law for each instalment before asserting a claim.

A practical order is: freeze any unverified advance; identify each contracting party and beneficiary; classify every act as treatment, matching, advertising or independent service; collect evidence of the place and legal authority for each act; verify the clinic and any separate adviser; obtain German and destination-country legal review of the draft and payment route; then sign and pay only for services found lawful and realistically recoverable. If a proposal promises guaranteed custody, birth documents, secrecy from authorities or immunity through a foreign intermediary, treat it as a stop signal. This guide sets out the relevant German statutory provisions; individual facts and later legal amendments require confirmation before action.

Sources / Rechtsquellen

  1. ESchG § 1
  2. AdVermiG § 13a
  3. AdVermiG § 13b
  4. AdVermiG § 13c
  5. AdVermiG § 13d
  6. AdVermiG § 14
  7. AdVermiG § 14b
  8. BGB § 134
  9. BGB § 138
  10. BGB § 1591
  11. BGB § 812
  12. BGB § 817
  13. BGB § 139
  14. StGB § 3
  15. StGB § 9
  16. StGB § 11(1) Nr. 6

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards