Bulgaria · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Indexed case papers and an unmarked envelope prepared for legal review on an office desk

Surrogacy disputes and refusals in Bulgaria: evidence, appeals and remedies

The legal starting point

A refusal in a Bulgarian surrogacy-related matter can mean very different things: a municipality may decline a civil-status entry, a clinic may decline treatment or records, or parties may disagree about money, consent or parentage. The first question is not simply whether to appeal. Identify who made the decision, which legal act governs it, whom it affects and when it was communicated. Each route has different standing, proof and deadlines. This guide concerns remedies; it does not certify any surrogacy arrangement as lawful or enforceable.

Bulgarian Family Code Article 60(1)–(2) establishes maternity through childbirth: the mother is the woman who gave birth, including after assisted reproduction. A genetic link, payment, a private surrogacy agreement or a foreign clinic's promise does not by itself displace that rule in a Bulgarian parentage dispute. In particular, an administrative complaint cannot simply instruct the registrar to substitute an intended mother for the woman who delivered the child. Identify the correct parentage proceedings before requesting changes to the register.

Article 60(3) identifies persons who may bring a court action contesting recorded maternity, while Article 60(5) prevents challenging maternity of the woman who gave birth through assisted reproduction on that ground. Paternal status has separate presumptions and challenge rules under Articles 61–63; consent to assisted reproduction can matter. These provisions are not a general power for every intended parent to sue. A lawyer must test the applicant's standing, status, applicable limitation periods, all required parties and what the evidence can actually establish.

Identify the disputed act and the proper forum

Classify the problem from the document, not the agency's verbal explanation. A dated written refusal to issue a document, a missed statutory response, an adverse medical decision, a disputed invoice and a court judgment are not the same act. Ask whether the decision is final, what was applied for, whether the applicant is legally entitled to seek it, and whether a specialised statute replaces general administrative procedure. Record the actual recipient and the date of service; do not start counting an appeal period from an estimate.

For a potentially challengeable Bulgarian administrative refusal, the Administrative Procedure Code can provide internal review and judicial review. Articles 148–150 govern access to court, deadlines and the form of a court complaint. An interested person normally has to identify the issuing authority and act, grounds of unlawfulness and requested relief. An administrative appeal is not invariably mandatory before court review; check exceptions in special legislation and whether this particular registration dispute is instead for a civil court.

Disputed eventMain questionEvidence / possible route
Written municipal refusalWhat act, claimant and service date?Decision, application receipt; check administrative or specialised civil-status review.
Contested legal parentageWho gave birth and who has standing?Birth record, marital status, judgments; family-law action, not simple editing.
Clinic refusal or missing recordsWhat care, consent and regulatory duty?Consents, dated requests, medical file; evaluate supervisory or civil route.
Payment/contract conflictIs the promised service lawful and enforceable?Agreement, invoices, transfers; assess restitution or damages, not automatic enforcement.

Administrative refusals and deadlines

Article 149(1) of the Administrative Procedure Code generally allows 14 days from notification to challenge an explicit administrative act in court. Under Article 149(2), as amended with effect from 3 September 2025, a tacit refusal or tacit consent can generally be challenged within two months after the authority's decision period expires. These are starting rules, not a universal deadline for parentage actions, clinical disputes or every registry procedure. Confirm the particular act, valid notification, governing special law and available relief immediately.

Article 149(5) of the Administrative Procedure Code makes an application to declare an administrative act null (void) possible without the ordinary appeal time limit. Nullity has a higher and distinct legal threshold; calling an ordinary late appeal “nullity” does not cure delay. This rule concerns administrative acts, not every unanswered request. Have counsel distinguish an allegedly void act from an unlawful but challengeable act before relying on the exception.

If the administration has not answered, prove the complete application and receipt date before arguing that its silence is a tacit refusal. Where internal review was sought, Article 149(3) changes the calculation by reference to the superior body's decision or expiry of its decision period. Procedural issues such as incorrect appeal instructions, missing notice and service may matter, but should be examined against the current code, not assumed to extend time. Do not allow negotiations with an agency or clinic to consume a possible appeal window.

A useful administrative complaint identifies the authority, file number, challenged refusal or inaction, legal interest, chronology and specific requested decision. Attach proof of submission and service, the documents supplied, and the authority's reasons. Request access to the administrative file and retain the complete record. The remedy may be annulment and reconsideration rather than an order to recognise a disputed parent immediately. A court cannot create legal maternity merely because administrative processing was slow or unfair.

When an ordinary judicial administrative appeal is available, Article 152(1) normally requires filing it through the authority that issued the challenged act. Articles 150–151 set out the written complaint and attachments, including a power of attorney if represented, proof of the court fee if due, and copies for other parties. Identify the competent court and preserve dated filing confirmation. Electronic-service requirements changed in July 2026; verify the accepted filing channel for the actual party and procedure.

Parentage disputes are not clerical corrections

Where the disputed birth entry is said to misidentify a parent, first distinguish a typographical or factual error from a dispute over legal origin. Article 60 of the Family Code governs the substantive maternity question. Civil-status registration rules govern preparation and correction of records, but do not erase family-law requirements. An official may be unable to make the requested alteration without the necessary judicial determination. The current civil-registration procedure, authorised applicant and court jurisdiction require verification against the latest consolidated statute.

Civil Registration Act Articles 73–74 distinguish a change to an existing civil-status entry through a judicial or administrative route from the recording of that change on the basis of a court judgment or administrative act. Neither provision independently decides who is the legal mother. For a requested correction, obtain the complete original entry, specify the precise inaccuracy and ask which decision establishing the underlying change is required; a simple clerical mistake and contested origin can require different paths.

Who gave birth, whether she was married, who consented to assisted reproduction, whether paternity is presumed, the child's interests and existing judgments may all change the outcome. Some family-law claims are limited to named persons and statutory time windows. Do not treat the child's genetic testing, a power of attorney or a foreign birth certificate as a substitute for a Bulgarian court's analysis. Conversely, a document's foreign origin does not justify rejecting it without identifying the applicable recognition and procedural rules.

Damages and private claims

If a municipality or other public authority acted unlawfully, Article 1 of the State and Municipalities Liability for Damages Act may permit a damages claim for injury caused by unlawful administrative acts, actions or omissions. Compensation is not automatic: unlawfulness, actual damage, causation, proper defendant and the relevant procedural route need proof. Winning an administrative appeal does not itself establish a monetary award. Keep contemporaneous expenses, correspondence, invoices and records of proven financial or other harm.

Since 3 September 2025, Article 1(2) of the State and Municipalities Liability for Damages Act also addresses financial and non-financial damage from failure to issue a document within the time limit under Administrative Procedure Code Article 174. This is a specific statutory category, not compensation for every delayed answer or disputed birth entry. Establish that the document, legal duty and prescribed period fall within these provisions, and document actual loss before considering a claim.

A dispute with a clinic, agency or intermediary about advance payments, cancellation, promised services or withheld documents is not automatically a public-law appeal. Analyse who signed the agreement, the exact performance promised, what was paid, non-performance, applicable civil law and forum. The Obligations and Contracts Act offers general concepts, but an agreement cannot be assumed enforceable merely because it is written or notarised. First assess whether the disputed service or contractual object conflicts with mandatory law and whether any particular restitution or damages remedy survives.

Clinic decisions and medical oversight

For clinical consent, records or safety concerns, identify the treating institution and the actual service performed. The official 2023 Ordinance H-2 regulates assisted-reproduction medical standards and reporting; the Health Ministry also describes certification for certain medical establishments. Neither document supplies permission for an intended parent to compel gestation by another person. Ask for the informed-consent documents, clinical records and written medical reasons, and have an appropriate Bulgarian health-law specialist assess possible supervisory or patient-rights complaints.

Health Act Article 28b gives the patient access to health information about their own condition, including copies of medical documents, and permits written authorisation of another person to inspect and copy them. An intended parent or agent is not automatically entitled to the woman who gave birth’s private medical file. Address a records request to the provider with the patient’s written authorisation where necessary; if refused, retain the dated request and have a Bulgarian health-law specialist check the proper complaint route.

Check the time period of the procedure and the medical rule then in force. In particular, the former assisted-reproduction Ordinance No. 28 of 2007 was annulled with effect from 30 October 2020; citing it as the operative 2026 framework would misstate the law. A complaint to a medical supervisor may address compliance or documentation but does not determine the child's parentage or make a private arrangement valid. Do not allege a licensing breach without identifying a verifiable licence condition and the correct regulator.

Evidence and urgent protection

Build one indexed evidence folder: dated refusal and proof of service; original application and acceptance receipt; complete municipal or clinical correspondence; identity and marital-status documents; medical consent and childbirth records where lawfully accessible; the birth record; relevant court orders; contracts, payment evidence and disputed representations. Record each item's source, date, custodian and relevance. Prepare Bulgarian translations and authentication only where the receiving authority or court requires them. Protect medical data and the child's identity rather than circulating full records to intermediaries.

For urgency, write a chronology with a separate line for every filing, response and service event. Calculate each possible deadline independently and ask counsel about interim protection if a concrete imminent injury can be shown. Where the child lacks usable documentation or faces a welfare concern, pursue an immediate child-centred legal assessment alongside the underlying claim; do not improvise travel documents or make an unsupported claim of nationality. Reserve a separate analysis for foreign-order recognition, citizenship, passports and cross-border travel.

Two different dispute scenarios

Example A: the municipal office issues a dated written refusal to provide a requested record. First verify the applicant's right, the legal nature of the refusal, service date, special civil-registration rules and whether Article 149 is applicable; preserve the 14-day benchmark pending advice. Example B: an intended mother demands to replace the birth mother on the record based only on a surrogacy contract. Article 60 is a substantive obstacle; a generic administrative appeal cannot replace examination of standing and permissible family-law proceedings.

A defensible next-step sequence

A practical sequence is: (1) obtain the full written decision or prove official silence; (2) identify the person legally entitled to bring each claim; (3) ask Bulgarian counsel to classify the administrative, family, contractual or medical route; (4) calendar statutory deadlines before negotiating; (5) preserve originals and relevant communications; (6) choose precise relief—review, correction, determination of origin, records, restitution or damages—rather than an undefined request to “approve surrogacy”. Do not file contradictory versions of who the legal parents are.

Before filing, obtain a jurisdiction-specific opinion on standing, applicable law at the relevant date, procedural forum, and the child's immediate interests. The official sources below support the stated framework, but they do not prove the legality of any proposed program, the merits of an individual claim or a guaranteed result. The Civil Registration Act copy identified below dates to 2024 and must be checked for subsequent amendments.

Primary sources

  1. Bulgarian Family Code, Articles 60–63
  2. Administrative Procedure Code, Articles 83–84 and 148–152
  3. State and Municipalities Liability for Damages Act, Article 1
  4. Ordinance H-2 of 12 July 2023 on assisted reproduction
  5. Civil Registration Act (ministry copy updated through 8 October 2024)
  6. Ministry of Health: assisted-reproduction compliance service
  7. Obligations and Contracts Act
  8. Medical Supervision Agency: repeal of Ordinance No. 28
  9. Health Act, Article 28b (Ministry PDF, text dated 13 June 2024; later amendments must be checked)

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards