Slovenia · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Editorial photograph of organized legal papers, a redacted document and a laptop on a desk

Slovenia surrogacy disputes: refusals, liability and remedies

This guide is for anyone facing a refusal or dispute connected with a surrogacy arrangement that has a Slovenian connection: an intended parent, a woman who carried a pregnancy, a clinic or agency, or a family dealing with a foreign record. The first task is not to file a generic “appeal.” Identify who made the decision, which legal relationship it affects, and what outcome you need: review of a public decision, a healthcare-rights complaint, a payment or damages claim, or a decision about parentage or registration. Those routes have different rules and deadlines. It does not establish that a surrogacy programme is lawful or that a foreign parentage document will be recognised in Slovenia.

The statutory boundary and legal consequences

The current PISRS consolidated text of Slovenia’s Assisted Reproduction Act (ZZNPOB)—which PISRS labels an unofficial consolidated text—states in Article 7 that a woman is not eligible for medically assisted reproduction if she intends to hand the child to a third person after birth, whether for payment or free of charge; it labels this situation surrogacy. The PISRS page lists the 2024 Constitutional Court decision and the 2025 amendment and gives 18 December 2025 as the date from which the consolidated text is applied. The text still contains Article 7; before relying on that wording in a live case, compare it with the promulgated Act and amendments. Changes to other assisted-reproduction eligibility rules do not, by themselves, establish that Article 7 was repealed. Whether a particular arrangement falls within the provision depends on the facts; a contract, payment, foreign-clinic advertisement or citizenship does not itself create an exception.

Article 43 provides a fine of €2,000 to €20,000 for a legal entity that carries out an assisted-reproduction procedure contrary to Article 7. That provision targets the legal entity in the stated circumstances. Article 44 separately provides a €200–€650 fine for a person participating in the biomedical-expert group who performs an assisted-reproduction procedure contrary to Article 7 in a surrogacy case. These are statutory misdemeanour penalties, not damages awards to intended parents; they do not by themselves decide a child's legal status, the enforceability of every related contract, or liability beyond the persons and conduct specified by law. The Slovenian Constitution guarantees judicial protection and legal remedies for decisions determining rights and legal interests (Articles 23 and 25); Article 26 addresses compensation for damage caused by unlawful conduct in the exercise of public authority. These guarantees do not automatically override the substantive statutory restriction.

Match the remedy to the dispute

Classify the dispute before choosing a remedy. Ask who made the refusal and what it actually decides. Was it a formal decision by a state or local authority, or by a body exercising public powers? Is the issue a patient's rights during healthcare? Is the claim against a private clinic or agency for money, statements or services? Or is the real problem a child's parentage, birth registration, recognition, nationality or travel document? The table is a triage tool, not a guarantee that a claim is admissible or will succeed. Standing, the correct forum, any limitation period and the remedy available must be confirmed against the actual documents and facts.

Dispute typeRelevant route and its limits
Public authority or registryIf you received a formal administrative act affecting your rights or legal interests, follow the remedy stated in its notice and check whether an administrative appeal is available. Once the administrative procedure is final, judicial review may be available under the Administrative Dispute Act (ZUS-1). This route tests legality and procedure; it does not make a prohibited assisted-reproduction procedure permissible. A private clinic's email or booking refusal is not automatically an administrative act.
Clinic or healthcareRequest written reasons, copies of relevant records, the treatment plan and any consent forms. If the issue concerns respect, information, consent, access to records or the quality of care, use the Patient Rights Act procedure. That process addresses patient-rights issues; it cannot substitute for statutory eligibility rules or compel treatment that Article 7 excludes. Keep this route separate from a dispute about an agency's fees or a contract.
Agency, contract or paymentKeep the agreement, invoices, bank-transfer records, refund terms, advertisements, messages and proof of services actually supplied. A civil claim may concern repayment, a separable lawful service, misleading representations or proven loss. A promise to perform a prohibited act may be exposed to nullity, but that does not mean every connected clause is void or that every payment is automatically refundable. The claim must identify the defendant, the legal basis, the sum or other remedy requested, and the evidence supporting it.
Parentage or cross-border documentsTreat who is a legal parent as a separate question from whether a medical procedure was permitted, whether a contract is enforceable, and whether a foreign birth record or court decision will be recognised. Slovenian family law, conflict-of-laws rules and the law of the child's birth or another relevant state may all matter. Citizenship, a passport and permission to travel are further separate questions. Do not infer any of these outcomes solely from a surrogacy agreement, DNA test or foreign certificate.

Deadlines for challenging an administrative refusal

For an administrative refusal, save the complete decision and proof of service immediately. Check the issuing authority, legal basis, factual findings, reasons, operative part, service date and the “instruction on legal remedy.” Under the current General Administrative Procedure Act (ZUP), applicable since 7 February 2026, Article 235 sets a general appeal period of 21 days unless another law provides otherwise. ZUP-I also contains a transitional rule for decisions served before it entered into force where the previous appeal period had not yet expired: an appeal could be filed within 21 days of service. Check the notice in the actual decision and the statute governing that specific matter; a special law may set a different period, and transitional rules may matter. If the administrative appeal route is exhausted or unavailable, an action under ZUS-1 generally must be filed within 30 days after service of the administrative act that ends the procedure. A challenge based on administrative silence has additional statutory preconditions and waiting steps. Do not assume every refusal or delay opens the same court route. The filing should identify the error, explain why you have standing, state the relief requested, and attach the decision and supporting evidence. Obtain Slovenian procedural advice urgently if a deadline is running.

Contract validity, refunds and damages

Civil liability depends on the actual agreement and legal relationship. Under the Obligations Code, an obligation's object must be possible and permissible; a contract may be void if its object is impermissible, including because it conflicts with mandatory rules (Articles 34–37). Because Article 7 expressly excludes the specified assisted-reproduction use, an agreement requiring that prohibited procedure faces a serious nullity risk. The court must still examine the wording, purpose, parties, performance and whether a clause or separable service can stand independently. Article 87 addresses restitution after nullity; where return in kind is impossible or inconsistent with the nature of performance, monetary compensation may be considered. Article 91 permits damages against a party responsible for entering into a void contract only where the other party did not know and was not required to know the cause of nullity. Article 92 says the court considers nullity of its own motion and an interested person may invoke it; Article 93 says the right to invoke nullity does not expire. That last rule does not mean every repayment or damages claim is free of limitation periods: those claims may have their own limitation rules. Article 87 also allows a court, where nullity arises because the contract's content or purpose conflicts with fundamental moral principles, to refuse all or part of restitution to a dishonest party after considering the parties' honesty and the interests at stake. Evidence of what each party knew, represented, paid, received and lost can be decisive.

Patient-rights complaints

A patient-rights route is narrower than a contract or parentage case. The Patient Rights Act applies to patients using healthcare services and provides for a first review before the provider and, where statutory conditions are met, a second review before the national commission. Under Article 59, a first request about allegedly inappropriate conduct or attitude by healthcare staff generally must be made within 15 days of the alleged breach. A request about allegedly improper conduct during healthcare generally must be made within 30 days after the healthcare ends. If the patient learned of the breach later or its consequences appeared later, the Act provides an additional period of three months after the relevant earlier period. Do not wait for contract negotiations to finish before checking this deadline. A patient-rights representative can provide free advice and assistance. Use this process for healthcare rights, not as a claim to override Article 7.

Evidence to preserve

Build a dated evidence file. Preserve: (1) the exact refusal or decision, proof of service and any appeal instructions; (2) the contract, every version and its attachments; (3) invoices, bank records, refunds, escrow terms and payment recipients; (4) the clinic's or agency's advertising, and any licence or registration actually issued, plus statements about what was lawful; (5) emails, complete chat exports and the names and roles of participants; (6) medical records, informed-consent forms and written clinical reasons, requested through the proper channel; (7) for a child already born, the birth record, foreign judgments or orders, certified translations, apostilles or legalisation where required, and travel or nationality correspondence; and (8) a chronology showing who said what, when, and what loss followed. Keep originals and metadata, make secure copies, and avoid altering or publicly posting sensitive medical or child data. Do not obtain another person's confidential records without lawful authority.

If the child has already been born

If a child has already been born, separate the child's immediate needs from adult contract or money claims. Confirm lawful care and representation, birth registration, travel-document requirements and nationality with the competent authorities in the relevant countries; obtain urgent family-law advice if documents are refused or the child cannot travel. Do not assume a court can resolve all these matters in one proceeding or that a successful payment claim will determine parentage. If a foreign judgment or record exists, obtain the complete certified decision, proof of finality where relevant, and a precise list of what the Slovenian authority has refused to register or recognise. Any challenge must respect the child's best interests and privacy. No conclusion on the merits can be drawn without the documents and the laws of every relevant jurisdiction.

Practical next steps

Practical order: (1) record the refusal date and calculate the shortest plausible deadline; (2) obtain the complete written reasons and procedural notice; (3) identify whether the target is an administrative act, a patient-rights issue, a civil payment or damages claim, or a parentage or recognition question; (4) preserve the evidence listed above; (5) ask a Slovenian lawyer to check the current consolidated law and exact procedure before filing; and (6) where more than one country is involved, coordinate advice in each jurisdiction rather than treating a foreign programme as self-executing. Do not assume a refund, damages or recognition is guaranteed before legal review. The strongest next step is a specific, evidence-supported request to the correct body within the correct deadline—not a generic appeal sent to several institutions.

Legal sources

Not legal advice for an individual case.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards