Paraguay · Clinics, agencies, contracts and payments

A dark desk with redacted contract pages, a calculator, laptop and payment checklist
Editorial illustration only. It does not depict a real clinic, contract, person, approval or verified facility.

Paraguay surrogacy contracts, clinics, agencies and payments: what can be relied on?

Introduction

Choosing a clinic or agency in Paraguay for a surrogacy arrangement raises separate questions: may each provider lawfully perform its own services; which promises in a private agreement can be enforced; and what happens to parentage, birth registration and travel documents after birth? These questions must not be collapsed into one package promise. It is a transaction-risk guide, not confirmation that a surrogacy programme is lawful or that any named provider is licensed.

The cautious legal bottom line

Paraguay has no statute in its official primary law that comprehensively authorizes and regulates surrogacy contracts, agency commissions or payments to a gestational carrier. A recent ABC Color report quoting a Paraguayan lawyer likewise describes the absence of a specific framework, but that is secondary evidence, not an official legal determination. A search result cannot prove that no applicable rule or decision exists. Before signing, local counsel should recheck the current official legislation database, Gazette, ministry resolutions and relevant recent case law.

An indexed extract from the MSPBS’s 2025 Manual Nacional de Normas de Atención de Patologías Ginecológicas lists cycles of gestational surrogacy among assisted-reproduction techniques. The manual was approved by Resolution S.G. No. 050 dated 14 February 2025; Article 2 of that resolution directs its implementation and application in all establishments that form part of the National Health System. The resolution gives the manual official administrative significance for clinical practice, but the material does not show that it independently authorises a particular surrogacy programme or determines contract enforceability, payment legality or parentage. Paraguayan counsel should verify the full text and the resolution’s current status.

Until that review is complete, do not describe a clinic or agency as “approved for surrogacy” merely because it is a registered company, has a health-establishment permit or advertises a programme. Paraguayan law provides no general surrogacy-specific approval or safe harbour for any contract or payment model.

What general contract law does—and does not—settle

Paraguay’s Civil Code generally lets parties arrange their rights by contract, but only subject to mandatory law (Law 1183, art. 669). Article 673 identifies consent, an object and any legally prescribed form as essential contract requirements. Articles 299 and 357 of the Code’s provisions on legal acts address nullity where an act or its object is unlawful, legally prohibited, impossible, contrary to morality or good customs, or injures third-party rights. Article 300 says the legal effect is assessed by the act’s real content, not simply the label chosen by the parties.

These general provisions do not, by themselves, prove that every surrogacy agreement is valid or invalid. They do create a serious enforceability question for a term that purports to sell or transfer a child, compel a pregnant person’s medical choices, require an irrevocable surrender of parental status, or override the rights of the child or another person. A private contract should not be treated as a substitute for a clear legal basis. Article 715 requires good-faith performance of contractual conventions, but good faith does not cure an unlawful or invalid term.

Keep separate: (1) whether a clinic may perform a medical procedure; (2) whether an agency may provide and charge for its own services; (3) whether a particular clause is enforceable; and (4) how parentage, civil registration, nationality, exit documents and recognition abroad will be determined. A contract for services does not itself settle the child’s legal status.

Parentage needs particular caution. The official Civil Code provisions located address investigation and proof of filiation (arts. 234 and 242) and challenges to maternity, including allegations of simulated birth, child substitution or that the woman is not the mother of the child treated as hers (art. 240). They do not expressly set out a surrogacy-specific parentage route. An ABC Color report dated 20 October 2026 quotes a specialist saying that, under the Civil Code, the woman who gives birth is the mother, but it does not identify the specific provision supporting that proposition. Treat this as a material risk indicator, not a complete legal opinion: before embryo transfer or payment, obtain current written advice from Paraguayan counsel on the applicable filiation and civil-registration rules.

Map the parties and contracts before paying

Identify who contracts with whom: clinic and patient; agency and intended parent(s); gestational carrier and any other contracting party; and any separate lawyer, donor service, insurer, coordinator or payment custodian. An “all-inclusive” package can conceal who owes each service, who holds the funds and who is responsible if a subcontractor fails. Require each provider’s full legal name, registration or RUC details, address, authorised representative and actual role. Ask which tasks are subcontracted and require written approval before substitution. Do not assume an agency is medically licensed or that a clinic guarantees legal parentage.

Clauses that need specific answers

Have an independent Paraguayan lawyer—chosen by you, not supplied solely by the clinic or agency—review the contract before payment. It should define the scope and exclusions; deliverables and milestones; total price, taxes, currency and payment dates; proof of completed services; and who pays for medicines, tests, complications, birth, neonatal care, insurance, accommodation and travel. Attach every incorporated policy and price list. Oral assurances and marketing messages should not replace signed terms.

Write out cancellation and refund rules for failed embryo transfer, no pregnancy, miscarriage, medical contraindication, multiple pregnancy, delay, provider closure or loss of authorisation, a party’s withdrawal, breach and disputed invoices. State what has actually been earned, what is held for future work, which third-party expenses are evidenced, who decides a disputed release and when an unused balance is returned. Avoid a clause that makes the entire sum automatically non-refundable regardless of services performed or consumer law that applies.

The agreement must not promise a guaranteed pregnancy, live birth, transfer of parentage, birth certificate, citizenship or permission to leave Paraguay. Include informed-consent and confidentiality duties, direct access to treating clinicians, access to medical records, and clear rules on who may use or disclose medical or genetic data. Do not accept terms that force a person to undergo or refuse treatment, block independent medical advice, penalise the exercise of bodily autonomy, or purport to make surrender of parental status irrevocable. Such terms are high risk; ask local counsel to identify their legal basis and limits in writing.

Specify governing law, the competent court or other dispute forum, language, method of serving notices, and how each signer receives the final contract and annexes. If any party cannot read the governing language, arrange a qualified legal translation before signature. Notarisation or an apostille may prove specified formal matters; neither establishes that the agreement’s substance is lawful or every clause enforceable.

How to structure and document payments

Demand an itemised budget that separates clinic fees, medicines and laboratory costs, third-party invoices, agency service fees, the carrier’s documented expenses, insurance, travel and any proposed compensation. The sources do not establish a surrogacy-specific tariff or a rule making every category of payment automatically permissible. Reimbursement, compensation and agency commission may raise different legal questions. Do not label compensation as “expenses” to disguise its nature, and do not assume a label makes a payment lawful.

A payment expressly conditional on surrendering a child or irrevocably relinquishing parental status is especially high risk. Do not make it on an agent’s verbal assurance. Obtain an independent written opinion identifying the legal basis, the recipient’s rights, the possible consequences if the agreement is held invalid, and the treatment of funds already paid. This is a risk warning, not a claim that every reimbursement or payment is necessarily unlawful.

Prefer traceable bank transfers to the named contracting party or direct payment against third-party invoices. Keep dated receipts and records of the payer, beneficiary, currency, exchange rate, purpose, milestone and refund terms. Avoid cash, cryptocurrency, an agent’s personal account, unreceipted transfers and unexplained offshore accounts. A segregated or escrow account may reduce misuse risk only if the custodian, release triggers, insolvency treatment and refund procedure are real and documented; it does not make the underlying arrangement lawful. Do not pay a large advance on a promise that parentage, registration or exit documents are guaranteed.

Verify the clinic and the agency separately

The Health Code (Law 836/1980) places reproductive-health services under the Ministry’s supervision and control (arts. 18–19). Article 24 requires express consent for medical care, subject to the Code’s stated emergency and other statutory exceptions; article 239 assigns the Ministry responsibility for regulating, authorising/registering and controlling health establishments. The Ministry’s published compilation sets out general establishment-habilitation requirements; the specific resolution currently in force prevails. Ask the Ministry to confirm the facility’s current, facility-specific authorisation and verify the registration of each treating professional. Match the documents to the actual premises, legal name and services offered.

A general company registration, social-media profile, foreign certificate or health-facility permit does not by itself prove that surrogacy is specifically authorised or that a surrogacy contract is enforceable. Paraguay has no specific licence category for surrogacy agencies.

Where a transaction qualifies as a supplier–consumer relationship, Law 1334/1998 protects consumers and says their statutory rights cannot be waived. Article 15 requires clear information, as applicable, about the supplier’s name and address, service, quality, price and taxes, payment method, budget/service validity, health or safety risks and other essential facts. Ask for this information in writing, preferably in Spanish. Do not assume every participant automatically has consumer status; the facts and the capacity in which each service is purchased matter.

One important limit is in article 4(d): the Act excludes professional services that require a university degree and a licence from the competent authority from its statutory definition of “services”, although it expressly includes advertising for those services. Whether this exclusion affects a particular clinic, agency or claim requires fact-specific legal review.

Risk-check matrix: evidence to request

Issue to verifyEvidence to request
Provider identity and authorityCurrent company/RUC details; facility-specific MSPBS authorisation; treating professionals’ registration. Verify directly, not only from screenshots.
Agency scope and commissionsSigned scope, itemised fee, subcontractor names, conflict disclosures and the identity of the party responsible for each service.
Payment custody and refundsAccount holder, written release conditions, dated receipts, third-party invoices and clear events that trigger a refund.
Claims that surrogacy is “approved”Exact statute, article, resolution or court decision; official text and date. Marketing, a notarial stamp or another country’s licence is not enough.
Parentage and travel outcomeSeparate written advice on parentage, birth registration, nationality and exit documents in Paraguay and each destination country.
Consent and sensitive recordsDirect clinician access, informed consent, record access, confidentiality, data-use limits and a process for changing or withdrawing consent.

Treat missing documents, inconsistent company names, payment to an unrelated person, unexplained “government fees”, refusal to disclose subcontractors, guaranteed legal outcomes or pressure to sign immediately as stop-and-check signals. They do not automatically prove fraud, but they justify pausing and independently verifying the facts before transferring money.

If a promise fails or a dispute starts

Pause new discretionary payments when a material promise cannot be evidenced, but do not interrupt medically necessary care or interfere with the pregnant person’s medical decisions. Preserve signed and draft agreements, annexes, advertisements, messages, emails, receipts, bank records, invoices, consent forms and a dated timeline. Send a factual written notice identifying the clause, service, amount, evidence and remedy sought; request an itemised account and a response deadline. Avoid threats and public disclosure of private medical information.

For health-establishment authorisation or health-service concerns, contact the Ministry of Public Health and Social Welfare (MSPBS). For a dispute that qualifies as a consumer matter, ask the consumer-protection authority SEDECO about the available complaint procedure. Depending on the facts, a lawyer may assess contractual performance, refund/restitution, adjustment, damages or a challenge to validity. Civil Code article 671 allows a lesion-based claim for nullity or equitable modification within two years under its stated conditions; that is not a universal deadline for every surrogacy dispute. Ask local counsel promptly to classify the claim and calculate the applicable time limit. Suspected fraud, coercion or immediate safety risks may require separate urgent action; the label alone does not establish a criminal offence.

Before making the first transfer: checklist

  • Obtain a written, current Paraguayan legal opinion on the proposed arrangement and the exact contracts—not a generic statement that surrogacy is “legal”.
  • Verify the clinic’s current facility-specific authorisation and each clinician’s professional registration directly with MSPBS.
  • Verify each company’s legal identity, RUC, address, signatory, bank-account holder and actual role; identify all subcontractors.
  • Separate the clinic agreement, agency-services agreement and any agreement involving the gestational carrier; get all annexes and translations.
  • Require itemised fees, milestone-based invoices, receipts, cancellation/refund triggers and an accounting for third-party costs.
  • Confirm that medical consent and treatment decisions remain with the patient and treating clinician; do not accept coercive or irrevocable bodily/parentage clauses.
  • Obtain separate written advice on parentage, civil registration, citizenship and exit documents in Paraguay and the intended destination country.
  • Keep all records and do not pay unexplained cash, personal accounts, unsupported official fees or sums tied to guaranteed legal outcomes.

If a provider will not disclose the legal basis for a central promise, identify the person receiving the money, explain a refund or allow independent review, the safest next step is to pause—not to rely on a marketing claim or a notarised signature.

Sources and legal materials

  1. S1 — Ley Nº 1183 — Código Civil, Libro Segundo: actos jurídicos, objeto ilícito y nulidad. Official Civil Code text: legal acts, unlawful objects and nullity.
  2. S2 — Ley Nº 1183 — Código Civil, Libro Tercero: contratos y obligaciones. Official Civil Code text: general contract rules, consent, good faith and the lesion-based action.
  3. S3 — Ley Nº 1334/1998 — Defensa del Consumidor y del Usuario. Official Consumer Protection and User Defence Act.
  4. S4 — Ley Nº 836/1980 — Código Sanitario. Official Health Code text.
  5. S5 — MSPBS — Compilación práctica de requisitos para habilitación de establecimientos de salud. Official Ministry compilation of general health-establishment authorisation requirements; confirm the current applicable resolution.
  6. S6 — ABC Color — reportaje sobre la ausencia de un marco específico para la gestación subrogada en Paraguay (fuente secundaria). Secondary news report quoting a Paraguayan lawyer about the lack of a specific surrogacy framework. Publication-date display is inconsistent (20/22 October 2026); contextual evidence only.
  7. S7 — Ley Nº 1183 — Código Civil (texto completo; filiación y maternidad, arts. 234, 240 y 242). Official full Civil Code text; arts. 234, 240 and 242 address filiation investigation/proof and challenges to maternity, but do not expressly set out a surrogacy-specific parentage route.
  8. S8 — MSPBS — Manual Nacional de Normas de Atención de Patologías Ginecológicas (2025). Official 2025 clinical manual; the indexed extract lists gestational-surrogacy cycles among assisted-reproduction techniques. Clinical guidance is not standalone legal authorisation.
  9. S9 — MSPBS — “Salud presenta Manual Nacional de Normas de Atención de Patologías Ginecológicas” (4 July 2025). Official MSPBS release on the manual’s launch and its intended use by health professionals.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards