Portugal · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Organized case papers, a redacted-style document, a notebook and a portfolio on a neutral office desk
Editorial illustration only; it is not evidence of a real authority, facility, approval or person.

Portugal surrogacy disputes: refusals, liability and remedies

A refusal connected with surrogacy in Portugal is not automatically an appealable surrogacy decision. First identify who refused what, whether the refusal is a formal administrative act, and whether the underlying authorisation procedure is actually operating. Those facts determine the forum, evidence and deadline.

As of 21 October 2026, the National Council for Medically Assisted Procreation (CNPMA) still says that Law 90/2021 entered into force on 1 January 2022 but awaits government regulation. The safe conclusion is narrow: the statute exists, but the regulator’s own page does not confirm an operational route for new approvals. Do not rely on a clinic’s promise, a draft regulation or a press release announcing cabinet approval as proof that a programme can presently be authorised.

What the legal status means in practice

Law 90/2021 amended Law 32/2006 on medically assisted procreation. It took effect on 1 January 2022 and sets out a statutory model for exceptional, gratuitous gestational surrogacy, prior CNPMA authorisation and the rights of the people involved. The CNPMA’s current public guidance nevertheless says that the 2021 law awaits implementing regulation. In November 2023, the government announced that the Council of Ministers had approved a decree-law intended to regulate surrogacy; the announcement itself does not establish that the measure was published and entered into force.

An older Constitutional Court ruling, Judgment 225/2018, invalidated parts of the earlier 2016 framework, including the provisions that made surrogacy subject to prior authorisation and the restriction that prevented the gestational carrier from revoking consent until the child was delivered. It is important historical context, not a substitute for reading the later 2021 amendments. A dispute must be assessed against the exact act, contract, dates and facts rather than an assumption that the earlier process simply resumed.

The statutory model is narrow, and it is not a blanket guarantee

Article 8 of Law 32/2006, as amended by Law 90/2021, describes surrogacy as exceptional and gratuitous. It identifies the absence of a uterus, an injury or disease of the uterus, or another clinical situation that absolutely and definitively prevents the woman from carrying a pregnancy. At least one intended beneficiary’s gametes must be used; the gestational carrier cannot provide the ovum used in that procedure. The carrier should preferably already have been a mother, although the law allows the circumstances of a particular case to be considered.

The law also says it applies to Portuguese citizens and foreign nationals permanently resident in Portugal. It requires prior CNPMA authorisation, following consultation with the medical and psychologists’ professional orders, and a written agreement containing specified safeguards. These are statutory conditions, not evidence that an application channel is currently available. A visitor or non-resident should not assume eligibility from the fact that a clinic accepts foreign patients.

The statute says a child born through a compliant surrogacy arrangement is regarded as the child of the beneficiaries, but that wording must not be treated as an automatic solution for an unapproved arrangement, a disputed consent, a foreign programme or a contested civil-register entry. Parentage, registration, nationality and permission to travel are separate questions.

Match the dispute to the document and the decision-maker

Use the table to choose an initial route, not to assume that every route is open in a surrogacy case. The current regulatory gap makes written confirmation of the competent body and available procedure especially important.

Dispute pattern Evidence to secure first Initial response to consider
CNPMA or another authority refuses an application or gives no clear answer The complete written decision, date and proof of service, application file, missing-document notices and legal reasons Ask for the legal basis, whether the act is final and which remedies and deadlines are stated; have a Portuguese administrative lawyer assess review or court proceedings promptly.
Clinic refuses treatment or says it can proceed without public authorisation Clinic’s written position, licence/authorisation details, medical record, consent forms and all versions of the proposed agreement Separate a clinical decision from a claim about legal permission. Verify the clinic and procedure with the relevant authority before paying or starting treatment.
Intermediary retains money, promises approval or demands a fee Signed terms, invoices, bank records, advertisements, chats, emails and a dated timeline of promises Preserve evidence and obtain advice on possible civil, consumer and, where facts support it, criminal routes. Do not make further payments merely to “unlock” an approval.
The gestational carrier changes her position or withdraws consent All signed consent records, the agreement, medical correspondence, date of the birth and any registration step Do not pressure the carrier or attempt self-help. Obtain urgent independent Portuguese advice; the statute addresses revocation of consent up to registration of the child.
The parties disagree about parentage or a register entry Birth and medical records, identity documents, consent and authorisation records, any registry decision and proof of notice Treat parentage and registration as a distinct issue. Do not assume a contract, genetic link or foreign birth certificate resolves Portuguese status or another country’s recognition.

If the authority refuses or does not decide

Start by obtaining the complete signed decision, its legal basis, the identity of the decision-maker, the date and method of notification, the administrative file and any instructions about review. Keep the original envelope or electronic notification and proof of when it was received. A phone call, clinic email or informal statement may not be the appealable administrative act, although it can still be relevant evidence.

For a formal administrative act, Portuguese general administrative procedure rules may allow a complaint to the author of the act. Under Article 191 of the Administrative Procedure Code (CPA), the default period is 15 days unless a different rule applies; Article 192 generally gives the competent body 30 days to decide. These are general rules, not a surrogacy-specific appeal timetable, and they do not prove that a CNPMA authorisation procedure is currently open. The legal character of the act, applicable special rules and notification date must be checked for the individual case.

Silence or failure to perform a legally required act is different from a formal refusal. Article 187 CPA provides a one-year period for administrative complaints and appeals against unlawful omissions. Under CPTA Articles 66–69, an administrative action may seek an order requiring the competent body to perform a legally due act; for administrative inaction, Article 69 generally sets a one-year period from expiry of the legal deadline to issue the act. For a formal refusal, a private claimant generally has three months to challenge an annulable act under Article 58; null acts are not subject to a time limit under the general rule. Article 58(3) also allows limited exceptions: a justified impediment under the applicable procedural rules; certain administration-induced errors where timely filing could not reasonably be expected (with a separate three-month period running from when the error ceases); and an excusable delay caused by ambiguity in the legal framework or difficulty identifying or classifying the challengeable act, provided no more than one year has elapsed since the act or its required publication. These are narrow, fact-sensitive exceptions, not automatic extensions; Portuguese counsel should assess them promptly. Article 59 governs when the judicial period starts and provides that administrative review generally suspends it, without preventing a court claim while the review is pending. The classification, standing, notification date and any special rules are case-specific; do not calculate a deadline or assume a complaint is mandatory without Portuguese administrative-law advice.

Consent and the carrier’s independent rights

Law 90/2021 provides that the gestational carrier’s consent can be revoked, at her will, until the child’s birth is registered. It also protects the carrier’s fundamental, health, social and employment rights and states that the agreement cannot impose terms that infringe the rights specified in Article 13-A. A clause purporting to erase those rights should not be treated as enforceable simply because it was signed.

If consent is disputed, preserve the exact versions of every consent form and agreement, messages about the decision, medical records and the timing of any birth-registration step. Do not rely on an unsigned summary, a translated clause without the original, or a promise that the carrier “cannot change her mind.” The current lack of implementing regulation makes it especially important to obtain case-specific advice about the legal effect and practical handling of the statutory text. If a pregnancy or child is already involved, seek urgent independent advice and prioritise safety and the child’s interests.

Contracts, clinics, agencies and money

The statutory model requires a written agreement supervised by the CNPMA and is gratuitous. It allows only the value of actual health-care expenses, including transport, as described by the law; it is not a licence for a fee, reward or disguised payment for carrying the child. Article 39 of Law 32/2006, as amended, creates criminal exposure for specified non-compliant arrangements and promotion of them; obtaining economic benefit from an arrangement or its promotion can carry a penalty of up to five years’ imprisonment. Whether a particular act satisfies an offence depends on its facts and the exact statutory elements.

If a clinic or intermediary has taken money, separate the questions: what service was actually supplied, what did the written terms promise, what was paid and to whom, and did the payment relate to lawful documented medical expenses or to the surrogacy itself? Preserve invoices and payment evidence. Do not assume that a civil claim to recover money would validate an otherwise prohibited arrangement, or that an invalid or unenforceable term automatically resolves every restitution or damages issue. A Portuguese lawyer should assess civil, consumer and criminal dimensions separately.

Build an evidence file before choosing a remedy

Create one chronological file and keep originals unchanged. Separate facts you can prove from what another person told you. Record who made each decision, when you learned of it and what you did next. Keep a copy of the file in a secure location and restrict access to sensitive medical and identity data.

  • Every application, refusal, request for information, decision and notification, including the envelope or electronic delivery record.
  • All contract drafts and signed versions, consent forms, amendments, termination notices and correspondence about consent.
  • Medical reports needed to explain the relevant clinical condition, with the patient’s lawful authority and appropriate confidentiality protections.
  • Invoices, receipts, bank transfers, refund terms, advertising, intermediary promises and communications showing who received each payment.
  • Birth, identity and civil-registration documents if a child has been born, plus the exact registry decision and date of service.
  • A dated event log and a short list of the result sought: reconsideration, access to the file, return of money, correction of an act, protection of rights or urgent interim relief.

A safe sequence for the next 48 hours

First, identify the actor: CNPMA or another public body, clinic, intermediary, the carrier, civil registry or a foreign authority. Second, ask for the decision and reasons in writing and obtain the complete file. Third, write down the date of notification and have counsel calculate every possible administrative and court deadline. Fourth, check the CNPMA’s current published position directly and request written confirmation of whether any legal procedure is available for the facts in question.

Fifth, preserve documents and payments; do not alter messages, create backdated paperwork, conceal the arrangement or pay a new “approval fee.” Sixth, ask counsel to separate the remedy sought from any criminal, contractual, parentage or cross-border issue. If there is a pregnancy, a newborn, a threatened deadline or risk to someone’s health or safety, say so at the outset and seek urgent assistance rather than waiting for ordinary correspondence.

In a complaint or application, state the decision challenged, the date received, the facts in chronological order, the specific legal error alleged, the evidence attached and the concrete remedy requested. Ask for written acknowledgement. Avoid publishing names, medical data or the child’s information online; use secure channels and redact unnecessary personal data in copies.

What this guide does not establish

This guide does not establish that a new surrogacy programme can currently be approved in Portugal, that a particular contract is valid, that intended parents automatically acquire parentage, or that a foreign judgment or birth certificate will be recognised. It does not decide whether a particular refusal is lawful or which party has standing. Those conclusions require the actual file, the relevant dates and the current official procedure.

Official sources

The following official materials support the legal points above. The CNPMA page is especially important because it states the regulator’s current public position on implementation.

  1. Law No. 90/2021 of 16 December, amending the assisted-procreation framework
  2. CNPMA: Gestação de substituição (current public information)
  3. Constitutional Court, Judgment 225/2018 (historical framework)
  4. Administrative Procedure Code, Articles 187 and 191–192
  5. Code of Procedure in Administrative Courts, Article 58
  6. Code of Procedure in Administrative Courts, Article 59
  7. Council of Ministers communication, 16 November 2023 (decree-law approval)
  8. Consolidated Law No. 32/2006, Article 39 (criminal provisions)
  9. Code of Procedure in Administrative Courts, Articles 66–69 (action to require a legally due act)

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards