Georgia · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Redacted administrative papers, indexed case folders and a checklist arranged for legal review

Georgia surrogacy disputes: refusals, liability and remedies

Start with the decision that is actually disputed

A surrogacy dispute in Georgia is not one single type of case. A refusal to enter intended parents in a birth record is an administrative-law problem; a disagreement about fees or a failed service may be contractual; injury or lack of informed consent may raise medical-liability issues; and a disagreement over parentage may require a different claim from a challenge to the registry’s paperwork decision. Identify the act, omission or promise that caused the problem before choosing a remedy. The result also depends on who is bringing the claim, which document exists, when the relevant events occurred, and whether the matter is governed by Georgian law or by a second country’s law.

The statutory starting point is limited, not universal

Article 143 of Georgia’s Law on Health Care addresses in-vitro fertilisation in specified circumstances. Its surrogacy clause describes transfer of an embryo to another woman where a woman does not have a uterus and makes the couple’s written consent obligatory. Article 143(2) says that, if a child is born within the provision’s scope, the couple is deemed to be the parents and the donor or surrogate is not entitled to be recognised as a parent. Read the conditions in the actual statute; do not turn that wording into a promise that every intended parent, family form or treatment pathway automatically qualifies. The civil-registration procedure adds documentary requirements. The current Georgian-language text of Order No. 18 of the Minister of Justice, especially Article 19, is important alongside Article 143. Because the current consolidated Order No.

Check the registration documents before arguing about the outcome

Article 19 of the Civil Registration Procedure approved by Order No. 18 requires, in addition to the documents required generally, evidence from the medical institution confirming extracorporeal fertilisation, issued at embryo implantation, and a notarised agreement made before the fertilisation. The rule lists possible agreement structures involving the woman giving birth, genetic parent or parents, an intended parent who is not genetic, and/or donor or donors. The correct structure depends on the actual participants and the applicable version of the rule; do not assume a template agreement covers every configuration. The same provision states that the donor and the surrogate mother must not be entered as the child’s parents in the birth record. If the required agreement is not submitted, Article 19(4) provides for registration without the parents’ details, with the child’s name and surname entered on the basis of a guardianship and custody authority’s statement. That is a specific registration consequence, not proof that no birth can be registered at all. Separately check whether the agreement was properly notarised and signed before the relevant treatment step. These details come from the accessible original version of Order No. 18, not a verified current consolidation. Confirm them against the current Georgian text and amendments applicable on the relevant dates before treating them as current requirements.

The seven-day registration rule can make the timeline urgent

Under Article 16(2) of Order No. 18, where the medical birth certificate identifies a child as born through extracorporeal fertilisation, the registration authority is to register the birth once the Article 19 documents are submitted, but no later than seven calendar days after the medical certificate is presented. If the required documents are not presented within that period, registration proceeds under the general procedure. This does not mean that every later correction or parentage claim is automatically barred after seven days; it means that the initial special registration path may change. A child’s registration, the names entered as parents, the issue of a travel document, nationality, and recognition abroad are separate legal questions. Article 49¹ of the Law on the Legal Status of Aliens and Stateless Persons says that a child born in Georgia through surrogacy may leave Georgia only if both parents’ details appear in the birth record. Do not assume that a birth certificate alone resolves nationality, passport eligibility or entry into the parents’ destination country. The seven-day timing described here comes from the accessible original version of Order No. 18, not a verified current consolidation. Confirm the current Georgian text and amendments applicable on the relevant dates before treating it as the governing deadline.

What counts as an actionable administrative refusal?

An administrative dispute usually becomes clearer once the competent civil-status authority has issued a written individual act refusing registration, refusing to record parent details, declining to correct a record, or refusing to provide a document. Ask for the full decision, its legal grounds, the factual reasons, the date it was made available and the appeal instructions. An oral explanation at a counter may be useful evidence of what happened, but it is a poor substitute for a formal decision when a statutory appeal deadline may run. Article 177 of the General Administrative Code allows an interested party to appeal an administrative act and treats an authority’s failure to issue an act within the prescribed timeframe as a refusal to issue it. An unlawful action or omission not tied to issuing an act may also be challengeable. Standing is not automatic: the applicant should explain how the decision directly affects their own legally protected right or interest, and a child’s interests may require separate representation if the adults’ positions conflict.

An administrative complaint needs a clear claim and a calendar check

Articles 180–181 of the General Administrative Code generally set a one-month period for an administrative complaint from publication of, or official familiarity with, the act. A complaint about an authority’s action is generally due within one month after the interested person became aware of it. The Code provides that no appeal period is determined where the authority has failed to observe the deadline for issuing an administrative act, and that a missed period may be restored for force majeure or another good reason. These provisions must be applied to the specific type of decision and the facts; do not assume that an informal request restarts time. The written complaint should identify the receiving authority, the applicant and address, the authority and act being challenged, the precise remedy requested, the supporting circumstances, and the attached documents. Attach the challenged act if it was sent to the applicant. The usual review period is one month unless a special rule applies; an extension is possible only under the Code’s conditions. For an administrative court claim, check whether a statutory exception to the general prior-complaint requirement applies, and keep proof of filing and receipt.

The official English consolidated text currently available on Matsne was checked. Georgian is the authoritative language, and a special law or the type of decision may alter the route or calculation; verify the applicable Georgian wording before relying on a deadline.

The court route and the requested remedy must match the problem

The Administrative Procedure Code provides claims to annul or declare invalid an administrative act and claims seeking issuance of an administrative act. Article 2(5) sets a general precondition: unless another law provides otherwise, a court will not admit an administrative claim against an authority unless the claimant has first used the one-off administrative complaint procedure under the General Administrative Code. Confirm whether a statutory exception applies and that the complaint was filed with the correct body. Article 22(3) generally gives one month to challenge an individual administrative act, the decision on an administrative complaint, or expiry of the period for deciding that complaint, unless another law provides otherwise. Article 23(3) generally gives one month from refusal to issue an administrative act for a claim seeking its issuance. The official English consolidated text currently available on Matsne states these general rules; before filing, verify the Georgian text applicable on the relevant dates, the exact trigger and any special procedure.

The current Code also provides a special route for certain decisions of the Public Service Development Agency made under the Law on the Legal Status of Aliens and Stateless Persons: Articles 21¹³⁵–21¹³⁶ allow a claim to be filed directly with Tbilisi City Court within 10 calendar days after service of the relevant individual act. This route does not automatically cover every civil-registration refusal. Identify the legal basis of the actual decision and confirm applicability in the Georgian text before choosing the procedure.

A claim may seek annulment of a refusal, a declaration that an action or omission was unlawful, or an order requiring the authority to issue an act or reconsider the application. The court’s power and appropriate relief depend on the statutory scheme and established facts. If issuing the act requires no further fact-finding and the matter is not within the authority’s discretion, the Code allows the court to resolve the issue directly; otherwise, the court may require lawful reconsideration. A successful challenge therefore does not necessarily mean the judge will directly order the exact parentage entry requested. Article 29 generally suspends a challenged individual administrative act when a court claim is filed, subject to statutory exceptions. That suspension may not resolve every practical consequence, such as the child’s travel-document problem; discuss urgent interim protection and the correct form of claim with Georgian counsel.

Contract and agency disputes require a separate liability analysis

A disagreement with a clinic, agency, coordinator, surrogate or intended parent is not automatically an administrative case. Start with the signed contract and identify each actual party, the promises made, the payment recipient, the event said to constitute breach, any notice or cure clause, termination terms, refund formula, dispute-resolution clause and governing-law provision. Advertising, chat messages, invoices and bank transfers can help explain what was promised, but they do not necessarily amend a notarised agreement or establish that every promised outcome was legally possible. Under Article 394 of the Civil Code, damages may be claimed for breach of an obligation where the obligor is responsible for the breach. The Civil Code also addresses restoration and monetary compensation. The available remedy may be performance, termination, restitution, repayment or damages, depending on the agreement, the nature of the breach and applicable law. Do not promise a full refund or the enforcement of a clause without analysing causation, fault, proof of loss, the contract’s validity and any mandatory rules. A contract may meet a registry-document requirement yet still raise separate questions about its private-law enforceability.

Medical harm and patient autonomy are not just contract questions

If the dispute concerns treatment, injury, disclosure, records or informed consent, analyse the rights of the person who received medical care. Article 10 of Georgia’s Law on Patient Rights permits patients or their legal representatives to apply to court for compensation for property and non-property damage arising from violation of patient rights, medical malpractice, other malfunctions of a medical institution, or improperly conducted state supervision. Civil Code Articles 992 and 1007 may also be relevant to tort liability and harm caused during treatment. Liability still requires proof under the applicable legal test; the existence of a bad outcome alone does not establish negligence. The surrogate is a patient in relation to her own treatment and pregnancy care. Georgia’s Law on Health Care recognises a patient’s right to refuse medical intervention, subject to legal exceptions, and written informed consent is required for extracorporeal fertilisation. A contract should not be treated as permission to force a competent person to undergo a medical procedure or to ignore a patient’s rights. Keep medical-malpractice claims separate from disagreements over payments, and obtain the complete medical record and an independent expert assessment where appropriate.

Build the evidence file around each legal element

Each party generally must prove the facts on which its claim or defence relies. Articles 102–103 of the Civil Procedure Code identify evidence such as party explanations, witness testimony, written or material evidence and expert findings. A party that cannot obtain relevant material may ask the court to request it; evidence obtained unlawfully has no legal force. This makes early, lawful preservation important, particularly where a clinic or agency controls the records. Create a dated chronology and keep originals or certified copies of the notarised agreement and amendments, identity and civil-status documents, clinic records, embryo-transfer confirmation, birth medical certificate, registration application, missing-document requests, written refusal and proof of delivery. Preserve emails, messaging exports, invoices, payment records, refund calculations, consent forms and the exact versions of documents submitted. For a medical claim, record the alleged departure from professional standards, the injury, the causal link and the losses. For an administrative claim, connect every disputed factual finding to the specific document that disproves or qualifies it.

Deadlines differ by claim type; do not use one clock for everything

For ordinary contractual claims, Article 129 of the Civil Code generally provides a three-year limitation period, and Article 130 links commencement to when the claimant knew or ought to have known that the right was infringed. Article 1008 provides a three-year period for tort-damages claims from the time the injured person becomes aware of the damage or the person liable. Special rules may apply to particular claims, and the legal characterisation of a claim can change the calculation. A one-month administrative deadline should not be confused with a civil limitation period. Record the earliest date of the refusal, notice, injury, discovery of the responsible person, contractual breach and each formal reply. Ask Georgian counsel to calculate each possible deadline separately, including whether the period can be restored, whether a special procedure applies, and whether a complaint or negotiation changes the calculation. Do not delay filing simply because the parties are discussing settlement or because an agency has promised to respond. A criminal complaint, where there are concrete grounds to suspect fraud, coercion or document falsification, does not replace civil or administrative filings and should not be used as a substitute for proof.

A practical sequence for the first days of a dispute

First, secure the child’s immediate documentation and care needs without making assumptions about nationality or travel rights. Second, request the complete written decision or a formal response identifying the legal basis and missing items. Third, compare the submitted file with Article 19 of Order No. 18 and the version in force on the relevant dates; ask the authority to identify the exact deficiency rather than accepting a vague statement that “the papers are not correct.” Fourth, calculate administrative and court deadlines from documented service or knowledge dates, and obtain Georgian legal advice before choosing the forum. Fifth, preserve the contract and medical evidence, send any contract notice in the required form, and quantify the loss claimed. Sixth, separate the remedies: registry correction or a new administrative act; contractual repayment or damages; medical compensation; and any cross-border parentage or travel process. A Georgian registration result does not itself guarantee that another state will recognise parentage or issue a passport. We have not found a verified Georgian reported judgment on the particular dispute patterns described; confirm the current Order No. 18 against its Georgian text. Before relying on the general one-month period, also check whether the special direct-to-Tbilisi-City-Court route in Articles 21¹³⁵–21¹³⁶ applies; it may carry a 10-calendar-day deadline.

Primary legal sources and source limitations

Source-access caveat: the page for Order No. 18 exposes its original version, not a confirmed current consolidated text; Articles 16 and 19 and amendments applicable on the event dates need Georgian-lawyer verification. The official English consolidated texts of the General Administrative Code (latest English publication listed: 17 December 2025) and Administrative Procedure Code (publication dated 16 September 2026) were checked; the authoritative Georgian wording and any special rule applicable to the particular decision still require confirmation. No verified Georgian judgment on the dispute patterns described is relied upon.

From our lawyers' practice

The Georgian registration appeal was separate from the agency claim

Parents were refused registration of their child in Georgia. An intermediary suggested waiting while he “sorted it out”, and the family did not clearly understand the reason for refusal.

Our lawyer obtained the complete written refusal, proof of its service date and a copy of the original submission. Comparing them showed which attachments the authority had been missing. The family had a separate complaint against the agency for losing some papers, but that did not replace an appeal against the state decision. The appeal was filed separately and within the period calculated from service, while a claim for expenses was sent to the agency. By the end of this stage, the family was still awaiting the registration decision and had no certificate, but was no longer losing time waiting for the intermediary.

Details have been changed to protect the client's confidentiality.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards