Oman · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Illustrative desk with indexed legal files and a redacted refusal letter.

Oman: Surrogacy Disputes, Refusals, Liability and Remedies

Not advice for an individual case.

Start with the act being challenged

A surrogacy dispute in Oman may involve a public-authority refusal, clinic decision, agency payment demand, possible medical negligence, privacy breach or dispute over a child’s civil status. Each involves different parties, evidence and procedure. Identify the exact act, actor, date and lawful outcome sought.

Do not assume a surrogacy agreement can be enforced. Omani medical law restricts assisted reproduction, and contract remedies require their own legal basis. A complaint may still preserve records, investigate misconduct, challenge a public decision or pursue a supportable financial claim.

The central statutory restriction

Article 29 of Royal Decree 75/2019, the Law Governing the Practice of the Medical Profession and Allied Health Professions, permits assisted-reproduction techniques by medical professionals only between spouses, with written consent from both and while the marriage remains valid under Sharia, subject to conditions and controls issued by the Minister. Although it is not a detailed surrogacy code, this wording is difficult to reconcile with a third-party gestational carrier. Clinic advertising, a private contract, payment or an earlier oral assurance does not prove the arrangement is lawful.

The restriction concerns the reproductive technique itself. It does not decide separate questions of parentage, birth registration, nationality, travel documents, civil liability or recognition of a foreign judgment. Each requires its own legal and factual analysis; a refusal about a child’s records should not be confused with whether a clinic may perform a procedure.

Article 59 provides imprisonment of one to five years and a fine of OMR 3,000–10,000, or either, for violations of Article 29. This is a statutory sanction, not a finding of guilt in a particular case; the facts, actor, evidence and competent authorities’ decisions matter.

Why a private agreement may not secure performance

The Civil Transactions Law, Royal Decree 29/2013, requires a contract’s object to be legally effective and not prohibited by law or Sharia (Article 116). Article 121 addresses a cause contrary to Sharia, public order or public morals; Articles 125–126 address nullity and its effects. If an agreement requires a medical act inconsistent with Article 29, a court may not enforce that performance. The outcome depends on the terms, purpose, services already supplied, parties and relief sought.

Article 171 permits a party to a valid bilateral contract, after putting the defaulting party in default as required, to seek performance or rescission; compensation may be awarded where justified. Article 173 addresses restoration of the parties to their former position after rescission and compensation where restoration is impossible. These provisions should not be presented as a guarantee that a surrogacy agreement is valid or that all payments will be returned. A claim for repayment, damages or unjust enrichment must be assessed against the possible nullity of the arrangement, the legal basis for each payment, the evidence and any applicable limitations.

Do not automatically ask a court to compel embryo transfer, pregnancy-related conduct, delivery of a child or another act that conflicts with the statutory restriction. Ask Omani counsel to separate any potentially lawful financial, information, safety or procedural claim from a request for prohibited performance.

Identify the correct route before filing

Choose the route by who made the decision; confirm jurisdiction, standing and current procedure.

  • Public authority: obtain the written decision or proof of the request and receipt; check Administrative Court jurisdiction and any required prior grievance.
  • Private clinic or agency: request the contract, itemised payments, records, explanation and evidence preservation in writing. A private dispute is not automatically administrative.
  • Possible medical error or injury: obtain the clinical file and independent assessment; check the special medical-error process and civil compensation route.
  • Possible fraud, coercion, falsification or threats: preserve original messages and payment records; discuss a report to the Royal Oman Police or Public Prosecution with counsel. Do not exaggerate or publicly accuse anyone.
  • Health or genetic data disclosure: preserve evidence, limit further circulation and assess a complaint under the current Personal Data Protection Law.

Challenging a public authority refusal: deadlines matter

The Administrative Court Law (Royal Decree 91/99, as amended) gives the Administrative Court jurisdiction over specified administrative disputes. Article 6(2) covers review of final administrative decisions, and Article 6 treats an authority's refusal or failure to decide, when a decision is legally required, as such a decision. Article 8 instead sets the grounds for judicial review, including lack of jurisdiction, defects of form or reason, illegality, error in applying or interpreting law, and misuse of power. The claimant needs a personal interest. Article 7 excludes certain matters, notably nationality cases; neither a private clinic's refusal nor every dispute about a child is automatically reviewable in this court. Identify the specific public decision and statutory exclusion before choosing this route.

For final administrative decisions covered by Article 6(2), Article 9 generally requires a grievance to the issuing authority or its superior first. It must be submitted within 60 days of notification or definite knowledge of the decision. The authority has 30 days to decide; silence is treated as rejection. A court claim must then be filed within 60 days after notification of the grievance outcome or expiry of the response period. Other categories have different requirements. Counsel should confirm that the route applies, calculate the deadline under the applicable time-counting rules and identify the proper respondent.

File it in a traceable way: identify the decision, dates, alleged legal error and requested result, and keep proof of receipt. Article 5 of the Civil Transactions Law states that periods are calculated by the lunar calendar unless a law provides otherwise; counsel should confirm its application to this procedural deadline. Do not assume informal complaints or negotiations suspend a statutory deadline.

Medical error, injury and professional discipline

Articles 42–47 of Royal Decree 75/2019 address responsibility for medical error. A medical professional is responsible for a medical error that causes harm to a patient, but Article 43 sets out circumstances in which liability does not arise, including appropriate care and use of available means, conduct consistent with scientific and technical standards, harm attributable to the patient or an external cause, medical complications, and action taken to avert a more serious imminent harm. An adverse outcome alone therefore does not prove negligence.

Article 44 addresses compensation for established errors causing death, permanent or partial disability, wounds or injuries under applicable compensation rules; moral-damage compensation may also be available where justified. Article 47 assigns the Supreme Medical Committee to determine error in cases referred by the Public Prosecution, competent court or Minister. Under Article 39, investigation, arrest or pre-trial detention for a medical-error complaint require a Public Prosecution order after it receives the committee’s final report confirming error. This specialist route is distinct from an agency billing dispute or contract claim.

If physical injury occurred, prioritise care. Preserve treatment notes, test results, consent forms, medication records, appointment messages and receipts. Request the full clinical file in writing and seek an independent view on the alleged departure from accepted practice and causation. A complaint or disciplinary process does not itself guarantee compensation.

Health records and confidentiality

Oman’s Personal Data Protection Law (Royal Decree 6/2022, amended by Royal Decree 68/2026) protects health data and governs processing, confidentiality and complaints. Article 5 generally requires Ministry authorisation to process health or genetic data under implementing rules; statutory exceptions and consent rules apply. Article 15 requires erasure when the processing purpose ends, except where a dispute is pending or a legal obligation requires retention. Use the current consolidated text, not the original 2022 version.

Separately, Article 33 of the medical-professions law bars medical professionals from disclosing patient secrets learned through practice without written consent. Exceptions cover disclosure to competent authorities to prevent or detect crime; specified public-health and hereditary-disease situations; personal notification to a spouse in that spouse’s interest; official expert or witness duties; insurer or minister-authorised examinations within their purpose; and disclosure needed for the physician’s defence. The exact exception must fit the facts.

If medical, genetic or identity records have been disclosed without an apparent lawful basis, keep a copy of the material, record where and when it appeared, note who could access it and avoid reposting it. Ask the responsible organisation to restrict further access and preserve relevant logs and records. Depending on the facts and current rules, a data-subject complaint to the competent Ministry may be available. Do not destroy relevant evidence or demand deletion of records that must be retained for a pending dispute or legal obligation.

Build an evidence file before making allegations

A remedy depends on proving the act, responsible person, loss or risk and legal basis for the requested result. Build a dated chronology and preserve original files. Collect only material you may lawfully hold; do not access another person’s account, alter records, impersonate anyone or publish intimate information to pressure a party.

  • All signed agreements, terms, consent forms, amendments and agency or clinic representations.
  • Invoices, itemised statements, bank transfers, receipts, refunds offered and payment instructions.
  • Emails, messages, letters, call summaries and evidence of when a refusal or demand was received.
  • Requests to the authority, clinic or agency; acknowledgements; written decisions; and proof of service or delivery.
  • Medical records, test results, expert opinions and records of injury, treatment or related expenses.
  • Relevant identity and status documents, but only where necessary and stored securely.
  • A list of witnesses, what each can establish, and where the original records are held.

Keep an unaltered copy and a separate working copy for redactions or translations. Record who supplied each document and when. If a record may be lost or deleted, ask counsel promptly about formal preservation or urgent relief.

A practical sequence for the first response

  1. Stabilise the situation. Address urgent medical needs, immediate threats and any child-safety concern first. Do not use a legal complaint as a substitute for emergency assistance.
  2. Define the outcome. Choose a lawful, specific request: a reasoned decision, access to records, correction of inaccurate data, investigation of alleged misconduct, a refund where legally supportable, compensation for proven injury, or review of a reviewable public decision.
  3. Identify the responsible actor. Separate the clinic, agency, medical professional, contracting party and public authority. One event may require more than one route, but do not name every participant as a defendant without a legal basis.
  4. Preserve evidence and calculate deadlines. Make a dated chronology and have an Omani lawyer identify any grievance, limitation, appeal or complaint period immediately.
  5. Send a focused written notice where appropriate. State the facts, attach a short evidence list, identify the requested action and set a reasonable response date only if a deadline is not prescribed by law. Avoid threats, admissions about disputed facts or demands for prohibited performance.
  6. Choose the formal route. Use the competent health regulator or technical committee for a professional/medical issue, the relevant data-protection complaint route for a data issue, the police or Public Prosecution where a suspected offence warrants it, and the competent civil or administrative court for a justiciable claim.
  7. Review the result before escalating. Keep every submission and reply. Escalate on the basis of the governing procedure, not simply because a first letter was unanswered.

Remedies are different from sanctions

Criminal reports ask authorities to investigate; complainants do not control prosecution. Professional complaints may lead to discipline. Administrative proceedings challenge reviewable public decisions. Civil claims may seek payment, rescission or damages where legally supported. These outcomes differ; none guarantees another.

Do not assume criminal proceedings recover money, a regulator decides parentage, or a civil court orders a restricted procedure. Counsel should identify each claim’s legal basis, forum, evidence, remedy and deadline. If enforceability is central, address Article 29 and the Civil Transactions Law.

Scope and source limitations

It does not determine parentage, nationality, birth registration, exit permission, recognition of foreign judgments or entitlement to a particular refund; those issues require separate review.

Qanoon.om’s Arabic texts were checked for the cited provisions, but the site says it is not an official legal source. Decree.om provides an English legal-translation database, though access to the consolidated medical-law text was limited. Before filing or calculating a deadline, obtain the current Arabic Official Gazette text and have Oman-qualified counsel confirm amendments, implementing decisions, jurisdiction and procedure.

Sources and legal materials

The linked Arabic legislation database is not an official source; verify the Official Gazette text before relying on it.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards