Kuwait · Disputes, refusals and remedies

Redacted paperwork, medical records and indexed evidence arranged for legal review
Editorial illustration only; not a real authority, clinic, legal document or case record.

Kuwait: Surrogacy Refusals, Disputes and Remedies

The practical bottom line

Treat any surrogacy arrangement to be performed in Kuwait as legally high-risk. UK government guidance states that surrogacy is illegal in Kuwait. Article 24 of Kuwait Law No. 70 of 2020 directs the Ministry of Health to regulate embryos, artificial insemination and fertilisation consistently with public order. The sources do not establish the exact offence, penalty or civil outcome for every case, or prove that a foreign arrangement will be recognised. A signed paper or broker’s assurance is not proof that treatment, payment, parentage or transfer can be compelled.

Classify the dispute first

Write down who did what, where and when: who signed, who paid, which company or clinic received money, where treatment and birth occurred, what was promised, and what was refused. Record whether embryo transfer, pregnancy or birth has already occurred and whether a child is currently affected. These facts influence jurisdiction, legal standing, applicable law and urgency. Separate a clinical refusal, refund claim, suspected deception, medical injury and parentage dispute instead of filing one vague complaint. A Kuwait authority may address conduct within Kuwait; a foreign clinic, bank or agency may require a different route.

Do not assume the agreement is enforceable

A surrogacy agreement does not become enforceable merely because it was signed, notarised, translated, paid for or made subject to foreign law. Public-order and family-status rules may limit local enforcement; the precise effect requires Kuwaiti advice on the actual document and facts. The sources do not establish a general right to compel a surrogate to become pregnant, continue a pregnancy, surrender a child or sign a parentage document. Do not promise that a court can order those outcomes. Separate promises, such as returning an unearned fee or correcting a deceptive invoice, must be analysed individually; their outcome is not guaranteed either.

If a clinic refuses or stops treatment

Ask for a dated written decision explaining the reason, the clinical or regulatory basis, which services were completed, what remains outstanding and how any stored embryos or other material, records and prepaid balance will be handled. Request copies of consent forms and an itemised account. Do not pressure staff to perform a procedure they say is prohibited or medically unsafe. The refusal may be legally justified; the separate dispute may concern communication, charges, records or professional conduct. Those issues should be assessed separately from a demand to complete a surrogacy arrangement.

Build a precise refund or payment claim

Create a transaction ledger showing date, payer, recipient, amount and currency, stated purpose, invoice, contractual milestone, service actually delivered, cancellation or refund term and disputed balance. Preserve bank statements, card slips, transfer confirmations, receipts and messages explaining what each payment covered. Send a concise written demand to the actual contracting party, not just a broker, stating the amount, calculation and supporting documents. You may propose a response date, but it is not a statutory deadline unless a verified rule or contract makes it one. Any repayment or damages claim depends on the governing law and public-order limits; recovery is not guaranteed.

If you suspect deception or fraud

Preserve original advertisements, web pages, profiles, company details, names used, bank beneficiaries, phone numbers, messages and voice notes. Export conversations with dates and keep unedited originals; prepare a separate chronology. Distinguish a broken promise or disagreement from evidence of intentional deception. After local advice, report credible suspected crime to the competent police or prosecuting authority and state only facts you can support. Do not threaten, impersonate an official, fabricate medical papers or publish a surrogate’s or child’s sensitive details. A criminal report investigates alleged wrongdoing; it does not itself decide a civil refund, parentage or custody.

Medical harm and professional misconduct

If the dispute concerns negligent treatment, injury, an unauthorised procedure or professional misconduct at a Kuwait healthcare facility, consider the medical-liability route. Article 34 of Law No. 70/2020 identifies fault-based circumstances, including departure from established medical rules or failure to exercise necessary care; it does not make a doctor strictly liable for every unsuccessful outcome. Article 34 also excludes liability in specified circumstances, including harm attributable to the patient’s own conduct, refusal or failure to follow medical instructions when documented, concealment of material health information, recognised or unexpected medical complications, and certain external causes. Whether an exception applies depends on the evidence and statutory conditions. Article 37 gives the Medical Liability Authority a technical role in complaints and cases involving medical errors or professional violations in public and private facilities. Evidence of a particular breach and harm is needed, not merely disappointment that fertility treatment failed.

How the medical-liability complaint works

The Authority’s English guidance lists a complaint form, a Civil ID, proof of the relationship with the healthcare facility, and a medical report establishing the alleged harm and causal link. Its official Arabic FAQ specifically states that Civil IDs are required for both the patient and the complainant. Depending on the case, the complainant may also need to establish legal standing or their relationship to the affected person; confirm the current form and case-specific requirements before filing. The Authority reviews medical errors and professional violations; its official Arabic FAQ states that it does not handle financial-compensation claims. Do not assume its report awards damages. The site states that an objection to a committee report must be filed within 15 days of receipt or notification under Article 49. Record the notification date and confirm the deadline and filing method with counsel. The official site estimates the overall process at 100–250 days; treat this as indicative, not a statutory deadline. Separately, Article 84 of Law No. 70/2020 says claims arising from a violation of this Law lapse three years from the medical act or violating procedure. Do not assume that this period governs every contractual claim; counsel should confirm its scope, start date and interaction with the Article 49 objection period.

Request records and invoices

Article 28 of Law No. 70/2020 allows the patient or legal representative to make a written request to the healthcare facility for a detailed or brief medical report and copies of reports, test results, treatment information and invoices or fees. The article lists these specific materials; it should not be treated as an express right to a complete copy of the entire medical file. The Authority’s official Arabic FAQ also states that a complainant is not entitled to receive a copy of the facility’s medical file through the complaint process. Send the request to the facility’s administration, identify dates and specific items, keep proof of delivery and ask how to collect the response. Confidentiality rules may require consent or proof of authority for a third party. Do not alter or remove originals.

A formal licensing refusal has a separate route

If the issue is a formal refusal of a healthcare-practice or facility licence, use Article 5 of Law No. 70/2020 rather than the medical-error complaint route. The licensing administration should decide within 60 days; no decision within that period counts as a refusal. An interested person may submit a reasoned grievance to the Undersecretary within 15 days after receiving the refusal or deemed refusal. The Undersecretary has up to 30 days to decide; silence is treated as rejection, after which the decision may be challenged before the competent court. Confirm service dates and standing. This procedure does not automatically apply to every clinic dispute.

If a child has already been born

If pregnancy or birth has occurred, treat the child’s welfare and legal status as a separate priority. A contract or foreign birth certificate does not by itself establish how Kuwait will determine parentage, birth registration, nationality, guardianship, passport eligibility or permission to leave the country. These questions may depend on parentage rules, marriage and civil-status records, nationality law and authorities in more than one country. Do not arrange travel, register a person as a legal parent or submit conflicting declarations without specific advice from Kuwaiti counsel and counsel in the country of birth. If the child’s safety or a deadline is involved, say so at the outset and seek urgent advice.

Map every country involved

Where treatment, payment, the surrogate, intended parents and birth are in different countries, prepare a jurisdiction map. For each event record location, date, participants, contract clause, currency and documents issued. Ask counsel to identify governing law, competent court, limitation period, possible interim relief and whether a foreign judgment or civil-status document needs recognition. A contract selecting foreign law or a foreign court order does not establish recognition in Kuwait. Equally, Kuwaiti law cannot automatically decide a claim against a foreign entity abroad. Parallel advice may be necessary; do not assume one forum can grant every remedy.

Evidence checklist

Keep a secure evidence folder containing every contract version and translation; payment and refund records; complete messages and original emails; advertisements saved with date and URL; clinic letters, consent forms, treatment records and reports; company and licence details; and, where relevant, birth, marriage, identity and travel documents. Add a dated chronology and a list separating disputed facts from established facts. Keep originals read-only and work from copies. Store reproductive and child-related information securely and share it only with people who need it for the case. Evidence should be preserved lawfully; do not access accounts or records without authority.

A practical sequence of next steps

Use this sequence: (1) protect immediate health and the child’s welfare; (2) do not sign new waivers or make further payments until the terms are reviewed; (3) request preservation of records and any stored material; (4) obtain written reasons for refusal and a full payment account; (5) classify the issue as clinical, regulatory, payment/contract, suspected crime or parentage/travel; (6) file with the body that has jurisdiction and keep proof; (7) calendar each service date and deadline; and (8) ask Kuwaiti counsel whether a separate civil claim or urgent court measure is available. Do not assume that a medical complaint pauses civil limitation periods or that negotiations suspend deadlines.

Match the remedy to the problem

Depending on the facts, possible routes include a written request for records or refund; a Ministry of Health or licensing complaint about a regulated facility; a Medical Liability Authority complaint about alleged medical error or professional misconduct; a police or prosecutorial report where evidence supports suspected crime; or a civil claim for repayment, loss or other relief where a viable legal basis exists. These routes do different jobs. The Authority says it does not decide financial-compensation claims, and a medical complaint is not a substitute for a civil claim. Conversely, a payment dispute alone does not prove medical error or fraud. Local counsel should assess evidence, standing, defendant identity, deadlines and public-order limits.

Example: the intermediary stops responding

Suppose a couple pays an intermediary, a Kuwait clinic refuses treatment, and the intermediary stops replying. Do not assume the clinic owes the entire payment if it did not receive the funds, or that the intermediary must return every amount without reviewing the agreement and governing law. Trace the money, identify each contracting party, obtain the clinic’s written reasons, preserve the intermediary’s representations and request an itemised refund calculation. If medical injury is alleged, open a separate medical-liability track. If a child has been born, treat parentage and travel as a separate urgent issue. One situation may create several claims with different evidence and forums.

Scope and review limitations

The Kuwaiti primary statute and official medical-liability guidance were reviewed; UK government guidance says surrogacy is illegal in Kuwait. Check the complete current text of every Ministry of Health rule on assisted reproduction; no reported Kuwaiti judgment resolving a specific surrogacy-contract dispute is known. Before relying on a conclusion, Kuwaiti counsel should verify current ministerial decisions and the Official Gazette, the exact agreement, each party’s status and any cross-border law.

Sources and legal limits

The Kuwaiti statute is published in Arabic; this guide’s descriptions are explanatory and are not an official English translation.

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards