Australia · Regional rules

Surrogacy in Victoria, Australia: State Rules, Approval and Parentage

Surrogacy in Victoria, Australia: State Rules, Approval and Parentage

Victoria’s legal framework

Victoria does not operate under a single uniform Australian surrogacy code. Its assisted-reproduction approval process, permitted reimbursements, surrogate's decision-making rights and subsequent parentage order are governed principally by Victorian law. The questions to answer first are where the treatment will occur, where the child will be born, where any embryo was created, and which court or registry must recognise parentage. A clinic's willingness to proceed, an informal family agreement or genetic connection cannot substitute for the applicable statutory approvals. This article addresses Victoria's regional rules rather than offering a guide to all Australian states or a guarantee of eligibility.

The main state sources are the Assisted Reproductive Treatment Act 2008 (Victoria), particularly Part 4, and the Assisted Reproductive Treatment Regulations 2019. Parentage and birth records engage the Status of Children Act 1974 and the Victorian births registration regime. The Patient Review Panel (PRP) makes the pre-treatment approval decision for arrangements involving treatment by a Victorian registered assisted reproductive treatment (ART) provider. The County Court of Victoria considers the subsequent parentage procedure; Births, Deaths and Marriages Victoria (BDM) updates the registration after an appropriate order. Since 1 January 2025 ART-provider regulation has been administered by the Department of Health rather than the former VARTA. Use the Act's authorised version 031 effective 30 September 2026: older explanatory notes and forms may not reflect every amendment.

Under section 40(1)(a) a doctor's opinion must ordinarily support the conclusion that the intended parent is unlikely to conceive, carry a pregnancy or give birth in the circumstances, or, where the intended parent is a woman, that pregnancy, carrying or delivery would likely put her life or health or the baby's at risk. The statutory language needs application to the actual proposed intended parent or parents; a diagnosis, relationship label or clinic marketing promise alone is not the statutory test. Obtain a documented medical opinion and confirm with the provider how the facts fit the current law. Do not infer from this regional rule that all foreigners, singles or same-sex couples are either automatically eligible or automatically excluded.

Eligibility and informed consent

For ordinary PRP approval, section 40 requires the surrogate to be at least 25, to have previously carried a pregnancy and given birth to a live child, and not to contribute her own oocyte to conception. This makes Victoria a gestational-surrogacy jurisdiction for the standard approved ART pathway. Finishing her own family is described in official health guidance as preferred, not a statutory prerequisite. The surrogate's partner, where there is one, is a relevant participant in required counselling and advice. Verify identities, age, past live birth, proposed gamete sources and medical consents before committing money or treatment dates. These checks do not themselves constitute Panel approval.

Section 41 permits the PRP to approve an arrangement even when it is not satisfied about one or more matters in section 40(1), but only if the proposed circumstances are exceptional and approval is reasonable. This is a discretion, not a general waiver, automatic exemption or right to insist upon treatment. A request should identify the precise unmet condition and evidence explaining the exceptional circumstances. The Panel still has to apply the Act and consider welfare and informed choice. Do not present an ordinary preference, a cheaper programme or a prior informal agreement as sufficient for this exception. Obtain specific legal advice before planning treatment around section 41.

Before entering an arrangement, section 43 requires the intended parent, surrogate and her partner (if any) to undergo counselling on social and psychological implications, the relinquishment of the child and the future relationship, and to obtain information about legal consequences. Under section 40 the PRP considers the counsellor's report and parties' acknowledgement of counselling and legal advice. The Panel also examines whether parties understand what happens if the intended parents refuse the child or the surrogate does not relinquish it. Written advice from separate lawyers is recommended in the Panel's guidance to avoid conflicts, but the form of that recommendation should not be confused with the statutory wording. Keep dated reports and advice evidence.

Approval, payments and rights

Contact a Victorian registered ART provider, check its present registration, and obtain the PRP's current surrogacy application pack. Assemble the doctor's opinion, each participant's details and consent, counselling material, legal advice acknowledgements and, if available, the written arrangement and supporting records. The parties should be ready to appear at a private Panel hearing by videoconference; the Panel's official guidance describes attendance of intended parents, surrogate and partner, and potentially donors. Section 39 prevents a registered ART provider carrying out the relevant treatment before PRP approval. The Panel provides a decision and reasons; approval is not a promise that a clinic must treat, that pregnancy will result or that later parentage will be granted.

Victoria permits altruistic surrogacy, not a fee or reward for acting as a surrogate. Under section 44 a surrogate may be reimbursed only for prescribed costs actually incurred as a direct consequence of the arrangement; where her partner is a party, prescribed costs actually incurred by that partner may also be reimbursed. The precise categories and evidence must be checked against the in-force Regulations 2019 rather than guessed from another state or a clinic's quote. Section 44(3) makes the arrangement void and unenforceable beyond the permitted reimbursement matter. Record invoices, purpose, payee and reimbursement basis. Never relabel compensation as an expense merely to bypass the statutory prohibition.

A surrogacy agreement does not transfer parental status by signature, bind the surrogate to a medical decision or guarantee surrender of the child. Section 44A expressly preserves her rights as a pregnant woman to decide about management of pregnancy and birth, despite contrary oral or written terms. The possibility that a party changes their position is material: the Panel itself assesses whether everyone understands the consequences of non-relinquishment or non-acceptance. Independent advice should cover consent, privacy, clinical choices, financial disagreements and child welfare. Coercive clauses or statements that a pregnancy can be controlled by intended parents should not be used.

Advertising and parentage after birth

Section 45 restricts publication of specified advertisements and statements seeking or offering surrogacy participation or arrangements, including public online publication. It is unsafe to treat an agency's advertisement, social-media solicitation or payment offer as legally acceptable merely because it appears online. Review exact proposed communications with local counsel. The Victorian Department of Health keeps ART-provider regulatory information and a provider register: confirm the treating entity against the current record rather than accepting a brand name or an intermediary's assurance. An ART clinic's regulatory status does not verify the legal status of an independent agency, its advertising or any cross-border undertaking.

Birth and parentage must be planned separately from approval to undertake treatment. In the ordinary Victorian birth pathway, BDM explains that the surrogate is the legal mother at birth and her partner, if any, is the other parent, and the initial birth registration is in their names. A pre-birth contract, gamete contribution or PRP approval does not by itself make intended parents the legal parents on the birth record. The Victorian parentage rules and the court order must be applied to the precise facts and consent position. Preserve the initial registration, medical evidence, counselling records, identification and PRP documents for the post-birth application.

For a child born under a surrogacy arrangement, the ordinary Substitute Parentage Order route is not triggered by a Victorian birth alone. Under section 20 of the Status of Children Act 1974, the child must have been conceived as a result of a procedure carried out in Victoria, and the intended parents must live in Victoria when they apply. The application is normally made no earlier than 28 days and no later than six months after birth; the court may allow an application at another time. Before the hearing, a certified copy of the child's birth certificate must be filed if available. Under section 22, the court must be satisfied that an order is in the child's best interests, that the child lives with the intended parents when the application is made, that the surrogate and any partner who is a party have not received a material benefit or advantage (apart from permitted cost reimbursement), and that the surrogate freely consents, subject to narrow statutory exceptions. If her partner is a party, the court must also consider that partner's consent. For an arrangement assisted by a registered ART provider, PRP approval must have been obtained before the arrangement was entered into, not merely before treatment. The separate section 39 treatment gate does not replace this parentage condition. Obtain case-specific advice before committing to the route, especially if intended parents live outside Victoria or the procedure occurred elsewhere.

Arrangements without a registered ART provider

Where no registered ART provider assisted and the surrogate became pregnant through artificial insemination, section 23 of the Status of Children Act adds conditions to a post-birth Substitute Parentage Order application. The surrogate must have been at least 25 before entering the arrangement. The intended parents, surrogate and her partner if a party must have received the required counselling on the social and psychological implications and relinquishment, and information about legal consequences. Counselling must be provided by a registered ART provider's counsellor or another person meeting prescribed requirements. The section 22 court tests still apply, including the child's best interests, the child living with the intended parents at application, no material benefit or advantage beyond permitted reimbursement, and the surrogate's free consent, subject to narrow statutory exceptions. The section 20 requirements about the procedure being carried out in Victoria and intended parents living in Victoria at application also remain relevant. This does not establish that every private arrangement is lawful or exempt from other requirements. Confirm the conception method, evidence, applicable route and current requirements with Victorian counsel before relying on it.

Territorial pathways and international effects

Where a child was conceived under a surrogacy arrangement in another Australian state or territory, was born in Victoria, and already has a corresponding parentage order from the other jurisdiction, the intended parents may apply for a Victorian Registration Order under sections 29B–29F of the Status of Children Act 1974. Before the hearing, they must file a certified copy of the birth certificate and a sealed copy of the corresponding order. They must notify the Secretary in writing at least 14 days before the hearing; current BDM guidance identifies the recipient as the Secretary of the Department of Justice and Community Safety and recommends registered or tracked post. The court may make the order only if the statutory criteria are met, including the child's best interests, a genuine connection to the state or territory of conception when the arrangement was entered into, no purpose of avoiding Victorian requirements, and the child living with at least one intended parent at the time of application. The surrogate must have been at least 25 before entering the arrangement, must freely consent, and must not have received a material benefit or advantage beyond reimbursement permitted by the applicable interstate law. If her partner was a party, the court must consider that partner's consent. The Act contains narrow exceptions to some consent requirements; they are not automatic. Do not apply the section 20 28-day-to-six-month period mechanically to this separate route. If the child was born outside Victoria, contact the relevant birth-state registry and court.

Victoria's law does not resolve every Australian federal or foreign question. Citizenship, immigration, passports, exit and entry formalities, and recognition by a foreign home state depend on the applicable national law and facts. A Victorian order or birth certificate is important evidence but must not be described as automatically conferring citizenship, a passport or recognition abroad. Before pregnancy, foreign-intended-parent cases need a written plan assessing the parents' residence, the child's likely citizenship pathway, travel documents, timing and risks if the parents' home state refuses recognition. Separate that cross-border analysis from the narrow Victorian approval and registration steps discussed here.

Use this routing check rather than choosing a procedure solely because the family lives in Melbourne. If treatment is provided by a registered Victorian ART provider, secure PRP approval before entering the arrangement where required for a later parentage order, and in all events before treatment under section 39. If the procedure occurred in Victoria and the child is born in Victoria, the ordinary section 20 Substitute Parentage Order route also depends on the intended parents living in Victoria when they apply, the 28-day-to-six-month filing window (unless the court grants leave for another time), the child's living with them at application, and the section 22 tests on the child's best interests, the surrogate's free consent (subject to narrow statutory exceptions) and no material benefit beyond permitted reimbursement; if the surrogate's partner is a party, the court must also consider that partner's consent. If conception occurred in another Australian state or territory and the child was born in Victoria, obtain the corresponding order first and then assess a Victorian Registration Order, including written notice to the Secretary at least 14 days before the hearing and the statutory criteria. If no registered ART provider assisted and the pregnancy followed artificial insemination, check the additional section 23 requirements. If the child was born outside Victoria, identify the competent court and registry in the birth jurisdiction; Victorian guidance alone is not enough. Where facts overlap or documents conflict, obtain coordinated advice before filing.

Remedies and practical next steps

If the PRP refuses an arrangement, ask for its formal written reasons and review options rather than arranging treatment despite refusal. Under sections 96–98 of the Victorian ART Act an affected person may apply to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal for review of a reviewable Panel decision, including refusal of surrogacy approval, generally within 28 days of the decision. A Court's refusal of a parentage or registration order is a different legal problem with different procedural rules. Where a document is missing, consent is disputed or the birth-registration process stalls, determine the deciding body and the precise legal ground first; do not assume that a PRP review fixes a County Court decision.

Before treatment and before entering the arrangement, obtain a current-law eligibility opinion, the doctor's opinion, the surrogate's identity, age and prior live-birth evidence, gamete-source records, counselling and legal-information evidence, an itemised reimbursement plan, the provider-registration check and the PRP decision. For provider-assisted arrangements, confirm that PRP approval predates entry into the arrangement, not merely the treatment date. Before birth, identify who will initially register the child and who will prepare court evidence. After birth, obtain the initial record; confirm where the conception procedure occurred, where the child was born and where the intended parents live; preserve evidence of the child's living arrangements and all required consents; and check the applicable filing window and whether court leave is needed. File a certified birth certificate if available. For interstate cases, obtain the sealed corresponding order and notify the Secretary in writing at least 14 days before the hearing. If no registered ART provider assisted and pregnancy followed artificial insemination, check section 23's age and counselling requirements. International families should separately review nationality, immigration and travel documents. For the ordinary section 20 route, the application is normally made between 28 days and six months after birth unless the court grants leave for another time. For a no-provider artificial-insemination arrangement, confirm that the surrogate was at least 25 before entering the arrangement and that the section 23 counselling and legal-information requirements were met.

The decisive Victorian difference is a two-stage system: statutory scrutiny of an assisted-reproduction surrogacy arrangement before treatment, followed by a fact-dependent court and registration process after birth. The surrogate's bodily autonomy survives any agreement; commercial rewards and prohibited public recruitment do not become lawful by contract; and the section 41 exception remains discretionary. Before acting, verify the exact current regulations on prescribed costs, up-to-date court procedure and forms, proposed participants' factual eligibility, and all international connections with qualified local advisers.

Primary and official sources

  1. Assisted Reproductive Treatment Act 2008, authorised version 031
  2. Assisted Reproductive Treatment Regulations 2019, version 005
  3. Patient Review Panel
  4. Births, Deaths and Marriages Victoria: Surrogacy
  5. Victorian assisted reproductive treatment reform
  6. Patient Review Panel: Applications
  7. Victorian registered ART providers
  8. Better Health Channel: Surrogacy
  9. Status of Children Act 1974, authorised version 045
  10. PRP outcome and statutory review guidance

Last updated:

Author: Khachatrian Razmik, LL.M.

International surrogacy and parentage legal services — LEX SURROGACY by Lex Agency · Author profile · Editorial standards